Guide · Taxes

    Objecting to a German Tax Assessment: A Guide for Landlords

    Calculate deadlines, explain discrepancies in depreciation and rental expenses, and understand payment obligations and cost risks.


    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo
    13 November 20269 min read

    01Checking your tax assessment: which differences matter?

    A smaller refund does not automatically mean your tax assessment is wrong. Start by comparing your submitted return with the amounts accepted and reading the explanatory notes. For rental properties, reductions in depreciation allowances can have particularly long-lasting effects.

    DifferencePossible explanationUseful documents
    Lower building depreciationThe tax office has assigned a smaller share of the cost to the buildingPurchase agreement, substantiated purchase price allocation and, where appropriate, an expert valuation
    Lower depreciation rateA shorter actual useful life has not been acceptedProperty-specific evidence of the shorter useful life
    Renovation costs not immediately deductibleClassification as capital expenditure or acquisition-related production costsItemised invoices, descriptions of the work and a timeline of the measures
    Expenses during a vacancy disallowedDoubts about a genuine intention to letAdvertisements, letting agent instructions and documented letting efforts
    Travel expenses reducedInsufficient evidence of the purpose or extent of travelTrip records showing the date, destination, purpose and distance
    Rental loss not fully recognisedFor example, a review of below-market lettingTenancy agreement, evidence of the local market rent and, where appropriate, a forecast of the overall rental surplus

    Do not confuse purchase price allocation with useful life

    Purchase price allocation determines how much of the acquisition cost relates to the depreciable building. Useful life determines the depreciation rate. A report on a shorter useful life therefore does not automatically replace a valuation of the building and land components.

    The Federal Ministry of Finance's purchase price allocation tool is not a binding valuation standard. However, a contractual allocation is not automatically accepted either: in particular, it must reasonably reflect the actual relative values. Further information is available in the guides to purchase price allocation and remaining useful life reports.

    For renovations, one relevant rule is the 15% threshold under section 6(1), no. 1a of the German Income Tax Act (EStG). If the repair and modernisation expenditure covered by the rule, excluding VAT, exceeds 15% of the building's acquisition cost within three years of acquisition, it may constitute acquisition-related production costs. Not every expense counts towards this test; conversely, spending below the threshold is not automatically immediately deductible.

    02The objection deadline: calculate notification and expiry separately

    The objection period is generally one month after notification of the assessment (section 355 of the German Fiscal Code, AO). What matters is receipt by the tax office within the deadline, not when you send your objection.

    For an assessment sent by ordinary post within Germany, the following rules generally apply:

    1. The starting point is the actual posting date, which is not necessarily the date printed on the assessment.
    2. The assessment is generally deemed notified on the fourth day after posting (section 122(2) AO).
    3. If that day falls on a Saturday, Sunday or public holiday, the end of this four-day period moves to the next working day.
    4. The one-month objection period runs from the notification date determined in this way. Its expiry also moves to the next working day if it falls on a Saturday, Sunday or public holiday.

    Example: posting in November 2026

    The following dates are assumptions. This example concerns ordinary domestic post, not formal service.

    StepDate
    Assumed posting dateMonday, 02.11.2026
    Fourth day afterwards: notificationFriday, 06.11.2026
    Calculated end of the one-month periodSunday, 06.12.2026
    Actual deadlineMonday, 07.12.2026

    If the assessment demonstrably arrives later or does not arrive at all, the deemed-notification rule does not apply unchanged. Inform the tax office promptly of the circumstances and retain any available evidence. Where there is doubt, the authority must establish receipt and its timing. Earlier actual receipt does not generally shorten the statutory four-day period.

    For electronic notification, a distinction must be made between electronic transmission and making a document available for retrieval. Do not simply apply the postal rule to an ELSTER assessment. Check the notification information and the rules governing the specific delivery method; if in doubt, do not wait until the last possible day to object.

    Missing appeal instructions or a missed deadline

    If proper instructions on how to challenge the assessment are missing, an objection can generally be lodged within one year of notification (section 356 AO).

    If you miss the deadline through no fault of your own, reinstatement of the deadline may be available (section 110 AO). You must generally apply within one month after the obstacle has ceased to exist and also submit the objection within that period. You must explain and substantiate the reasons that prevented timely action. Illness alone is not automatically sufficient.

    Receipts and documents for the tax assessment of a rental property
    AI-generated illustrative image

    03Lodging an objection: content, submission and reasons

    You can lodge an objection in writing, electronically or orally for an official record at the competent tax office (section 357 AO). A telephone call alone is not sufficient.

    ELSTER provides an electronic submission route with a transmission record. Select the objection form and save the submission confirmation. An ordinary email can also be sufficient if the tax office has opened that channel for electronic communication; a qualified electronic signature is generally not required for an objection. Reliable evidence of receipt is particularly important when the deadline is close.

    Template for an objection to preserve the deadline

    To the tax office [name]

    Tax number: [number]

    I hereby lodge an objection to the income tax assessment for [year] dated [date].

    I will submit my reasons and supporting documents separately.

    [Name, address, date]

    For a joint assessment, it should be clear on whose behalf the objection is being lodged.

    Four elements will help when you submit your reasons:

    • Disputed item: Which item was treated differently?
    • Requested change: What amount or treatment are you requesting?
    • Reasons: Why is the change justified on the facts and under the law?
    • Evidence: Which invoices, contracts or expert reports support your request?

    Observe any deadlines the tax office sets for further information or evidence. Providing reasons later is possible, but it is not a reason to leave the proceedings unattended indefinitely.

    04Worked example: a smaller building share reduces depreciation

    The following model illustrates only the effect of different building shares. All figures are assumptions, not market data or a promise of tax treatment. It assumes acquisition costs of €324,000 to be allocated, a straight-line depreciation rate of 2% that is legally applicable to the property, and a full depreciation year.

    ItemRequested treatmentTreatment in the assessment
    Building share80%60%
    Depreciable building acquisition cost€259,200€194,400
    Annual depreciation at 2%€5,184€3,888
    Difference in annual depreciation€1,296

    The difference is: €324,000 × (80% − 60%) × 2% = €1,296 annually.

    For a separate, simplified tax illustration, assume a constant marginal tax burden of 40%. The solidarity surcharge, church tax and other interactions are disregarded. The calculation is then:

    €1,296 × 40% = a tax difference of €518.40 per full year.

    This is not a calculation using an individual's income tax tariff. The actual impact depends, among other things, on taxable income and whether the higher depreciation allowance is accepted. Extrapolating over decades would not be reliable without additional assumptions.

    The purchase price allocation does not directly change the rent or mortgage instalment. However, tax-related cash flow can change through a refund, additional payment or adjusted advance tax payments.

    Classifying the cost of advice and expert reports

    The tax office charges no fee for objection proceedings. Tax advice and expert reports can nevertheless incur costs, which remain payable even if the objection fails. There is no automatic reimbursement of these costs by the tax office in ordinary objection proceedings.

    Advisory fees sufficiently connected with rental income may be deductible rental expenses. For expert reports, the reason and purpose matter: depending on the circumstances, the cost may be immediately deductible or form part of incidental acquisition costs. You should therefore not assume an immediate tax deduction in your financial assessment. Read more in the guide to deductible rental expenses.

    05During the objection: payment obligations and risks

    Additional tax initially remains payable

    An objection does not suspend the payment obligation. A separate suspension of enforcement is required for this purpose (section 361 AO). It may be available in particular where there are serious doubts about the lawfulness of the assessment; undue hardship may also be relevant.

    Apply for suspension for the disputed amount and explain your reasons. The application alone does not postpone the due date. To the extent that the objection ultimately fails, interest on the suspended amount may arise (section 237 AO). If you pay first, you can still pursue the objection and receive a refund of overpaid tax if the assessment is corrected accordingly.

    The tax office can also change the assessment against you

    During objection proceedings, the challenged assessment is generally reviewed in full. The tax office may discover errors in your favour and assess a higher amount of tax.

    Before making such a detrimental amendment, it must warn you of that possibility, state its reasons and give you an opportunity to respond (section 367(2) AO). Withdrawing the objection can prevent a detrimental amendment within the objection proceedings. It does not, however, prevent changes permitted under other statutory correction provisions.

    Staying the proceedings and bringing a court action

    If the same legally relevant issue is being considered in an applicable case before one of the courts specified in section 363 AO, a stay of the objection proceedings may be available. Where the statutory conditions are met and the relevant case is relied upon, a stay can also arise by operation of law. A merely similar case is not enough. A stay does not suspend the payment obligation.

    If the tax office rejects the objection by issuing an objection decision, the time limit for bringing an action before the fiscal court is generally one month after notification (section 47 of the Fiscal Court Code, FGO). Unlike an objection, court proceedings usually involve court fees and other cost risks.

    Organising receipts for the accounts of a rental apartment
    AI-generated illustrative image

    06Amendment requests, provisional assessments and reservations of review

    Not every error calls for the same procedural route.

    SituationPossible routeImportant limitation
    A clearly identifiable expense was omittedRequest for a limited amendment under section 172 AOA requested change in the taxpayer's favour generally needs to be specified within the objection period; the request does not preserve the objection deadline
    An obvious clerical or calculation error by the tax officeCorrection under section 129 AONot a general route for correcting errors of law or valuation
    Facts or evidence become known subsequentlyAmendment under section 173 AOFor changes in the taxpayer's favour, the late disclosure must generally not be attributable to gross fault on the taxpayer's part
    Assessment subject to a reservation of reviewAmendment request under section 164 AOOnly while the reservation remains effective and the statutory time limits permit a change
    Assessment is provisional in certain respectsAmendment within the scope of provisionality under section 165 AOOther disputed issues are unaffected by the provisional status

    An amendment request is therefore not a universally equivalent substitute for an objection. Where the legal position is unclear, several items are disputed or a deadline is approaching, choose the appropriate procedure carefully.

    07A decision guide for landlords

    An objection is particularly worth examining where there is a substantiated discrepancy, the depreciation base is affected or substantial rental expenses have been omitted. Compare the potential tax benefit with the cost of evidence, the time involved and the risk of further corrections.

    Protect the deadline first. Then establish which evidence is actually needed. An expert report is not the right first step for every reduction, and a procedure with no official fee is not automatically risk-free.

    This guide provides general information on German tax law as at October 2026. It does not replace individual tax or legal advice.

    08Free initial consultation on property investment calculations

    In a free initial consultation, we discuss your investment objectives and the financial fundamentals of an investment property. Individual objection proceedings and definitive advice on tax matters should be handled by a tax or legal adviser. Arrange an initial consultation.

    FAQFrequently asked questions

    How long do I have to object to a German tax assessment?

    Generally, one month after notification. For ordinary post within Germany, notification is generally deemed to occur on the fourth day after posting. Weekends, public holidays and later receipt can affect the calculation. The objection must reach the tax office within the deadline.

    Does lodging an objection with the tax office cost money?

    The tax office charges no fee for objection proceedings. Tax advice or expert reports can incur costs. Whether these are immediately deductible as rental expenses depends on their specific connection with the letting activity and their purpose.

    Do I have to give reasons for my objection immediately?

    No. You can first clearly state that you are objecting to a specific assessment and announce that your reasons will follow. Submit the documents afterwards and observe any deadlines the tax office sets.

    Do I still have to pay additional tax while my objection is pending?

    Yes. Only a granted suspension of enforcement can suspend the payment obligation to the relevant extent. Applying alone is not enough. To the extent that the objection ultimately fails, interest may arise on the suspended amount.

    Can my objection result in a less favourable tax assessment?

    Yes. The tax office can amend the challenged assessment to your disadvantage, but it must first warn you, explain its reasons and give you an opportunity to respond. Withdrawal can prevent a detrimental amendment within the objection proceedings, but does not rule out changes under other correction provisions.

    What can I do if the tax office has reduced my depreciation allowance?

    First check whether the building share or the depreciation rate was changed. Purchase price allocation depends on the relative values of the building and land. A shorter actual useful life requires separate property-specific evidence. The Federal Ministry of Finance's allocation tool is not a binding valuation standard.

    How do I lodge an objection through ELSTER?

    Select the objection form in your ELSTER account. Include your tax number, the type of tax, the year and the assessment date. Add your reasons or state that they will follow. Submit the objection in time and save the transmission confirmation.

    Written by
    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo

    Writes about Taxes, AfA (depreciation), Existing properties and Portfolio building.

    Since 2020, Eduard has bought seven properties of his own and supported more than 150 clients. He writes about tax levers, property documents and portfolio building – with honest numbers instead of rosy projections.

    This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.

    Free · Instant · No sign-up

    Download this guide as a PDF

    The complete guide as a clean A4 file – with a cover page, all chapters and page numbers. Keep it on hand, read it offline, or go through it at your own pace during your consultation.

    • All chapters, tables and worked examples
    • Read offline – on your phone or printed out
    • Go through it at your own pace or pass it on
    • Free, no sign-up, no email required

    A4 format · 2,460 words · As of 13 November 2026

    Related guides

    All guides