Property purchase fallen through: Which costs may be deductible?
How to evidence your intention to let, assess abortive expenditure and check whether German real estate transfer tax can be refunded.
01Failed property purchase: When costs may be deductible
A failed purchase can leave you with bills even though you never acquire the property: the survey has been paid for, the contract drafted or the loan already agreed. If these expenses related to an intended letting, a deduction against rental income may be available.
The legal basis is the income-related expense rules in section 9 of the German Income Tax Act (EStG), read together with section 21. Deductible expenses can arise before the first rent is received. Even if the project is ultimately abandoned, the connection with the intended income source may remain.
A deduction is not a refund of the bill. Allowable expenses reduce the amount on which tax is calculated. Whether and when this produces tax relief depends on your other income and personal tax position.
02Document your intention to let
You must have been genuinely committed to letting the property. Merely considering whether you might live in it yourself or perhaps let it is not enough. The overall picture established by objective circumstances is what matters.
Useful evidence includes documents from before the purchase fell through:
- Mortgage applications stating that the property is intended as an investment or for letting
- Rental calculations and documents relating to the proposed management of the property
- Correspondence with the estate agent, seller or property manager about letting
- Existing tenancy agreements and rental details for the property
- A clear chronology of the intended purchase, costs incurred and abandonment
The fact that a property was marketed with tenants in place does not, by itself, prove your own intention to let. Conversely, expenses incurred during the search are not excluded simply because no purchase contract has yet been signed. The decisive issue remains whether a sufficiently specific connection with a genuinely intended letting can be demonstrated.
If the property was intended solely for your own occupation, there is no deduction against rental income. Where mixed use was intended, expenses must be allocated accordingly.

03Which expenses may qualify?
The following overview assumes that your intention to let is established and that you ultimately bear the costs. For expenses that would have formed part of acquisition costs had the purchase succeeded, it must also be clear that they will no longer lead to the intended acquisition.
| Type of expense | Tax treatment when the purchase falls through |
|---|---|
| Surveyors and building experts | May be deductible, even if the survey causes you to abandon the purchase. |
| Notary: drafting, notarisation and cancellation | May be deductible as abortive acquisition expenditure. |
| Land register: priority notice and its removal | May be taken into account once the acquisition has definitively failed. |
| Commitment interest on an undrawn loan | May be deductible where the connection with the intended letting is established. |
| Compensation for not drawing down a loan | May be deductible if it relates to financing the failed rental property purchase. |
| Mortgage brokerage and the bank's valuation | Check the connection with the project, payment and possible refunds. |
| Reservation fee and estate agent's commission | Not automatically deductible: check the legal basis, repayment claims and whether the cost is ultimately borne by you. |
| Viewings and appointments to unwind the transaction | Income-related travel expenses may qualify; private elements must be excluded. |
| Legal assistance with unwinding the transaction | May be deductible to the extent that the dispute relates to the failed rental investment. |
For qualifying trips using your own car, a mileage allowance of €0.30 per kilometre travelled can generally be claimed. Record the date, route, purpose and kilometres driven. This is not the distance allowance for a one-way commute to work.
Do not write off reservation fees too quickly
A reservation fee you have paid is not automatically lost for good. In particular, standard-form reservation agreements with estate agents may be invalid. First check whether you can reclaim the payment. A tax deduction is not a substitute for examining your civil-law claims.
04Real estate transfer tax: A refund requires a separate process
Cancelling the purchase contract does not automatically remove the real estate transfer tax liability. Under section 16 GrEStG, an application may allow the tax not to be assessed or an existing assessment to be cancelled.
The frequently mentioned two-year period does not apply uniformly to every case.
- Before legal ownership transfers: Section 16(1) GrEStG covers, among other cases, cancellation by agreement within two years of the tax liability arising. Exercising a reserved contractual right of withdrawal is also subject to the conditions set out there.
- After legal ownership transfers: Reacquisition by the seller is subject to the specific requirements of section 16(2) GrEStG.
- Where contractual conditions are not fulfilled: Special statutory provisions may apply. The two-year period must not simply be assumed to apply in these cases.
In particular, the acquisition must genuinely be reversed and the seller must regain their original power to dispose of the property. A notarised cancellation agreement alone is not sufficient in every situation.
Send the application to the tax office responsible for the real estate transfer tax and include the documents relating to the reversal. Refunded transfer tax cannot also be claimed as an expense ultimately borne by you. If no refund is available, the tax treatment requires separate consideration.
05Worked example: The cost you might still bear
The following amounts and tax effect are assumptions only, not market figures or a promise of tax relief. Nina intended to let a flat. The acquisition definitively fails, and all the listed expenses are paid in the same calendar year. Her intention to let is established. The example assumes that all costs are accepted for tax purposes and that there are no claims for reimbursement.
| Assumed expense | Amount |
|---|---|
| Building surveyor | €900 |
| Notary and land register, including reversal of the transaction | €1,400 |
| Commitment interest | €300 |
| Compensation for not drawing down the loan | €2,000 |
| Legal assistance with reversing the transaction | €1,000 |
| Travel: 600 km × €0.30 | €180 |
| Total expenses | €5,780 |
For illustration, the calculation assumes average tax relief of 35% across the entire deductible amount. This is not a calculation using the statutory income tax tariff or a statement of Nina's personal tax rate.
- Assumed tax relief: €5,780 × 35% = €2,023
- Remaining cost: €5,780 − €2,023 = €3,757
Real estate transfer tax is not included in the model. Actual relief may differ or arise only through the later use of a tax loss.

06Tax return, timing and loss relief
Which tax year matters?
For ongoing income-related expenses, the cash-payment principle in section 11 EStG generally applies. For abortive acquisition expenditure, it also matters when it becomes clear that the intended acquisition will no longer take place and that the expenditure has been lost. Not every payment therefore automatically belongs in the tax return for the year in which it was made.
If payment and definitive failure occur in different years, the timing of the deduction should be considered separately. Buying another flat later does not automatically turn costs clearly attributable to the failed purchase into acquisition costs of the new property. The position may differ for services actually reused for the later acquisition.
How to prepare your return
- Compile invoices and payment records: Allocate each expense to the intended property.
- Evidence your intention to let: Include financing documents, calculations and correspondence.
- Document the failure: Record the reasons, timing and reversal of the transaction.
- Check reimbursements: Account for repayments and disclose outstanding claims.
- Declare the rental income position: Generally claim the expenses in the rental income section, Anlage V, and explain the circumstances in a supplementary schedule.
Refunds of expenses already deducted must be taken into account for tax purposes, generally in the year received. For damages payments, the treatment depends on which loss the payment compensates.
What if you do not have enough other income?
An accepted loss can generally be offset against other positive income. If an unrelieved loss remains, section 10d EStG may allow it to be carried back to the two preceding tax assessment periods or carried forward. Statutory limits and further conditions apply.
Submit the necessary returns and ensure that any remaining loss carryforward is formally assessed. Do not assume that a four-year filing period always applies: mandatory returns, voluntary returns and loss assessments can raise different deadline issues.
07Checks before buying remain more important
Tax recognition does not make a failed purchase financially harmless. Before notarisation, check the financing, declaration of division, collection of owners' resolutions, meeting minutes, annual budget and identifiable maintenance risks.
Costs of an unsuccessful sale must be distinguished from those of a failed purchase. They are generally not deductible against rental income merely because the property was previously let.
This guide provides general information and does not replace individual tax or legal advice.
08Free initial consultation
A free initial consultation is an opportunity to discuss your planned property investment, its financial calculations and important documents to review before buying. Your tax adviser should assess whether costs already incurred qualify for a deduction.
Arrange a free initial consultation
FAQFrequently asked questions
Can I deduct costs if a property purchase falls through?
A deduction may be available if the expenses relate to a genuinely intended letting and you can evidence that intention. Each expense and any potential reimbursement claims must be assessed. If the property was intended solely for your own occupation, there is no deduction against rental income.
What is abortive income-related expenditure?
It is expenditure incurred in pursuing an intended source of income that does not materialise. For a failed property purchase, this may include survey, notarial or financing costs. The connection with the planned letting must be demonstrable.
Are notarial fees deductible when a purchase falls through?
Fees for drafting, notarisation and cancellation may be deductible where the intention to let is established. The same may apply to land register costs. In particular, the acquisition must have definitively failed and you must ultimately bear the costs.
Will I get real estate transfer tax back after the transaction is reversed?
A refund or cancellation of the tax assessment is possible on application if the requirements of section 16 GrEStG are met. Relevant factors include whether legal ownership has transferred, the reason for reversal and whether it has genuinely been carried out. The two-year period does not apply to every case.
Is compensation for not drawing down a loan deductible?
It may qualify as an income-related expense if the loan was demonstrably intended for the proposed rental property and the compensation relates to the failed project. This deduction against rental income is not available for financing intended for owner-occupation.
What happens if I have no other income in the relevant year?
Subject to section 10d EStG, an accepted tax loss may be carried back to the two preceding tax assessment periods or carried forward to later years. The necessary returns and, where applicable, formal assessment of the remaining loss carryforward are important. This does not automatically produce an immediate payment.
How do I prove that I intended to let the property?
Useful evidence includes contemporaneous financing applications stating the letting purpose, your own rental calculations and correspondence about the planned letting. Existing tenancy agreements for the property can provide additional support. The overall picture is decisive; no single document guarantees acceptance.

Writes about Financing and Taxes.
Romolo brings almost 17 years of banking and financing experience, including leading around 145 sales staff, to his work. He writes about financing, taxes and property decisions that fit your life for the long term.
This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.



