Guide · Letting

    Fixed-term tenancies: three grounds and common pitfalls

    Under section 575 of the German Civil Code, a fixed-term residential tenancy requires a statutory reason disclosed in writing. We explain the formalities, extensions and alternatives, and compare letting with vacancy.


    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo
    20 October 20268 min read
    Fixed-term residential tenancies at a glance
    3 grounds
    permitted by law
    personal occupation, substantial building works, service accommodation
    in writing
    when the agreement is concluded
    the reason for the fixed term must be disclosed
    4 months
    before expiry
    the earliest the tenant may request confirmation
    +€33,300
    over three years
    fixed-term letting rather than vacancy in the example, before tax

    You have bought a flat that your daughter is due to occupy in three years when she starts university. Or you intend to carry out substantial alterations to the building in two years. You do not want the flat to stand empty until then. Is a tenancy with a fixed end date the answer?

    It can be, but only under strict conditions. A preferred end date is not enough for a fixed-term residential tenancy under section 575 of the German Civil Code [Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch, BGB]. If the landlord fails to provide a sufficiently specific reason in writing when the agreement is concluded, the tenancy is generally indefinite. Any subsequent ordinary termination by the landlord then requires a legitimate interest, such as a genuine need for personal occupation [Eigenbedarf].

    01What a fixed-term tenancy is

    A tenancy is concluded either for an indefinite period or for a fixed term (section 542 BGB). An indefinite tenancy can end, in particular, through notice of termination or a mutual termination agreement. For ordinary termination, the landlord generally needs a legitimate interest, such as a need for personal occupation. A valid fixed-term tenancy generally ends on the agreed date.

    German legislation places strict limits on fixed-term residential tenancies. Tenants should not lose their protection against termination through successive short contracts. Within the scope of section 575 BGB, a fixed term therefore requires one of the grounds listed in that provision. This is known as a qualified fixed-term tenancy.

    Ordinary termination is generally excluded during the term. This also binds you as the landlord. Rights to extraordinary termination, for example for substantial rent arrears, and statutory special termination rights remain available where their respective conditions are met.

    02The three permitted grounds

    Section 575(1) BGB provides an exhaustive list of three grounds. Other reasons, such as a planned sale, do not justify a fixed term under this provision.

    The three grounds under section 575 BGB
    GroundMeaningExample
    Personal occupationThe landlord intends to use the premises as a home for themselves, family members or members of their householdThe daughter moves in to attend university in September 2029
    Alterations or demolitionThe landlord intends lawfully to demolish, substantially alter or repair the premises, and continuation of the tenancy would significantly impede the worksCombining two flats after the necessary permission has been granted
    Service accommodationThe premises are to be let to someone required to perform servicesA flat for the employer's caretaker

    The reason must be specific enough for the tenant to understand it and check it later. Simply repeating the statutory wording is not sufficient. “Personal occupation” alone is too vague. “My daughter Anna will begin university in this city in the winter semester of 2029 and move into the flat” describes the plan more specifically; the details must reflect the landlord's actual intentions.

    Key handover in a bright rental apartment
    AI-generated illustrative image

    03Written form, information and extensions

    The tenant must receive the reason in writing when the agreement is concluded. Including it in the tenancy agreement itself is the simplest approach. Merely supplying it later does not retrospectively remedy the original omission. Where the agreed term exceeds one year, the written-form requirement for the agreement under section 550 BGB must also be observed; otherwise, the tenancy is generally treated as indefinite. In that case, however, termination cannot take effect before one year has elapsed since the accommodation was handed over.

    No earlier than four months before expiry, the tenant may request confirmation that the reason still applies. You must respond within one month. If you respond late, the tenant may demand an extension corresponding to the delay (section 575(2) BGB). The extension does not arise automatically.

    If the reason materialises later than expected, for example because the start of university is postponed by a semester, the tenant may demand a corresponding extension. If the reason disappears altogether, the tenant may demand continuation for an indefinite period. The landlord bears the burden of proving that the reason materialises and the duration of any delay (section 575(3) BGB).

    How to prepare a fixed-term tenancy agreement
    1. 01
      Check the reason

      Does your plan fall within one of the three permitted grounds? A sale does not.

    2. 02
      Set the date

      Align the end date with the specific planned start of occupation or building works. A general time buffer is no substitute for a sound justification.

    3. 03
      Describe the reason precisely

      For personal occupation: the person, relationship, circumstances and timing. For building works or service accommodation, explain the relevant circumstances. Including the explanation in the agreement itself is the simplest approach.

    4. 04
      Conclude the agreement in writing

      Both parties sign; the tenant receives the specific reason for the fixed term in writing when the agreement is concluded.

    5. 05
      Keep supporting documents

      Retain evidence of the plan, such as university plans, building permission or an employment contract.

    6. 06
      Prepare to provide information

      Expect a request from four months before expiry and respond within one month.

    04What happens if the fixed term is invalid

    If the reason is missing or insufficiently specific, the agreement is generally treated as an indefinite tenancy (section 575(1), sentence 2 BGB). You do not automatically regain possession of the flat.

    In an individual case in 2013, the Federal Court of Justice [Bundesgerichtshof, BGH] allowed supplementary interpretation of an agreement so that a mutual waiver of ordinary termination rights replaced the invalid fixed term for the intended period of commitment (BGH VIII ZR 388/12). This does not create an automatic waiver in every agreement with an invalid fixed term. Whether a binding period exists, and how long it lasts, depends on the agreement and the circumstances. If such a waiver applies, ordinary termination is restricted accordingly. A subsequent ordinary termination by the landlord generally requires a legitimate interest, such as personal occupation, and compliance with the statutory notice period. Ask a lawyer to assess the consequences of an invalid fixed term in your particular case.

    05Alternatives: a termination waiver and temporary use

    Not every landlord intends to occupy the flat later. If the aim is simply to prevent a tenant leaving after a few months, a fixed-term tenancy under section 575 BGB is not required.

    A waiver of ordinary termination rights [Kündigungsverzicht] may serve that purpose. Both parties waive ordinary termination for a specified period. A standard-form clause must generally not bind the tenant for more than four years, measured from conclusion of the agreement to the earliest possible end of the tenancy. The Federal Court of Justice confirmed the general four-year limit for standard-form agreements (BGH VIII ZR 27/04). The tenancy remains indefinite and does not automatically end when the binding period expires. See the guide to tenancy agreement clauses.

    This must be distinguished from letting accommodation for temporary use [vorübergehender Gebrauch] under section 549(2), no. 1 BGB, for example to meet a specifically limited housing need during a project or a relative's hospital stay. A short contractual term alone is not sufficient. Where the arrangement genuinely qualifies as temporary use, certain protections do not apply, including Germany's rent cap on new lettings [Mietpreisbremse] and key provisions protecting tenants against ordinary termination. The requirements of section 575 BGB also do not apply to this exception. The decisive factor is therefore the actual nature of the use, not merely the agreed end date.

    Inspection documents and apartment keys in a bright rental apartment
    AI-generated illustrative image

    06Worked example: vacancy or a fixed-term letting before moving in

    The Kellers have bought a two-room flat for €200,000, financed with a €160,000 loan. Their daughter is due to move in to attend university in three years. Until then, they are considering leaving it empty to avoid the risks of letting it in the meantime. The names are fictional; the figures form a simplified worked example, not a forecast.

    For simplicity, we assume annual interest of 3.8% and principal repayments of 1.5%, both calculated on the original €160,000 loan. These annual amounts are held constant for the three-year comparison; the model does not reproduce an actual repayment schedule with a declining outstanding balance. The interest rate is solely a calculation assumption, not a current financing offer.

    The monthly rent excluding service charges is €750. In the letting scenario, the €2,100 annual recoverable costs are assumed to be covered in full by the tenant's service-charge payments; the table shows the net amount. The model includes a further €900 a year in non-recoverable payments, including any contributions to the maintenance reserve of the owners' association [Wohnungseigentümergemeinschaft, WEG]. This item is treated solely as a cash outflow, not as an amount that can simply be deducted in full for tax purposes.

    Payments into the maintenance reserve are not immediately deductible against rental income. A deduction can become available under the applicable conditions only when the funds are used for measures that qualify for tax recognition; even then, the expenditure is not always immediately deductible. The full owners' service charge [Hausgeld] must therefore not simply be deducted for tax purposes. Loan principal repayments are not deductible against rental income either: they reduce the outstanding debt but use current cash.

    One year of vacancy compared with one year of fixed-term letting
    VacancyFixed-term letting at €750 a month
    Rent excluding service charges€0€9,000
    Interest (3.8% of €160,000)−€6,080−€6,080
    Principal repayments (1.5% of €160,000)−€2,400−€2,400
    Recoverable share of owners' service charge, after reimbursement−€2,100€0
    Non-recoverable share of owners' service charge, including any reserve contributions−€900−€900
    Cash flow before tax−€11,480−€380
    Simplified worked example. Assumes full payment of rent and service charges, unchanged financing and no additional refurbishment, management or legal costs. In the vacancy scenario, the flat is held solely for later personal occupation or rent-free use by the daughter, with no intention to let it. Tax effects are not included in this cash-flow calculation.

    Under these assumptions, vacancy produces an annual cash outflow of €11,480. Fixed-term letting leaves a pre-tax shortfall of €380 a year. The difference is €11,100 annually, or €33,300 before tax across three identical model years. The improvement in cash flow should not be equated with a profit or a particular rate of return.

    An after-tax comparison depends on different factors from a cash-flow calculation. Building depreciation [Absetzung für Abnutzung, AfA] depends, among other things, on the depreciation basis and the applicable rate; it is not a current cash outflow. Personal income tax depends in part on taxable income. Where letting is limited from the outset and followed by personal occupation, a forecast of the overall rental surplus may also be required to demonstrate an intention to generate taxable income. By contrast, vacancy solely for private purposes, with no intention to let, does not qualify for expense deductions against rental income. Ask a tax adviser to calculate the tax treatment and its effect on your personal cash flow.

    Difference over three years, before tax
    Vacancy
    −€34,440
    Fixed-term letting
    −€1,140
    Three identical model years, with no rent increases and no adjustment of interest or principal repayments for the declining loan balance. Simplified worked example based on the stated payment assumptions.

    The calculation also has limitations. The Kellers face the risk that their daughter's move is delayed or that the tenant acquires a statutory right to an extension. Refurbishment costs may also arise before she moves in; refurbishment after precisely three years is not necessarily required. These costs, rent arrears and additional management or legal costs are not included here. Whether interim letting remains cheaper overall also depends on these items.

    07Who a fixed-term tenancy suits

    A fixed-term tenancy may suit you
    • You intend to use the flat at a foreseeable date for yourself, family members or members of your household.
    • You plan lawful substantial building works that would be significantly impeded by continuation of the tenancy.
    • You can already specify and substantiate the reason.
    Consider another approach
    • You only want to retain a tenant for a few years. A termination waiver may be an option.
    • You intend to sell later. A sale is not a permitted reason for a fixed term.
    • Your plan is vague, such as “perhaps we will move there in retirement”.

    08Risks and common mistakes

    A vague reason. An insufficiently specific reason can invalidate the fixed term. The tenancy is then generally indefinite. A subsequent ordinary termination by the landlord requires a legitimate interest and must respect the applicable notice periods and any termination waiver.

    A delayed plan. If the move is delayed, the tenant may demand an extension. If the plan is abandoned, for example because the daughter studies elsewhere and no longer needs the flat, the tenant may demand continuation for an indefinite period.

    Burden of proof. The landlord bears the burden of proving that the reason for the fixed term materialises and the duration of any delay. Keep supporting evidence.

    Rent arrears and interest rates. A fixed-term tenancy does not protect against non-payment, damage or higher interest rates when refinancing. The calculation above assumes full payment of rent and service charges.

    Tenant selection. A three-year term might suit students, people starting their careers or those in a transitional phase. Whether there is demand depends on the particular location and property. Check affordability and documents just as carefully as for an indefinite tenancy; see tenant selection.

    FAQFrequently asked questions

    Are fixed-term residential tenancies allowed in Germany?

    Yes. Within the scope of section 575 of the German Civil Code, one of three grounds is required: later occupation by the landlord, their family or household members; lawful substantial building works that continuation of the tenancy would significantly impede; or subsequent letting to someone required to perform services. The specific reason must be disclosed in writing when the agreement is concluded.

    What happens if the fixed-term agreement contains no reason?

    The key question is whether the tenant received the specific reason in writing when the agreement was concluded; it may be in a separate document. Without a valid fixed term, the tenancy is generally indefinite. A mutual waiver of ordinary termination rights may arise through supplementary interpretation in an individual case, but is not automatic. Ordinary termination by the landlord generally requires a legitimate interest and compliance with the applicable notice period. Ask a lawyer to assess the consequences in your particular case.

    Can the tenant end a fixed-term tenancy early?

    Ordinary termination is generally excluded during a valid fixed term. Extraordinary or statutory special termination rights may apply where their respective conditions are met, for example following a refusal to permit subletting or certain rent increases. Not every refusal or increase qualifies. The parties can agree to end the tenancy; merely proposing a replacement tenant does not end the agreement.

    How long can a fixed-term tenancy last?

    Section 575 of the German Civil Code specifies no general maximum term. The duration must match the specific reason for the fixed term. For terms exceeding one year, the agreement's written-form requirement under section 550 must also be observed; otherwise, it is generally treated as indefinite, although termination cannot take effect before one year has elapsed since the accommodation was handed over. Whatever the duration, the reason must be disclosed in writing when the agreement is concluded.

    Must I contact the tenant before the term expires?

    Under section 575(2) of the German Civil Code, the landlord must respond to a qualifying request for information. No earlier than four months before expiry, the tenant may request confirmation within one month that the reason still applies. If the response is late, the tenant may demand an extension corresponding to the delay; the extension is not automatic.

    How does a fixed-term tenancy differ from a termination waiver?

    A valid fixed-term tenancy under section 575 of the German Civil Code generally ends automatically on the agreed date and requires a statutory reason. A termination waiver excludes ordinary termination for a specified period, while the tenancy remains indefinite. A standard-form waiver must generally not bind the tenant for more than four years from conclusion of the agreement to the earliest possible end of the tenancy.

    Does Germany's rent cap on new lettings apply to fixed-term tenancies?

    Yes. A fixed term under section 575 of the German Civil Code does not provide an exemption. The cap applies in designated areas unless a statutory exception applies; rules concerning the previous rent and modernisation may also be relevant. Accommodation genuinely let for temporary use is subject to a separate exception. A short tenancy alone is not enough.

    09Further reading

    10Sources

    • Section 575 BGB and section 575a BGB (fixed-term tenancy, extraordinary termination)
    • Section 549 BGB, section 550 BGB, section 573c BGB (exceptions, written form and notice periods)
    • Federal Court of Justice, judgment of 10 July 2013, VIII ZR 388/12 (supplementary interpretation where a fixed term is invalid)
    • Federal Court of Justice, judgment of 6 April 2005, VIII ZR 27/04 (general four-year limit for a standard-form termination waiver)
    • Section 32a EStG (income tax tariff)
    • Worked example: own calculation using the payment assumptions explained in the article

    This guide provides general information and does not replace individual legal, tax or investment advice. The cash-flow figures are simplified illustrations, not forecasts or promises of returns. Discuss contractual questions with a lawyer and tax consequences with a tax adviser.

    Written by
    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo

    Writes about Purchase process, Notary and land registry and Letting.

    Kevin combines twelve years of sales experience with nine years specialising in property and more than 500 consultations. He writes about property quality, location risks and a safe path from the first comparison to completion.

    This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.

    Free · Instant · No sign-up

    Download this guide as a PDF

    The complete guide as a clean A4 file – with a cover page, all chapters and page numbers. Keep it on hand, read it offline, or go through it at your own pace during your consultation.

    • All chapters, tables and worked examples
    • Read offline – on your phone or printed out
    • Go through it at your own pace or pass it on
    • Free, no sign-up, no email required

    A4 format · 3,416 words · As of 20 October 2026

    Related guides

    All guides