Berlin will: Disadvantages for property owners
How to plan spousal protection, tax allowances and liquidity together, with a transparent comparison across both deaths.
01How a Berlin will works
Under a Berlin will, spouses appoint each other as sole heirs and usually name their children as the ultimate heirs. Registered civil partners can also make a joint will; unmarried couples cannot. Under the usual single-estate arrangement, the children inherit only after the surviving spouse dies (section 2269 of the German Civil Code, BGB).
The surviving spouse becomes the full heir and can generally sell, mortgage or let properties. Their ability to change who inherits later may, however, be restricted. Gifts that prejudice the rights of ultimate heirs appointed under binding provisions may also give rise to recovery claims after the surviving spouse’s death.
The key is to separate financial provision, succession and taxation: a tax-efficient estate plan is of little help if it leaves the surviving spouse short of regular income.
02Disadvantage 1: Children’s allowances may go unused
Children generally have an inheritance tax allowance of €400,000 per parent, while spouses have an allowance of €500,000 (section 16 of the German Inheritance and Gift Tax Act, ErbStG). If children receive nothing on the first death, they do not use their allowance in relation to that parent for that inheritance.
When the surviving parent dies, their own assets and the assets previously inherited come together. This can increase both the children’s taxable acquisitions and the applicable tax rate. A higher tax bill is not inevitable, however: asset values, debts, previous gifts and tax exemptions all matter.
Treat the family home and rental properties differently
The surviving spouse’s acquisition of the family home may be exempt from tax (section 13(1), no. 4b ErbStG). In particular, the deceased must have lived there until death or have been prevented from doing so for compelling reasons. The recipient must designate it for their own residential use without undue delay and generally continue living there for ten years. Moving out earlier can result in the exemption being withdrawn retrospectively; compelling reasons preventing continued use may justify an exception.
Additional restrictions apply to children: the exemption covers no more than 200 m² of living space, although a proportionate exemption is possible for larger homes. Children must also satisfy the requirements for prompt owner-occupation and the retention period (section 13(1), no. 4c ErbStG).
Qualifying residential rental properties may be included at 90% of their tax value, subject to section 13d ErbStG. This is not a full exemption. Property values for tax purposes are also not automatically identical to purchase prices or estimated market values.

03Example: A house, three rental flats and two children
All figures below are illustrative assumptions, not market values or promises about tax outcomes. Gerd and Monika each own half of the following debt-free assets. Their two children together are both over 27.
| Asset | Assumed value | Value used in the model |
|---|---|---|
| Owner-occupied family home | €600,000 | €600,000 before the family home exemption |
| Three rental flats | €900,000 | €810,000 after section 13d ErbStG |
| Savings | €300,000 | €300,000 |
| Total | €1,800,000 | €1,710,000 |
The stated property values are assumed to be the values used for tax purposes. The rental flats are in Germany and meet the requirements of section 13d ErbStG.
Gerd dies first. The comparison is between:
- Option A — conventional Berlin will: Monika inherits everything; the two children later inherit her estate in equal shares.
- Option B — Berlin will with legacies: Monika remains the sole heir. On the first death, the children receive equal legacies consisting of Gerd’s shares in the flats and his savings. His half of the family home remains with Monika. No usufruct is included in this calculation.
A legacy does not make the children owners immediately. It creates a claim against the heir; the transfer of the property shares must subsequently be legally implemented and entered in the land register.
Assumptions for the tax calculation
To make the calculation transparent, the following additional assumptions apply:
- Monika meets the conditions for the family home exemption; neither child receives that exemption on the second death.
- There are no previous gifts to aggregate, additional debts or compulsory share claims that have been asserted.
- No tax-free equalisation of accrued gains arises under section 5 ErbStG in this model. Monika’s special survivor’s allowance under section 17 ErbStG is fully offset by qualifying tax-free survivor benefits.
- The flat-rate deduction for estate-related expenses of €15,000 per death is included. Monika bears the relevant expenses on the first death; on the second, the deduction is allocated equally between the children. No higher deductible expenses are assumed.
- The asset values and holdings on the second death are fixed as shown below. Spending, changes in value, additional savings and reductions in wealth caused by tax and expense payments are not rolled forward. This is a comparison of two snapshot models, not a wealth forecast.
Financial provision first: How much rent does Monika keep?
The three flats are assumed to generate total annual rent of €27,000, excluding service charges. After €4,500 of ongoing costs that cannot be passed on to tenants, €22,500 remains before income tax. Loan payments, additional major repairs and rent losses are not included and would need to be added to a personal financial plan.
| Annual cash flow for Monika | A: Berlin will | B: Legacies without usufruct |
|---|---|---|
| Rent from her ownership shares, excluding service charges | €27,000 | €13,500 |
| Costs not recoverable from tenants | −€4,500 | −€2,250 |
| Surplus before income tax | €22,500 | €11,250 |
In this model, Option B reduces Monika’s annual rental surplus by €11,250 before income tax. The income tax liability cannot be calculated directly from these figures: depreciation, other deductible expenses, other income and the applicable assessment arrangements must be considered separately.
Inheritance tax across both deaths
Under Option A, Monika receives a value of €855,000 on the first death after the valuation reduction for the rental flats. Deducting the €300,000 family home exemption, the €15,000 flat-rate estate expense deduction and the €500,000 personal allowance leaves €40,000 taxable. At 7%, inheritance tax is €2,800.
Under Option B, each child has an acquisition valued for tax purposes at €277,500 on the first death: €202,500 from the qualifying shares in the flats and €75,000 in savings. Both therefore remain below their personal allowance. Monika also pays no inheritance tax under the model assumptions.
| Calculation step | A: Berlin will | B: Legacies |
|---|---|---|
| Total tax on the first death | €2,800 | €0 |
| Estate value on the second death after section 13d ErbStG | €1,710,000 | €1,155,000 |
| Less flat-rate estate expense deduction | −€15,000 | −€15,000 |
| Acquisition per child before personal allowance | €847,500 | €570,000 |
| Personal allowance per child | −€400,000 | −€400,000 |
| Taxable acquisition per child | €447,500 | €170,000 |
| Tax rate under section 19 ErbStG | 15% | 11% |
| Tax on the second death, both children | €134,250 | €37,400 |
| Inheritance tax across both deaths | €137,050 | €37,400 |
The calculated difference is €99,650. It results from these specific assumptions and is not a general tax saving available through legacies. Different survivor benefits, tax-free equalisation of accrued gains, higher expenses or changed property values can all alter the outcome.
04Other disadvantages: Binding provisions, compulsory shares and liquidity
Binding provisions limit later changes
Reciprocal provisions are provisions one partner makes specifically in consideration of the other partner’s provision (section 2270 BGB). While both are alive, they can amend the will together. Unilateral revocation of reciprocal provisions generally requires a notarised declaration that reaches the other partner.
Binding effect generally arises after the first death (section 2271 BGB). An agreed amendment clause can preserve flexibility. A timely disclaimer of the inheritance can also release the survivor from the binding effect under the statutory conditions; it is not, however, a risk-free way to retain the inherited assets while redirecting their eventual distribution. Narrow statutory exceptions also exist.
Compulsory shares can require immediate cash
Children who are not appointed as heirs on the first death can generally claim a compulsory share in cash (section 2303 BGB).
With the additional assumption that the spouses are subject to the German community of accrued gains regime and have two children together, each child’s compulsory share here is 1/8 of the net estate under civil law. On an assumed €900,000 estate with no further deductible estate liabilities, that would be €112,500 per child. The tax valuation reduction for rental flats does not automatically reduce this calculation base.
A compulsory share penalty clause can make a claim less financially attractive, but cannot exclude the statutory entitlement. If a compulsory share is actually claimed, it can use the allowance in relation to the first parent to die. This must be coordinated with the will’s provisions and the surviving spouse’s liquidity.
Remarriage can create new claims
A new spouse may acquire compulsory share rights. Under certain conditions, testamentary provisions may also be challenged because a new person entitled to a compulsory share has entered the family. A remarriage clause should therefore address not only the children’s protection but also the survivor’s future financial provision and practical freedom of action.
Property cannot pay a tax bill on its own
Inheritance tax and compulsory shares must be paid in cash. Without sufficient reserves, borrowing or a sale may become necessary. For qualifying residential property, a deferral under section 28(3) ErbStG may be available on application for up to ten years, to the extent that the tax could otherwise only be paid by selling that property. This is no substitute for liquidity planning.

05Planning options that may help
| Planning element | Potential benefit | Important limitation |
|---|---|---|
| Legacies on the first death | Use allowances in relation to the first parent to die | Assets and potentially income leave the survivor’s control |
| Usufruct for the spouse | Retain rental income despite transferring ownership | Cost allocation, valuation and income tax require separate planning |
| Express power to amend | Adjust the ultimate succession within defined limits | Must be legally sound and sufficiently specific |
| Compulsory share penalty clause | Encourage children not to claim on the first death | Does not prevent the claim |
| Remarriage clause | Set out the consequences of a new marriage in advance | Can itself trigger transfer claims and liquidity needs |
A usufruct can preserve the surviving spouse’s right to rental income from transferred flats. Whether the previous net surplus remains available depends particularly on who bears ongoing costs and major repairs. The capital value of the usufruct may reduce the children’s taxable acquisition; the right granted to the spouse must also be assessed for their own tax position. The calculation above therefore cannot be applied unchanged to a usufruct arrangement.
Take care with deferred legacies: legacies that become due only when the surviving heir responsible for fulfilling them dies are generally treated as acquisitions from that survivor under section 6(4) ErbStG. They therefore normally do not use the allowance in relation to the first parent to die. Other due-date arrangements require separate assessment; not every delay has the same tax consequences.
Lifetime gifts can also help. Acquisitions from the same person within ten years are generally aggregated (section 14 ErbStG). Once the relevant period has elapsed, allowances may become available again. Where ultimate heirs have been appointed under binding provisions, the inheritance-law restrictions on gifts must also be considered.
Read more about these approaches in Gifting property with a usufruct and Leaving property by inheritance or making a lifetime gift.
06When a Berlin will may be suitable
It may be appropriate where the spouse’s financial security takes priority, the children should not receive assets immediately and the anticipated taxable acquisitions remain within the available allowances.
An individual review is particularly important where there are several properties, children from previous relationships, substantial increases in value or changed family circumstances. Giving children co-ownership shares also creates a need to agree on letting, repairs and sales.
A joint handwritten will must generally be written entirely by hand by one partner and signed by both. The place and date should be included. A notarised will, together with the court’s record of its opening, can often replace a certificate of inheritance for land registry purposes; further evidence may nevertheless be required if doubts remain.
Conclusion: A Berlin will is a tool for protecting a spouse, not automatically the most tax-efficient succession arrangement. Have financial provision, compulsory shares, binding effects and both deaths assessed together by a German notary or specialist lawyer and a tax adviser. This guide explains general principles as at October 2026 and does not replace individual advice.
07Free initial consultation on property planning
A free initial consultation can help you assess the ongoing income, costs and liquidity requirements of your rental properties. Legal and tax advice on succession remains the responsibility of a notary or specialist lawyer and a tax adviser. Arrange an initial consultation.
FAQFrequently asked questions
What is the main disadvantage of a Berlin will for property owners?
For larger estates, children’s tax allowances in relation to the first parent to die may go unused. On the second death, the assets are combined in the surviving parent’s estate. Whether this creates additional tax depends on asset values, debts, previous gifts and exemptions.
Can children claim a compulsory share under a Berlin will?
Yes. If they are not appointed as heirs on the first death, they can generally claim their compulsory share in cash from the surviving parent. A compulsory share penalty clause may discourage a claim, but does not remove the statutory entitlement.
Can the surviving spouse change a Berlin will?
Reciprocal provisions are generally binding after the first death. A valid express power to amend may allow changes. A timely disclaimer of the inheritance and narrow statutory exceptions may offer other possibilities, but require individual legal assessment.
Does the spouse inherit the family home tax-free?
This is possible if the statutory conditions are met. In particular, the deceased must have used the family home themselves or have been prevented from doing so for compelling reasons. The surviving spouse must designate it for their own residential use without undue delay and generally live there for ten years. Moving out earlier may result in retrospective withdrawal of the exemption.
Are legacies with a usufruct better than a conventional Berlin will?
They can use children’s allowances on the first death while preserving rental income for the spouse. Whether the arrangement is better overall depends on the usufruct’s valuation and tax treatment, the allocation of costs and the survivor’s financial needs. Unchanged net rental income or a tax saving is not guaranteed.
Does a Berlin will have to be notarised?
No. Generally, one partner can write the entire joint will by hand and both can sign it. The place and date should be included. For property, a notarised will together with the court’s record of its opening can often replace a certificate of inheritance in land registry proceedings.

Writes about Taxes, AfA (depreciation), Financing and Investment concept.
Andriy is Managing Director of the InvestImmo Group and has been an entrepreneur in the property industry since 2020. His experience in estate agency, property marketing and his own investments shapes his view on property selection and long-term investment concepts. His team handles the personal advice for investors.
This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.



