Guide · Erben und Schenken

    Property in a Testament: Allocation and Vermächtnis

    Coordinate property ownership, equalisation and financing through clear German succession arrangements and transparent illustrative calculations.


    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo
    2 November 202612 min read
    Illustrative assumptions: three apartments, two children, one grandchild
    €20,000
    Equalisation in scenario 1
    Paul pays Lena if she receives all remaining cash
    €380,000
    Assets per child in scenario 1
    before costs and taxes
    €320,000
    Difference between the children in scenario 2
    Lena receives €540,000, Paul €220,000
    €40,000
    Cash Vermächtnis for Noah
    in both scenarios

    You own several rented apartments. You want your daughter to receive the largest, your son the two smaller ones, and your grandchild some money for education. Your Testament therefore says: “My daughter receives the apartment on Lindenstraße.”

    That sentence leaves important questions unanswered. Is your daughter an heir or a Vermächtnisnehmerin, the beneficiary of a specific testamentary gift? Should she receive more wealth than her brother? Must she make an equalisation payment? And who bears any outstanding financing?

    For property investors, three aspects need to work together: legal allocation, economic distribution and liquidity after death. Equal property values do not necessarily produce equal disposable rental income.

    01Why “receives the apartment” is not enough

    Heirs generally succeed to the estate as a whole. Where there are several heirs, the estate initially belongs to the Erbengemeinschaft, the community of co-heirs. This is distinct from allocating a particular apartment. A Vermächtnisnehmer instead has a claim against whoever must fulfil the Vermächtnis, usually the heirs.

    Under § 2087 BGB, leaving individual assets to someone generally points away from appointing that person as an heir where the intention is doubtful. However, distributing virtually all assets individually may still amount to an appointment of heirs when the whole Testament is interpreted. There is no automatic rule equating an apartment’s value with an inheritance percentage. Express inheritance shares and separate property-allocation provisions avoid relying on that interpretation.

    02Three tools for allocating property

    Teilungsanordnung, Vorausvermächtnis and Vermächtnis
    QuestionTeilungsanordnungVorausvermächtnisVermächtnis to a non-heir
    Who benefits?A co-heir when the estate is dividedAn heir in addition to participation in the remaining estateA person outside the group of heirs
    Does the inheritance percentage change?NoNo; the economic benefit can increaseNo; the estate becomes subject to a claim
    Equalisation?Where needed to preserve inheritance sharesGenerally no offset where the gift is clearly additionalDepends on the terms of the Vermächtnis
    Legal basis§ 2048 BGB§ 2150 BGB§ 2174 BGB
    Implementation for propertyErbauseinandersetzung and transfer of ownershipFulfilment of the VermächtnisFulfilment of the Vermächtnis
    Tax issue to examineInheritance share and allocation of reliefAdditional acquisition and the associated obligationSeparate acquisition and personal allowances

    These distinctions follow from the relevant succession rules. Tax treatment is not determined solely by the heading used in the Testament.

    A Teilungsanordnung is a starting point where the children should receive equal economic value. A Vorausvermächtnis is worth considering where one child should deliberately receive something additional. A Vermächtnis can benefit a grandchild, unmarried partner or another person without making them a co-heir.

    The arrangement may also concern a right to use a property rather than ownership. For example, discuss whether a Nießbrauch, a right to use the property and receive its income, fits the intended support arrangements. See the glossaries on Nießbrauch and Berliner Testament.

    Receipts and documents for the tax assessment of a rental property
    AI-generated illustrative image

    03Worked example: three apartments and three beneficiaries

    Illustrative assumptions, not a market valuation or an offer: Helga is widowed. Her children are Lena and Paul, and her grandchild is Noah. The estate contains three debt-free apartments with assumed market values of €320,000 for A, €220,000 for B and €180,000 for C, plus €80,000 in cash. Total assets are €800,000. Noah receives a €40,000 cash Vermächtnis. This asset-distribution calculation excludes other liabilities and estate-administration costs.

    Scenario 1: Each child inherits one half. Lena receives A and the cash remaining after Noah’s Vermächtnis; Paul receives B and C. Any difference in value is equalised.

    Scenario 2: Lena receives A as an additional Vorausvermächtnis. Both children remain equal heirs and share the estate remaining after both Vermächtnisse have been fulfilled.

    In scenario 1, Paul must fund the equalisation separately because all estate cash goes to Noah and Lena. The €20,000 payment therefore depends on this particular cash allocation; it cannot be inferred from the apartment values alone.

    In scenario 2, Paul does not automatically become sole owner of both smaller apartments. The calculation allocates only half of the remaining assets to him. If he is to own B and C outright, an additional division arrangement and potentially further equalisation are needed. Lena receives €320,000 more than Paul, but €160,000 more than she receives in scenario 1.

    First, rental cash flow

    Illustrative assumptions: For scenario 1, annual rent excluding service charges is €12,000 for A and €15,300 for B and C together. All modelled running costs are assumed immediately deductible for income-tax purposes. The AfA figures are assumptions only. Additional income tax is modelled at a flat 40% of taxable rental profit to demonstrate the mechanics; this is expressly not an individual German income-tax calculation.

    Paul has the higher annual surplus in this model. However, he holds two apartments and must fund the one-off equalisation payment. Add a separate liquidity plan showing what remains after loan payments, planned building works and a chosen cash reserve. The annual rental calculation does not replace that exercise.

    Then, Erbschaftsteuer

    Illustrative valuation assumptions: The apartments are in Germany, are privately held and satisfy § 13d ErbStG. Exceptionally for this example, their assessed property values equal the assumed market values. The following 90% valuation applies only on those assumptions.

    Where unlimited German inheritance-tax liability applies, a child generally has a personal allowance of €400,000. A grandchild whose intervening parent is still alive generally has an allowance of €200,000. Earlier acquisitions and personal circumstances must also be checked.

    A Teilungsanordnung does not change inheritance percentages. However, that does not mean every tax relief can simply be divided in half: § 13d(2) contains rules governing relief when the estate is divided. Deductibility of obligations arising from Vermächtnisse and estate expenses also affects the taxable acquisition. Consequently, this example deliberately does not state a final inheritance-tax bill for either child.

    The choice still matters for tax planning. Lena’s additional acquisition can use more of her allowance. A reliable comparison requires a Steuerberater to calculate both arrangements using the actual assessed values, expenses, earlier gifts and precise distribution.

    04Loans, sales before death and other pitfalls

    Who pays the loan? A security interest over property, personal liability for a loan and the internal allocation of costs are separate matters. § 2165 BGB generally does not give the beneficiary a right to demand an unencumbered transfer. § 2166 contains an interpretation rule for certain debts secured by a Hypothek. It cannot simply be applied to every Sicherungsgrundschuld. Releasing the existing borrower through an assumption of debt generally requires the lender’s consent.

    Have the documents expressly address who bears instalments internally, who funds repayment and what happens if the bank refuses consent. Where a Teilungsanordnung is used, outstanding debt should also be reflected in the economic equalisation calculation.

    The apartment is no longer in the estate. A Vermächtnis of a specific apartment can fail if that apartment no longer belongs to the estate at death. § 2169 BGB provides a rule for cases of doubt. Sale proceeds do not automatically replace the apartment. Have an alternative provision drafted for a sale, replacement purchase or other change.

    AfA and the disposal period. On a gratuitous acquisition, the predecessor’s depreciation position generally continues. For § 23 EStG, the predecessor’s acquisition is generally attributed to the successor. An estate division involving equalisation from personal funds can instead create a partly paid acquisition. The building component, depreciation and relevant disposal period then require separate analysis.

    Grunderwerbsteuer. Acquisitions on death and property transfers between co-heirs to divide an estate are generally covered by the exemptions in § 3 nos. 2 and 3 GrEStG. A later, separate purchase is not exempt merely because the parties previously inherited together.

    Reviewing financing documents and monthly costs together
    AI-generated illustrative image

    05Structuring a Testament with several properties

    1. Prepare an inventory. Record Grundbuch details, ownership shares, estimated values, outstanding loans, rents and foreseeable capital expenditure. Distinguish estimates from tax valuations.
    2. Set the distribution objective. Should the children receive equal wealth, or should someone receive an additional benefit? Must a particular apartment remain in one person’s ownership?
    3. Expressly identify heirs and shares. Separate appointment of heirs from allocation of individual apartments.
    4. Resolve equalisation and financing. Specify the valuation method, payment date and any instalments. Discuss the implications of borrowing and insufficient liquidity.
    5. Plan for alternatives. What should happen after a sale, a beneficiary’s earlier death or an Ausschlagung, meaning rejection of the inheritance?
    6. Check form and implementation. An eigenhändiges Testament must generally be written entirely by hand and signed. A notarielles Testament is an alternative. Subsequent transfer of property under a Vermächtnis generally requires an Auflassung, the formal agreement to transfer ownership, and entry in the Grundbuch.

    Do not assume that choosing a particular form of Testament eliminates every later evidential requirement or notarial cost. Ask in advance which documents the Grundbuchamt will require in the circumstances.

    06Which tool fits which objective?

    Start with the economic objective
    ObjectiveStarting point for drafting
    Equal wealth for the childrenTeilungsanordnung with a clear equalisation mechanism
    An additional benefit for one childAn unambiguous Vorausvermächtnis
    A gift to someone outside the group of heirsVermächtnis defining the benefit precisely
    Sole ownership of an apartment for one childSpecific transfer and financing arrangements, not merely a share of the remainder
    Support without immediate transfer of ownershipExamine a right of use as a separate option

    This is an orientation aid, not individual drafting advice. Earlier gifts, family obligations and available cash may matter more than the number of apartments.

    07Risks and limits

    Pflichtteil. Under the conditions of § 2306 BGB, an heir entitled to a Pflichtteil who faces specified restrictions or obligations may reject the inheritance and claim this compulsory monetary entitlement. This is not restricted to cases where the economic inheritance is below the Pflichtteil. Deadlines and consequences must be checked before rejecting an inheritance.

    Illustrative Pflichtteil calculation: Under the simplified family assumptions, Paul’s statutory inheritance share is one half and his Pflichtteil is one quarter of the relevant estate. For an estate of €800,000 with no other deductible liabilities, that is €200,000, not €190,000. Testamentary Vermächtnisse are not simply deducted beforehand for this purpose. Paul’s modelled acquisition of €220,000 does not remove the need to examine his legal options.

    Values change. Review the plan after significant sales, purchases, building investment or family changes. Define the valuation date and method to be used for equalisation.

    Rental property needs liquidity. Allow for missed rent, non-recoverable costs, maintenance and possible Sonderumlagen, special assessments by the owners’ association. A high property value does not itself pay an equalisation claim when due.

    Applicable law and future changes. The law applicable to the particular acquisition determines the outcome. This guide makes no prediction about future allowances or tax rates and does not base planning on unconfirmed court or reform reports.

    FAQFrequently asked questions

    How do Teilungsanordnung and Vorausvermächtnis differ?

    A Teilungsanordnung allocates estate assets while preserving inheritance shares. A clearly additional Vorausvermächtnis benefits an heir without counting towards that heir’s share. It does not itself change the inheritance percentages.

    Does a Vermächtnis immediately transfer apartment ownership?

    No. It generally creates a claim to transfer. An apartment transfer normally requires an Auflassung, the formal ownership-transfer agreement, and entry in the Grundbuch.

    Is inherited property under a Vermächtnis subject to tax?

    A Vermächtnis can be subject to Erbschaftsteuer. Actual liability depends on assessed values, personal allowances, earlier acquisitions and deductible obligations. The 90% valuation applies only where § 13d ErbStG requirements are met.

    Does fulfilling a Vermächtnis trigger Grunderwerbsteuer?

    Acquisitions on death are generally exempt under § 3 no. 2 GrEStG. Transfers between co-heirs to divide an estate generally fall under no. 3. Additional or later independent transactions require separate examination.

    What if the specified apartment is sold before death?

    If the apartment no longer belongs to the estate at death, the specific Vermächtnis may fail under § 2169 BGB. Sale proceeds do not automatically replace it. An express alternative provision can clarify the intended outcome.

    Who bears an outstanding property loan?

    That depends on the Testament, loan agreement and security arrangements. Property security, personal loan liability and internal cost allocation are separate questions. Releasing the existing borrower through an assumption of debt generally requires the bank’s consent.

    08Further reading

    09Sources

    Editorial date: 28 October 2026. General information, not individual tax, legal or investment advice. All model calculations use expressly stated assumptions and are neither offers nor promises of returns.

    Written by
    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo

    Writes about Purchase process, Notary and land registry and Letting.

    Kevin combines twelve years of sales experience with nine years specialising in property and more than 500 consultations. He writes about property quality, location risks and a safe path from the first comparison to completion.

    This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.

    Free · Instant · No sign-up

    Download this guide as a PDF

    The complete guide as a clean A4 file – with a cover page, all chapters and page numbers. Keep it on hand, read it offline, or go through it at your own pace during your consultation.

    • All chapters, tables and worked examples
    • Read offline – on your phone or printed out
    • Go through it at your own pace or pass it on
    • Free, no sign-up, no email required

    A4 format · 2,745 words · As of 02 November 2026

    Related guides

    All guides