Dissolving a community of heirs: sell the property, buy out co-heirs or keep it
Three siblings, one rented flat and no shared plan. We explain the four ways out of a community of heirs, what each costs and which tax implications are often overlooked.
Your mother has left a tenanted flat, and there are now three names in the land register. Your sister needs money and wants to sell. Your brother wants to keep the flat because it has reliably generated rental income for years. And you are wondering who actually has the authority to call in a tradesperson if a pipe bursts in the bathroom.
This is how almost every community of heirs involving a property begins. The law does not force anyone to stay together forever. But it does not make leaving easy either, because the heirs can only dispose of the flat jointly.
In this guide, we explore the four ways out of the community of heirs, use an example to calculate what each option yields, and explain the tax consequences that are often overlooked when buying out co-heirs.
01What a community of heirs means when property is involved
If several people inherit, the estate as a whole passes to all of them jointly (§§ 1922, 2032 BGB). Lawyers call this joint ownership of the undivided estate (Gesamthand). This means that no co-heir owns a specific part of the flat, such as the living room. Instead, they all own everything jointly, each with a proportional share of the estate.
In everyday terms, this means two things. The heirs can only sell or encumber the flat jointly (§ 2040 BGB). For ongoing management, however, a majority is sufficient, calculated according to the size of their shares of the estate (§§ 2038, 745 BGB). Any heir can arrange urgent measures, such as dealing with the burst pipe, on their own.
| Question | Who decides? | Legal basis |
|---|---|---|
| Selling the flat, registering a land charge | all jointly | § 2040 BGB |
| Finding a new tenant, adjusting the rent, appointing a property manager | majority based on shares of the estate | §§ 2038, 745 BGB |
| Emergency repairs, meeting a deadline | any co-heir acting alone | § 2038 para. 1 sentence 2 BGB |
| Demanding dissolution | any co-heir acting alone, at any time | § 2042 BGB |
| Selling their own share of the estate | any co-heir acting alone, with notarisation | § 2033 BGB |
There is one limitation. If the deceased ruled out division of the estate in their will, this generally applies for a maximum of 30 years (§ 2044 BGB). And before any distribution, the estate’s debts must be settled first, for example an outstanding loan on the flat (§ 2046 BGB).
02The four ways out of a community of heirs
The best option depends primarily on whether the heirs agree and whether one of them wants to keep the flat and can afford to do so.
| Option | When it is suitable | Costs and consequences |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Joint sale | Everyone wants money rather than the flat. | Estate agent fees depending on the contract, sale with the tenant in place, proceeds divided according to shares. |
| 2. Takeover with a buyout | One co-heir wants to keep the flat and can buy out the others. | Notarised agreement, no land register fees within two years, no property transfer tax. See below for tax consequences. |
| 3. Selling a share of the estate | One heir wants to leave, but the others do not want to sell. | Notarised agreement (§ 2033 BGB), co-heirs have a two-month right of first refusal (§ 2034 BGB). Buyers are difficult to find. |
| 4. Partition auction | No agreement is possible. | Court costs, valuation report, proceeds often below market value, months to years. |
Option 1: sell jointly
Selling is the simplest option if everyone agrees. All co-heirs sign the sale agreement before a notary. After deducting the estate’s debts, they divide the proceeds according to their shares.
If the flat is tenanted, the buyers are usually investors. The tenancy agreement passes to the buyer (§ 566 BGB). This reduces the pool of potential buyers somewhat, as owner-occupiers are excluded, but provides a predictable basis for valuation using the rental income.
Option 2: let one co-heir take over
One co-heir takes over the flat and buys out the others. This is the option most families look for when one person is attached to the property. The contract is called an estate division agreement (Erbauseinandersetzungsvertrag) and must be notarised because ownership of property is being transferred.
Two advantages make it cost-effective. No property transfer tax is payable because co-heirs, as well as their spouses, are exempt when the estate is divided (§ 3 No. 3 GrEStG). And registration in the land register is free of charge within the two-year period.
Option 3: sell your own share of the estate
Anyone who wants to leave independently can sell their share of the entire estate, but not a share of the flat (§ 2033 BGB). The agreement requires a notary. If they sell to an outsider, the remaining co-heirs can exercise their right to buy on the same terms within two months (§ 2034 BGB).
In practice, this option is difficult. An outside buyer takes a place in a community of heirs in dispute and usually pays considerably less than the calculated value.
Option 4: partition auction
If no agreement is reached, any co-heir can apply to the local court for the flat to be auctioned (§ 753 BGB, §§ 180 et seq. ZVG). The proceeds are then distributed among the heirs. We explain the process, costs and tenants’ rights in detail in our guide to partition auctions.

03Worked example: what a sale and a buyout yield
„Can I leave it to someone in my will or give it away?“
We regularly hear this question in consultations about buy-to-let flats. The answer is yes. However, anyone with several children should be aware that, on their death, a flat will become part of a community of heirs unless the will provides otherwise.
Take three siblings, Jana, Tim and Lukas. They inherit equal shares in a tenanted flat with no outstanding debt. A valuation report puts its market value at €240,000. The tenants pay €9,000 a year in rent excluding service charges. The names are fictional, and the figures are a worked example, not a forecast.
Lukas wants to keep the flat. Jana and Tim want money. We compare a joint sale with a takeover by Lukas.
| Sale to a third party | Takeover by Lukas | |
|---|---|---|
| Market value or purchase price | €240,000 | €240,000 |
| Seller’s estate agent commission (3.57%, assumed) | −€8,568 | €0 |
| Notary for estate division agreement (2.0 fee multiplier, net) | paid by the buyer | −€1,070 |
| Land register (within 2 years) | paid by the buyer | €0 |
| Property transfer tax | paid by the buyer | €0 |
| Amount each for Jana and Tim | €77,144 | €80,000 |
| Lukas pays out | – | €160,000 + €1,070 notary fee |
For Jana and Tim, the takeover by Lukas is actually slightly better than a sale because there is no estate agent commission. Lukas, however, has to raise €160,000. If he does not have the money, he needs a loan, for which he can use the flat itself as security once he is registered as the owner.
The value used in the calculation is important. A takeover price that is too low means a loss for the siblings being bought out; one that is too high means a loss for the person taking over. A market valuation report costs money, but establishes a basis that leaves no further room for dispute.
04Taxes when dividing an estate
This is where most guides stop. For Lukas, however, the calculations are only just beginning, because buying out the other heirs changes his tax position.
The Bundesfinanzhof treats payments to buy out co-heirs as a purchase price (decision of 05.07.1990, GrS 2/89). Lukas therefore has his own acquisition costs for two thirds of the flat: the €160,000 buyout payment plus the notary’s fees. For the remaining third, which he inherited, he carries forward his mother’s figures (§ 11d EStDV).
| Basis | Annual depreciation allowance | |
|---|---|---|
| Inherited third: mother’s acquisition costs of €150,000 × 75% building share × 1/3 | €37,500 | €750 |
| Two thirds acquired through the buyout: €161,070 × 75% building share | €120,803 | €2,416 |
| Total depreciation (2%, built after 1924) | €3,166 | |
| For comparison: mother’s depreciation allowance for the entire flat | €2,250 |
The higher depreciation reduces his tax on the rental income. But there is a downside. A new ten-year holding period for capital gains tax purposes begins for the two thirds Lukas paid for (§ 23 EStG). If he sells the flat within this period, he must pay tax on the gain attributable to this portion. For the inherited third, his mother’s holding period continues; she bought in 2008. This portion would be tax-free on sale.
The siblings being bought out should also look closely. For them, the buyout payment counts as sale proceeds for tax purposes. If their mother bought the flat less than ten years ago, Jana and Tim could realise a taxable gain. In this example, she bought in 2008, so the holding period has expired. Our guide Selling or letting an inherited property explains how to calculate the holding period for inherited flats.

05Continuing to let jointly: which rules apply?
Not every community of heirs has to be dissolved immediately. Some siblings deliberately keep the flat, for example because it has a reliable tenancy and nobody needs the money. Clear rules help in this situation.
The tenancy agreement continues with all the heirs as landlords (§ 1922 BGB). The tenants do not need to sign anything. However, they should be told which account to pay the rent into now and who their contact person is.
- 01Set up an estate account
A joint account into which the rent is paid and from which service charges, property tax and repair costs are paid.
- 02Appoint a contact person
By majority decision, a co-heir or a property manager can take over the day-to-day management of the letting (§§ 2038, 745 BGB).
- 03Agree how to distribute the rent
Without an agreement, income is only divided when the estate is divided (§ 2038 para. 2 BGB). A written agreement on annual distributions provides peace of mind.
- 04Coordinate tax returns
Rental income is assessed jointly for everyone and then allocated according to their shares (§ 180 para. 1 no. 2a AO). One person submits the joint assessment return, and each person pays tax on their share.
- 05Agree exit arrangements in advance
If you want to prevent anyone from applying for an auction immediately, set out in an agreement the conditions under which a co-heir may exit and the valuation to be used.
In this example, €9,000 in rent excluding service charges leaves €8,000 before tax after €1,000 in non-recoverable costs, or around €2,667 a year for each of the three heirs. How much remains after tax depends on each person’s individual tax rate. This can be checked separately for each person using the Rental income calculator.
06Which option suits whom?
- all heirs get on well and want to let the property long term
- the flat is debt-free and has a reliable tenancy
- a co-heir or a property manager looks after it reliably
- a co-heir needs the money or wants to leave
- the heirs live far apart and rarely communicate
- major repairs or decisions by the owners’ association are coming up
07Risks: what to watch out for
A prolonged dispute is usually the most expensive option. As long as the community of heirs is deadlocked, rent increases, repairs and decisions at owners’ meetings are left unresolved. During this time, an empty flat incurs service charges and property tax without generating any rent.
| Risk | What happens | What helps |
|---|---|---|
| Dispute over the value | Takeover falls through, auction becomes a risk | A market valuation report by a qualified valuer |
| Estate debts | Mother’s loan continues, bank demands payment | Settle debts before distribution (§ 2046 BGB) |
| New holding period for capital gains tax | Sale of the acquired portion within ten years is taxable | Plan the holding period before taking over |
| Financing the buyout | The heir taking over cannot obtain a loan | Check financing before the notary appointment |
| Two-year deadline missed | Land register entry incurs a full fee | Apply for the correction early |
| Vacancy and maintenance | Ongoing costs without income | Appoint a property manager, keep a reserve in the estate account |
FAQFrequently asked questions
Can one co-heir force the sale of the property alone?
They cannot sell it alone, but they can demand that the community of heirs be dissolved (§ 2042 BGB). If the others refuse, their remaining option is a court-ordered partition auction at the local court.
How long does it take to dissolve a community of heirs?
If everyone agrees, it often takes only a few months to reach the notary appointment and registration. A court-ordered partition auction usually takes considerably longer because a valuation report must be prepared and co-heirs can apply for a temporary stay of proceedings.
Is property transfer tax payable when one co-heir takes over the property?
No. Co-heirs who acquire a property as part of the division of the estate are exempt, as are their spouses (§ 3 No. 3 GrEStG).
Who receives the rent while the community of heirs exists?
The rent belongs to the estate. Unless otherwise agreed, it is not distributed until the estate is divided (§ 2038 para. 2 BGB). For tax purposes, however, it is still allocated to each heir every year in proportion to their share.
Can the community of heirs terminate the tenants’ tenancy?
A tenancy can only be terminated on statutory grounds, for example if a co-heir needs the property for their own use. Whether a majority is sufficient or everyone must consent depends on the individual case. Have this checked by a legal professional beforehand.
What does it cost to sell an inheritance share?
The contract must be notarised. The notary’s fee depends on the value of the inheritance share. The other co-heirs have two months to exercise their right of first refusal (§ 2034 BGB).
Do I have to pay tax if I am bought out?
For tax purposes, the buyout payment counts as sale proceeds. It becomes taxable if the deceased bought the property less than ten years ago and a profit is made (§ 23 EStG).
08Further reading
- Auction to dissolve joint ownership: process, costs and rights
- Selling or letting an inherited property
- Passing on property through inheritance and gifts
- Property holding period for capital gains tax
- Community of heirs in the glossary
- Estate in the glossary
09Sources
All sources accessed on 14.10.2026.
- § 2032 BGB to § 2042 BGB (community of heirs), particularly § 2033, § 2034, § 2038, § 2040 BGB; § 2044, § 2046 BGB
- § 745 BGB, § 753 BGB, § 566 BGB, § 1922 BGB
- § 3 GrEStG (no. 3, co-heirs)
- GNotKG, schedule of fees no. 14110 with note 1
- § 23 EStG, § 11d EStDV, § 180 AO, § 16 ErbStG
- § 180 ZVG (auction to dissolve joint ownership)
- BFH, decision of 05.07.1990, GrS 2/89 (division of an estate, buyout payment as acquisition costs)
- BMF letter of 14.03.2006, IV B 2 - S 2242 - 7/06, BStBl I 2006, 253 (division of an estate)
- Example calculation: own assumptions, as at 14.10.2026
Disclaimer: This guide provides general information and is not a substitute for legal or tax advice. All figures are illustrative calculations with disclosed assumptions, as at 14.10.2026.

Writes about Purchase process, Notary and land registry and Letting.
Kevin combines twelve years of sales experience with nine years specialising in property and more than 500 consultations. He writes about property quality, location risks and a safe path from the first comparison to completion.
This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.



