Guide · Erben und Schenken

    Pflichtteil and Property: Calculate and Fund the Claim

    How property is valued, when gifts count and how heirs can prepare to fund a German compulsory-share claim.


    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo
    4 November 202613 min read
    Illustrative assumptions: two rented apartments, one heir, one Pflichtteil
    €150,000
    Daughter's Pflichtteil
    including the gift supplement
    €30,000
    Amount attributable to a gift
    made 4.5 years before death
    €10,440
    Heir's cash flow before tax
    without a Pflichtteil loan
    €4,060
    With a Pflichtteil loan
    €110,000 at 3.8%

    Imagine this fictional situation: your father has left you two rented apartments, and his Testament names only you as heir. Your sister has been excluded. A few weeks after the funeral, a letter arrives from her lawyer. She requests information about the estate, a valuation and payment of her Pflichtteil in cash.

    Many heirs are unprepared for this. The wealth is tied up in apartments, there is little money in the bank, and the claim is immediately due. Understanding the calculation helps both heirs and owners arranging their estate during their lifetime.

    01Who qualifies and how much they receive

    Potential claimants include the deceased's descendants, spouse or registered civil partner, and parents. Closer descendants can exclude more distant descendants and parents; in particular, parents generally do not qualify where descendants entitled to inherit exist. Siblings have no Pflichtteil. The classic case is exclusion from succession by a Testament or Erbvertrag, a binding inheritance agreement. Claims can also arise where an inheritance share is too small or following certain disclaimers of an inheritance.

    The Pflichtteil equals half the statutory inheritance share. Family circumstances and the matrimonial property regime determine that share. Under Zugewinngemeinschaft, the German statutory matrimonial regime, a surviving spouse inherits one quarter alongside children (§ 1931 BGB), plus another quarter as a flat-rate adjustment for accrued gains (§ 1371 BGB). The children divide the remainder equally.

    Pflichtteil shares in common family situations
    Family at deathStatutory share per childPflichtteil per childSpouse's Pflichtteil
    Widowed, 1 child1/11/2–
    Widowed, 2 children1/21/4–
    Widowed, 3 children1/31/6–
    Married under Zugewinngemeinschaft, 2 children, spouse is sole heir1/41/8–
    Married under Zugewinngemeinschaft, 2 children are sole heirs, spouse excluded– (heirs)–1/8 plus actual Zugewinnausgleich

    The final row is a special case. An excluded spouse receives the kleiner Pflichtteil, calculated without the flat-rate increase, and can also claim the actual adjustment for accrued gains, or Zugewinnausgleich (§ 1371(2) BGB). For the implications of a joint spousal will, see Berliner Testament.

    02How the property is valued

    The assets and value of the estate on the date of death determine the Pflichtteil (§ 2311 BGB). For property, this means Verkehrswert: the price achievable on the market. The tax office's inheritance-tax valuation and the 10% inheritance-tax discount for qualifying rented residential property do not apply here. The deceased's debts are deducted.

    An expert valuation can help resolve a disagreement; in litigation, the court determines the relevant value. A sale price achieved close to the date of death under normal market conditions can provide important evidence, but is not automatically binding. The deceased cannot prescribe the value themselves (§ 2311(2) BGB).

    The claimant has a right to information (§ 2314 BGB). They can request an inventory of the estate, prepared by a notary if requested, and a valuation. The estate bears these costs, economically affecting the heir. For rented apartments, relevant documents include Mietverträge, Hausgeldabrechnungen and outstanding loan balances: rental agreements, statements of owners' association charges and financing records.

    Receipts and documents for the tax assessment of a rental property
    AI-generated illustrative image

    03Gifts and the ten-year period

    Parents can reduce their estate by making lifetime gifts. The Pflichtteilsergänzungsanspruch limits the resulting erosion of protected inheritance rights (§ 2325 BGB). Qualifying gifts are notionally added to the estate, and the claimant receives their applicable share of that additional amount.

    Tapering. A gift made within the final year before death counts in full. Its inclusion falls by one tenth for each additional year. Once the relevant ten-year period has elapsed, it is no longer included (§ 2325(3) BGB).

    Lower-value principle. For property, the value at the time of the gift is generally compared with the value at death, and the lower value applies (§ 2325(2) BGB). The gift-date value must be adjusted to purchasing power at the date of death. Retained rights of use can further affect valuation. Simply comparing the two nominal prices is therefore insufficient.

    To the extent that the heir is not obliged to provide the supplement, a subsidiary claim against the recipient may arise under § 2329 BGB. A mere liquidity shortage on the heir's part does not automatically suffice. Someone who received an apartment as a gift without becoming an heir can therefore also face a claim.

    04Illustrative calculation: two apartments and one claim

    Werner is widowed and has two children, Markus and Petra. He leaves two rented apartments with market values of €300,000 and €260,000, a bank balance of €40,000 and a €120,000 loan. His Testament appoints Markus as sole heir. Four and a half years before his death, he also gave Markus a third apartment. We assume its gift-date value, already adjusted to purchasing power at death, is €200,000, and its market value at death is €220,000. No rights of use were retained. Other deductible estate costs and gifts are excluded from this example. The names are fictional and the figures are illustrative assumptions, not a market forecast or offer.

    The financing calculation covers only the two inherited apartments. Any income, expenses and borrowing associated with the previously gifted third apartment are excluded.

    Illustrative assumptions: Petra's Pflichtteil
    Amount
    Apartments at market value€560,000
    Bank balance€40,000
    Loan−€120,000
    Estate€480,000
    Pflichtteil: statutory share of 1/2 × 1/2 = 1/4€120,000
    Gift to Markus: lower, purchasing-power-adjusted value of €200,000; fifth year before death: 6/10€120,000
    Pflichtteilsergänzung: 1/4 × €120,000€30,000
    Petra's total claim€150,000
    Editorial calculation based on §§ 2303, 2311 and 2325 BGB; dated 28 October 2026.

    Without the gift supplement, Petra would receive €120,000. The gift increases her claim by €30,000 even though it occurred four and a half years earlier. A comprehensively retained Nießbrauch could prevent the time-based reduction. The supplement would then need to be recalculated, taking the valuation of the retained right into account.

    Illustrative financing calculation: paying the claim

    Markus has €40,000 in the bank and must pay €150,000. For the remaining €110,000, we assume a loan with 3.8% interest and 2% initial principal repayment. These are calculation assumptions, not current market terms or a financing commitment. Annual debt service is €6,380. Higher interest would place more pressure on cash flow. No liquidity reserve or financing fees are included.

    Illustrative assumptions: Markus's year with the inherited apartments
    Without the Pflichtteil paymentWith the Pflichtteil loan
    Net rent from both apartments€21,000€21,000
    Costs not recoverable from tenants−€3,600−€3,600
    Existing loan payments (€120,000 loan)−€6,960−€6,960
    Pflichtteil loan payments (€110,000 loan)−€6,380
    Cash flow before tax€10,440€4,060
    Additional income tax at an assumed 42% on €6,840 rental profit−€2,873−€2,873
    Cash flow after tax€7,567€1,187
    Illustrative simplified annual calculation: assumed marginal tax rate of 42%; depreciation of €6,000; interest on the existing loan of €4,560; principal repayment on that loan of €2,400. Rental profit: €21,000 − €3,600 − €4,560 − €6,000 = €6,840. Additional income tax: €2,872.80, rounded to €2,873. Costs are assumed to be currently tax-deductible; contributions to a WEG-Erhaltungsrücklage, the owners' association maintenance reserve, are not deductible merely upon payment into the reserve. Solidaritätszuschlag and Kirchensteuer are excluded. Interest on the loan taken out solely to pay the Pflichtteil is treated here as private and non-deductible. This is not an individual tax calculation under § 32a EStG. Dated 28 October 2026.

    In this example, the Pflichtteil absorbs more than 80% of the after-tax surplus. The apartments still cover the modelled outgoings, but a major repair or lost rent would create a shortfall. Markus could alternatively sell an apartment. Selling costs, a possible Vorfälligkeitsentschädigung for early loan repayment and taxation of a private property sale would then need assessment. For property acquired without payment, the predecessor's acquisition date is generally also relevant.

    Illustrative assumptions: Markus's cash flow after tax
    Without the Pflichtteil payment
    +€7,567
    With the Pflichtteil loan
    +€1,187
    Editorial calculation; dated 28 October 2026.

    Inheritance tax. Markus can generally deduct a Pflichtteil that has been asserted as an estate liability (§ 10(5) ErbStG). Petra's inheritance-tax liability arises when she asserts the claim (§ 3(1), no. 1 and § 9(1), no. 1(b) ErbStG). The illustrative €150,000 is below the €400,000 personal allowance for children, provided relevant earlier acquisitions have not already used it up. For Markus, the gift made four and a half years earlier is aggregated with his inheritance under § 14 ErbStG.

    Reviewing financing documents and monthly costs together
    AI-generated illustrative image

    05Planning during the owner's lifetime

    Owners who know that one child will receive nothing, or less than the others, can prepare. The available tools are limited but can be effective.

    Five ways to organise Pflichtteil exposure
    1. 01
      Pflichtteilsverzicht.

      A child waives their compulsory-share rights through a notarised agreement (§§ 2346(2), 2348 BGB), often in exchange for compensation. This is the most direct route to clarity for everyone involved.

    2. 02
      Specify Anrechnung.

      When making a gift to a child, you can stipulate that it will be credited against their Pflichtteil (§ 2315 BGB). A later unilateral instruction is insufficient; any subsequent agreement requires separate legal assessment.

    3. 03
      Give early, without retained Nießbrauch.

      Once the relevant ten-year period has fully elapsed, the gift generally ceases to generate a supplement. Crucially, the period must actually have started; gifts between spouses follow the special rule. This approach is suitable only if you can afford to give up the income.

    4. 04
      Plan liquidity.

      Suitable term life insurance benefiting the heir or deliberately retained reserves can reduce pressure to sell. Cover, beneficiary designations and potential Pflichtteil and tax consequences of the insurance require separate examination.

    5. 05
      Coordinate the Testament.

      Who inherits, who receives a particular apartment through a Vermächtnis, and how are differences balanced? A coordinated will can reduce conflict but cannot rule out Pflichtteil claims or litigation.

    Deprivation of the Pflichtteil is possible only within the narrow conditions of § 2333 BGB, for example certain serious offences against the deceased. A final prison sentence of at least one year without probation is not sufficient by itself: for this ground, the offence must have been intentional and participation in the estate must consequently be unreasonable for the deceased. The deprivation must also be properly justified in the required form. A family falling-out is not enough.

    06Who should address the issue early?

    Clarify the Pflichtteil early
    • Most of your wealth is held in property and cash is scarce.
    • One child is intended to take over the house or apartments, while the others are not.
    • There are children from different relationships or difficult family circumstances.
    Less immediate pressure
    • All children inherit equal shares and get along.
    • Sufficient liquid assets are available to pay claims.
    • A Pflichtteilsverzicht has already been notarised.

    07Risks surrounding the Pflichtteil

    Liquidity. The claim is payable in money while the estate is often tied up in property. Financing availability depends, among other things, on creditworthiness, collateral and debt-service capacity.

    Valuation disputes. An expert assessment may produce a materially higher or lower value. Every change in market value affects the claim. Disputes prolong uncertainty for both sides.

    Interest rates and the market. Higher refinancing rates or falling rents can make a Pflichtteil loan harder to service. Vacancy and maintenance create additional pressure.

    Arrangements that backfire. A retained Nießbrauch can reduce the gift-tax value while also preventing the Pflichtteilsergänzung period from starting. For a gift to a spouse, that period cannot start before the marriage ends; if the marriage continues until death, there is no time-based reduction. Both calculations should be assessed together before making arrangements.

    FAQFrequently asked questions

    How is the Pflichtteil calculated for property?

    The starting point is the relevant net estate, with property generally assessed at market value on the date of death. The Pflichtteil equals half the statutory inheritance share. Qualifying lifetime gifts may generate an additional supplement.

    Must the Pflichtteil be paid in money?

    Generally yes. It does not confer ownership of an apartment. The parties can agree on another form of settlement, but a property transfer requires the appropriate notarial formalities.

    Do gifts made within the last ten years count?

    Qualifying gifts generally count on a basis reduced by one tenth each year. Whether the period has started is crucial. A comprehensive retained Nießbrauch and gifts between spouses can prevent it from starting.

    How can owners plan for a Pflichtteil?

    Options include a notarised Pflichtteilsverzicht, timely provisions crediting gifts against the claim and sufficient liquidity. Early gifts may reduce the supplement but have legal and financial consequences. Deprivation is possible only under narrow statutory conditions.

    When does a Pflichtteil claim become time-barred?

    The standard period is three years, generally starting at year-end once the claim exists and the claimant knows, or without gross negligence should know, the relevant circumstances and debtor. Special rules require assessment. The limitation period does not defer payment.

    Is the Pflichtteil subject to inheritance tax?

    Tax generally arises when the claim is asserted. Personal allowances and relevant earlier acquisitions must be considered. The heir can generally deduct the asserted claim as an estate liability.

    Can the heir request deferred payment?

    Deferral may be available for undue hardship under § 2331a BGB, taking the claimant's interests into account. The Nachlassgericht decides on application where the claim is undisputed. Jurisdiction for disputed claims needs separate assessment.

    08Further reading

    09Sources

    Editorial date: 28 October 2026. The linked statutory versions and decisions are authoritative.

    Note: This guide provides general information and does not replace individual tax, legal or investment advice. Pflichtteil issues and estate arrangements should be coordinated with a specialist inheritance lawyer or notary and a Steuerberater. All example figures are illustrative calculations using disclosed assumptions, dated 28 October 2026.

    Written by
    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo

    Writes about Existing properties, Investment calculations and Property assessment.

    Rula has worked in financial services since 2021. He focuses on existing investment properties, transparent calculations and an honest assessment of building condition and running costs.

    This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.

    Free · Instant · No sign-up

    Download this guide as a PDF

    The complete guide as a clean A4 file – with a cover page, all chapters and page numbers. Keep it on hand, read it offline, or go through it at your own pace during your consultation.

    • All chapters, tables and worked examples
    • Read offline – on your phone or printed out
    • Go through it at your own pace or pass it on
    • Free, no sign-up, no email required

    A4 format · 2,937 words · As of 04 November 2026

    Related guides

    All guides