Guide · Wealth Building

    Property as a Store of Value: What Holds Up?

    What official price indices tell you — and how two simplified model purchases illustrate the impact of rent, costs and holding period.


    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo
    21 October 20267 min read
    Property as a store of value: a retrospective
    +80.0%
    Prices over 20 years
    Assumed nominal capital growth
    +20.0%
    After inflation
    With cumulative inflation of 50% over the same period
    −8.0%
    In one year
    Example of an annual price decline
    +18.0%
    Rental growth over ten years
    Example: from €600 to €708 a month

    Illustrative calculation, simplified: The following figures demonstrate possible developments. They are assumptions, not historical market data.

    When families discuss money, the idea often comes up sooner or later: property as a dependable store of value [Betongold]. Behind it lies the belief that a flat never loses its value, whatever happens on the stock market. Property can help build wealth. That does not guarantee that it will preserve its value.

    A closer look is therefore worthwhile. The price declines in Germany in 2023 and 2024 show that property prices can fall too. How much substance is there to the idea once we examine the figures?

    01What the expression means

    The expression combines two images. Concrete represents something solid that you can touch. Gold symbolises value that survives crises, although its price can fluctuate too. The term usually refers to flats and houses held as investments, or more broadly to property of any kind.

    Three assumptions lie behind it. First, that property prices rise over the long term. Second, that they at least keep pace with inflation. Third, that they fluctuate less than other investments. Official figures can test the first two over specified periods. The third would require a methodologically comparable assessment of the asset classes; a house price index alone does not establish it.

    02What prices since 2005 show

    The Federal Statistical Office’s house price index [Häuserpreisindex] tracks the prices of residential properties acquired by private households. Quality-adjustment methods account for differences between the properties traded. This makes the index suitable for comparisons over time, but it is not a valuation of an individual flat. It is also published through Eurostat.

    Looking at developments since 2005 encompasses both periods of rising prices and declines. The outcome depends on the starting and finishing dates, as well as inflation. The following illustrative calculation, simplified, demonstrates this relationship using assumed price and inflation paths. The periods represent calculation scenarios, not particular historical calendar years.

    German residential property, nominal and inflation-adjusted
    Period in the exampleTotal nominal changeNominal change per yearTotal real change
    5 years+10.0%+1.9%−12.0%
    10 years+50.0%+4.1%+15.4%
    20 years+80.0%+3.0%+20.0%

    The examples assume cumulative inflation of 25%, 30% and 50% over the respective periods. The three rows are independent examples, not a continuous time series. “Per year” means the compound annual growth rate, not the simple average of annual percentage changes. “Real” means price changes adjusted for consumer price inflation; rental income and costs are not included. The calculation is the nominal value factor divided by the inflation factor, minus one.

    The 20-year example therefore gives 1.80 ÷ 1.50 − 1 = 20% real capital growth. This is equivalent to approximately 0.9% a year. The nominal increase therefore does not represent an equivalent gain in purchasing power.

    The second finding is in the first row. A nominal price rise of 10% is not enough to preserve purchasing power when cumulative inflation is 25%: 1.10 ÷ 1.25 − 1 gives a real loss of 12%. This does not describe the sale proceeds of a particular flat. It shows why a higher selling price alone does not establish a real profit. The guide to property as an inflation hedge explores this in more detail.

    Property values fluctuate too

    Averages over 20 years smooth out what happens in between. Several years of rising prices do not prevent a subsequent decline. One year of losses can also be followed by another. For owners, the long-term trend is therefore not the only consideration: they also need to be able to withstand a weak market financially.

    The following illustrative calculation, simplified, demonstrates such fluctuations. The seven annual rates are freely chosen assumptions and do not reproduce a historical index series.

    Annual change in residential property prices
    Year 1
    +6.0%
    Year 2
    +8.0%
    Year 3
    +12.0%
    Year 4
    +6.0%
    Year 5
    −8.0%
    Year 6
    −2.0%
    Year 7
    +3.0%
    Illustrative calculation, simplified: assumed annual price changes, not historical market data or a forecast.

    One difference from listed shares is the visibility of price fluctuations: a flat has no daily stock-market quotation. A valuation can estimate its worth; a sale establishes the price actually achievable. This does not mean that property necessarily fluctuates less than shares.

    Well-maintained apartment buildings in a German residential neighbourhood
    AI-generated illustrative image

    03Rent as the second component

    Looking only at capital value leaves out an important component of a property investment. A rented flat can generate ongoing rental income. Physical gold in a safe, by contrast, generates no ongoing payments.

    The actual rentals sub-index within the Harmonised Index of Consumer Prices measures changes in residential rents paid. It is not equivalent to a time series covering only unchanged existing tenancy agreements. Nor does it automatically describe rents for new lettings in a particular location. The guide to rental price trends discusses rental developments.

    Illustrative calculation, simplified: if monthly rent rises from €600 to €708 over ten years, the increase is 18%. If a flat’s price rises from €200,000 to €300,000 over the same period, the increase is 50%. This example shows that rent and purchase prices can grow at different rates; it does not describe a historical development. The relationship can be different over other periods.

    For an investment calculation, this means that rent after costs can make a substantial contribution to the overall result. It can continue to arrive during years of falling property prices, provided the flat remains let and the rent is paid. The size of that contribution depends on the particular property and period.

    04Two purchases in retrospect

    We compare two hypothetical purchases. Illustrative calculation, simplified: all purchase prices, sale prices, rents and costs are assumptions. The calendar years illustrate different purchase dates and holding periods; the calculations do not reproduce actual market developments in those years. These are neither customer experiences nor forecasts. Both purchases are made entirely with cash, so financing costs do not affect the comparison. Tax is excluded.

    Buyer A purchases a rented flat in the model in 2015 for €200,000, with a further €20,000 in acquisition costs. Rent remains unchanged at €600 a month throughout the holding period. Management, maintenance and void periods are allowed for at a flat 20% of rent. The model assumes a sale in 2025 for €300,000 — 50% above the purchase price.

    Buyer B purchases a flat in the model in the second quarter of 2022 for €300,000, with a further €30,000 in acquisition costs. Rent remains unchanged at €750 a month throughout the holding period. The sale takes place four years later, in the second quarter of 2026, for an assumed €276,000 — 8% below the purchase price. Costs are again assumed at a flat 20% of rent.

    The examples assume ten and four full rental years respectively, and selling costs of 3% of the assumed sale price. Rental income is therefore €600 × 12 × 10 = €72,000 and €750 × 12 × 4 = €36,000 respectively. Unlike the preceding rental example, these purchases assume no rent increases.

    An index movement does not, by itself, entitle a landlord to raise an individual rent by the same amount. The tenancy agreement and statutory requirements determine what is permitted; consult a lawyer if you need advice on the legal requirements for an adjustment. The cost allowance is a modelling assumption, not a forecast of actual expenditure, and provides no protection against major repairs or special assessments.

    Two purchases, two entry points
    Buyer A (2015–2025)Buyer B (2022–2026)
    Purchase price and acquisition costs−€220,000−€330,000
    Rent over the holding period€72,000€36,000
    Costs, assumed at 20% of rent−€14,400−€7,200
    Assumed sale price€300,000€276,000
    Selling costs of 3%−€9,000−€8,280
    Result before tax+€128,600−€33,480
    Illustrative calculation, simplified: author’s calculation using the stated assumptions. Not historical market results. Excluding financing and tax.

    The results are nominal sums of the cash flows shown, not annualised returns. For Buyer A, the calculation is −€220,000 + €72,000 − €14,400 + €300,000 − €9,000 = €128,600. For Buyer B, the equivalent calculation is −€330,000 + €36,000 − €7,200 + €276,000 − €8,280 = −€33,480.

    Buyer A achieves a positive result in the model. €57,600 comes from rent after the assumed costs, and €71,000 from the change in value after acquisition and selling costs. An additional purchasing-power comparison illustrates the difference between nominal and real values: with assumed cumulative inflation of 30% over ten years, €286,000 would be needed at the end to preserve the purchasing power of the initial €220,000 investment. This comparison alone does not establish a total real return. The timing of rental payments and inflation during the holding period would also need to be taken into account.

    Buyer B also purchases a rented flat in the model, but at a different time and with a different initial rental yield. The comparison therefore does not isolate purchase timing alone. After four years, the assumed value is below the purchase price, while acquisition and selling costs further reduce the result. Rent cushions the loss but does not offset it.

    Components of the overall result
    A: Rent after costs
    +€57,600
    A: Change in value after costs
    +€71,000
    B: Rent after costs
    +€28,800
    B: Change in value after costs
    −€62,280
    Illustrative calculation, simplified: components of the two model purchases, not a forecast. Excluding financing and tax.

    What follows from this? A longer holding period gives rental income more time to contribute and can spread the impact of one-off transaction costs. It guarantees neither a profit nor the freedom to choose when to sell. For land and flats held as private assets, a sale after more than ten years generally falls outside German taxation of private disposal transactions under section 23(1), first sentence, no. 1 of the German Income Tax Act [Einkommensteuergesetz]. Consult your tax adviser about the precise holding-period calculation and any other relevant tax classification.

    A couple looking over residential buildings while planning for the long term
    AI-generated illustrative image

    05Where the comparison with gold falls short

    Gold and flats are both tangible assets. The similarities soon end.

    FeatureWhat it means for a flat
    DivisibilityAn individual flat cannot readily be converted into cash in small portions. Selling a co-ownership share is different from selling a freely tradable investment unit.
    SaleA sale can take weeks, months or longer. Depending on the arrangements and process, it may involve estate agency fees, other transaction costs and time.
    Acquisition costsProperty transfer tax, notarial fees, land registration and, where applicable, estate agency fees add to the purchase cost. Their amount depends partly on the federal state and agency agreement. The examples assume a flat 10% of the purchase price; these costs do not automatically increase the property’s value.
    Running costsMaintenance, management and costs that cannot be passed on to tenants affect cash flow; larger expenses may arise irregularly.
    IncomeRent can arrive monthly while the flat is let and payments are received.
    RulesChanges to tenancy law, energy requirements and tax law can affect income and value.

    Acquisition costs in particular make short holding periods more difficult. In these two examples, the initial expense is 10% of the purchase price, with further costs on sale. This does not establish a universal minimum cost burden of 10%.

    06Who this type of investment may suit

    Property may suit you
    • You can hold the flat for ten years or longer.
    • Your calculation relies on rent, not a rising resale price.
    • You have reserves for repairs and lost rent.
    Less likely to suit you
    • You will need the money again within a few years.
    • The figures only work if the value rises.
    • A large share of your wealth is already invested in property in one location.

    07Risks property does not protect against

    Purchase timing. Buying before a price decline can leave the property’s value below the purchase price for years, as with Buyer B in the model. A long planning horizon does not prevent such declines.

    Location. The index is an average for Germany as a whole. In regions with declining populations and high vacancy levels, prices may fall over extended periods. Alongside location, factors such as condition, lettability and purchase price influence the result.

    Interest rates. Rising interest rates can put pressure on property prices because buyers can borrow less on the same budget. Other factors, including supply, demand and incomes, also play a part. Buyers using finance additionally face the risk of more expensive refinancing.

    Maintenance. Concrete ages. Roofs, heating systems and pipework may require repair or replacement. Applicable energy requirements can also create costs. Have the technical measures assessed for the particular building; consult a lawyer if you need advice on your legal obligations.

    Unpaid rent and void periods. Rent can contribute ongoing income, but it can also stop. A rising index does not protect an individual property against payment difficulties or vacancy.

    FAQFrequently asked questions

    What does the German expression for property as a store of value mean?

    The colloquial expression Betongold refers to property held as an investment. It conveys the belief that houses and flats preserve their value as reliably as gold. It is not a guarantee of capital preservation; gold prices fluctuate too.

    Is property a safe investment?

    Property offers no guarantee against losses. Prices can fall, and there are additional risks such as void periods, unpaid rent, interest-rate changes and maintenance. Viability depends on the individual property, its financing and the reserves available.

    Is property still a worthwhile investment in 2026?

    The year alone cannot answer that question. What matters is the specific flat’s purchase price, achievable rent, costs, financing and risks. Test a scenario without capital growth too. Sustainable positive operating cash flow is helpful, but does not guarantee overall success.

    Does property protect against inflation?

    Not automatically. Property prices and rents may outpace inflation over some periods but lag behind it over others. Rent adjustments depend on the contract and applicable legal requirements. Costs and the timing of cash flows also matter when calculating a total real return. Consult a lawyer if you need advice on the legal requirements for rent adjustments.

    Why can rents rise more slowly than purchase prices?

    Increases in existing rents are subject to contractual and statutory limits, including the local comparable rent and caps on increases where applicable. Purchase prices may respond more quickly to interest rates and demand. However, rents do not rise more slowly than purchase prices in every period. Consult a lawyer if you need advice on which limits apply to your tenancy agreement.

    How long should you hold an investment property?

    Ten years or longer can be a useful planning horizon, but is neither a universal minimum nor a guarantee of profit. A longer holding period gives rent more time to contribute. For property held as a private asset, a sale after more than ten years generally falls outside section 23 of the German Income Tax Act. Consult your tax adviser about the precise holding-period calculation and tax classification.

    08Further reading

    09Sources

    Official price and rental indices provide context for the overall market. The numerical examples in this article instead use the assumptions expressly stated for each calculation, rather than reproducing historical index movements.

    • Eurostat, German house price index (prc_hpi_a, annual data; prc_hpi_q, quarterly data)
    • Eurostat, German Harmonised Index of Consumer Prices (prc_hicp_aind), overall index and actual rentals sub-index
    • Section 23 of the German Income Tax Act
    • Worked examples: author’s calculation using the assumptions stated in the text, excluding financing and tax

    Note: This guide provides general information and does not replace individual tax, legal or investment advice. The simplified illustrative calculations are not forecasts and do not promise any return.

    Written by
    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo

    Writes about Existing properties, Investment calculations and Property assessment.

    Rula has worked in financial services since 2021. He focuses on existing investment properties, transparent calculations and an honest assessment of building condition and running costs.

    This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.

    Free · Instant · No sign-up

    Download this guide as a PDF

    The complete guide as a clean A4 file – with a cover page, all chapters and page numbers. Keep it on hand, read it offline, or go through it at your own pace during your consultation.

    • All chapters, tables and worked examples
    • Read offline – on your phone or printed out
    • Go through it at your own pace or pass it on
    • Free, no sign-up, no email required

    A4 format · 3,051 words · As of 21 October 2026

    Related guides

    All guides