Holiday apartment as an investment: what remains after costs and tax
More rent per night does not mean more money at the end of the year. We compare the figures for a holiday apartment honestly with those for a long-term rental apartment and show where the tax office takes a closer look.
You have spent your summers on the same coast for years. In the evenings, you do the sums in your head: €120 per night, 150 nights a year — that would be €18,000 in rent. A conventional flat bought for the same price might bring in €11,000. The holiday let looks like the better investment.
On paper, that is true. Your bank account often tells a different story. Letting commissions, end-of-stay cleaning, electricity, internet, furniture and vacancies in the low season are paid for by the holiday let owner, not the guest. And the tax office looks more closely at whether you actually intend to make a profit.
This guide compares the figures for both: a holiday let and a flat let on a long-term basis, with the same purchase price and the same financing. By the end, you will know which factors determine the outcome.
01What distinguishes a holiday let from a long-term rental flat
Both involve letting property, but they are two different businesses. With long-term letting, you have one tenant, one contract and twelve rent payments a year. With a holiday let, you have 20 to 50 guests a year, each involving arrivals, keys, cleaning and reviews.
| Feature | Holiday let | Flat let on a long-term basis |
|---|---|---|
| Income | per night, highly seasonal | monthly rent excluding service charges, consistent |
| Running costs | paid by the owner (electricity, water, heating, internet) | largely recoverable from the tenant |
| Marketing | platform or agency, commission usually charged as a percentage | a one-off tenant search every few years |
| Furnishings | fully furnished, regular replacement | usually unfurnished |
| VAT | short-term accommodation is subject to VAT (7%) | residential letting is exempt from VAT |
| Depreciation | straight-line, no special depreciation allowance under section 7b | straight-line; declining-balance depreciation and special depreciation allowances possible for new builds |
| Legal hurdles | local development plan, restrictions on alternative use, declaration of division | tenancy law, rent cap |
| Personal use | possible, with tax consequences | not possible |
The table already indicates the likely outcome. A holiday let generates more revenue, but takes more work and costs more to run. Whether you ultimately have more left over depends almost entirely on one figure: occupancy.
02Worked example: holiday letting versus long-term letting
Take the Brandt family. The names are fictional, and the figures are a worked example, not a forecast. The Brandts have €30,000 of their own funds to cover the incidental purchase costs and borrow the full purchase price of €300,000. Mr Brandt alone has taxable income of €70,000 a year.
Option A is a furnished holiday flat occupied for 120 nights a year. Option B is a 75-square-metre flat let on a long-term basis for €12 per square metre, excluding service charges. The holiday flat also requires €15,000 for furniture, paid from their own funds.
| Holiday let | Long-term letting | |
|---|---|---|
| Income | €14,400 | €10,800 |
| Letting commission (20% of income) | −€2,880 | €0 |
| Cleaning (30 changeovers at €60) | −€1,800 | €0 |
| Electricity, water, heating, internet | −€2,400 | €0 |
| Non-recoverable building service charges, maintenance | −€1,800 | −€1,800 |
| Furniture reserve | −€1,000 | €0 |
| Interest (€300,000 at 3.8%) | −€11,400 | −€11,400 |
| Mortgage principal repayment (1.5%) | −€4,500 | −€4,500 |
| Annual result before tax | −€11,380 | −€6,900 |
| Tax loss (including depreciation of €4,950, furniture depreciation of €1,500) | −€12,330 | −€7,350 |
| Tax saving on taxable income of €70,000 (single, section 32a EStG 2026) | +€4,921 | +€2,997 |
| Annual result after tax | −€6,459 | −€3,903 |
| per month | −€538 | −€325 |
The holiday let generates €3,600 more income. Yet letting commission, cleaning and utility costs alone swallow up €7,080. Overall, the Brandts pay around €213 more out of their own pockets each month for the holiday let than for the long-term rental flat, even though tax relief offsets part of the cost.
Both options include €4,500 in mortgage principal repayments. This builds equity; it is not a loss. Excluding principal repayments, the holiday let would produce an after-tax result of around −€1,959 a year, compared with around +€597 for long-term letting.
Even at 160 nights — almost every other day — the holiday let does not catch up with long-term letting in this example. That only changes if the nightly rate is significantly higher or you handle cleaning and guest services yourself. In that case, however, you are buying yourself a side job rather than an investment.
Enter the purchase price, rent and costs, and compare your options.

03The 25% rule: when the tax office recognises losses
You can offset rental losses against your salary. However, this only applies if you intend to generate a surplus over the long term. Lawyers call this an intention to generate income (Einkünfteerzielungsabsicht). Without it, the activity is commonly described as a hobby activity (Liebhaberei), and the losses do not count for tax purposes.
For a flat let on a long-term basis, the tax office generally assumes that this intention exists. For holiday lets, the Bundesfinanzhof has established stricter rules. In its judgment of 11 August 2025 (IX R 23/24), it set these out in concrete terms:
- 01Holiday guests only
The flat is let exclusively to changing holiday guests and kept available for that purpose at other times. Personal use, even for just one week, is not permitted under this test.
- 02Local average occupancy
Your letting days are compared with the average for holiday flats in the locality. Data from the Statistisches Landesamt may be used as a basis (BFH, IX R 33/19).
- 03No more than 25% below average
If your occupancy is no more than 25% below the local average, the intention is deemed to exist. In the case decided, the local average was 108 and 87 days a year respectively.
- 04Three to five years taken together
The decisive figure is the average over three to five consecutive years. A single weak year does not overturn the assessment.
- 05Otherwise, a forecast is required
If occupancy falls significantly below the threshold or you use the flat yourself, the tax office requires a forecast of the overall surplus, generally over 30 years.
You should therefore document every booking and every enquiry. Anyone who reserves the right to use the property personally should expect to have to prepare a forecast. If it is negative, the losses in the worked example will not be recognised for tax purposes. For the Brandt family, that would mean €4,921 less in tax savings each year.
04VAT, business activity and depreciation
Letting residential accommodation is normally exempt from VAT. This does not apply to short-term guest accommodation (§ 4 No. 12 sentence 2 UStG). Holiday letting is therefore subject to VAT at the reduced rate of 7% (§ 12(2) No. 11 UStG).
Many private landlords qualify for the small business VAT exemption. It applies if total turnover did not exceed €25,000 in the previous year and does not exceed €100,000 in the current year (§ 19 UStG). You then do not charge VAT, but you also cannot reclaim input VAT on incidental purchase costs or furniture. Anyone with several flats or other activities subject to VAT should review the threshold with their tax adviser.
| Topic | Holiday flat | Legal basis |
|---|---|---|
| VAT | 7% on overnight accommodation, except for businesses qualifying for the small business VAT exemption | § 4 No. 12 sentence 2, § 12(2) No. 11, § 19 UStG |
| Straight-line depreciation | 2%, or 3% for properties completed from 2023 onwards | § 7(4) EStG |
| 5% declining-balance depreciation | Generally unavailable, as the property does not serve residential purposes | § 7(5a) EStG, BFH IX R 8/97 |
| Special depreciation allowance for newly built rental housing | Excluded | § 7b EStG, BMF dated 21 May 2025, paragraphs 35–36 |
| Income category | Income from letting and leasing; potentially income from a commercial business if hotel-like services are provided | § 21 or § 15 EStG |
Depreciation is the often-underestimated issue. Back in 2000, the Bundesfinanzhof ruled that holiday flats let to successive guests do not serve residential purposes (IX R 8/97). However, the incentives for new rental housing specifically target residential use. Anyone assessing a newly built holiday flat on the basis of 5% declining-balance depreciation is making the figures look better than they are.
If you offer hotel-like services, such as daily cleaning, breakfast or a reception desk, the letting activity may become a commercial business. Trade tax may then be payable, and a sale is no longer tax-free after ten years. You should clarify this distinction with your tax adviser before buying.

05Checks before buying: is holiday letting even permitted here?
Whether a flat may be let to holiday guests is not solely up to the owner. Three levels of control have a say, and each can put an end to the plan.
- 01Read the declaration of division
If it specifies “residential use” without holiday letting, or contains an explicit prohibition, short-term letting is risky. A subsequent ban by majority resolution requires the consent of all owners (BGH, V ZR 112/18).
- 02Check the local development plan
Holiday flats are not permitted in every planning zone. The municipality can tell you whether the use is authorised or requires approval for a change of use.
- 03Check the local ordinance on the misuse of residential accommodation
Many cities, including Berlin, Hamburg and Köln, require a permit or registration number for short-term letting. Letting without a permit can result in fines.
- 04Ask about municipal charges
Each municipality sets its own visitor tax, guest contribution, tourism levy and second-home tax. Obtain written confirmation of the current rates.
Also ask the seller for booking figures for the past three years, reviews on the platforms and the contract with the letting agency. A holiday flat without a documented track record is a bet on your own marketing.
06Who a holiday flat suits — and who it does not
- You have known the area for years and can assess prices and occupancy realistically.
- You want to manage guests, reviews and furnishings yourself, or you have a reliable local agency.
- Your equity is sufficient to withstand a weak year even without tax savings.
- You also want somewhere for your own holidays and accept a lower financial return in exchange.
- You want an investment requiring little effort and providing predictable income.
- The financing only works with the tax savings from offsetting losses.
- Your calculations assume declining-balance depreciation or special depreciation allowances.
- You live far away and have no one locally.
07Risks: what to watch out for
Occupancy. A rainy summer, building work outside the property or a new holiday park nearby can quickly cut the number of nights booked by a quarter. In the example calculation, 30 fewer nights cost around €2,400 a year.
Dependence on platforms. If a booking platform changes its commission, search rankings or rules, you feel the impact immediately. Your own repeat guests can only partly cushion the effect.
Tax recognition. If your occupancy falls significantly below the local norm or you use the flat yourself, you may lose the ability to offset losses. The investment must then stand on its pre-tax cash flow alone.
Regulation. Municipalities are tightening rules on the misuse of residential accommodation and second homes, especially in areas with housing shortages. What is permitted today may require a permit in a few years.
Interest rates and refinancing. As with any property bought with borrowing, the interest rate may be higher when the fixed-rate period ends. With fluctuating income, this hits harder than with a fixed monthly rent.
Maintenance and furnishings. Frequent guest changeovers cause floors, kitchens and furniture to wear out faster. Budget for a separate reserve for this, in addition to the service charge.
FAQFrequently asked questions
Is a holiday apartment a worthwhile investment?
That depends primarily on occupancy and costs. In the example, a holiday apartment let for 120 nights generates €3,600 more revenue than a long-term rental apartment, but leaves around €213 less per month after costs and tax. Owners who manage the letting themselves and achieve high occupancy may fare better.
Can I deduct losses from my holiday apartment for tax purposes?
Yes, if you let exclusively to holiday guests and your letting period is no more than 25% below the local average. The determining factor is the average over three to five years (BFH, IX R 23/24). If you use the property yourself or occupancy is significantly lower, the tax office requires a forecast of the overall rental surplus.
Do I have to pay VAT on a holiday apartment?
Short-term accommodation is subject to VAT at a rate of 7%. If your total turnover was no more than €25,000 in the previous year and is no more than €100,000 in the current year, you can use the small business VAT exemption under Section 19 UStG.
Does declining-balance depreciation apply to a new holiday apartment?
Generally not. Declining-balance depreciation under Section 7(5a) EStG requires residential use, and according to case law, apartments let to holiday guests do not serve residential purposes. The special depreciation allowance under Section 7b EStG expressly excludes holiday apartments. Straight-line depreciation of 2% or 3%, respectively, remains available.
Am I allowed to let my owner-occupied apartment to holiday guests?
That depends on the declaration of division, the local development plan and the city's rules. If holiday letting is permitted in the declaration of division, the owners' association cannot simply prohibit it by a majority resolution (BGH, V ZR 112/18). In many major cities, you also need a permit under the rules governing the use of residential property for non-residential purposes.
Is the sale of a holiday apartment tax-free after ten years?
Yes, for private lettings: the holding period for tax-free disposal is ten years (Section 23 EStG). If you use the apartment exclusively yourself, a sale may also be tax-free sooner. However, if the letting is classified as a commercial business, the profit is taxable regardless of how long you have held the property.
How do I finance a holiday apartment?
Banks often assess holiday apartments more cautiously than long-term rental apartments because the income fluctuates. Expect to need a larger deposit and a household affordability calculation that works even without rental income. Compare financing terms before buying.
08Further reading
- A flat as an investment: advantages and disadvantages
- Furnished letting: surcharge, tax and tenancy law
- Offsetting rental losses against your salary
- Special depreciation allowances and declining-balance depreciation
- The property holding period for tax-free sales
- Glossary: prohibition on the misuse of residential accommodation
09Sources
All sources accessed on 14 October 2026.
- BFH, judgment of 11 August 2025, IX R 23/24 (customary local letting duration, 25% threshold, period of three to five years)
- BFH, judgment of 26 May 2020, IX R 33/19 (comparison with statistical office data)
- BFH, judgment of 14 March 2000, IX R 8/97 (holiday flats do not serve residential purposes)
- BGH, judgment of 12 April 2019, V ZR 112/18 (a ban on short-term letting requires the consent of all owners)
- § 4 No. 12, § 12(2) No. 11, § 19 UStG, gesetze-im-internet.de
- §§ 7, 7b, 21, 23, 32a EStG, gesetze-im-internet.de
- BMF circular of 21 May 2025 on the special depreciation allowance under § 7b EStG, paragraphs 35–36
- Keyword data: Semrush, Germany database, as at 14 October 2026
Disclaimer: This guide provides general information and is not a substitute for tax or legal advice. All figures are illustrative calculations with disclosed assumptions, as at 14 October 2026.

Writes about Financing and calculations, Taxes and Care properties.
Michael combines his experience as a banker and former portfolio manager at a family office with his practice as a property investor himself. He writes about robust calculations, financing, risks and strategic portfolio building.
This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.



