Buying a property with a right of residence: what the discount is really worth
A lifetime right of residence can justify a price discount. In return, use of the affected rooms stays with the holder for an uncertain period. We explain how the discount, rent forgone and ongoing outgoings fit together.
Simplified illustrative calculation: A flat with a market value of around €250,000 without a right of residence [Wohnrecht] is offered for €160,000. The sales particulars contain a sentence that is easy to overlook: “Lifetime right of residence for the seller, aged 75.” The seller wants money for her retirement but wishes to remain in her flat. In this example, the right covers the entire flat. You are therefore buying a flat that, for an indefinite period, you can neither move into yourself nor let to a tenant without an appropriate agreement.
For some buyers, this price discount may fit their long-term investment plans. For others, the uncertain waiting period is a risk they should not take. What matters is whether the financing is affordable and what the calculation does, and does not, tell you.
01What you are buying when a property has a right of residence
A right of residence registered as a property right allows a person to occupy a building or part of it to the exclusion of the owner (section 1093 BGB). It is recorded in Section II of the German land register [Grundbuch] and remains in place following an ordinary sale. You become the owner, but use of the rooms covered by the right belongs to the holder.
Five points matter to you as a buyer.
| Point | Legal position | What it means for you |
|---|---|---|
| Duration | If granted for life, generally until the holder dies (sections 1090 and 1061 BGB); any time limits or conditions must be considered | The end date may be uncertain |
| Transferability | Generally not transferable (section 1092 BGB) | The holder cannot sell the right on |
| Letting by the holder | Not without appropriate permission | The flat may remain unused after the holder moves out; check the deed and agreements |
| Ordinary maintenance costs | Generally borne by the holder (section 1093 in conjunction with section 1041 BGB) | This does not automatically oblige the owner to undertake every major repair; check the deed and other ownership obligations |
| Compulsory auction | Survival depends on the auction conditions; section 52 of the German Compulsory Auction and Compulsory Administration Act [ZVG] refers in particular to inclusion in the minimum bid | Have priority relative to the enforcing creditor and the specific conditions checked; survival is not guaranteed in every case |
A right of residence is not a tenancy agreement. The right alone does not create an obligation to pay rent; a separately agreed payment is a different matter. Local comparative rent schedules and tenancy-law rent increase rules do not apply merely because a right of residence exists. For operating costs [Betriebskosten], owners’ association charges [Hausgeld] and property tax [Grundsteuer], both the agreement and the statutory rules are relevant. Distinguish the internal allocation of costs between owner and holder from your obligations to the owners’ association and the relevant authorities. An internal reimbursement agreement does not automatically release you from those obligations. Read the deed establishing the right [Bestellungsurkunde] carefully before buying, and ask a lawyer to assess any unclear provisions on costs and use.
02How the discount is calculated
The buyer and seller freely negotiate the price of a property with a right of residence. The capitalised value for tax purposes, which can also be relevant to gifts and inheritances, offers one possible guide. For lifetime rights, it is calculated by multiplying the annual value of the right by a valuation factor (section 14(1) of the German Valuation Act [BewG]). The customary local rent for the affected rooms can provide the starting point for the annual value. For tax valuation, section 16 BewG caps the annual value at the value assigned to the asset under that Act divided by 18.6. This tax value cannot simply be equated with the asking price or the unencumbered market value.
The German Federal Ministry of Finance’s valuation factors are based on mortality tables and a statutory discount rate of 5.5%. A tax valuation must use the official factor applicable on the relevant valuation date for the holder’s age and sex.
Simplified illustrative calculation: The following table shows how different assumed valuation factors affect the capitalised value. The factors are freely chosen calculation assumptions, not official values for a particular age or sex. Monthly rent of €800 and an annual value of €9,600 are assumed; the statutory annual-value cap does not apply in this illustrative calculation. The final column simply shows the arithmetic deduction from an assumed unencumbered market value of €250,000, not a market price forecast.
| Calculation case | Assumed valuation factor | Annual value | Capitalised value | €250,000 less capitalised value |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 12.5 | €9,600 | €120,000 | €130,000 |
| B | 11.0 | €9,600 | €105,600 | €144,400 |
| C | 9.4 | €9,600 | €90,240 | €159,760 |
| D | 7.5 | €9,600 | €72,000 | €178,000 |
There are two things you should know about the official valuation method. First, the capitalised value is based on statistical survival probabilities. It does not tell you whether an individual holder will live for five years or twenty; the valuation factor is not a remaining lifespan expressed in years. Second, the tax calculation incorporates discounting at 5.5%. Anyone using a different financing rate or required return for their investment assessment will value the same waiting period differently. The tax capitalised value is therefore, at most, a starting point for negotiation, not an objective purchase price. Ask a tax adviser to calculate the tax value for your circumstances.

03Financing: why banks hesitate
A bank secures its loan through a registered land charge [Grundschuld]. If the right of residence ranks ahead of that land charge, it can reduce the mortgage lending value [Beleihungswert] and make the security harder to realise. In an auction, the right might survive under the applicable conditions. The bank must therefore consider its scope and priority when making its lending decision.
Possible approaches include contributing more of your own capital or providing additional security, such as a land charge over another, unencumbered property. Another possibility is a change of priority [Rangrücktritt] approved by the holder, placing the land charge ahead of the right of residence. This can weaken the holder’s protection in a compulsory auction. None of these arrangements guarantees loan approval. The holder should obtain independent advice from a lawyer before agreeing to a change of priority.
04Worked example: discount versus rent forgone
Thomas, 48, wants to buy a flat as a long-term investment. He is offered the flat from the opening example: market value without the right of residence €250,000, customary local rent excluding ancillary charges [Kaltmiete] €800 a month. The seller is 75 and retains a lifetime right of residence over the entire flat. Under the assumed deed, she pays the operating costs; Thomas pays his share of contributions to the maintenance reserve and management costs, around €1,200 a year. Using the illustrative assumed valuation factor of 9.4 gives a capitalised value of €9,600 × 9.4 = €90,240. This is a simplified illustrative calculation, not an age-based tax valuation. Thomas pays €160,000. The agreed discount against €250,000 is therefore €90,000, independently of the calculated capitalised value. The names are fictional, and the figures are a worked example, not a forecast.
When does rent forgone reach that discount? We compare it with the rent excluding ancillary charges that Thomas would have received from an unencumbered flat let continuously throughout the period.
| Right of residence ends after | Rent forgone | Discount less rent forgone | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scenario A | 6 years | €57,600 | +€32,400 |
| Scenario B | 10 years | €96,000 | −€6,000 |
| Scenario C | 14 years | €134,400 | −€44,400 |
| Scenario D | 18 years | €172,800 | −€82,800 |
€90,000 ÷ €9,600 gives 9.375 years, rounded to 9.4 years. Before this point, the discount exceeds cumulative rent forgone; afterwards, it is smaller. This does not automatically determine which purchase is more profitable overall: among other things, the interest savings or investment return associated with the lower purchase price and other cost differences are missing. Rising rents would bring this purely nominal comparison point forward.
It is important to recognise that this calculation translates a person’s remaining lifetime into euros. For the seller, every additional year in her flat is precisely the reason for entering into the agreement. Anyone buying on this basis should be comfortable with that and should not count on the right ending early.
What the purchase costs each month
In addition to the purchase price, there are ongoing payments without corresponding rental income. In the example, a bank finances 80% of the purchase price, with Thomas providing a second property as security. For the €128,000 loan, we assume interest of 3.8% and an initial principal repayment rate of 1.5%. This is a simplified illustrative calculation, not a financing offer. The initial annualised loan payment is therefore €6,784. His own contribution of €32,000 towards the purchase price and acquisition costs are additional and are not included in the following ongoing outgoings.
The absence of current rental income does not, by itself, rule out a deduction for income-related expenses. Whether expenses incurred before letting or later depreciation can be recognised for a purchase subject to a lifetime right of residence depends particularly on a demonstrable intention to earn taxable income and the specific circumstances. Principal repayments are not deductible expenditure. Contributions to the owners’ association’s maintenance reserve [Erhaltungsrücklage] are not immediately deductible either; only actual eligible expenditure by the association may become relevant. The full owners’ association charge is not deductible. Thomas should ask a qualified tax adviser to assess interest, depreciation and ongoing expenditure before buying.
If total annual payments remained unchanged at €7,984, 14 years would mean around €112,000 paid out of pocket before the first rent was received: €111,776 to be precise. This assumes an unchanged loan payment and constant reserve contributions and management costs; additional repairs, special levies, acquisition costs and possible refinancing effects are excluded. Principal repayments build equity and are not equivalent to interest expense. With a level-payment amortising loan, the principal component increases over time. Multiplying the initial €1,920 principal repayment by 14 therefore does not give a reliable 14-year repayment total; a repayment schedule is required.

05What to check before buying
- 01Read the land register and deed
Have Section II, the priority of the right and the deed establishing it checked, including all provisions on costs.
- 02Clarify how costs are shared
Who pays operating costs, owners’ association charges, property tax and major repairs? Check internal reimbursement separately from your obligations to the association and authorities, and obtain legal clarification of gaps.
- 03Agree what happens if the holder moves out or enters a care home
What applies if she moves out permanently? Can the property then be let, and who is entitled to the rent? Moving out does not automatically end the right.
- 04Obtain written confirmation of financing
Clarify the bank’s position, mortgage lending value, additional security and outstanding approval conditions before entering into a binding commitment.
- 05Run different scenarios
Compare the discount with rent forgone over short and long periods, and allow for monthly outgoings without income, acquisition costs and maintenance risks.
- 06Check the condition
Viewing an occupied flat is only possible by arrangement. Ask to see the minutes of the owners’ association meetings.
06Who might suit a purchase with a right of residence
- You have a long investment horizon and do not need rental income for years.
- You can comfortably cover the ongoing outgoings without income.
- You have substantial capital of your own or additional security for the bank.
- You can accept that the end date of the right of residence is uncertain.
- You need rental income to cover the financing.
- Your calculations only work if the right of residence ends soon.
- The deed’s provisions on costs are unclear or missing.
- You want to use the property yourself in the foreseeable future.
07Risks when buying with a right of residence
Duration. The right of residence may last considerably longer than you allow for in your own planning. The tax valuation factor is not a lifespan forecast. Rent forgone may exceed the discount while you continue paying without receiving income.
Maintenance. The holder’s statutory maintenance obligation is generally limited to ordinary maintenance. Major repairs and special owners’ association levies [Sonderumlagen] may affect you financially as the owner. Whether there is an obligation to undertake works or a right to reimbursement, and to what extent, requires separate assessment. The right of residence limits your use of the property. Ask a lawyer to clarify the specific allocation of obligations.
Financing and interest rates. A bank may require more of your own capital, additional security or different terms, or may decline to finance the purchase. At an assumed 4.2% rather than 3.8%, annualised interest on the original €128,000 rises by €512 a year. This is a sensitivity calculation, not a statement about current market offers.
Tax. Do not assume that tax relief will apply across the board. The possible deduction of individual expenses requires separate assessment; in particular, principal repayments and mere contributions to the maintenance reserve are not deductible as ongoing letting expenses. Discuss the tax consequences with your tax adviser.
Resale. A continuing right of residence may narrow the pool of buyers and reduce the price compared with an otherwise comparable unencumbered property. A further discount against your own purchase price is not inevitable, however: market changes, the scope of the right and its remaining duration also affect the achievable price.
FAQFrequently asked questions
Can you buy a property with a right of residence?
Yes. In an ordinary sale, the registered right of residence remains in place and also binds the new owner. You become the owner, but the holder may continue occupying the rooms covered by the right. If granted for life, it generally ends on the holder’s death.
How much is a property with a lifetime right of residence worth?
One possible guide is the unencumbered market value less the capitalised value of the right. The tax capitalised value is calculated from the annual value and an official valuation factor; it does not determine the market price. Simplified illustrative calculation: at €800 monthly rent and a freely assumed factor of 9.4, the result is €9,600 × 9.4 = €90,240. This is not an age-based tax valuation. A tax valuation must take account of the applicable official factor and the statutory annual-value cap. The buyer and seller negotiate the actual purchase price. Our right of residence calculator offers an additional calculation aid. Ask a tax adviser to calculate the tax value.
Will a bank finance a property with a right of residence?
Financing may be possible, but depends on the property, the scope and priority of the right, your creditworthiness and the security available. If the right ranks ahead of the land charge, it may reduce the mortgage lending value. The bank may require more of your own capital or additional security, or may decline financing.
Who pays the ancillary costs for a property with a right of residence?
The deed establishing the right and the statutory rules are relevant. The holder generally bears ordinary maintenance costs. Responsibility for operating costs, owners’ association charges, property tax and major repairs should be expressly clarified. An internal reimbursement agreement does not automatically change your obligations to the owners’ association or the authorities. Ask a lawyer to assess any unclear provisions on costs.
What happens if the holder moves into a care home?
Moving into a care home does not automatically end the right. The deed should specify whether the flat may then be let and who is entitled to the rent. Without an appropriate provision or agreement, the flat may stand empty until the right ends. Ask a lawyer to clarify the available options.
Can a right of residence be removed from the land register?
Yes, provided the legal and land registration requirements are met. Following the holder’s death, proof of death is generally required for a lifetime right; further evidence or procedural requirements may apply depending on the entry. During the holder’s lifetime, relinquishing the right with consent to its removal is one option, potentially in return for compensation. Agreed time limits or conditions may also be relevant. Ask the notary to check the entry and deed.
What is the difference between buying with a right of residence and buying with a usufruct?
With a usufruct, the holder may generally also let the property and retain the rent. A right of residence does not permit this without an appropriate provision. If either right covers the entire flat, the buyer may have neither its use nor its rental income while the right lasts. Cost obligations and the annual value for tax purposes may differ. Discuss the specific arrangement with a lawyer and the tax consequences with a tax adviser.
08Further reading
- Glossary: Right of residence
- Calculator: Right of residence
- Glossary: Usufruct
- Checking the purchase agreement for a flat
- The notary appointment when buying a flat
- Glossary: Mortgage lending value
09Sources
- Section 14 BewG (valuation factors, 5.5% interest rate, adjustments) and section 16 BewG
- German Civil Code (BGB): section 1030, section 1041, section 1061, section 1090, section 1092, section 1093
- Section 52 ZVG
- German Federal Ministry of Finance: Official valuation factors for calculating the capitalised value of lifetime uses or benefits under section 14(1) BewG
- Worked examples: our own calculations using the assumptions stated in the text
Note: This guide provides general information and does not replace tax, legal or investment advice for individual circumstances. The calculations use the stated assumptions. Ask a tax adviser or lawyer, as appropriate, to assess tax and legal questions relating to your specific purchase.

Writes about Existing properties, Investment calculations and Property assessment.
Rula has worked in financial services since 2021. He focuses on existing investment properties, transparent calculations and an honest assessment of building condition and running costs.
This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.



