Capital drawdown: keep the rent or live on the sale proceeds?
How to compare rental surpluses and withdrawals, using transparent assumptions, German tax rules and a clear view of your remaining assets.
01Capital drawdown or rent: what are you actually comparing?
A mortgage-free rental flat can provide ongoing income in retirement. Selling it, by contrast, releases the capital tied up in the property. A withdrawal plan allows you to use that money towards living expenses over a defined period.
Do not compare monthly payments alone. Remaining assets, tax, possible health insurance contributions and your financial security after the withdrawal plan ends also matter.
A withdrawal is not the same as a return. With interest-bearing capital drawdown, it consists of interest and a repayment of your own capital. If you continue letting, you retain the flat, although neither its value nor future rental surpluses are guaranteed.
02How to calculate capital drawdown
For a fixed withdrawal at the end of each month and a constant positive monthly interest rate, the formula is:
Monthly withdrawal = capital × i ÷ [1 − (1 + i)^(−n)]
- Capital: the amount available to invest at the outset.
- i: the monthly interest rate expressed as a decimal.
- n: the number of monthly withdrawals.
In the following model, 2% is a nominal annual rate with monthly interest accrual. Therefore, i = 0.02 ÷ 12. An effective annual rate would require a different conversion into a monthly rate. With no interest, the calculation is simply capital ÷ months.
Illustrative calculation using €231,432
All the figures below are illustrative assumptions, not market values or investment offers. The interest rate remains constant throughout the term. Withdrawals take place at the end of each month; tax, investment costs and inflation are initially excluded. Calculations use unrounded figures, while monthly amounts are shown rounded to the nearest euro.
| Use of capital | At 0% interest | At 2% nominal annual interest |
|---|---|---|
| Full drawdown over 20 years | €964 | €1,171 |
| Full drawdown over 25 years | €771 | €981 |
| Withdraw interest only, preserving nominal capital | €0 | €386 |
At 2%, extending the term from 20 to 25 years reduces monthly withdrawals by approximately €190. In return, the capital lasts five years longer. With interest-only withdrawals, only the nominal capital is preserved: inflation can reduce its purchasing power.

03Example: a mortgage-free flat in retirement
Renate is a fictional property owner aged 70 at the start of the calculation. She is considering whether to keep or sell her rental flat. The example uses the following assumptions:
| Starting point | Assumption |
|---|---|
| Sale price of the flat | €240,000 |
| Monthly rent excluding service charges, paid in full | €800 |
| Annual management and maintenance costs borne by Renate | €2,000 |
| Annual allowable depreciation on the building | €3,000 |
| Outstanding mortgage | €0 |
| Estate agent fees payable by the seller | 3.57% of the sale price |
| Other selling costs | €0 |
The estate agent fee of 3.57% is purely an assumption, not a universally applicable rate. Other selling costs and rental losses are assumed to be zero in this model and must be added when assessing an actual decision.
Sale proceeds and rental surplus
Available sale proceeds: €240,000 − €8,568 estate agent fees = €231,432.
Annual rental surplus before tax: €800 × 12 − €2,000 = €7,600, equivalent to approximately €633 per month.
The sale assumes that the flat is held as a private asset, the ten-year period under section 23 of the German Income Tax Act (EStG) has expired, and the activity does not constitute commercial property trading. The model therefore includes no tax on the disposal gain.
| Comparison before tax | Keep the flat | Sell, draw down over 20 years | Sell, draw down over 25 years |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly rental surplus or withdrawal | €633 | €1,171 | €981 |
| Assets after 20 years | Flat with an uncertain market value | Capital exhausted | Capital remaining for another five years in the model |
| Main burden | Letting, repairs, possible special assessments | Finite term, investment and interest rate risks | Lower withdrawals, still a finite term |
If Renate starts at 70, the 20-year plan ends at 90 and the 25-year plan at 95. These are planning horizons, not statements about her life expectancy.
A reliable after-tax calculation requires personal information. This includes when pension payments began, the taxable share of the pension, other income, deductible expenditure, church tax and health insurance status. For that reason, the three options are not compared using generic net figures here.
04Understanding tax and health insurance
Sale: the ten-year period and private assets
For a rental property held as a private asset, a sale after the ten-year period has expired is generally outside the scope of income tax under section 23 EStG. The dates of the binding purchase and sale contracts normally determine the period, rather than registration in the land register.
A sale within that period may constitute a taxable private disposal. Special circumstances, such as a transfer without payment or commercial property trading, require separate assessment. See the property disposal tax holding period for more detail.
Withdrawals: your own capital is not new interest income
Under a withdrawal plan based on interest-bearing bank deposits, repayment of your own capital is generally not taxable. Interest, however, is investment income.
The German saver's allowance is €1,000 per person, or €2,000 for jointly assessed married couples and registered civil partners. It applies to total qualifying investment income, not separately to each account.
Above the available allowance, investment income is generally subject to 25% tax plus the solidarity surcharge and, where applicable, church tax. Without church tax, the combined rate including the solidarity surcharge is 26.375%. Applying for a favourable-rate assessment may reduce the liability if taxation at ordinary income tax rates is more favourable.
Example for interest-only withdrawals: If €231,432 remains invested throughout the year and interest is withdrawn as it accrues, a nominal annual rate of 2% produces €4,628.64 in annual interest. Assuming the full €1,000 saver's allowance is available, with no church tax and no favourable-rate assessment, tax is approximately €957.05. This leaves approximately €3,671.59 a year, or €306 per month on average.
With capital drawdown, by contrast, the interest-bearing balance falls. The tax liability therefore changes too. The modelled withdrawal of €1,171 is consequently not a fixed after-tax payment. If tax is paid from the invested capital in addition to withdrawals, the plan must be adjusted accordingly.
Funds, securities and pension insurance contracts have different rules for calculating and taxing returns. The bank deposit calculation cannot be applied to them unchanged.
Letting: depreciation is not a cash outflow
Rental income is taxable after deducting allowable expenses. The example assumes that the €2,000 of costs is fully deductible in the same year and that a further €3,000 of building depreciation is allowable:
Taxable rental income: €9,600 − €2,000 − €3,000 = €4,600 a year.
Depreciation reduces taxable profit, not current cash holdings. Conversely, merely paying into the maintenance reserve of a German condominium owners' association does not immediately create a deductible expense. Major building works may also receive different tax treatment from routine repairs.
Health insurance: insurance status is decisive
For people compulsorily insured under Germany's statutory health insurance scheme for pensioners, private rental and investment income is generally excluded from contribution calculations. For voluntary members of statutory health insurance, this income may instead attract contributions up to the contribution assessment ceiling; income already taken into account also matters. Related effects on long-term care insurance should be considered.
Private health insurance contributions are not directly based on this income. Further information is available in rental income in retirement.
05Where the sale proceeds could be held
A withdrawal plan needs sufficient accessible cash. Easy-access savings and fixed-term deposits with staggered maturities can form part of the arrangement. Easy-access rates can change, while fixed-term deposits are often inaccessible during their term. Each reinvestment may take place at a lower interest rate.
Bonds are not bank deposits. They can carry price and default risks, particularly if sold before maturity. A higher expected return is therefore not directly comparable with interest on a protected bank deposit.
Deposit protection: check banking licences and existing balances
Statutory deposit protection generally covers up to €100,000 per depositor per credit institution, including eligible interest. Different brands may belong to the same credit institution.
For certain temporary high balances, section 8 of the German Deposit Guarantee Act (EinSiG) provides increased protection of up to €500,000 for six months, subject to conditions. Qualifying events can include transactions involving privately used residential property. Selling a rental investment flat does not, by itself, establish entitlement to this higher protection.
To keep the example proceeds of €231,432 entirely within the standard statutory limit, at least three legally separate credit institutions are required. Existing balances and a buffer for interest must also be taken into account.
06Combining approaches rather than choosing all or nothing
- Retain a reserve: Use only part of the proceeds for regular withdrawals. A separate reserve can cushion unexpected expenses, but reduces the monthly withdrawal.
- Sell later: Continue letting for now and reconsider a sale if your liquidity needs or management burden change. The future sale price and time needed to sell remain uncertain.
- Split a property portfolio: Sell one flat while retaining others as rental assets. Practical guidance is available in selling a tenanted flat.
- Consider lifetime payments: A contractual lifetime annuity or an insurance annuity purchased with a lump sum can help address the risk of payments ending after a fixed term. Costs, the payer's creditworthiness, security arrangements, inflation and survivor benefits require separate assessment.

07Which risks belong in the decision?
| Risk | Implications for your planning |
|---|---|
| Living longer than planned | This income source ends when the withdrawal plan finishes. Check whether other lifetime income covers essential spending. |
| Inflation | A fixed withdrawal loses purchasing power. Preserving nominal capital does not automatically protect against inflation either. |
| Falling interest rates | The planned withdrawal may no longer be sustainable when money is reinvested. |
| Care needs and unexpected expenses | Additional withdrawals can shorten the term. |
| Letting risks | Vacancies, unpaid rent, repairs and special assessments can reduce the rental surplus. |
| Inheritance | Full capital drawdown leaves no assets from this invested amount at the end of the plan. |
Rents can rise, but not without limits: contract terms, tenancy law and local demand constrain increases. A particular future property value is equally uncertain.
08Conclusion: separate monthly cash availability from remaining wealth
In the example, a rental surplus of approximately €633 compares with monthly withdrawals of approximately €1,171 over 20 years, both before tax. The larger payment under capital drawdown arises mainly from consuming your own assets.
Selling may make sense if you need more liquidity or want to stop being a landlord. Keeping the property or combining approaches may fit better if you place greater weight on ongoing rental income and retaining assets. Your financial security in later life, the specific property and an individual calculation after tax and possible insurance contributions are decisive.
This guide provides general information on the legal and tax framework as at October 2026. It does not replace individual investment, tax or legal advice.
09Free initial consultation
A free initial consultation gives you an opportunity to discuss your circumstances and the options of keeping or selling. The discussion is based on your property documents, liquidity needs and transparent assumptions. Arrange an initial consultation.
FAQFrequently asked questions
What does capital drawdown mean?
Capital drawdown means gradually spending your own assets as well as the returns they generate. Under a plan designed to consume the entire balance, the invested capital is exhausted at the end of the planned term. Actual outcomes depend on factors including returns, costs, tax and additional withdrawals.
How do I calculate a monthly withdrawal?
With a constant positive monthly interest rate, the formula is: capital × i ÷ [1 − (1 + i)^(−n)]. Here, i is the monthly interest rate and n is the number of withdrawals at the end of each month. Starting with €231,432 at a nominal annual rate of 2% with monthly interest accrual produces approximately €1,171 a month over 20 years before tax and investment costs. Without interest, divide the capital by the number of months.
Is selling a rental flat tax-free after ten years?
For property held as a private asset, a sale after the ten-year period has expired is generally outside the scope of income tax under section 23 of the German Income Tax Act. The binding purchase and sale contracts normally determine the dates. Commercial property trading and unusual acquisition circumstances require separate assessment.
How is capital drawdown taxed?
For interest-bearing bank deposits, repayment of your own capital is generally not taxable. Interest is taxable to the extent it is not covered by the available saver's allowance. This is €1,000 per person or €2,000 for joint assessment. Above that amount, investment income is generally subject to 25% tax plus the solidarity surcharge and, where applicable, church tax; a favourable-rate assessment may be beneficial. Different rules may apply to other investments.
What happens if I live longer than planned?
Once the invested capital is fully consumed, payments from that withdrawal plan stop. Other sources of income are unaffected. A longer planning horizon, separate reserves and lifetime income can help cushion this risk, but may reduce the amount immediately available.
Is it better to live only on the interest?
With interest-only withdrawals, nominal capital is preserved, but the payments are smaller. With €231,432 and an assumed nominal annual interest rate of 2%, the payment is approximately €386 a month before tax. With the full €1,000 saver's allowance available, no church tax and no favourable-rate assessment, approximately €306 a month remains on average. Inflation can still reduce the purchasing power of the capital.

Writes about Purchase process, Notary and land registry and Letting.
Kevin combines twelve years of sales experience with nine years specialising in property and more than 500 consultations. He writes about property quality, location risks and a safe path from the first comparison to completion.
This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.



