Guide · Kapitalanlage

    Selling a tenanted flat: what remains after mortgage and tax

    The tenant stays, the buyer bases their calculations on the rent, and the timing determines the tax and early repayment charge. We explain the process and calculate what you are left with.


    Managing Director of the InvestImmo Group
    Updated 16 October 202611 min read
    What makes the difference in this example
    €21,691
    Tax on a sale before the deadline
    due to depreciation being added back
    €3,500
    Early repayment charge
    assumed; no longer payable after ten years
    +€31,390
    higher proceeds from a later sale
    at the same price; not a forecast
    €0
    Impact on the tenancy agreement
    the buyer takes it over

    You bought a flat a few years ago and rented it out. Now you are thinking about selling it. Perhaps you need the money, perhaps the flat no longer fits your portfolio, or perhaps the current price is tempting.

    The first question is usually what happens to the tenant. The more important question comes next. What will actually remain in your bank account after the outstanding mortgage, early repayment charge and tax? Two dates in the calendar can often make a five-figure difference here.

    01What happens to the tenant when you sell

    The principle is that “a sale does not terminate a tenancy”. Once entered in the land register, the buyer assumes all rights and obligations under the tenancy agreement (§ 566 BGB). The rent, term and agreed conditions remain as they are. The tenant does not have to consent or sign a new agreement. We explain the details in our guide A sale does not terminate a tenancy.

    TopicWhat appliesLegal basis
    Tenancy agreementtransfers to the buyer unchanged§ 566 BGB
    Tenancy depositThe buyer takes it over; if the tenant subsequently cannot recover it from the buyer, the seller remains liable§ 566a BGB
    Right of first refusalonly applies if the flat was converted into an individually owned unit after the tenant moved in§ 577 BGB
    Buyer’s need for personal occupationpossible, subject to the statutory notice period; following a conversion, only after at least three years§§ 573, 577a BGB
    Viewingswith advance notice and at reasonable times, where there is a specific reason such as a saleBGH, 04.06.2014, VIII ZR 289/13

    The right of first refusal therefore only affects some flats. If you bought a flat that was already let as an individually owned unit, this will generally not concern you. Find out more in the glossary under Tenant’s right of first refusal.

    02Who buys a tenanted flat

    There are three groups of buyers for a tenanted flat. They approach the numbers very differently.

    Property investors are the largest group. They are interested in the rent, not the kitchen. They divide the purchase price by the annual net rent excluding service charges and compare this purchase price multiple with other properties on the market. A flat with a monthly rent excluding service charges of €720 and a price of €230,000 has a multiple of around 26.6. If the rent is significantly below the local rent index, this pushes down the price because rent increases are only possible within certain limits.

    Owner-occupiers are looking for a flat to move into. A tenanted flat is only an option for them if they can terminate the tenancy on grounds of personal occupation and are willing to wait. This takes time and is not guaranteed. Owner-occupiers therefore usually pay less for a tenanted flat than for a vacant one.

    The tenant themselves is often the most straightforward buyer. They know the flat, there are no viewings and no need to move out. Ask them before appointing an estate agent.

    From our conversations
    „Who will buy it from me after ten years?“

    We often hear this question in consultations, even before the purchase. For a standard tenanted, individually owned flat, the honest answer is: primarily other property investors who base their calculations on the rent. The closer the rent is to market levels and the better organised the owners’ association’s records are, the wider the pool of buyers. Nobody can promise you a buyer or a price.

    When valuing tenanted flats, surveyors primarily use the income approach, alongside comparable sale prices. Our guide Property valuation reports explains when a valuation report is worthwhile and what it costs.

    Reviewing a site plan and residential building model
    AI-generated illustrative image

    03What selling costs

    Under the usual contractual arrangements, the buyer pays the property transfer tax and the notary’s fees for the purchase agreement. Other costs fall to the seller.

    ItemAmountWhen it applies
    Seller’s share of estate agent’s commissionfreely negotiable; 3.57% including VAT in this examplewhen using an estate agent; where the buyer is a consumer, no more than half the total commission (§ 656c BGB)
    Removal of the land chargenotary and land registry fees, usually a few hundred eurosif the buyer does not take over the land charge (Removing a land charge)
    Early repayment chargedepends on the outstanding balance, interest rate and remaining termif you repay the loan during the fixed-rate period
    Energy performance certificatea few hundred euros, depending on the typemust be available at the viewing (§ 80 Abs. 4 GEG)
    Tax on the gainpersonal income tax rateif the sale agreement is signed within ten years of the purchase (§ 23 EStG)

    The two major costs are the last two items in the table relating to early repayment and tax. Both depend on the date.

    The early repayment charge no longer applies once the fixed-rate period ends. If your loan has a longer fixed-rate period, you can terminate it ten years after full disbursement by giving six months’ notice, without paying compensation (§ 489 Abs. 1 Nr. 2 BGB). Before then, you may terminate early when selling, but must compensate the bank for its loss (§ 490 Abs. 2 BGB). Work through your own case using the Early repayment charge calculator.

    The tax no longer applies if more than ten years elapse between the two notarised purchase agreements. For a tenanted flat, there is no owner-occupation exemption. The catch lies in how the gain is calculated. The depreciation (AfA) you claimed during the years the property was let reduces your acquisition costs (§ 23 Abs. 3 Satz 4 EStG). This creates a gain even if you sell at the original purchase price. Our guide The property speculation period explains this in detail, including how to calculate the deadline.

    Tool
    What does selling before the deadline cost?

    Enter the purchase and sale dates, prices and depreciation claimed.

    04Worked example: sell now or after the relevant periods have expired

    Thomas is single and has taxable income of €75,000 a year. On 01.07.2018, he bought a rented two-room flat under a notarised purchase agreement for €180,000, or €198,000 including purchase costs. He financed €180,000 at 1.5% interest with an initial repayment rate of 2% and a ten-year fixed-rate period. The flat currently generates €720 in rent excluding service charges. A buyer offers €230,000. The name is fictional, and the figures are a worked example, not a forecast.

    Thomas compares two options. Option A is to sell now, with the purchase agreement signed at the end of 2026 and the mortgage repaid in January 2027. Option B is to sell with a purchase agreement signed after 01.07.2028, once the capital gains tax holding period has expired and the fixed-rate period ends at the same time. For B, we assume the same price to isolate the effect of these periods.

    What Thomas has left after the sale
    A: Sale at the end of 2026B: Sale after 01.07.2028
    Sale price€230,000€230,000
    Estate agent and removal of the land charge (assumption)−€9,000−€9,000
    Early repayment charge (assumption)−€3,500€0
    Outstanding mortgage balance−€147,385−€141,186
    Tax on the gain (income tax + solidarity surcharge, 2026)−€21,691€0
    Left in the bank account+€48,424+€79,814
    Gain in A: €230,000 − €9,000 − €3,500 − (€198,000 − €26,928 depreciation allowance) = €46,428. Tax calculated under § 32a EStG for 2026, single, with no church tax. Rental income and costs up to mid-2028 are not included. Own calculation, as at 14.10.2026.

    Why is the gain so high when the flat sells for only €50,000 more than it cost? This is down to the depreciation allowance (AfA). Over eight and a half years, Thomas has claimed €26,928 in depreciation, reducing his tax bill. If he sells within the holding period, the tax office recaptures this amount through the taxable gain. The early repayment charge counts as a selling cost and reduces the gain (BFH, 11.02.2014, IX R 42/13). He cannot deduct it as an income-related expense against rental income.

    Where the €31,390 difference comes from
    No tax on the gain
    +€21,691
    No early repayment charge
    +€3,500
    An extra year and a half of repayments
    +€6,199
    Assuming the same sale price. The price in 2028 may be higher or lower.

    The result is not an argument for always waiting. Thomas has funded the repayments in Option B himself, using rent and his own money. And nobody knows whether a buyer will still pay €230,000 in 2028. If the price falls by more than around €25,000, the tax and early repayment charge savings are wiped out. The calculation shows how large a price difference is needed to make an early sale worthwhile.

    From our conversations
    „Can the next buyer depreciate only the remaining 30 per cent, or can they claim depreciation in full again?“

    The buyer claims depreciation on their own purchase price, not on your residual value. Straight-line depreciation starts afresh for them, at 2% of the building component per year for an older building constructed in 1925 or later (§ 7 Abs. 4 EStG). Special depreciation allowances, such as those under § 7b EStG, and declining-balance depreciation are available only to those who buy by the end of the year of completion. For an investor, an existing flat has therefore not exhausted its tax benefits.

    Apartment buildings with a shared green courtyard
    AI-generated illustrative image

    05Sell or keep

    Whether selling is worthwhile depends less on the market than on your circumstances. These questions will help you decide.

    Points more towards selling
    • The capital gains tax holding period has expired and the fixed-rate period will end soon anyway
    • The owners’ association is planning major refurbishment work requiring a special levy
    • You need the equity for a flat with a better rent-to-price ratio
    • You want to reduce your concentration risk in a single city or building
    Points more towards keeping
    • The purchase agreement was signed less than ten years ago and tax will swallow a large share of the gain
    • The outstanding mortgage balance is low, the flat covers its costs and the tenant pays reliably
    • You are selling only because the price currently seems high, without a plan for the money
    • An early repayment charge would significantly reduce the proceeds

    An alternative to selling is to borrow against the property. If you need equity for your next flat, you can often use your existing flat as additional security rather than selling it. Our guide to borrowing against a property explains how this works.

    06The process in eight steps

    How to sell a rented flat
    1. 01
      Check the relevant periods

      The date of your purchase agreement, the end of the fixed-rate period and your right to terminate under § 489 BGB. These determine the earliest date on which you can sell without tax or an early repayment charge.

    2. 02
      Gather the documents

      Land register extract, declaration of division, minutes of the last three owners’ meetings, annual budget and service charge statement for owners, tenancy agreement with all rent increases, proof of the tenancy deposit, energy performance certificate.

    3. 03
      Establish the value

      Comparable prices and the purchase price-to-annual-rent multiple; obtain a valuation report if you are unsure.

    4. 04
      Inform the tenant

      Be open and do so early, making clear that the tenancy agreement will remain in place.

    5. 05
      Market the property

      Either yourself or through an estate agent; every advert must include the mandatory information from the energy performance certificate (§ 87 GEG).

    6. 06
      Check the buyer

      Request confirmation of financing from the bank before the notary appointment.

    7. 07
      Have the purchase agreement notarised

      Include provisions covering rent, the deposit, the service charge reconciliation and the handover date.

    8. 08
      Complete the transaction

      Terminate and repay the mortgage, remove the land charge, inform the tenant about the new landlord and declare the gain in your tax return for the year in which you receive the proceeds if the holding period had not yet expired.

    Step 7 is often underestimated. The tenant will continue paying you until they know about the change of ownership. Specify in the purchase agreement when the buyer becomes entitled to the rent, who will prepare the current service charge reconciliation and how the deposit will be transferred.

    07Risks: what to watch out for

    While waiting until you can sell tax-free, you bear the price risk. If interest rates rise, fewer buyers will be able to secure financing. If a special levy is on the horizon, buyers will want a discount. The tenant may also give notice in the meantime, leaving you with a vacant flat and the task of finding a new tenant. Conversely, selling within the holding period can make sense if major maintenance work is imminent or the money is urgently needed elsewhere. Calculate both options in euros to see at what price difference waiting is no longer worthwhile.

    FAQFrequently asked questions

    Can I sell my tenanted flat without the tenant's consent?

    Yes. The tenant does not need to consent or be informed before you look for a buyer. The buyer takes over the tenancy agreement unchanged (§ 566 BGB). The tenant's cooperation is only needed for viewings, with advance notice and at reasonable times.

    Does my tenant have a right of first refusal?

    Only if the flat was converted into an individually owned unit after the tenant moved in (§ 577 BGB). In that case, the seller must inform the tenant about the sale contract and their right of first refusal. The tenant has two months to declare in writing that they will buy on the same terms. If you sell to family members, the right of first refusal does not apply.

    Is a tenanted flat worth less than a vacant one?

    For owner-occupiers, yes, because they cannot move in immediately. For property investors, the rent is what matters. A market-level rent with a reliable tenant can support the price, while a rent well below the local rent index pushes it down. There is no standard discount; it depends on the pool of buyers.

    Do I have to pay tax when selling a tenanted flat?

    If no more than ten years pass between your purchase contract and the sale contract, the gain is taxable at your personal income tax rate (§ 23 EStG). Depreciation (AfA) previously claimed increases the gain. After ten years, the sale of a privately held property is tax-free, provided you are not classified as a commercial property trader.

    Can I deduct the early repayment charge for tax purposes?

    Only if the sale is taxable within the ten-year period. In that case, it reduces the gain as a selling expense. It does not qualify as an income-related expense for the rental activity (BFH, 11 February 2014, IX R 42/13).

    Can the buyer terminate the tenancy on the grounds of personal use?

    Yes, if they need the flat for themselves or close relatives and comply with the statutory notice periods (§ 573 BGB). If the flat was converted into an individually owned unit after the tenant moved in, a blocking period of at least three years from the sale applies, rising to up to ten years in some municipalities (§ 577a BGB). For details, see the guide Termination for personal use.

    When is the best time to sell a tenanted flat?

    From a tax and financial perspective, it is often shortly after ten years have passed since the purchase, if the fixed-rate period also ends then or the loan can be terminated. Nobody can predict the market price. You should therefore calculate how far the price could fall before waiting is no longer worthwhile.

    Who prepares the service charge statement after the sale?

    The seller prepares the statement for accounting years that had already ended when ownership changed (BGH, 2 December 2003, VIII ZR 168/03). According to the prevailing legal view, the buyer is responsible for the current year. The settlement of advance payments is agreed in the sale contract.

    08Further reading

    09Sources

    All sources accessed on 14 October 2026.

    Disclaimer: This guide provides general information and is not a substitute for tax or legal advice tailored to individual circumstances. All figures are illustrative calculations based on disclosed assumptions, as at 14 October 2026.

    Written by
    Managing Director of the InvestImmo Group

    Writes about Taxes, AfA (depreciation), Financing and Investment concept.

    Andriy is Managing Director of the InvestImmo Group and has been an entrepreneur in the property industry since 2020. His experience in estate agency, property marketing and his own investments shapes his view on property selection and long-term investment concepts. His team handles the personal advice for investors.

    This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.

    Free · Instant · No sign-up

    Download this guide as a PDF

    The complete guide as a clean A4 file – with a cover page, all chapters and page numbers. Keep it on hand, read it offline, or go through it at your own pace during your consultation.

    • All chapters, tables and worked examples
    • Read offline – on your phone or printed out
    • Go through it at your own pace or pass it on
    • Free, no sign-up, no email required

    A4 format · 3,308 words · As of 16 October 2026

    Related guides

    All guides