Let or sell your house? Compare the figures
Moving home raises a question: let your former home or sell it? A worked example with an inexpensive existing mortgage highlights the differences and tax implications.
You are moving home. Perhaps for work, because your family is growing, or because your children have moved out. The house you have lived in will be left behind. Should you sell it or let it?
It may feel like an instinctive decision. However, financing, cash flow and tax conditions provide a framework for assessing it. If you let the house first and sell a few years later, you may face tax on a gain that could have been exempt on an immediate sale.
01The starting point
The Becker family bought a terraced house in 2019 for €380,000, plus €30,000 in acquisition costs. The names are fictional and the figures are an illustration, not a forecast. In autumn 2026, they move to another city and buy another home. The example assumes that they have occupied the house continuously since buying it.
- Outstanding mortgage: €260,000, interest rate 1.2%, fixed until 2029, monthly payment €1,000
- Assumed sale price: €450,000; an individual valuation remains necessary for the decision
- Assumed rent excluding service charges [Kaltmiete]: €1,500 a month; the rent actually achievable depends on the local market, the condition of the house and statutory rent limits
- The couple's taxable income before additional rental income or property disposal gains: €110,000, assessed jointly
The Beckers need funds towards their next home. For the new mortgage, we use an assumed interest rate of 3.8%. This serves only as an illustration and does not describe a specific mortgage offer.
The tax effect is also simplified: we apply an assumed flat income tax rate of 40% to additional taxable income. This illustrative rate is not derived from the €110,000 income figure. The solidarity surcharge and church tax are excluded. The actual additional tax depends on total taxable income and the tax schedule applicable in the relevant year. Ask your tax adviser to calculate it for your circumstances.
02Start with the tax position
A sale of privately held property generally falls within section 23(1), sentence 1, no. 1 EStG if no more than ten years have passed between acquisition and disposal. There is an exception for an owner-occupied home. A sale may be exempt if you used the property
- exclusively as your own home between acquisition or completion and sale; or
- as your own home in the year of sale and the two preceding calendar years.
The second route requires a continuous period, but not three complete calendar years. The middle calendar year must be covered in full (Federal Fiscal Court [Bundesfinanzhof, BFH], 27.06.2017, IX R 37/16). Subsequent letting in the year of sale can be compatible with the exemption where the required period of owner-occupation has been met (BFH 03.09.2019, IX R 10/19).
For the Beckers, assuming continuous owner-occupation, a notarised sale agreement in their moving-out year, 2026, can meet the exemption conditions. Someone who sells the following year without living there during that year does not meet this second exemption. Have your tax adviser assess the specific occupation and contract dates before moving out.
If the acquisition took place more than ten years ago, a private sale generally falls outside this taxation under section 23 EStG, even after letting. See the guide to the property disposal holding period.

03Option 1: sell
If the Beckers sell in 2026 for €450,000, the assumed estate agency fee and outstanding mortgage must be deducted. Any early repayment charge [Vorfälligkeitsentschädigung] depends on the contract, redemption date and the lender's calculation. A low contractual interest rate alone does not mean that no charge will apply. We assume zero for this example; a specific redemption statement is needed before deciding. No other potential selling costs have been included.
| Amount | |
|---|---|
| Sale price | €450,000 |
| Estate agency fee at 3.57% (assumption) | −€16,065 |
| Mortgage redemption | −€260,000 |
| Early repayment charge (assumption) | €0 |
| Cash proceeds in the model | €173,935 |
| Tax on the gain if the owner-occupation exemption applies | €0 |
Using the €173,935 towards the next home reduces the new mortgage by the same amount. At an assumed 3.8%, the illustrative annual interest saving is €6,609.53, rounded to €6,610. This simplified calculation ignores repayments during the year; the actual first-year saving depends on the financing schedule. Interest on a home used exclusively for your own occupation is generally not deductible against income.
Selling also reduces administration: no tenant, no service charge statement and no second property to manage from a distance.
04Option 2: let
If the Beckers let the house, the assumed 1.2% mortgage remains in place until its fixed-rate period ends in 2029. Compared with the 3.8% new mortgage rate assumed in the example, this is a financing advantage. Interest can be a deductible rental expense where it is economically connected with the letting (section 9(1), sentence 3, no. 1 EStG). Building depreciation [Absetzung für Abnutzung, AfA] may also be available. This example assumes completion between 1925 and 2022 and therefore a standard straight-line depreciation rate of 2% (section 7(4), sentence 1, no. 2, letter b EStG). Different standard rates apply to earlier or later completion. The basis is generally the original acquisition or construction costs allocated to the building, including associated acquisition costs, rather than its current market value.
Start with the bank account: cash flow before tax. The following calculation represents a simplified full year of letting with no void period. The €3,000 is assumed to comprise administration and maintenance expenditure actually paid and deductible in the same year, rather than money set aside in a reserve. Contributions to a property owners' association's maintenance reserve [WEG-Erhaltungsrücklage] are not immediately deductible; only actual tax-deductible expenditure from the reserve can qualify. Nor is the entire owners' service charge [Hausgeld] automatically deductible.
| Amount | |
|---|---|
| Rent excluding service charges | €18,000 |
| Non-recoverable costs actually paid and immediately deductible (assumption) | −€3,000 |
| Mortgage payments, including interest and principal | −€12,000 |
| Cash flow before tax | +€3,000 |
| Taxable rental surplus: rent − costs − €3,120 interest − €6,150 depreciation | €5,730 |
| Assumed additional tax: 40% of €5,730 | −€2,292 |
| Cash flow after tax in the example | +€708 |
| Principal repayment already included in mortgage payments: additional equity built | €8,880 |
These assumptions produce a pre-tax surplus of €3,000. After the illustrative tax charge, €708 remains each year. The inexpensive existing mortgage supports the calculation; a rate of 3.8% on the same outstanding balance would increase the interest burden. Further repairs or lost rent could absorb the surplus. Discuss deductible expenditure, the depreciation basis and your personal tax position with your tax adviser.
What does this mean for the next home? The Beckers do not have €173,935 of sale proceeds to put towards it. All else being equal, their new mortgage is correspondingly larger, and the lender assesses whether their income supports both loans. A lender may discount rental income in its assessment; the treatment depends on the lender. See How much can I borrow?.
05Comparing the two options
| Sell | Let | |
|---|---|---|
| Funds for the next home | €173,935 | €0 |
| Interest effect on the next home, ignoring repayment schedules | approximately €6,610 less | no equivalent saving |
| After-tax result from the former home | €0 | +€708 at an assumed tax rate of 40% |
| Principal repaid on the former home, simplified calculation | – | €8,880 |
| Tax on a sale in 2028, separate illustrative calculation | – | €14,494 at an assumed tax rate of 40% |
| Tax on a sale after the specific ten-year period expires in 2029 | – | generally €0 under section 23 EStG |
The simplified comparison shows an illustrative interest saving of approximately €6,610 from selling, against a rental surplus of €708 after the assumed tax charge. This is not a complete cash flow or wealth comparison: mortgage payments and repayment schedules for the next home are not included. The illustrative €8,880 of principal repaid on the former home builds equity in addition to the remaining cash surplus. It is already included in the mortgage payments deducted and is not an additional cash receipt. Whether selling allows an equivalent increase in repayments on the new home depends on the agreed mortgage payment and must not be assumed automatically.
Three points may support letting. In the example, the existing mortgage remains at 1.2% for approximately three more years. The Beckers retain a property with potential future rental income. And after their specific ten-year period expires in 2029, a private sale can generally take place without taxation under section 23 EStG.
A sale in the intervening period may, however, trigger an additional tax liability. For a sale in 2028, we assume a letting period with a total of 24 months of deductible depreciation. This equals two full annual allowances totalling €12,300. Following a move in autumn 2026, the actual depreciation depends on when letting starts and when economic ownership transfers. The example produces a taxable gain of €36,235. At the assumed additional tax rate of 40%, the tax charge is €14,494.
Before selling within the ten-year period, ask your tax adviser to calculate both the taxable gain and the additional tax arising from it.

06How to make the decision
- 01When did you buy?
If the acquisition was more than ten years ago, a private sale generally falls outside section 23 EStG. Otherwise, have the precise expiry date established from the contracts.
- 02Do you need the money for your next home?
Selling may simplify the financing and save non-deductible mortgage interest. Compare the complete loan schedules for both options.
- 03How inexpensive is your mortgage?
An existing mortgage below the rates actually available to you on new borrowing may support letting while the fixed rate lasts.
- 04Does the rent cover the property?
Calculate cash flow using realistic administration, maintenance and void costs. Separate actual expenditure, reserves, principal repayments and tax-deductible amounts.
- 05Do you want to be a landlord?
Letting from a distance may involve appointing a managing agent, selecting tenants and organising repairs. See the guide to letting a flat.
07Which option may suit you?
- Your mortgage is substantially cheaper than new offers actually available to you.
- The rent largely covers mortgage payments and costs.
- You can hold the property until the ten-year period has expired, or it has already expired.
- You need the proceeds towards your next home.
- You do not want to handle tenants and property management.
- Much of the holding period remains and an early sale is likely.
08Risks of letting your former home
The fixed rate ends. When the fixed-rate period ends in 2029, the Beckers must repay or refinance any remaining balance. At an assumed refinancing rate of 4%, interest costs may rise. Whether they need to contribute additional cash depends on the outstanding balance, new repayment terms, rent and costs, among other factors.
Unpaid rent and void periods. If a detached or terraced house is let as a single unit, the failure of that tenancy can remove all rental income.
Maintenance. For a legally separate house outside a property owners' association, you bear the costs of the roof, heating and façade yourself. A financial buffer is sensible, but setting money aside does not itself create a tax deduction. For a terraced house within a property owners' association, responsibilities and cost allocation depend on the legal ownership structure.
Restrictions on termination. Moving back in generally requires a lawful reason for ordinary termination, such as a genuine need for personal occupation [Eigenbedarf]; notice periods and possible hardship objections must be considered. Wanting to sell is not sufficient on its own. A sale does not terminate the tenancy. An existing tenancy may narrow the buyer pool and affect the achievable price; it does not establish a universal price discount. If you plan to move back in or sell with vacant possession, seek advice from a lawyer at an early stage.
Tax risk. A sale within the ten-year period after letting may produce a taxable gain if no owner-occupation exemption applies. Discuss the timing of the sale with your tax adviser.
FAQFrequently asked questions
Will I pay tax when I sell my owner-occupied home?
A private sale within the ten-year period may be exempt if you used the house exclusively as your own home between acquisition or completion and sale, or continuously in the year of sale and the two preceding calendar years, including the whole middle year. Once the precise ten-year period has expired, a private sale generally falls outside section 23 of the German Income Tax Act [Einkommensteuergesetz, EStG]. Have your tax adviser assess the occupation and contract dates.
What happens to my tax position if I let my house after moving out?
The taxable rental surplus is generally subject to income tax. Economically related interest, eligible expenses and building depreciation may be deductible; principal repayments and simply setting money aside in reserves are not. Letting does not automatically remove the owner-occupation exemption on sale. Within the ten-year period, the specific occupation and sale dates matter. Discuss the implications with your tax adviser.
How much depreciation can I claim when letting my former home?
The basis is generally the building's original acquisition or construction costs, including associated acquisition costs but excluding land. Standard annual straight-line depreciation is 2% for completion between 1925 and 2022, 3% from 2023 and 2.5% before 1925. The first rental year may require a pro-rated allowance. Current market value is not the depreciation basis. Ask your tax adviser to establish the applicable depreciation basis.
Can I deduct interest on my existing mortgage after moving out?
Generally yes, to the extent that the loan is economically connected with acquiring or constructing the house now being let. The interest may then be deductible against rental income. Principal repayments are not deductible. If the loan has mixed uses or has been refinanced, discuss the allocation with your tax adviser.
Is it better to sell a house vacant or tenanted?
A vacant house may also appeal to buyers who want to live in it themselves. An existing tenancy may narrow the buyer pool and affect the price, but a higher price with vacant possession is not guaranteed. Compare local valuations, tenancy terms and the costs of leaving it empty. The guide to selling a tenanted flat provides further information.
Can I let the house first and move back in later?
Moving back is possible if the tenancy ends validly. Termination for personal occupation requires a lawful basis; notice periods and possible hardship objections must be considered. A fixed-term residential tenancy requires a statutory reason communicated in writing when the agreement is made. Consult a lawyer about your planned return before signing the tenancy agreement.
09Further reading
- Property disposal holding period
- Selling a tenanted flat
- Sell or let an inherited property
- Tax on rental income
- Calculator: tax on a property disposal
- Glossary: early repayment charge
10Sources
- Section 23 EStG (ten-year period, owner-occupation exemption, depreciation adjustment)
- Section 7 EStG (subsection 4, sentence 1, no. 2: 3%, 2%, 2.5%)
- Section 9 EStG (loan interest as a deductible expense)
- BFH, judgment of 27.06.2017, IX R 37/16; BFH, judgment of 03.09.2019, IX R 10/19 (bundesfinanzhof.de)
- Federal Ministry of Finance [Bundesministerium der Finanzen, BMF], letter dated 05.10.2000 on private disposal transactions, paragraph 25
Note: This guide provides general information and does not replace individual tax, legal or investment advice. The figures are simplified illustrations, not a forecast. Consult a tax adviser for your personal tax calculation and a lawyer for legal questions.

Writes about Investment properties, New builds and renovation and Financing.
Nadeem is a qualified insurance and finance merchant, spent around eight years self-employed in the insurance and finance industry and has specialised in investment property since 2024. He writes about new builds, renovation, financing and the running costs of rented property.
This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.



