Guide · Wealth Building

    Private Pension Insurance or Rental Property?

    Guarantees, letting risks and German tax rules compared, with an illustrative property budget rather than a return promise.


    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo
    4 November 202611 min read
    Illustrative assumptions: retirement planning over 27 years
    €535
    Monthly contribution
    Rental apartment, rounded, before personal taxes
    €25,000
    Initial equity
    Assumed purchase costs, not a market estimate
    €198,340
    Comparison budget
    Initial capital plus rounded contributions, without interest
    €250,000
    Assumed final value
    Apartment, not a valuation forecast

    You have an offer for a private pension insurance policy on your desk, perhaps from your bank adviser or someone you know. At the same time, you are considering a rental apartment. Both are intended to provide additional retirement income. Which approach suits you?

    The honest answer depends less on headline returns than on the risks you are willing to accept. A contractual lifelong insurance pension covers longevity risk; the guaranteed minimum benefit depends on the policy. A rental apartment offers a tangible asset and potential rental income; tax savings are not guaranteed. You bear financing, maintenance and letting risks.

    01Two approaches, two principles

    Private pension insurance accumulates contributions over several years and pays a pension from an agreed age for as long as you live. Traditional policies provide contractually specified guaranteed benefits. The 1% Höchstrechnungszins under § 2 Abs. 1 DeckRV concerns the calculation of the Deckungsrückstellung, the insurer’s actuarial reserve, for contracts within its scope. It is neither a guaranteed return on the full contribution nor a blanket ceiling on every benefit promise. With unit-linked policies, performance depends on investment funds; guarantees may be limited or absent.

    A rental apartment can be financed with a loan. Whether rent after costs covers the instalments, and whether the loan is repaid by retirement, depend on financing, letting and additional payments. Costs continue after the debt has been repaid.

    Key differences
    Private pension insuranceRental apartment
    GuaranteeContract-specific minimum benefit, no universal contribution returnNone; value and rent fluctuate
    LongevityLifelong pension, including at 95Rent while let; sale possible
    BorrowingNoneUsually required, with interest-rate risk
    Tax during accumulationContributions from taxed incomeInterest and building depreciation potentially deductible
    Tax in retirementFor an unsubsidised lifelong annuity, generally the statutory earnings component; check the fraction under section 22 EStGRental surplus after allowable expenses and depreciation is taxable
    Work involvedLimitedLetting, management, owners’ meetings
    InheritanceDepends on pension guarantee period or death benefitApartment passes to heirs

    02Accumulation: contributions and costs

    Contributions to a new, unsubsidised private pension insurance policy generally come from net income without a Sonderausgabenabzug, a deduction for qualifying personal expenses. Older contracts and subsidised products follow different rules and are outside this comparison. Acquisition, administration and, where applicable, fund costs can reduce benefits. Review the cost disclosures in the required product documents and compare effective costs, where disclosed, together with guaranteed and non-guaranteed benefits on a consistent basis.

    For an apartment, your contribution is the gap between rent and the loan instalment, plus expenses. Interest attributable to letting and eligible building depreciation can reduce the taxable rental result as Werbungskosten, income-related expenses. Tax relief depends on that result, its tax recognition and your other income; a refund is not automatic. The effect of a deduction depends on your Grenzsteuersatz, or marginal tax rate.

    Reviewing financing documents and monthly costs together
    AI-generated illustrative image

    03The 27-year calculation: illustrative assumptions

    Julia is a fictional investor aged 40 who wants additional income at 67. For this example, she buys a rental apartment for €250,000 and finances the purchase price with a Volltilgerdarlehen, a loan scheduled to be fully repaid over 27 years. We also assume €25,000 in purchase costs paid from savings. This is a calculation assumption, not a statement about usual purchase costs. The apartment is assumed to produce an unchanged €850 monthly Kaltmiete, rent excluding service charges. Management and maintenance together cost €1,800 annually. This baseline excludes vacancy, major special assessments and cost increases.

    Illustrative assumptions: Julia’s monthly budget
    AmountExplanation
    Loan instalmentapproximately −€1,235€250,000 loan, 3.8% nominal interest, 27 years
    Rent excluding service charges+€850Constant and collected in full
    Management and maintenance−€150Assumed monthly expense
    Contribution before personal taxesapproximately −€535Not an after-tax burden
    Simplified monthly annuity calculation; the exact bank instalment and final payment depend on payment and interest conventions. All subsequent budget figures use the rounded €535 contribution. Neither a financing offer nor a forecast.

    Using these rounded figures, Julia contributes €173,340 over 324 months. Including the assumed purchase costs, her budget totals €198,340. An exact loan statement would differ slightly. Personal taxes are deliberately excluded: as the interest component falls, the taxable rental surplus may increase. A constant contribution before tax therefore does not mean a constant after-tax burden.

    The 3.8% nominal interest rate over the full term is purely illustrative. The availability and cost of a suitable fully amortising loan must be checked against a specific offer. A shorter fixed-interest period introduces refinancing risk. This example provides no evidence of current market interest rates.

    A fair insurance comparison must include the initial €25,000 too. An alternative using the same budget would have that amount available at the outset and €535 each month thereafter. Without interest or costs, this also produces €198,340. This is merely a budget reference, not an insurance value or guarantee. Only a specific offer can establish whether a policy accepts this payment pattern, what it costs, and what pension or capital benefit it guarantees. A savings model earning 1% would not constitute a universally valid upper limit on insurance guarantees.

    Illustrative assumptions: final value and budget reference
    Apartment, assumed debt-free final value
    €250,000
    Comparison budget, without interest or costs
    €198,340
    The property value is assumed unchanged solely for illustration, excluding selling costs. The budget reference includes €25,000 initially and 324 payments of €535. It is neither an insurance offer nor a projected maturity benefit. Personal taxes and inflation are excluded.

    What does this show? Under these assumptions, Julia ends up with a debt-free apartment generating €850 monthly rent before expenses. After the assumed running costs, €700 remains before taxes. The assumed property value exceeds the interest-free budget reference, but this does not prove a return advantage over insurance. That would require the policy’s actual guaranteed and non-guaranteed benefits and a complete comparison after costs and taxes. A fall in property value, vacancy or major refurbishment would worsen the result. Selling may also incur costs. For insurance, distinguish guaranteed benefits from non-binding projections and surplus participation.

    04Retirement income: tax and health insurance

    In retirement, the picture changes. Taxable amounts can differ substantially; any after-tax advantage depends on individual circumstances.

    For an unsubsidised lifelong private annuity, a statutory earnings component is generally taxable. Its size depends on age at commencement and must be checked under section 22 EStG. The following calculation uses an assumed taxable fraction of 17% purely for illustration; it does not validate a specific insurance policy.

    For an apartment, the tax surplus after deductible expenses and depreciation is generally fully taxable. The following illustrative example compares taxable amounts only, not the actual tax payable in a future retirement year. The assumed insurance pension is freely chosen and is not derived from the preceding budget.

    Illustrative assumptions: taxable amounts in retirement
    Private pension of €700 monthlyApartment producing €700 monthly after costs
    Annual payment before personal taxes€8,400€8,400
    Assumed building depreciationNot applicable€4,400
    Annual taxable amount€1,428€4,000
    Apartment with no depreciation remaining€8,400
    The tax calculation assumes a taxable pension fraction of 17% purely for illustration. For the debt-free apartment, annual building depreciation of €4,400 is assumed to remain available purely for illustration; land cannot be depreciated. Running costs are assumed fully and immediately deductible here. Contributions to a WEG-Erhaltungsrücklage, the owners’ association’s maintenance reserve, are not deductible simply upon payment into the reserve. This is not a comparison of actual tax bills in 27 years.

    In this example, the apartment’s taxable amount with depreciation is €2,572 higher. That does not translate into a fixed additional tax bill: total taxable income, personal deductions and the law applicable at the time determine the result. Whether and for how long the assumed depreciation is available depends particularly on the building allocation, depreciation method and commencement date.

    For health insurance, both approaches are treated similarly while you are compulsorily insured in the Krankenversicherung der Rentner, the statutory pensioners’ health insurance system. A purely privately financed, unsubsidised pension and rental income generally do not attract additional health or long-term care insurance contributions in that system. Occupational pension benefits follow different rules. For voluntary statutory members, both income categories may attract contributions up to the contribution assessment ceiling. See rental income in retirement.

    A couple looking over residential buildings while planning for the long term
    AI-generated illustrative image

    05Flexibility, termination and inheritance

    Terminating or selling. You can terminate pension insurance and receive the Rückkaufswert, its surrender value. Particularly in the early years, this is often considerably below contributions paid. You can also sell an apartment, but timing and price are uncertain. Depending on the arrangements, costs may include an estate agent, releasing charges over the property or a Vorfälligkeitsentschädigung, an early-repayment charge. Selling a privately held rental apartment within ten years may trigger income tax on the disposal gain.

    Dividing the investment. Whether a policy can be borrowed against or made paid-up, and the consequences, depend on the contract and statutory requirements. A single apartment cannot, in practice, be liquidated in small, readily tradable portions. Owners of several apartments can sell one and retain the others.

    Inheritance. If the insured person dies early, the insurer pays only the agreed benefits, such as payments during a Rentengarantiezeit, a guaranteed payment period. Without such arrangements, remaining capital may stay with the insurance pool. The apartment passes to heirs together with any debts and obligations; potential inheritance tax requires separate assessment.

    06Which approach suits whom?

    More suited to insurance
    • You want a guaranteed minimum benefit and lifelong payments.
    • You have no interest in letting or property management.
    • You prefer contractually agreed benefits to letting and financing risks.
    More suited to a rental apartment
    • Your income and reserves can cover financing, maintenance and missed rent even without a tax refund.
    • You can sustain contributions over many years and hold adequate reserves.
    • You want a tangible asset you can sell or leave to heirs.

    The two approaches are not mutually exclusive. One possible combination is an apartment alongside a smaller pension insurance policy covering part of your longevity risk. The guide to calculating your retirement income gap helps establish the size of the shortfall.

    07Risks on both sides

    Inflation reduces the purchasing power of insurance benefits. A nominally guaranteed pension loses real value when prices rise. The Höchstrechnungszins is not a return on contributions and provides no inflation protection. Costs reduce benefits; guarantees also depend on the insurer’s ability to pay and the applicable protection mechanisms.

    Property exposes you to market risks. Vacancy, unpaid rent, maintenance and special assessments fall to you. The value can decline, particularly in weaker locations.

    Property exposes you to interest-rate risk. Interest rates may be higher when the fixed-interest period ends. Our calculation using 3.8% over 27 years is a simplification.

    Laws can change for both. The taxation of pensions, rental income and insurance may change. The tax discussion describes general principles; the illustrative amounts are not promises about the law in your eventual retirement.

    FAQFrequently asked questions

    Which is better for retirement?

    It depends on your budget, risk capacity and the actual policy. A lifelong insurance pension covers longevity risk. An apartment provides a saleable asset but requires reserves and exposes you to letting, valuation and financing risks.

    How is a private pension taxed in Germany?

    For an unsubsidised lifelong private annuity, a statutory earnings component is generally taxable. Its size depends on age when payments begin; it is not a tax rate. Lump sums follow different rules.

    Is the Höchstrechnungszins a guaranteed return?

    No. It concerns the calculation of actuarial reserves for insurance contracts within its scope. Guaranteed benefits are set by the policy; it does not directly establish a return on your full contributions.

    Is rental income taxed more heavily in retirement?

    The rental surplus after deductible costs and depreciation is generally taxable in full, whereas only the Ertragsanteil of an unsubsidised private lifelong pension is taxable. The actual tax difference depends on total income and personal circumstances.

    Should I surrender an existing policy to buy property?

    Do not rush. Check the surrender value, existing guarantees, tax consequences and alternatives such as making the policy paid-up. Then assess the specific property financing, including reserves.

    Can I combine both approaches?

    Yes. An apartment can provide wealth and rental income, while a supplementary lifelong insurance pension covers part of longevity risk. The combined commitments must remain affordable.

    08Further reading

    09Sources

    Note: This guide provides general information and does not replace individual investment, insurance, tax or legal advice. All calculated amounts are illustrative examples based on disclosed assumptions, not forecasts. Editorial date: 28 October 2026.

    Written by
    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo

    Writes about Purchase process, Notary and land registry and Letting.

    Kevin combines twelve years of sales experience with nine years specialising in property and more than 500 consultations. He writes about property quality, location risks and a safe path from the first comparison to completion.

    This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.

    Free · Instant · No sign-up

    Download this guide as a PDF

    The complete guide as a clean A4 file – with a cover page, all chapters and page numbers. Keep it on hand, read it offline, or go through it at your own pace during your consultation.

    • All chapters, tables and worked examples
    • Read offline – on your phone or printed out
    • Go through it at your own pace or pass it on
    • Free, no sign-up, no email required

    A4 format · 2,534 words · As of 04 November 2026

    Related guides

    All guides