Developer insolvency: protection and remaining risks
If a developer becomes insolvent during construction, priority notices, MaBV instalments and guarantees can limit the risks. We explain their limits and use explicit assumptions to illustrate the additional costs and lost income buyers may face.
You have bought a new-build flat. The structural shell is up, the roof is on, and almost two-thirds of the purchase price has been paid. Then a letter arrives: the property developer [Bauträger] has filed for insolvency. Work on site has stopped.
Developer insolvency can affect buyers even after careful preparation. Rising construction or financing costs can put additional pressure on a project. German law provides several forms of protection, but none offers complete protection against losses and delays.
„What happens if the developer becomes insolvent and I am left bearing the costs?“
Blanket reassurance would be misplaced. Understanding what each form of protection covers allows you to check whether it is in place before buying and include an adverse scenario in your calculations.
01Two routes: instalments linked to construction progress or a guarantee
The ordinance allows developers to accept buyers' money only subject to specified conditions. Two protection routes need to be distinguished.
| Route 1: instalments under section 3 MaBV | Route 2: guarantee under section 7 MaBV | |
|---|---|---|
| When you pay | once the statutory and contractual conditions are met, then according to the prescribed construction stages | earlier payments may be permitted where valid security is provided |
| Number of instalments | no more than seven, assembled from the statutory component amounts | not tied to the section 3 schedule; other legal restrictions continue to apply |
| What protects you | payment conditions, staged payments and the priority notice; no guarantee of value | security from an eligible credit institution or insurer covering the relevant repayment claims |
| In the event of insolvency | the secured ownership-transfer claim remains protected; completion and release from charges need resolving | an existing repayment claim covered by the guarantee can be pursued |
| Practical checks | check payment conditions, construction progress and release from charges | check the scope, validity and release conditions of the guarantee |
Under the first route, payments follow the statutory construction stages. Where ownership of land is being transferred, 30% is provided for after earthworks begin, followed by proportions of the remaining 70% for the structural shell, roof, building services, windows and other work (section 3(2) MaBV). The first stage therefore requires earthworks to have begun, not to have been completed. Details are explained in the glossary entry on the MaBV payment schedule.
„At which construction stages are payments due, and how are they secured before completion?“
This question should be addressed before signing the contract. The answer lies in the payment schedule, statutory conditions and security documents. Also establish which conditions the notary confirms and which additional evidence is required.
02Priority notice and release from charges: what happens to the land and building if things go wrong
Before a payment under section 3 MaBV, the relevant conditions must be satisfied, including the legal conditions relating to the contract, a priority notice securing the transfer of ownership [Auflassungsvormerkung] with the agreed ranking, secured arrangements for release from property charges not being assumed by the buyer, and the building-law requirements (section 3(1) MaBV). These include a building permit [Baugenehmigung] or the statutory alternative evidence. The notary's notice that payment is due [Fälligkeitsmitteilung] concerns the conditions the notary is responsible for confirming. It is not a general confirmation of construction progress or every technical and building-law requirement.
The priority notice secures your claim to a transfer of ownership. That secured claim remains protected in insolvency (section 106(1) InsO), even if construction does not continue. This does not mean that you automatically become the owner without further checks or payments. Outstanding obligations, contractual conditions and release from charges need to be resolved.
The construction work itself, where a contract remains incompletely performed by both parties, is generally subject to the insolvency administrator's choice whether to perform it once insolvency proceedings have opened (section 103 InsO). If the administrator declines performance, claims arising from non-performance can be lodged as claims in the insolvency proceedings. Whether, and to what extent, they receive payment depends on the proceedings.
The financing bank's release declaration [Freistellungserklärung] sets out the conditions under which its property charges will cease to encumber your flat. If construction is not completed, the bank may reserve the right to refund payments made in accordance with the contract, up to the proportionate value of the contractual property, instead of releasing the charges (section 3(1) MaBV). This reservation also matters when assessing whether arranging completion yourself is feasible as planned. Obtain the declaration and have its implications explained by your notary or an appropriately qualified lawyer.

03The 5% completion security
Under a property developer contract [Bauträgervertrag] with a consumer, security amounting to 5% of the agreed total remuneration must generally be provided with the first progress payment, covering timely completion without substantial defects (section 650m(2) BGB in conjunction with section 650u BGB). A private property investor can also be a consumer; this should not be equated with every commercial or corporate purchasing arrangement.
The security can be provided through a suitable guarantee or surety (section 650m(3) BGB). If the developer requests security by retention, progress payments are withheld up to the full security amount. This does not mean merely deducting 5% from each successive instalment. On a purchase price of €340,000, the security amounts to €17,000.
This protection is often informally called a completion guarantee [Fertigstellungsbürgschaft]. It is not a substitute for comprehensive security. Whether and when you can draw on it depends on the secured claim and the arrangements. If covered losses exceed €17,000, that amount is insufficient in this example. Have an appropriately qualified lawyer assess the scope of the security and the conditions for claiming under it.
04The advance payment guarantee under section 7 MaBV
If a developer wishes to accept payments outside the conditions or payment schedule under section 3 MaBV, security is required for the repayment claims covered by the legislation (section 7(1) MaBV). A suitable bank or insurance guarantee serves this purpose. The security must generally remain in place until the conditions of section 3(1) MaBV are met and the contractual property is fully completed. Other civil-law restrictions on agreements requiring advance payments continue to apply.
An advance payment guarantee [Vorauszahlungsbürgschaft] secures repayment claims, not completion of the flat. Insolvency does not automatically trigger cancellation of the transaction and payment under the guarantee. There must be an enforceable repayment claim covered by the security. For investors seeking a particular flat, the distinction between repayment and completion matters.
05Worked example: insolvency after completion of the structural shell
Illustrative calculation, simplified: The Hartmann family have bought a 65 m² new-build flat for €340,000 as an investment. They are contributing €34,000 of their own funds and intend to borrow the remaining €306,000 of the purchase price. The assumed nominal interest rate is 3.8%; this is not a statement about current market offers. The family are fictional and the figures are an illustration, not a forecast.
Payments have followed the instalment schedule. After earthworks begin, the structural shell is completed and the roof coverings and gutters are installed, 63.6% has been paid in this example. The developer files for insolvency. After proceedings open, the insolvency administrator declines to complete the development. The buyers join forces and appoint a surveyor and other contractors.
For simplicity, the calculation treats the outstanding purchase price of €123,760 as the original remaining completion budget. This is not a statement about actual construction costs or the legal settlement of the contract. It assumes completion costs rise by 30% and rental income starts nine months late. It also assumes that ownership transfer and release from charges are secured for construction to continue, with no additional payments arising from settlement of the original contract.
The 5% security is modelled as a separate guarantee, not a retention. The example assumes that a covered claim exists and the full €17,000 is paid. All €34,000 of the buyers' own funds have already been used, leaving €182,240 of the loan drawn down. That balance remains unchanged during the nine months, with no capital repayments or further drawdowns. Purchase transaction costs, commitment interest and financing for additional costs are excluded.
| Assumption | Amount | |
|---|---|---|
| Already paid (30% + 28% + 5.6%) | 63.6% | €216,240 |
| Outstanding under the contract | 36.4% | €123,760 |
| Completion by other contractors | 30% above the assumed remaining budget | €160,888 |
| Additional completion costs | −€37,128 | |
| 5% completion security | full payment under the separate guarantee assumed | +€17,000 |
| Interest during nine months of suspended work | 3.8% × €182,240 × 9/12 | −€5,194 |
| Lost rent over nine months | €845 a month | −€7,605 |
| Financial impact before tax | −€32,927 |
On these assumptions, the financial impact is around €33,000 before tax. It combines additional expenditure and income forgone, so it is not the same as an additional payment immediately falling due. The €845 monthly figure represents planned rent excluding service charges; possible changes in ongoing letting costs are disregarded. The nine months also represent the additional wait beyond the planned start of rental income. Interest during the originally planned construction period is not included in this additional impact.
The €216,240 already paid is not automatically lost in full. Equally, there is no guarantee that the land and unfinished building are worth exactly that amount, or that completion can be achieved at the assumed cost. Without the assumed payment under the security, the financial impact in the example increases by €17,000 to €49,927.
What might qualify for tax relief? Financing interest may be deductible as expenses incurred before rental income begins where an intention to let can be demonstrated. The tax effect depends on personal circumstances and how the expenditure is attributed; no specific tax saving is stated here. Completion expenditure generally needs to be assessed as part of acquisition or construction costs and depreciation. Payments under security arrangements also require tax assessment. Rent forgone is not, simply by being lost, a deductible expense. Discuss the individual treatment with your tax adviser.
What if there were an advance payment guarantee? Following a valid reversal of the transaction and with an appropriately covered repayment claim, the Hartmanns could claim the €216,240 under the guarantee. An insolvency filing alone does not achieve this. If the purchase is reversed before ownership transfers because of non-performance and on the basis of a legal entitlement, cancellation of the German property transfer tax [Grunderwerbsteuer] assessment may be available on application, subject to the statutory conditions (section 16(1), no. 2 of the German Property Transfer Tax Act [GrEStG]). If ownership has already transferred, the conditions are governed by section 16(2) GrEStG. Repayment of the purchase price instalments does not automatically reimburse interest and notary's fees; following a complete reversal, the flat would not be acquired or retained. Have a lawyer guide you through the reversal and your tax adviser assess its tax consequences.
06What to check before the notary appointment
- 01Payment schedule
For payments under section 3 MaBV: no more than seven instalments assembled from the statutory component amounts, with no payment before the applicable conditions are satisfied. Any departure relying on section 7 MaBV must be validly secured; other legal restrictions continue to apply.
- 02Priority notice and release from charges
Obtain the release declaration. Read the reservation covering non-completion in particular; a reference in the contract is no substitute for examining it.
- 03Building consent
Is a building permit or the statutory alternative evidence available? Who checks and documents this condition?
- 045% security
Does consumer protection apply, and how will the full security amount be provided with the first progress payment: by guarantee or retention?
- 05Advance payment
If payment is requested outside the section 3 arrangement, have a lawyer examine the section 7 security before paying.
- 06Who is the developer?
Check the actual contracting company, even if a familiar group stands behind it: incorporation date and capital in the commercial register [Handelsregister], and available annual accounts in the company register [Unternehmensregister].
- 07Track record
Which projects has the contracting company or group completed, how long ago, and were there delays? A track record does not guarantee solvency.
- 08Financing
Establish what evidence your bank requires before disbursement. A lender's document checks do not replace an independent assessment of construction progress and defects. Agree how your own funds will be used as well.

07If it happens: the first steps
When you learn of an insolvency filing, make no further payments without first obtaining a legal assessment of whether payment is due and who should receive it. A filing is not the same as the opening of proceedings. During the preliminary stage, court orders and the powers of any provisional administrator are decisive.
Once insolvency proceedings have opened, the administrator can be asked to state whether they will perform a contract falling within section 103 InsO. They must respond to such a request without undue delay (section 103(2) InsO). Have a lawyer co-ordinate the approach.
Inform your lender and contact the other buyers. Jointly arranging completion may be a solution, but it requires a workable legal and financial structure. Establish who can commission work and make decisions, how common property will be dealt with, and how costs will be allocated. An independent surveyor can document construction progress and defects; new contracts with tradespeople need to define clearly the work being taken on.
Involve a lawyer with recognised specialist status in German construction and architects' law [Fachanwalt für Bau- und Architektenrecht] and relevant experience at an early stage. Key questions include claims under the 5% security, release from property charges, settlement of the contract and securing the construction site.
08Which protection suits whom
- The payment schedule follows the MaBV and the applicable payment conditions are documented.
- Your financing includes an assessed buffer for a year's delay and additional costs.
- The developer can provide completed projects and meaningful accounts.
- You are being asked to pay ahead of the prescribed construction stage.
- The developer is a recently established project company without its own track record.
- Your cash flow cannot withstand even one month without rent.
09Risks that may remain despite security
Additional completion costs. New contractors may charge more, for example because of additional inspections, interfaces between work packages and liability questions concerning earlier work. Security covers these costs only within its scope and available amount.
Suspended work. Interest may continue to accrue while rental income is absent. Before buying, calculate your pre-tax cash flow for a year without rent, taking account of your loan's actual drawdown and interest conditions.
Defects in the unfinished building. Claims against the insolvent developer may have limited recoverable value. Whether other security or claims exist depends on the individual circumstances. New contractors do not automatically take responsibility for earlier work. Read more in the guide to liability for defects in new builds. Have an appropriately qualified lawyer assess your claims.
Tax deadlines. Construction delays may affect the timing conditions for planned depreciation claims. Declining-balance depreciation [degressive AfA] and special depreciation allowances [Sonder-AfA] have different requirements. When buying a new flat, acquisition by the end of the year of completion may be particularly relevant; physical handover alone does not determine when acquisition occurs for tax purposes. Planning-application, construction-start, acquisition and completion dates need separate consideration for the particular relief claimed. See the guide to special depreciation allowances and declining-balance depreciation for details. Discuss the conditions and deadlines with your tax adviser.
Time and stress. Organising joint completion can involve considerable work. Buyers living far away may need local support.
FAQFrequently asked questions
What is an advance payment guarantee when buying from a developer?
It secures the repayment claims relating to buyers' payments that are covered by the legislation. Payments outside the conditions or instalment schedule under section 3 MaBV require security under section 7 MaBV; other legal restrictions continue to apply. The security must generally remain in place until the conditions of section 3(1) MaBV are met and the contractual property is fully completed. Insolvency alone does not trigger payment.
What is the difference between a completion guarantee and an advance payment guarantee?
Under section 650m(2) BGB, completion security for a property developer contract with a consumer generally amounts to 5% of the agreed total remuneration. It secures timely completion without substantial defects. An advance payment guarantee instead secures covered repayment claims, not completion. Access to either security and payment depend on the relevant legal conditions. Have an appropriately qualified lawyer assess the scope and conditions.
Is my money lost if the developer becomes insolvent?
Not necessarily. A valid priority notice protects the secured claim to a transfer of ownership, and the MaBV restricts the acceptance of payments. However, the instalments do not guarantee an equivalent value for the land and unfinished building. You may still bear additional completion costs, interest and lost rent.
What does the insolvency administrator do with my contract?
Once insolvency proceedings have opened, the administrator can choose whether to perform a contract falling within section 103 InsO. If performance is declined, claims arising from non-performance can be lodged in the insolvency proceedings. The ownership-transfer claim secured by a priority notice remains protected under section 106 InsO, but outstanding obligations and release from charges still need to be resolved. Have a lawyer guide you through the next steps.
Can I withdraw from the contract after an insolvency?
This may be possible under certain conditions; insolvency alone is not a universal basis for withdrawal. Withdrawal can be financially disadvantageous if payments already made can be recovered only as unsecured insolvency claims. Before making a declaration, have a lawyer examine the grounds for withdrawal, the security and the consequences for your ownership-transfer claim.
How can I assess a developer's financial stability before buying?
These checks cannot provide a reliable guarantee of solvency. You can examine available annual accounts in the company register, capital and incorporation date in the commercial register, and completed reference projects. Focus on the actual contracting company. A legally compliant payment schedule is important but does not prove financial stability.
10Further reading
- Checking a property developer contract
- New build or existing property as an investment
- Glossary: MaBV payment schedule
- Glossary: release from property charges
- Land register entry: how long it takes
- Calculator: property cash flow
11Sources
- Section 3 MaBV (conditions, release from charges, instalments) and section 7 MaBV (provision of security)
- Section 650m BGB (5% security) and section 650u BGB (property developer contract)
- Section 103 InsO (administrator's choice whether to perform the contract) and section 106 InsO (priority notice)
- Section 16 GrEStG (cancellation of the tax assessment when a transaction is reversed)
This guide provides general information and does not replace individual legal, tax or investment advice. The worked example is based on expressly stated assumptions and is not a forecast.

Writes about Existing properties, Investment calculations and Property assessment.
Rula has worked in financial services since 2021. He focuses on existing investment properties, transparent calculations and an honest assessment of building condition and running costs.
This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.



