New-build defect liability: making use of five years
Five years sounds like a long time, until water appears in the underground car park in the fourth winter. We explain deadlines, defect notifications and protecting claims, with an example of potential remedial costs for investors.
In February, your tenant calls. The wall below the bedroom window is damp. The flat is three and a half years old, bought from a developer [Bauträger], and you vaguely remember five years of statutory defect liability [Gewährleistung]. Is a phone call to the developer enough?
A phone call can constitute a valid defect notification, but it is difficult to prove later and does not, by itself, suspend limitation. Claims can become difficult to enforce if deadlines pass unnoticed, notifications cannot be evidenced or responsibility for the underground car park remains unclear.
01What statutory defect liability means for a new build
Under a developer contract, construction of the building is generally governed by German law on contracts for work [Werkvertragsrecht] (§ 650u BGB). The developer owes you work free from defects. The five-year period concerns claims for defective contractual performance, not every problem arising within five years. After acceptance, you generally have to establish that the relevant defect existed at acceptance, even if it only became visible later. Section 634 BGB provides the following rights:
| Right | What it means | When |
|---|---|---|
| Remedial performance [Nacherfüllung] | The developer remedies the defect at its own expense. | generally takes priority; statutory exceptions may apply |
| Arranging rectification yourself [Selbstvornahme] | You arrange repairs and recover the necessary costs, including requesting an advance (§ 637 BGB). | generally after a reasonable deadline passes without success; further requirements and exceptions apply |
| Price reduction [Minderung] or withdrawal from the contract [Rücktritt] | The purchase price is reduced; sufficiently substantial defects may justify reversing the transaction. | generally after an unsuccessful deadline and subject to further requirements |
| Damages [Schadensersatz] | Compensation for recoverable losses, such as lost rent or necessary expert fees. | in particular where the developer is legally responsible; additional requirements depend on the type of loss |
Statutory defect liability is not a guarantee. A guarantee would be a voluntary promise with its own conditions. A developer cannot simply exclude statutory defect rights when selling to consumers. By contrast, a purchase of an existing property may include an exclusion of liability for defects.
02When the limitation period starts and ends
The five years generally start on valid acceptance, not at the notarial appointment or when the tenant moves in. This makes the acceptance record an important document for your deadline calendar. For common property, do not assume that one acceptance date applies to every purchaser without checking.
| Area | Limitation period | Start |
|---|---|---|
| Your flat (individually owned property [Sondereigentum]) | generally five years for building defects | acceptance of the flat that is valid for your contract |
| Roof, façade, stairwell, underground car park (common property) | generally five years for building defects | acceptance of the common property that is valid for your contract; this may differ from the flat’s acceptance |
| Fraudulently concealed defect | standard three-year limitation period; for building defects, not before the five-year period expires | generally the end of the year in which the claim arose and the creditor knew, or was grossly negligent in not knowing, the relevant circumstances and the debtor’s identity |
| Separate work by tradespeople, such as a kitchen supplied by a kitchen specialist | depending on the contract and work, for example two or five years | acceptance or delivery, depending on the contract; check separately |
Enter the relevant acceptance dates in your calendar straight away. Set a reminder six months before each period expires. This is a suitable time for a thorough inspection. Limitation does not automatically extinguish the claim, but it can give the developer the right to refuse performance.

03How to notify the developer of defects properly
Report a defect in a way that enables the developer to identify it and allows you to prove the notification’s content and receipt later. This is known as a notice of defects [Mängelrüge].
- 01Describe the symptom, not the cause
Write down what you can see: “Damp patch, approximately 40 × 30 cm, below the bedroom window, growing since January.” You generally do not have to provide a technical diagnosis. A sufficiently specific description of the symptoms generally covers their underlying causes.
- 02Use writing and retain evidence
Keep the notification and dated photographs, and document receipt through an appropriate delivery method or an express acknowledgement. Registered post and email read receipts do not automatically prove every relevant fact. A telephone notification may be valid but is harder to evidence.
- 03Set a deadline
Request rectification and set a reasonable deadline, generally for completing the remedial work, not merely starting it. Its length depends on urgency, scope and technical feasibility; two to four weeks is not a universal rule.
- 04Arrange access
For rented flats, give the tenant timely notice of appointments. The tenant must allow necessary maintenance measures subject to the statutory requirements (§ 555a BGB).
- 05Document the response
Record every reply, appointment and delay. You will need this documentation if time becomes tight.
- 06Act after the deadline
Once a reasonable deadline has passed without success, arranging repairs yourself and claiming reimbursement or an advance may be possible under § 637 BGB. Clarify the requirements and preservation of evidence with a lawyer before commissioning work, and consult an expert on technical questions.
04Suspending the limitation period: notification is not enough
Written notification of a defect alone does not protect the claim against limitation. It calls on the developer to act, but the limitation clock generally keeps running.
Three important ways of suspending limitation are:
Negotiations. While you and the developer negotiate about the claim or its underlying circumstances, limitation may be suspended. The limitation period expires no earlier than three months after the suspension ends (§ 203 BGB). If the developer sends an expert, investigates and writes back, this may indicate negotiations. Whether and when negotiations end or lapse depends on the course of events; do not assume that silence means suspension continues.
Independent court proceedings to preserve evidence [selbständiges Beweisverfahren]. A court can appoint an expert to establish the condition, causes and remedial costs of a defect. Service of the application can suspend limitation for the claims covered (§ 204(1) BGB). Subject to statutory conditions, the effect can relate back to filing if service follows sufficiently promptly. Do not therefore rely on filing alone. This procedure may be appropriate when the deadline is approaching and the developer is not cooperating.
Legal action. An action for rectification or an advance towards costs can also suspend limitation. The scope of the claim, timely service and any retrospective effect of service must be considered.
These routes are not exhaustive. An acknowledgement can restart the limitation period where the statutory requirements are met; this differs from suspension.
05Common property: who takes responsibility
For defects in the roof, façade or underground car park, individual purchasers’ claims and collective action need to be coordinated. Within its powers, the community of property owners [Eigentümergemeinschaft] can pass a resolution organising the collective pursuit of defect rights and appoint a lawyer and an expert. Clarify with a lawyer which claims it can exercise. Individual owners should not assume without checking that their own limitation periods are protected as a result.
If the first property manager is connected with the developer or was proposed by it, conflicts of interest may arise. Clarify responsibilities and have the relevant limitation periods documented at the owners’ meeting.

06Worked example: the damp underground car park
Claudia owns a rented new-build flat in a building with 20 flats. Her co-ownership share [Miteigentumsanteil] is 50/1,000. In the fourth year after acceptance, damp patches appear on the underground car park ceiling. An expert estimates that repairing the waterproofing will cost €160,000. Claudia is a fictional owner; all amounts are assumptions for a simplified illustrative calculation, not a forecast.
The comparison uses two simplified scenarios. In the first, an enforceable defect claim exists and is protected in time, and a financially capable developer pays for all the remedial work. In the second, the limitation defence succeeds and the community bears the costs. Claudia’s allocation is assumed to follow co-ownership shares. Timely action alone guarantees neither liability nor payment.
| Claims protected and enforced | Limitation defence succeeds | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost of remedial work for the building | €160,000 | €160,000 |
| Who pays, under the model assumptions | Developer | Community of property owners |
| Claudia’s share (50/1,000) before tax | €0 | −€8,000 |
| Tax relief assuming immediately deductible maintenance expenditure and a tax relief rate of 35% | €0 | +€2,800 |
| Cost after tax in the simplified example | €0 | −€5,200 |
Before tax, Claudia’s share is €160,000 × 50/1,000 = €8,000. Whether and when she can deduct this as expenses incurred in earning rental income [Werbungskosten] depends, among other things, on the tax classification of the work and the actual use of the funds. Calling work “remedial work” does not establish immediate deductibility as maintenance expenditure [Erhaltungsaufwand]; capitalisation may be required.
Paying a special levy [Sonderumlage] or contributing to the community’s maintenance reserve [Erhaltungsrücklage] does not, by itself, create an immediate tax deduction. What matters is the community’s actual use of the funds for tax-deductible expenditure and its correct allocation. Nor are owners’ regular building charges [Hausgeld] automatically deductible in full. In the simplified example, the assumed tax relief reduces the cost from €8,000 to €5,200. The actual relief, however, depends on Claudia’s personal tax circumstances and the timing of the deduction. A special levy may require cash at short notice regardless of any later tax effect. Ask your tax adviser to clarify the classification and timing of the deduction.
And what about the flat itself? Suppose the bedroom window was leaking. A separate simplified illustrative calculation assumes a rent reduction of 10% over four months, monthly rent excluding service charges [Kaltmiete] of €845 and advance service-charge payments of €155. Total monthly rent is therefore €1,000. At the assumed percentage, the reduction is €1,000 × 10% × 4 = €400. Of this, €845 × 10% × 4 = €338 is attributable to rent excluding service charges and €155 × 10% × 4 = €62 to the advance service-charge payments.
The calculation basis for a rent reduction is generally total rent including service-charge payments. The 10% reduction is purely an assumption here; the legally appropriate reduction depends on the actual defect and its impact. Claudia may claim recoverable lost rent from the developer subject to the statutory requirements, in particular where the developer is legally responsible for the defect. In a dispute, ask a lawyer to assess the extent of the rent reduction and any compensation claims.
The calculation shows two things. Common property can create substantial financial risks even where an owner’s share appears small. Potential tax relief replaces neither protection of claims nor the necessary cash reserves, and does not automatically make good a loss.
07What you can do yourself and when to get help
- Report minor defects in your flat in writing and set a reasonable deadline for rectification.
- Keep a deadline calendar for the flat and common property based on the relevant acceptances.
- Inform tenants and coordinate appointments.
- The developer is not responding and the end of the five years is approaching.
- The defect affects common property and involves substantial costs.
- The cause is unclear, for example with damp, cracks or sound insulation problems.
08Risks: when statutory defect liability does not help
The developer no longer exists. A developer may operate through a separate project company. If it is dissolved or becomes insolvent after completion, enforcing your claims may become significantly harder or yield no financial recovery. The guide Developer insolvency explains what to consider before buying.
The limitation period expires unnoticed. This can happen particularly with common property if responsibilities and individual deadlines remain unclear.
The defect is difficult to prove. After acceptance, you generally have to establish defective performance at acceptance. Photographs, records and expert reports can help.
Wear and tear is not a construction defect. Ordinary wear, damage caused solely by a lack of maintenance and tenant damage generally do not establish defect claims against the developer. They do not, however, automatically exclude a separate construction defect. Follow maintenance intervals for heating, ventilation and smoke alarms, and document the work.
You still end up bearing the costs. Recovery of lost rent during remedial work and other consequential costs depends on entitlement, evidence and enforceability. Your own time and inconvenience are not automatically compensable. Maintenance remains a cost factor for new builds and should be budgeted for from the outset.
FAQFrequently asked questions
How long does statutory defect liability last for a new build?
Building defect claims generally become time-barred five years after valid acceptance [Abnahme] (§ 634a BGB). Different dates may apply to the flat and common property [Gemeinschaftseigentum]. The acceptances valid for your contract are decisive; the period is not a guarantee against every subsequent problem.
Is notifying the developer of a defect enough to stop limitation?
No. Notification alone does not suspend limitation. Negotiations or certain court procedures can do so (§§ 203, 204 BGB). For legal actions and independent evidence proceedings, service, the claims covered and any retrospective effect are particularly important. Do not rely on filing alone, and ask a lawyer to clarify the necessary steps in good time.
What must a notice of defects contain?
Describe the visible symptom accurately, including its location, the date and, where possible, photographs. Request rectification and set a reasonable deadline, generally for completing the remedial work. You do not normally have to identify the technical cause. Document the content and receipt.
What happens if the developer does not remedy the defect?
After a reasonable deadline passes without success, arranging repairs yourself and claiming reimbursement or an advance may be possible under the statutory requirements (§ 637 BGB). A price reduction or damages may also be available. Exceptions to the deadline requirement can apply. Clarify the requirements and preservation of evidence with a lawyer before commissioning work.
Who deals with defects in the common property?
Within its powers, the community of property owners [Eigentümergemeinschaft] can resolve to pursue claims collectively and appoint a lawyer and an expert through the property manager. Individual claims and deadlines must be considered. Costs are generally allocated according to co-ownership shares unless another valid allocation rule applies.
Does statutory defect liability still apply if I have rented out the flat?
Yes. Letting the flat does not remove your defect rights against the developer. Your tenant deals with you and may reduce the rent where the statutory requirements are met. The tenant must allow necessary maintenance measures subject to the statutory requirements.
Can the developer shorten the statutory defect liability period?
In a standard-form contract with a consumer, a developer generally cannot validly shorten the statutory limitation period for building defects. Nevertheless, have a lawyer check the contract before the notarial appointment. Further guidance is available in “Checking a developer contract”.
09Further reading
- Acceptance of a new build: checklist
- Checking a developer contract
- Community of property owners
- Property maintenance costs
- Rent reductions: table
- Glossary: special levy
10Sources
- § 634 BGB (rights in the event of defects) and § 634a BGB (limitation periods)
- § 637 BGB (arranging rectification yourself)
- § 203 BGB and § 204 BGB (suspension of limitation periods)
- § 555a BGB (maintenance measures in rented flats)
- § 650u BGB (developer contracts)
- § 309 BGB, no. 8(b)(ff) (no shortening of limitation periods for building defects in standard-form consumer contracts)
- Illustrative calculations: own calculations using expressly assumed remedial costs, co-ownership shares, tax relief rate, rental amounts and rent-reduction percentage.
This guide provides general information and does not replace legal, tax or investment advice for individual circumstances. The calculations use simplified assumptions. Discuss your legal and tax position with a lawyer or tax adviser, respectively.

Writes about Existing properties, Investment calculations and Property assessment.
Rula has worked in financial services since 2021. He focuses on existing investment properties, transparent calculations and an honest assessment of building condition and running costs.
This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.



