New-build acceptance: a checklist for your flat
Effective acceptance affects limitation periods and the burden of proof. We explain what to check room by room, how to reserve your rights and the possible financial consequences of a later handover.
The developer [Bauträger] has sent you an appointment. In two weeks, you are due to take over your new-build flat, receive the keys and sign a report. The flat smells of fresh paint, and the parquet gleams. That can make it easier to overlook defects on the day.
Acceptance is a key stage between signing before the notary and your first tenant moving in. You declare that the flat has essentially been built as agreed. A signature is not, however, the only possible form of acceptance. After acceptance, you generally have to prove defects yourself; careful documentation helps.
01The legal consequences of acceptance
When buying from a developer, the construction work is generally governed by German law on contracts for work [Werkvertragsrecht] (§ 650u BGB). Legally effective acceptance is the turning point, not necessarily the signing of a report.
| What changes | Before acceptance | After acceptance |
|---|---|---|
| Limitation period for defect claims | Generally has not yet started | For buildings, generally five years from acceptance |
| Burden of proving defects | The developer generally has to demonstrate contractual completion | Generally rests with you; special rules apply to defects covered by a reservation of rights |
| Outstanding payment | Individual developer instalments may already be due | Acceptance is relevant to payment becoming due (§ 641(1) BGB); other contractual and statutory payment conditions continue to apply |
| Known defects without a reservation of rights | Rights depend on the contractual position and stage of performance | Rights under § 634 nos. 1–3 BGB are lost if acceptance takes place without a reservation (§ 640(3) BGB) |
The last point is easily underestimated. If you know about a scratch on a window frame and accept the flat without reserving your rights in respect of it, you lose the corresponding rights to remedial performance [Nacherfüllung], arranging remedial work yourself with reimbursement or an advance towards costs [Selbstvornahme], and withdrawal from the contract or a price reduction [Rücktritt or Minderung], where their respective conditions would otherwise be met. The decisive issue is the missing reservation, not simply the missing entry in the report. Record your reservation expressly in the report for evidential purposes. Section 640(3) BGB does not exclude damages claims in the same way, but these have their own requirements.
Deemed acceptance
You cannot simply sit out acceptance. If, after completion, the developer sets a reasonable deadline and you do not refuse acceptance within that period, specifying at least one defect, the work is deemed to have been accepted [fiktive Abnahme] (§ 640(2) BGB). For consumers, this only applies if the request also explains, in text form [Textform], the consequences of neither declaring acceptance nor refusing it with a stated defect. Text form requires a readable declaration on a durable medium naming the person making it; a handwritten signature is not required.
02Two acceptances: individually owned property and common property
A flat involves different categories of ownership. Individually owned property may include floor finishes, internal doors, and bathroom and kitchen fittings. Common property belongs to the owners jointly, particularly the roof, façade, load-bearing walls, stairwell, lift and windows. For underground parking, external areas and individual components, the statutory classification and the declaration dividing the property into individual and common ownership [Teilungserklärung] need to be considered; not everything inside the flat is individually owned property.
Individually owned and common property may be accepted separately: for example, the flat when the keys are handed over and the common property after the remaining work is completed. This can produce different starting dates for limitation periods. What matters is effective acceptance in relation to the particular buyer; an appointment involving other buyers does not automatically bind every purchaser.
Acceptance of common property can involve substantial potential costs. Defective waterproofing in an underground car park may affect several owners. Claims against the developer should be considered first. If owners have to bear costs themselves, allocation follows the applicable cost-sharing rules, not necessarily their co-ownership shares [Miteigentumsanteile] alone. Jointly commissioning an independent expert can therefore be worthwhile.
If you buy a flat after other buyers have already accepted the common property, you are a late purchaser [Nachzügler]. Your limitation period may run differently from those of other owners. Before buying, ask whether, when and by whom the common property was accepted, and request the report. Earlier acceptance is not automatically effective for you too.

03Preparation: what to take to the appointment
A thorough acceptance inspection starts at home. Bringing the building specification and floor plan can help you spot discrepancies that might otherwise go unnoticed.
- 01Gather your documents
Developer contract, building specification, dimensioned floor plans, the record of selected finishes and fittings [Bemusterungsprotokoll], and all agreements on bespoke extras.
- 02Arrange a daylight appointment
Good light makes plaster, parquet and windows easier to inspect. A morning appointment may be preferable to a late afternoon in November.
- 03Arrange someone to accompany you
An independent building expert can identify technical weaknesses and document defects clearly. Obtain a written quotation covering the flat's size, travel, inspection scope and report.
- 04Pack your tools
A folding rule or laser distance measurer, torch, spirit level, a suitable plug-in socket tester if appropriate, camera, sticky notes and a pen that writes on plastic. Do not open electrical installations; a socket tester does not replace a professional electrical inspection.
- 05Ask for electricity, water and heating to be ready for testing
Request that all systems are operational and testable as far as possible. If the heating function cannot be tested, record this and agree a follow-up inspection.
- 06Allow enough time
Set aside two to three hours as a planning allowance for a three-room flat; extensive checks may take longer. Do not let yourself be rushed, even if the site manager has another appointment.
04The room-by-room checklist
Work systematically, ideally clockwise around each room, from top to bottom: ceiling, walls, windows, doors, floor and services. For every defect, record the room, exact location and photograph number. The following observations are inspection prompts; whether they constitute defects depends, among other things, on the agreed specification and technical requirements.
| Area | What to check | Possible defects or inspection prompts |
|---|---|---|
| Walls and ceilings | Evenness, corners, junctions with windows and doors; light shining across the surface only as a search aid | Cracks, visible filled patches, colour differences, missing required junction seals |
| Windows and balcony doors | Opening, tilting, closing, seals, frames, glazing | Scratched glass, stiff fittings, damaged frames |
| Roller shutters and shading | Raise and lower every shutter fully | Scraping noises, missing end stops, non-functioning motor |
| Internal doors | Gap dimensions, closing without catching, frames | Dents, uneven gaps, missing agreed door stops |
| Floors | Parquet, tiles, skirting boards, transitions | Scratches, hollow-sounding tiles requiring further investigation, open joints, differences in level |
| Bathroom and WC | Shower drainage slope, joints, taps, flush, drains | Standing water, missing required silicone seals, scratches in the bath or basin |
| Electrical installations | Safely check accessible sockets and switches for operation, consumer unit labelling | Dead sockets, missing covers, number of fittings differs from the building specification |
| Heating and ventilation | Heating function of radiators or underfloor heating, thermostats, ventilation system | Individual rooms cold despite heating operation, noises, missing filters |
| Balcony or terrace | Drainage slope, outlet, surface finish, balustrade, junction with the door | Puddles, loose balustrades, signs of missing waterproofing at the threshold |
| Cellar or storage room | Damp, door, light | Stains on walls, no light, sticking door |
Finally, compare the flat with the documents. Do the room dimensions match the floor plan? Are all the sockets, connections and fittings promised in the building specification and selections record present? A smaller living area may constitute a defect. Check the contractual agreement on floor area, the calculation method and the actual discrepancy.
05Accept, refuse or reserve your rights?
At the end of the inspection, you decide whether to accept. If you refuse, a formal record of the condition may additionally be required; this is not an alternative form of acceptance.
Accept while reserving your rights. For insignificant defects, acceptance with an express reservation of rights is an option. List every defect identified in the report. Where you are entitled to have defects remedied, you may retain a reasonable portion of the payment due, usually twice the estimated remedial cost (§ 641(3) BGB).
Refuse acceptance. Acceptance cannot be refused because of insignificant defects (§ 640(1) BGB). Substantial defects, however, may justify refusal. Examples include heating that does not work in winter, significant damp in a wall or missing fall protection on a balcony. The individual circumstances matter, including the nature, extent and combined effect of defects; habitability alone is not the sole test.
Have the condition formally recorded. If you refuse acceptance citing defects, the developer may require your participation in a joint record of the condition [Zustandsfeststellung] (§ 650g BGB). If you fail to attend an agreed appointment or one set with reasonable notice, a unilateral record may be possible subject to the statutory conditions. This does not apply if your absence is for a reason beyond your responsibility and you notify it promptly. The presumption that an unrecorded obvious defect arose later and is your responsibility requires the work to have been placed in your possession. It does not apply where the nature of the defect means it could not have been caused by you.
For insignificant defects, it is worth considering the financial consequences of a handover dispute. For substantial defects, that calculation does not replace a technical and legal assessment. Consult a lawyer if there is a dispute over acceptance, a reservation of rights or defect claims.
06Worked example: reserving your rights rather than refusing acceptance
Illustrative calculation, simplified: Jonas has bought a 65 m² new-build flat for €340,000. He contributes €34,000 of his own funds towards the purchase price and borrows €306,000 at an assumed nominal interest rate of 3.8% a year. The name and figures are illustrative, not a forecast or a statement about market rates. Purchase costs, capital repayments and other ongoing costs are excluded. The following calculation assumes that all the equity has already been used and that the drawn loan balance remains unchanged throughout the month considered.
Payments follow a contractual schedule based on the construction-stage payment framework under Germany's Estate Agents and Property Developers Ordinance [Makler- und Bauträgerverordnung, MaBV]. Shortly before handover, 86% of the purchase price has been paid in the example: €292,400, comprising €34,000 of equity and €258,400 of borrowing. A total of €47,600 remains outstanding for readiness for occupation, façade works and full completion. The following shares are calculation components of the assumed instalment agreement; the ordinance does not permit an unlimited number of separate instalments, but a maximum of seven part-payments based on construction progress.
During acceptance, Jonas and his expert identify eleven defects, including scratches on a window frame, two missing silicone seals, an internal door that catches, a roller shutter without an end stop and a dent in the parquet. The example assumes that the defects are insignificant individually and collectively, the flat is ready for occupation and the other handover and letting requirements are met.
| Share of the total purchase price | Amount | |
|---|---|---|
| Share for readiness for occupation, payable in exchange for handover | 8.4% | €28,560 |
| Share for façade works | 2.1% | €7,140 |
| Share for full completion | 3.5% | €11,900 |
| Estimated cost of remedying the eleven defects | €2,400 | |
| Usual retention (twice the remedial cost) | €4,800 |
Jonas accepts the flat, records all eleven defects in the report and reserves his rights. Under the assumed conditions, he retains €4,800 from a payment due until the defects have been remedied. In the example, he receives the keys and can let the flat. Acceptance with retained payment alone guarantees neither handover nor the ability to let.
What would have happened if he had refused acceptance because of these defects? On the assumption that they are insignificant, refusal would not be justified. A dispute could delay handover. For such a month, the following calculation shows interest outgoings and forgone rent, not the additional costs compared with an on-time handover.
Jonas incurs approximately €937 of interest outgoings that month and does not receive the assumed €845 rent excluding service charges. The total of approximately €1,782 is therefore neither entirely a cash payment nor a measure of the additional costs of delay. Loan interest would also arise after an on-time handover; further drawdowns could change the interest amount. A reliable comparison requires the drawdown and payment schedules for both scenarios, together with other costs and income.
Financing interest may be deductible as income-related expenses [Werbungskosten] where there is demonstrable intention to let and the necessary economic connection. A specific tax saving cannot reliably be derived from taxable income of €60,000 alone. Whether forgone rent is recoverable as a loss caused by delay depends, among other things, on responsibility, the contract and evidence. Consult your tax adviser about the tax treatment and a lawyer about potential compensation claims.
A valid reservation of rights with a reasonable retention can help secure remedial work without refusing acceptance because of insignificant defects. In the example, €4,800 remains temporarily unpaid for this purpose; the effectiveness of that leverage also depends on the developer's financial position.

07The acceptance report: what it must contain
The developer may bring a prepared form. You can use it, but check it before signing.
- Date, time and attendees, including their roles and your expert.
- Subject of acceptance: individually owned property, flat number according to the declaration dividing ownership, cellar and parking space where included in the particular acceptance scope; clearly distinguish common property.
- Every defect listed separately, with the room, location and photograph number. No catch-all descriptions such as “outstanding work”.
- Express reservation of rights: “The purchaser reserves their rights in respect of all defects listed.”
- Reasonable deadline for remedying defects, for example four weeks if justified by the nature and extent of the work, and how the developer will notify you of completion.
- Meter readings for electricity, water and heat, with photographs. You will need these for the first billing statement.
- Keys handed over, including the number, together with operating manuals and maintenance documents.
- No inaccurate confirmations or waiver wording, such as “The flat was taken over free of defects” or “No further claims exist”. Have such statements deleted or clearly corrected before signing.
Have a copy of the signed report handed to you immediately, if necessary by photographing every page.
08When an expert is particularly useful at acceptance
- You are buying your first new-build flat and have no construction experience.
- The appointment concerns acceptance of common property, including the roof, underground car park and façade.
- You live far away and cannot check remedial work yourself.
- The building specification contains extensive technical information on sound insulation, ventilation or waterproofing.
- You have relevant construction experience yourself, and the flat is small with basic fittings.
- A joint independent expert has already been commissioned for the same scope of common-property inspection; this does not replace inspection of your individually owned property.
09Risks: what can go wrong at acceptance
Hidden defects remain undetected. A leaking pipe behind a wall or defective waterproofing beneath the screed may remain undetected during a visual inspection. The generally applicable five-year limitation period for building defect claims starts at acceptance for these defects too, not when they are discovered. After acceptance, the burden of proof generally rests with you. Find out more in our guide to new-build defect liability.
Deemed acceptance works against you. If you fail to respond to a request with a deadline, you may have to accept the legal effects of acceptance under the statutory conditions without ever setting foot inside the flat.
The contract clause is unfavourable. Acceptance of common property by someone selected by the developer, excessively short deadlines or flat-rate handover charges may need scrutiny. Wherever possible, have these provisions assessed by a lawyer before entering into the contract rather than disputing them on acceptance day.
The developer does not remedy the defects. A reasonable deadline, justified retention and, subject to the statutory requirements, arranging remedial work with reimbursement may help. Have a lawyer check the requirements before commissioning work yourself. If the developer becomes insolvent, retained payment can be important but may not cover the remedial costs. Our guide to developer insolvency explains how to limit the risks.
The tenancy start date is uncertain. If you sign a tenancy agreement with a fixed move-in date before acceptance, a postponement may put you under pressure. Allow a buffer, as described in our guide to letting a new build for the first time.
FAQFrequently asked questions
What should a new-build acceptance report contain?
The acceptance report [Abnahmeprotokoll] should include the date, attendees, precise acceptance scope, each defect listed separately with its location and photograph number, an express reservation of rights [Vorbehalt], a reasonable deadline for remedial work, meter readings and the number of keys handed over. Have inaccurate confirmations that the property is free of defects and any waiver wording corrected or deleted before signing.
Can I refuse acceptance because of minor defects?
You cannot refuse acceptance because of insignificant defects (§ 640(1) of the German Civil Code [Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch, BGB]). Document the defects and expressly reserve your rights. Where you are entitled to have defects remedied, you may retain a reasonable portion of the payment due, usually twice the remedial cost (§ 641(3) BGB).
What happens if I do not record a defect in the report?
The missing entry alone is not decisive. If you know about the defect at acceptance and do not reserve your rights, you lose the corresponding rights under § 634 nos. 1–3 BGB, including remedial performance, arranging remedial work with reimbursement or an advance towards costs, and withdrawal from the contract or a price reduction (§ 640(3) BGB). Document the reservation expressly. This loss of rights does not apply to defects unknown to you at acceptance.
When is the common property accepted?
Common property [Gemeinschaftseigentum] may be accepted at a separate appointment after the relevant work is completed. A jointly commissioned independent expert can support the technical inspection. The limitation period starts with effective acceptance in relation to the particular buyer; acceptance by other buyers or a third party does not automatically bind every purchaser.
When does the limitation period for new-build defect claims start?
The limitation period for building defect claims is generally five years from effective acceptance (§ 634a BGB). If individually owned property [Sondereigentum] and common property are accepted separately, different starting dates may apply. For initially hidden defects too, the period generally starts at acceptance, not discovery.
How much does an expert cost for a construction acceptance inspection?
The cost depends on the flat's size, travel, inspection scope and the report required. Obtain a written quotation clearly describing these services. Clarify whether the inspection covers only individually owned property or also parts of the common property.
What is deemed acceptance?
Deemed acceptance [fiktive Abnahme] means that if the developer sets a reasonable deadline after completion and you do not refuse acceptance within it, specifying at least one defect, the work is treated as accepted. For consumers, the developer's request must explain in text form [Textform] the consequences of neither declaring acceptance nor refusing it with a stated defect (§ 640(2) BGB). Text form requires a readable declaration on a durable medium naming the person making it; a handwritten signature is not required.
10Further reading
- Reviewing a developer contract
- Glossary: construction acceptance
- Glossary: construction-stage payment schedule
- New build or existing property as an investment
- Flat handover report for landlords
- Calculator: property cash flow
11Sources
- § 640 BGB (Acceptance, deemed acceptance, reservation of rights for known defects)
- § 641 BGB (Payment becoming due, retention for defects)
- § 634a BGB (Limitation periods, five years for buildings)
- § 650g BGB (Recording the condition when acceptance is refused)
- § 650u BGB (Developer contract)
- § 3 MaBV (Construction-stage instalments)
- Worked example: own calculation using the assumptions stated in the article
This guide provides general information and does not replace individual legal, tax or investment advice. Discuss legal questions with a lawyer and tax questions with your tax adviser. The worked example uses the stated assumptions.

Writes about Investment properties, Purchase decisions and Financial viability.
Herbert has invested in property himself since 2023 and has worked in the property industry since 2024. His advice combines an investor’s perspective with clear explanations and an open assessment of opportunities and risks.
This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.



