Access to operating cost records: a landlord’s guide
Which documents landlords in Germany must provide, how digital access works and what happens when access is refused.
01Access to supporting records: landlords’ obligations
An operating cost statement showing an additional payment due often prompts questions: Which services have been charged? Were the invoices actually paid? Is the allocation basis correct? Access to the supporting records allows the tenant to check these details.
There is no need to suspect a specific error. A general interest in checking the statement is sufficient. The German Federal Court of Justice (BGH) confirmed this, among other decisions, in its judgment of 9 December 2020, VIII ZR 118/19.
Section 556(4) BGB has expressly set out this entitlement since 1 January 2025. The provision also allows landlords to provide the supporting records electronically. They therefore do not generally have to offer an appointment with paper files if suitable electronic documents provide the access required.
02Which documents must be available for inspection?
The key question is which documents the tenant needs to understand the costs charged and how they have been allocated. A summary of costs alone does not replace the underlying records.
| Documents | Scope of access |
|---|---|
| Invoices | Invoices for services charged to tenants, such as cleaning, gardening or lift maintenance |
| Service contracts | Where these establish the services, prices or distinction between recoverable and non-recoverable costs |
| Tax and fee assessments | For example, assessments for property tax, waste collection or wastewater charges |
| Insurance documents | In particular, premium invoices and contract terms relevant to the statement |
| Evidence of payment | Records showing payment of the costs charged, such as relevant bank statements |
| Meter readings and consumption records | The basis for heating and other consumption-related cost statements |
| Individual consumption data for other occupants | On request, where needed to check consumption-based allocation |
| Floor area or occupancy schedules | Where these form the basis of the allocation method used |
| Records covering mixed services | Including information on non-recoverable elements where needed to check the separation of costs |
Evidence of payment is included
Access is not limited to invoices. Tenants are generally also entitled to inspect the corresponding payment records. Under judgment VIII ZR 118/19, they do not need to demonstrate a special interest. This entitlement applies regardless of whether costs are accounted for by reference to the period in which services were provided or when payment was made.
Non-recoverable costs are not automatically excluded from inspection
Pure administration costs and repairs cannot be passed on to tenants as operating costs. However, this does not mean that information about them is always excluded from inspection.
For example, if a caretaker’s invoice includes both routine services and repairs, the separation of these costs must be verifiable. Documents unrelated to the operating cost statement, by contrast, are generally outside the scope of the right of access.
Apply data protection selectively
Unrelated transactions and unnecessary personal information may be redacted. The amounts, services and payment details required to check the statement must remain visible.
Where costs are allocated according to consumption, the right of access may also cover individual consumption data for other occupants. The BGH confirmed this in its judgment of 7 February 2018, VIII ZR 189/17. Data protection therefore does not justify a blanket refusal to disclose these figures. At the same time, you should not disclose personal information beyond what is required.

03Digital access, in-person inspection and copies
Electronic provision is expressly permitted
Since 1 January 2025, landlords have been allowed to provide the records electronically. Suitable options include an organised folder of PDFs or a secure download area. The documents should be complete, legible and clearly linked to the relevant items in the statement.
A broken link or illegible scans do not allow a proper review. Keep a record of which documents you provided and when, and ensure that there is a reasonable opportunity to access them.
The statutory permission for landlords does not, by itself, give tenants a general right to insist on a particular digital delivery method. Nevertheless, you should resolve practical access problems promptly.
Paper copies are not always required
For housing outside regulated social housing rent rules, tenants generally cannot insist that the landlord sends paper copies instead of providing a reasonable opportunity to inspect the records. Exceptions may apply where in-person inspection would be unreasonable in the circumstances, for example because of a considerable distance. This requires an assessment of the individual case; see BGH, judgment of 8 March 2006, VIII ZR 78/05.
Where an in-person inspection is offered, it usually takes place at the landlord’s or managing agent’s premises. Access itself must not be made conditional on a flat administration fee. Whether costs can be recovered for additional copies requested depends on the legal entitlement and circumstances.
04When tenants may withhold an additional payment
If a landlord fails to meet a legitimate request for access to supporting records, the tenant may assert a temporary right to withhold the additional payment concerned. This does not extinguish the debt.
What matters is whether access has been refused or inadequately provided—not simply whether the tenant has already looked at the records. A tenant who has been given proper access cannot postpone payment indefinitely by choosing not to review them.
Nor does every missing page automatically justify withholding the entire additional payment. The significance of the missing documents and the extent to which their absence prevents a review are decisive. If a dispute arises, landlords should seek legal advice on whether their claim is enforceable before taking further action.
Important deadlines
Section 556(4) BGB does not specify a separate fixed deadline for requesting access. This must be distinguished from the deadlines for issuing statements and raising objections:
- Issuing the statement: The tenant must generally receive it no later than twelve months after the end of the accounting period. Additional payment claims made after that deadline are generally excluded if the landlord is responsible for the delay.
- Objections: Tenants must generally notify the landlord of objections within twelve months of receiving the statement. Later objections remain possible if the tenant is not responsible for the delay.
- Access to records: Requesting access does not automatically extend the objection deadline. If a refusal of access prevents a review, this may be relevant to whether the tenant is responsible for raising an objection late.
05Worked example: a correction and delayed receipt of payment
All amounts and dates below are assumptions. They describe a fictional sequence of events, not a statutory payment deadline or a forecast.
A landlord prepares the statement for the 2025 calendar year. The tenant receives it on 15 November 2026, showing an additional payment of €540. On 20 November 2026, the tenant requests access to the supporting records.
The review reveals that the caretaker costs include repairs. In this example, the non-recoverable share allocated to the flat is €120.
| Assumption | Prompt access | Delayed access |
|---|---|---|
| Original additional payment claimed | €540 | €540 |
| Correction for the repair element | −€120 | −€120 |
| Corrected additional payment | €420 | €420 |
| Access to records provided | November 2026 | February 2027 |
| Assumed receipt of payment | December 2026 | March 2027 |
| Additional wait in the model | – | Around three months |
The calculation is the same in both cases: €540 − €120 = €420. The correction is necessary regardless of when the inspection takes place. The difference lies in the assumed timing of payment, not the amount legitimately owed.
In practice, payment does not depend solely on how quickly the records are provided. Further objections or payment difficulties may arise. Prompt access therefore does not guarantee prompt payment.
Tax treatment generally follows receipt
For private lettings, an additional operating cost payment must generally be recognised as rental income in the year it is received. In the model, payment arrives either in December 2026 or in March 2027, placing it in different tax years.
The €420 cannot be converted into a reliable after-tax amount without knowing the other relevant tax circumstances. The associated expenses and their allocation for tax purposes must be considered separately.

06Individually owned flats: obtain records from the managing agent early
For a let flat within a German condominium owners’ association, many documents are held by the association’s managing agent. Nevertheless, the landlord remains responsible for providing the tenant with access.
Under section 18(4) of the German Condominium Act (WEG), each flat owner may require the owners’ association to provide access to its administrative records. In practice, this is usually arranged through the managing agent.
Request the documents needed for your operating cost statement early. Do not wait for a tenant’s request or a resolution on additional contributions or adjustments to advance contributions. The tenancy-law deadline for issuing the statement runs independently; delays within the owners’ association do not automatically excuse a late statement.
The association’s annual accounts also cannot simply be passed on to the tenant unchanged. In particular, check which costs are recoverable, the allocation basis agreed in the tenancy agreement and the separation of non-recoverable costs.
07Checklist for an orderly process
- Acknowledge the request: Reply promptly and provide a realistic date and the proposed form of access. Responding within a few days is an organisational recommendation, not a statutory deadline.
- Assemble the documents: Match invoices, contracts, assessments, payment records and allocation information to the relevant statement items.
- Protect data selectively: Redact only information that is not required for the review.
- Provide access: Check legibility, completeness and technical accessibility, or arrange a reasonable in-person appointment.
- Address questions: Explain unclear allocations and provide any further documents required.
- Correct errors: Clearly show which item has changed and the remaining balance. For corrections to the tenant’s detriment, particular attention must be paid to the deadline for issuing the statement.
- Document the process: Keep the request, response, documents provided and corrections in an organised file.
A complete set of supporting records makes managing your investment property easier. It does not, however, replace checking whether costs are recoverable or preparing an accurate statement.
08Free initial consultation
In a free initial consultation, we discuss the ongoing costs and management tasks you should allow for when investing in a rental property. This does not include individual legal or tax advice. Request an initial consultation.
FAQFrequently asked questions
Do tenants have a right to inspect supporting records?
Yes. Under section 556(4) BGB, landlords must provide access to the records supporting the operating cost statement on request. Tenants do not need to suspect a specific error or provide a special justification.
May landlords provide the records digitally?
Yes. Since 1 January 2025, section 556(4) BGB has expressly permitted electronic provision. The documents must allow a proper review, meaning in particular that they must be complete, legible and accessible.
Must landlords send paper copies?
For housing outside regulated social housing rent rules, generally not if a reasonable opportunity for inspection is provided. Where in-person inspection would be unreasonable in the circumstances, an exceptional entitlement to copies may arise. The statutory permission to provide electronic records must also be considered.
Are bank statements and other occupants’ consumption data included?
Evidence of payment is generally included where it relates to the costs charged. For consumption-based allocation, individual consumption data for other occupants may also have to be made available on request. Unnecessary personal information and unrelated transactions may be redacted.
May tenants withhold an additional payment pending access?
If a legitimate request for access is not met, or access is inadequate, there may be a temporary right to withhold the additional payment concerned. The debt does not cease to exist. A tenant cannot undermine properly provided access simply by choosing not to review the records.
How can a flat owner obtain the owners’ association’s records?
Under section 18(4) WEG, each flat owner may require the owners’ association to provide access to its administrative records. This is usually organised through the managing agent. The owner letting the flat remains responsible for providing access to their tenant.
What deadline applies to requesting access?
Section 556(4) BGB does not specify a separate fixed deadline for requesting access. Tenants must generally notify the landlord of objections within twelve months of receiving the statement. An access request does not automatically extend that deadline, although late objections may remain permissible where the tenant is not responsible for the delay.

Writes about Purchase process, Notary and land registry and Letting.
Kevin combines twelve years of sales experience with nine years specialising in property and more than 500 consultations. He writes about property quality, location risks and a safe path from the first comparison to completion.
This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.



