Guide · Letting

    Lift costs in Germany: What tenants have to pay

    Which operating costs are recoverable, when ground-floor tenants contribute and how to separate repairs within a maintenance contract.


    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo
    14 November 20267 min read

    01Lift costs: separate operation from repairs

    A rental flat with a lift generates two different types of expenditure: ongoing operating costs and costs of maintaining or renewing the installation. For a property investor, this distinction is crucial. Not everything paid by the owners’ association through the owners’ service charge, known as Hausgeld, can be passed on to tenants.

    Section 2 no. 7 BetrKV covers the costs of operating a lift. Maintenance and repair expenditure that falls outside the specified operating services is excluded from operating costs under section 1(2) BetrKV. What matters is the service actually provided, not simply the wording on the invoice.

    Cost itemRecoverable through operating charges?What to check
    Electricity for operationYesConsumption and allocation must be traceable.
    Routine servicing, care and regular adjustmentYesDeduct any repair work included.
    Recurring inspections of operational readiness and safetyYesDistinguish these from inspections prompted by repairs.
    Ongoing emergency call operation and connection to a response centreGenerally yesWhere services support monitoring; treat purchase and repairs separately.
    Cleaning the lift installationYesDo not charge for it again through general building cleaning.
    Repairs and replacement of defective componentsNoRepair costs remain with the owner.
    Repair element of a comprehensive maintenance contractNoA fixed annual fee does not change this.
    Renewal or modernisationNoNot operating costs; any modernisation rent increase requires a separate assessment.
    Inspection required solely because of a repairGenerally noUsually attributable to the repair.

    Recoverable services are also subject to the requirement of reasonable cost management. Costs must be assigned to the correct accounting period and group of properties. Our guide to recoverable operating costs explains the basics.

    02Comprehensive maintenance contracts: deduct the repair element

    A comprehensive maintenance contract can bundle routine servicing, fault response, repairs and replacement parts into one annual fee. This helps the owners’ association plan expenditure, but does not remove the need to separate costs for the tenant’s operating cost statement.

    There is no universally applicable repair percentage. The actual scope of services and a substantiated breakdown are decisive. Nor is a description such as “fault rectification” enough to classify an invoice: it can cover different services.

    How to establish a breakdown

    1. Obtain the contract and service specification. Check which ongoing operating services and which repairs are included.
    2. Request a written explanation of the split. Ask the managing agent to obtain a substantiated separation of operating services and repairs from the lift company.
    3. Cross-check additional invoices. Establish whether services are already covered by the fixed fee or have been charged twice.
    4. Do not pass on unresolved amounts without checking. An arbitrary deduction without a sound basis may still be disputed. Obtain professional clarification where necessary.
    5. Make future contracts more transparent. Separate service items make annual accounting easier.

    Tenants generally have twelve months from receipt of the statement to raise objections. The statutory exception for objections delayed through no fault of the tenant remains applicable. This objection deadline is not the same as a limitation period for repayment claims.

    Inspection of the shared heating system in an apartment building
    AI-generated illustrative image

    03Do ground-floor tenants have to pay lift costs?

    Not using the lift does not generally provide an exemption

    Germany’s Federal Court of Justice has upheld, in principle, a standard tenancy clause requiring ground-floor tenants to contribute to lift costs (judgment of 20 September 2006, VIII ZR 103/06). A tenant’s actual non-use therefore does not automatically prevent recovery.

    A valid agreement on operating costs is still required. If the tenancy agreement expressly exempts the ground-floor flat, that exemption must be respected. You cannot simply transfer the resulting unrecoverable share to other tenants without an appropriate basis.

    Different rules for a part of the building not served by the lift

    Mere non-use is different from a flat being situated in a part of the building that the lift does not physically serve. In such a case, the Federal Court of Justice held that a standard clause requiring a contribution unfairly disadvantaged the tenant (judgment of 8 April 2009, VIII ZR 128/08).

    For developments comprising several buildings, check the actual access arrangements and contractual provisions. Combining properties into one accounting unit does not, by itself, justify every allocation of costs.

    04Which allocation method applies?

    For residential tenancies, the agreed method of allocating costs generally applies. Without a different agreement, section 556a(1) of the German Civil Code (BGB) normally provides for allocation by floor area; specific requirements apply where consumption or causation is recorded.

    Section 556a(3) BGB contains a special rule for rented flats in condominium ownership: unless otherwise agreed, the allocation method applicable between the owners generally applies. If that method does not meet the statutory standard of equitable discretion, costs must be allocated under subsection 1.

    Within the owners’ association, costs are generally allocated according to co-ownership shares unless a valid alternative arrangement applies. Agreements and resolutions can therefore determine the actual burden. Owning a ground-floor flat does not automatically exempt an owner from lift costs.

    Importantly, a valid allocation method does not turn repairs into recoverable operating costs. Further guidance is available in our article on operating cost allocation methods.

    05Worked example: €670 in costs, with €324 remaining with the landlord

    The following figures are assumptions for a full accounting year, not market data or cost commitments. Assume eight flats with a combined floor area of 600 m². The rented ground-floor flat measures 60 m². In this example, floor area is the agreed allocation basis both within the owners’ association and under the tenancy. The flat’s share is therefore 60 ÷ 600 = 10%.

    The tenancy agreement allows operating costs to be recovered and does not exempt the ground floor. The lift serves the building. For the assumed €3,600 comprehensive maintenance contract, a substantiated breakdown allocates 60% to operating services and 40% to repairs and replacement parts. The additional replacement of a defective door drive is not covered by the contract. Ongoing emergency call services are charged separately and are not already included in the comprehensive maintenance fee.

    Cost itemEntire buildingFlat’s share: 10%
    Electricity for operation€600€60
    Recoverable maintenance contract element: €3,600 × 60%€2,160€216
    Recurring safety inspection€400€40
    Ongoing emergency call operation€300€30
    Recoverable costs€3,460€346
    Repair element of maintenance contract: €3,600 × 40%€1,440€144
    Door drive repair€1,800€180
    Non-recoverable costs€3,240€324
    Total lift costs€6,700€670

    Of the flat’s €670 in lift costs, €346 can be passed on to the tenant in this model. €324 remains with the owner before tax. Spread over twelve months, this represents a monthly cost of €27. Passing on the entire comprehensive maintenance fee would overcharge the tenant by €144.

    The example covers only the lift costs listed. Other ownership costs, reserve contributions and future renewals are excluded. You should therefore also examine the flat’s owners’ service charge when preparing your overall calculation.

    06Tax: check deductibility and payment timing

    A cost that cannot be passed on is not automatically immediately deductible for tax. For a rented flat, operating and repair costs actually borne can generally qualify as deductible expenses against rental income. Repair and upkeep expenditure is usually deductible in the year of payment; where an owners’ association is involved, its actual expenditure and attribution to the owner must be considered.

    Paying into the maintenance reserve does not, by itself, create a tax deduction. What generally matters is when the association uses the funds for tax-deductible work.

    In addition, expenditure treated as acquisition-related production costs or other expenditure requiring capitalisation can prevent an immediate deduction. Recoverable costs and operating cost reimbursements received must also be accounted for in the tax calculation.

    A fixed “after-tax” cost therefore cannot generally be derived from the €324 figure. It depends, among other things, on the tax classification, timing of the deduction and the owner’s personal circumstances.

    Organising receipts for the accounts of a rental apartment
    AI-generated illustrative image

    07What property investors should check before buying

    • Lift contract: Are servicing, repairs and emergency call services clearly distinguished?
    • Annual statements: Have repair elements been correctly treated as non-recoverable?
    • Tenancy agreement: Is recovery of operating costs agreed, and are there ground-floor exemptions?
    • Owners’ association allocation rules: Which agreements and resolutions apply?
    • Technical condition: Which repairs or renewals are already foreseeable?
    • Funding of major work: Are existing funds sufficient, or might owners face additional payments?

    Major renewal work may be funded from the maintenance reserve or through a special levy. Each owner’s share depends on the applicable allocation rules. A new control system is not automatically a modernisation under tenancy law simply because of the old system’s age or the description used.

    Do not accept an item marked “recoverable” in the managing agent’s accounts without checking. The accounts between the owners’ association and an owner do not replace an assessment under tenancy law. Our overview of non-recoverable operating costs provides further guidance.

    08Conclusion: budget for the owner’s share from the outset

    Ongoing lift costs can generally be passed on under a valid agreement, often including to ground-floor tenants. Repairs and renewals do not belong in the tenant’s operating cost statement. A substantiated maintenance contract breakdown, the actual access arrangements and an appropriate allocation method are decisive.

    In the assumed model, €324 of the annual €670 lift costs remains with the owner before tax. Allow for these costs and possible major work before buying.

    Legal and tax position: October 2026. This guide provides general information and does not replace advice on individual circumstances.

    09Free initial consultation

    In a free initial consultation, we discuss how ongoing ownership costs fit into the financial assessment of a rental investment flat. Request an initial consultation.

    FAQFrequently asked questions

    Which lift costs can be recovered as operating charges?

    Under a valid operating costs agreement, electricity for operation, routine servicing and care, monitoring, recurring safety inspections and cleaning are among the recoverable costs under section 2 no. 7 BetrKV. Repairs and renewals are excluded.

    Do ground-floor tenants have to pay lift costs?

    Ground-floor tenants can generally be required to contribute under a valid standard tenancy clause. Actual non-use does not automatically exempt them. However, an express contractual exemption for the ground floor must be respected.

    What applies to flats in a part of the building without lift access?

    For a flat in a part of the building not physically served by the lift, Germany’s Federal Court of Justice held a standard clause requiring a contribution to be invalid. A shared accounting unit alone is therefore not a sufficient basis for recovery.

    Can the full cost of a comprehensive maintenance contract be passed on?

    Only if it contains exclusively recoverable operating services. Included repairs and replacement parts used for repair work must be deducted. This requires a substantiated breakdown specific to the contract; there is no universally applicable repair percentage.

    Are lift emergency call costs recoverable?

    Ongoing costs of operating an emergency call system and connecting it to a response centre are generally recoverable where they serve to monitor the lift. Purchase and repairs are excluded. Services already included in the maintenance contract must not be charged again.

    Who pays for renewing or modernising a lift?

    These costs are initially borne by the owners under the applicable allocation rules. They are not operating costs. Whether a modernisation rent increase is permitted requires a separate assessment; repair and upkeep costs alone do not qualify.

    Written by
    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo

    Writes about Financing and Taxes.

    Romolo brings almost 17 years of banking and financing experience, including leading around 145 sales staff, to his work. He writes about financing, taxes and property decisions that fit your life for the long term.

    This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.

    Free · Instant · No sign-up

    Download this guide as a PDF

    The complete guide as a clean A4 file – with a cover page, all chapters and page numbers. Keep it on hand, read it offline, or go through it at your own pace during your consultation.

    • All chapters, tables and worked examples
    • Read offline – on your phone or printed out
    • Go through it at your own pace or pass it on
    • Free, no sign-up, no email required

    A4 format · 1,998 words · As of 14 November 2026

    Related guides

    All guides