Caretaker costs in Germany: What can landlords recover?
Which services tenants can be charged for, how landlords should separate mixed costs and what remains payable in a worked example.
01Caretaker costs: The work performed is what matters
A “caretaker” entry in the owners’ association’s annual statement does not automatically qualify for inclusion in the tenant’s operating cost statement. What matters is the work actually performed, the tenancy agreement and the applicable allocation basis.
Under section 2 no. 14 BetrKV, caretaker remuneration, social security contributions and benefits in kind generally qualify as operating costs. However, portions relating to maintenance, repairs, replacement, decorative work and property administration are excluded. This applies whether a company or an employee performs the work.
A valid agreement is required
The tenancy agreement must provide for the tenant to bear operating costs. For residential tenancies, an agreement stating that the tenant pays “operating costs” can generally be sufficient. The specific contractual wording remains important. A breakdown prepared by the owners’ association’s managing agent does not replace a review of the tenancy agreement.
02Which caretaker duties are recoverable?
| Duty | Treatment in the operating cost statement |
|---|---|
| Cleaning stairwells and communal corridors | Generally recoverable |
| Clearing snow and gritting footpaths | Generally recoverable |
| Mowing lawns, trimming hedges and removing leaves | Generally recoverable where the conditions for gardening costs are met |
| Putting out and cleaning waste bins | Generally recoverable |
| Regular inspection rounds for day-to-day building operation | Generally recoverable; separate from repair and administrative duties |
| Repairing seals, locks or other defective components | Not recoverable |
| Appointing repair contractors and supervising their work | Not recoverable |
| Administering tenancies or conducting flat handovers | Not recoverable |
| General availability to receive fault reports outside normal working hours | Not recoverable as an administrative standby fee |
| Refurbishing or repainting the stairwell | Not recoverable |
A minor repair does not become an operating cost simply because it takes little time. Likewise, inspecting building equipment must be distinguished from repairing it. Meter-reading services require separate assessment under the relevant cost category; they are not automatically administrative costs.
No double charging
If the caretaker carries out gardening or building cleaning, the same labour must not be charged again under another heading. Both a caretaker and a gardening company may appear in the statement if they provide different, recoverable services. The key is that no service is charged twice.

03Separate mixed services on a substantiated basis
An unsupported deduction of, for example, 15% does not automatically make a mixed caretaker invoice suitable for recovery. The landlord must be able to substantiate the division between recoverable and non-recoverable duties. This is illustrated by the Federal Court of Justice judgment of 20 February 2008, VIII ZR 27/07.
Suitable supporting material includes:
- a service schedule with separate prices;
- activity and time records with an appropriate allocation of costs;
- another reliably documented breakdown of the work actually performed.
A percentage allocation is not invalid simply because it is expressed as a percentage. Its basis is what matters. A daily minute-by-minute log is not necessarily required in every case, but a general estimate unrelated to the services is not a reliable basis on its own.
Exclude general emergency standby fees
A fee for the caretaker’s general availability, for example to receive fault reports at night and arrange action, is not recoverable under the Federal Court of Justice judgment of 18 December 2019, VIII ZR 62/19. This is an administrative function.
Actual call-outs must be distinguished from standby arrangements: their treatment depends on the work performed. A repair remains non-recoverable even in an emergency. Equipment-specific operating or servicing tasks require separate assessment.
04Worked example: What the landlord bears
All the following figures are assumptions, not market prices or generally applicable cost ratios. The model concerns a rented flat of 72 m² in a building with twelve flats and 900 m² of residential floor area. It assumes a valid floor-area allocation both within the owners’ association and under the tenancy agreement.
The flat’s share is 72 ÷ 900 = 8%. The caretaker service costs €7,200 a year, plus €360 for general emergency standby availability. The assumed service schedule allocates 70% of the service cost to recoverable work, 20% to repairs and 10% to administration. This split is expressly not a recommendation for a standard percentage deduction.
| Item | Calculation | Flat’s annual amount |
|---|---|---|
| Total caretaker service | €7,200 × 8% | €576.00 |
| Recoverable work within that amount | €576 × 70% | €403.20 |
| Repairs within that amount | €576 × 20% | €115.20 |
| Administration within that amount | €576 × 10% | €57.60 |
| Additional emergency standby fee | €360 × 8% | €28.80 |
| Total costs including standby fee | €576 + €28.80 | €604.80 |
| Non-recoverable portion | €115.20 + €57.60 + €28.80 | €201.60 |
This means €403.20 can be included in the operating cost statement. The landlord bears €201.60 a year, or €16.80 a month, before tax. Passing on the entire €604.80 would be substantively incorrect in this example.
Tax effect: A simplified assumption only
Non-recoverable expenditure on a rental property can generally qualify as deductible income-related expenses. Recoverability from the tenant and tax deductibility are separate questions. Whether an immediate deduction is available depends, among other things, on the nature and tax classification of the expenditure.
The following model assumes that the entire €201.60 is deductible in the same year and produces an income tax reduction of exactly 35% of that amount. Solidarity surcharge and church tax are excluded.
| Calculation step | Amount |
|---|---|
| Non-recoverable costs | €201.60 |
| Assumed tax reduction: €201.60 × 35% | €70.56 |
| Remaining cost after the assumed tax reduction | €131.04 |
This is not a calculation using the 2026 income tax tariff and does not promise a tax saving. For ongoing cash-flow planning, initially allow for the full €201.60.
05Rented flats: Check documents and allocation rules
For a flat within a German owners’ association, the association usually appoints the service provider. As the landlord, you remain responsible for correctly billing your tenant.
- Review the association’s annual statement: Has the caretaker cost been properly split, or simply marked as entirely recoverable?
- Obtain the contract and supporting documents: Ask the managing agent for the service schedule, invoices and available activity records.
- Check the allocation basis: The allocation to the tenant follows the valid agreement or the statutory rules. Do not adopt the association’s allocation without checking it.
- Include only substantiated amounts: A list of tasks alone is insufficient if it does not support a clear allocation of costs.
- Improve future contracts: Separate service items make billing easier for all owners who let their flats.
Under section 556(4) of the German Civil Code (BGB), tenants can request access to the documents underlying the statement. These may include invoices, payment records and relevant contractual documents. The landlord may provide the documents electronically.

06Cost efficiency and common billing errors
Even services that are generally recoverable are subject to the statutory requirement of cost efficiency. A higher price alone does not establish a breach: the scope of service, quality and local circumstances must be comparable. You do not necessarily have to select the cheapest offer. Nevertheless, obtaining comparison quotes and documenting the selection can be useful.
In particular, avoid:
- Copying costs directly from the owners’ service charge: The association’s statement is not the same as the tenant’s operating cost statement.
- Unsupported percentage deductions: The breakdown must reflect the services actually provided.
- Duplicate labour charges: Check for overlaps between the caretaker and other contractors.
- Underestimating owner costs: Include non-recoverable portions and additional maintenance in your purchase calculations.
The tenant must generally receive the statement within twelve months of the end of the accounting period. After that, additional payment claims are normally excluded if the landlord is responsible for the delay. Errors can therefore have financial consequences; correcting a statement later does not automatically overcome the deadline.
Contributions to the maintenance reserve also reduce liquidity, but generally do not qualify as immediately deductible income-related expenses. Tax treatment normally depends on the subsequent use of the funds for qualifying work.
07Conclusion: Assess caretaker costs by service
Caretaker costs may be fully, partly or not recoverable at all, depending on the duties and contractual conditions. In the example, the landlord bears €201.60 of the €604.80 total before tax. A substantiated breakdown, the correct allocation basis and complete supporting documents are essential.
This guide provides general information as at October 2026 and does not replace legal or tax advice for individual circumstances.
08Free initial consultation
In a free initial consultation, we discuss how to account for owners’ service charges and non-recoverable owner costs when assessing a buy-to-let flat. The consultation does not replace an individual legal or tax review.
Request a free initial consultation
FAQFrequently asked questions
Can landlords recover caretaker costs from tenants?
Generally yes, if the tenancy agreement validly assigns operating costs to the tenant. However, section 2 no. 14 BetrKV excludes portions relating in particular to repairs, maintenance, replacement, decorative work and administration.
Which caretaker duties are not recoverable?
Examples include repairing defective components, appointing and supervising repair contractors, conducting flat handovers and refurbishment work. The specific service matters, not the provider’s job title.
Can a landlord simply deduct a fixed percentage?
An unsupported flat-rate deduction is insufficient. A percentage allocation can be substantiated if it is based on reliable service, price or time information. The key is an appropriate separation of the work actually performed.
Is a caretaker’s emergency standby fee recoverable?
A fee for general availability to receive fault reports and organise action is not recoverable under Federal Court of Justice judgment VIII ZR 62/19. Actual call-outs must be assessed separately according to the work performed.
Can tenants check caretaker costs?
Yes. Under section 556(4) BGB, tenants can request access to the supporting documents underlying the statement. These may include invoices, payment records and relevant contractual documents. They may be provided electronically.
What if the owners’ association’s statement does not split the costs?
Ask the managing agent for the caretaker contract, service schedule and available activity records. Do not copy the entry without checking it. Both the recoverable service and its associated cost must be substantiated.
Are non-recoverable caretaker costs tax-deductible?
For a rental property, they can generally qualify as deductible income-related expenses. Whether and when a deduction is available depends on the tax classification of the expenditure. The actual tax effect depends on personal circumstances and is not guaranteed.

Writes about Letting, Service charges (Nebenkosten), Tenancy law and Multi-family buildings.
As a civil engineer, property investor and advisor with around 14 years of finance practice, Moe looks at buildings from a technical angle first. He writes about build quality, letting, running costs (Nebenkosten) and investments that hold up beyond the brochure.
This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.



