Guide · Letting

    Operating Costs: Choosing an Allocation Method

    Floor area, occupancy or consumption: practical checks for landlords reviewing statements, condominiums and vacancy costs.


    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo
    2 November 202611 min read
    Illustrative assumptions: identical costs, different allocations
    €720
    Apartment A, 80 m², one resident
    allocated by floor area
    €300
    Apartment A, 80 m², one resident
    allocated by resident count
    €1,200
    Apartment B, 60 m², four residents
    allocated by resident count
    €675
    owner's share during three months of vacancy
    separate example below

    Suppose you purchase a building containing four apartments. A family with two children occupies 60 m², while a person living alone occupies 80 m². Water, wastewater and waste collection are allocated by residential floor area. Even if the family uses more water, its allocated bill can be lower. That is a consequence of the allocation method, not necessarily an accounting error.

    For an investor, three questions matter: Which costs can legally be passed on to tenants? Which allocation method applies? And what remains payable by the owner during vacancy? The agreement to pass on costs and the method used to distribute them are separate issues. § 556 BGB governs the Betriebskosten agreement; § 556a BGB addresses allocation. Betriebskosten are the recurring property operating costs covered by German tenancy rules.

    01What § 556a BGB requires

    Start with the valid provisions of the Mietvertrag, the tenancy agreement. Where there is no different agreed method, § 556a Abs. 1 BGB generally provides for allocation by residential floor area. The statutory allocation must take account of recorded consumption or causation. However, the existence of a water meter does not automatically override every existing contractual provision without further examination.

    For a rented condominium apartment, Absatz 3 refers to the allocation currently applicable between the condominium owners if the tenancy agreement does not provide otherwise. If that method conflicts with billiges Ermessen—an equitable assessment of the circumstances—Absatz 1 applies instead. Absatz 2 permits a unilateral change to recorded consumption or causation subject to its requirements.

    For central heating and hot water, generally 50–70% of costs are allocated by consumption. § 7 HeizkostenV requires a 70% consumption share for certain buildings. The remaining costs follow the permitted area-based or, where applicable, volume-based measures. The Heizkostenverordnung generally takes precedence over contractual arrangements, but its scope and exceptions matter, including the special treatment of a two-unit building partly occupied by its landlord. See our guide to Heizkostenabrechnung, the heating-cost statement.

    02Allocation methods at a glance

    Allocation methods: uses and limitations
    MethodPossible useAdvantageLimitation
    Residential floor areaFor example, property tax, insurance or garden maintenanceUnderstandable statutory starting pointDoes not reflect household size
    Resident countAgreed allocation of waste collection or unmetered water, for exampleReflects occupancyOccupancy and changes must be documented reliably
    Number of apartmentsValidly agreed allocation of suitable operating costsEqual share for each apartmentIgnores differences in size and use
    Consumption or causationMetered water; consumption-related heating and hot-water sharesBased on recorded useRequires reliable measurement and billing
    MiteigentumsanteileCondominium apartments where the corresponding WEG allocation appliesAligns with the owners' allocationOwnership shares need not match floor-area shares

    These are allocation methods, not independent permission to charge a particular expense. Acquisition, repair or administration costs do not become recoverable merely because an allocation method has been agreed. Under § 1 BetrKV, administration, maintenance and repairs are excluded from Betriebskosten.

    Different cost categories may use different allocation methods within one statement. Each must follow the applicable agreement or law. The method must be understandable and explained where necessary. However, the statement need not contain every detail of the underlying calculation: the BGH does not, for example, require a complete occupancy list within a statement using person-months. See our guide to the Betriebskostenabrechnung, the annual operating-cost statement.

    Organising receipts for the accounts of a rental apartment
    AI-generated illustrative image

    03Floor area versus residents: a worked example

    Illustrative assumptions, not market figures or an offer: The fully let example building contains four apartments, a total of 300 m² and nine residents. Occupancy and floor areas remain unchanged throughout the year. Water, wastewater and waste collection together cost €2,700. There is no apartment-level consumption measurement. For this comparison, assume that each alternative method validly applies to all the costs considered.

    ApartmentArea / residentsBy floor areaBy residents
    A80 m² / 1€720€300
    B60 m² / 4€540€1,200
    C70 m² / 2€630€600
    D90 m² / 2€810€600
    Total300 m² / 9€2,700€2,700

    Our calculation: €2,700 ÷ 300 m² = €9 per m²; €2,700 ÷ 9 residents = €300 per resident. Multiply the relevant unit cost by the apartment's floor area or number of residents to calculate its share.

    The total distributed remains unchanged in this example. Apartment B pays €660 more under the resident-based method, while apartment A pays €420 less. The shares of apartments C and D also change: this is not simply a transfer between two households.

    Which method is more suitable? Resident count reflects occupancy, but it does not measure actual consumption. It also requires additional administrative records. Where the agreement refers to people actually living in the apartment, data from the Melderegister, the official residents' register, are not necessarily sufficient. The BGH addressed this in its judgment of 23 January 2008, VIII ZR 82/07. Occupancy changes need to be accounted for reliably.

    Before purchasing, check which meters are installed and whether occupancy records and meter readings support the statements. Assess the economics of installing additional meters for the specific property rather than assuming that different household sizes justify an allocation change.

    04Changing the allocation method

    A fixed agreed method cannot be replaced simply because another seems fairer. Two routes are particularly relevant in practice. Special cases, such as a valid contractual Leistungsbestimmungsrecht—a right to determine the allocation on an equitable basis—require separate assessment. Such a provision does not create an unrestricted right to change the method.

    1. Change to recorded consumption or causation: § 556a Abs. 2 BGB permits a corresponding declaration in Textform for future billing periods. Textform is a German legal form requirement that does not generally require a handwritten signature. The declaration must reach the tenant before the relevant period starts. If the costs were previously included in the rent, the rent must be reduced accordingly.
    2. Agreed amendment: A change from a fixed floor-area method to resident count should be agreed with the relevant parties to the tenancy agreement. Review the complete allocation system so that different contractual arrangements do not result in recovering more than the actual costs. However, consent from everyone living in the building is not a universal statutory requirement for every individual contractual amendment.

    Limited use of a building facility does not automatically make an agreed allocation invalid. In its judgment of 20 September 2006, VIII ZR 103/06, the BGH accepted the allocation of lift costs to ground-floor tenants in the circumstances before it. That does not resolve every possible building configuration. Read more in our guide to lift costs.

    05Rented condominiums: the community's allocation

    For a condominium apartment, distinguish between two relationships: cost allocation within the Wohnungseigentümergemeinschaft, the community of condominium owners, and the operating-cost statement issued to your tenant. Unless the tenancy agreement provides otherwise, § 556a Abs. 3 BGB refers to the currently applicable community allocation. If it conflicts with billiges Ermessen, Absatz 1 applies instead.

    Nevertheless, the community's Jahresabrechnung, its annual accounts, is not a ready-to-send tenant statement. Non-recoverable items must be removed. In particular, administration, maintenance and repair expenses cannot be passed on as Betriebskosten. An otherwise appropriate allocation method does not change the legal nature of those expenses.

    Key handover in a bright rental apartment
    AI-generated illustrative image

    06Vacancy: the owner retains the floor-area share

    Where costs are allocated by residential floor area, a vacant apartment generally remains part of the total area. Its share cannot be shifted to occupied apartments by removing it from the denominator. This also applies to consumption-related costs allocated by area because individual consumption is not measured. The BGH confirmed the principle in its judgment of 31 May 2006, VIII ZR 159/05.

    Illustrative assumptions, separate vacancy scenario: For the same building, assume annual operating costs of €9,000 that can lawfully be allocated by floor area. Central heating and hot water with their separate consumption allocation are excluded from this simplified calculation. Apartment D measures 90 m² and is vacant for three months. Its assumed Kaltmiete—rent excluding operating costs—is €900 per month. For this planning example, costs are spread evenly over time.

    CalculationAmount
    Annual cost per m²: €9,000 ÷ 300 m²€30
    Apartment D's annual share: 90 m² × €30€2,700
    Owner's share for three months: €2,700 × 3/12€675
    Forgone Kaltmiete: 3 × €900€2,700
    Impact compared with continuous letting, before tax€3,375

    This calculation separates income not received from operating costs the owner must bear. It is not a complete return or tax calculation: financing, reletting expenses and other owner costs are excluded. Actual statements may allocate costs differently over time. Tax treatment needs individual assessment; forgone rent is not itself a separate deductible expense.

    For an acquisition assessment, we therefore suggest planning separately for lost rental income and operating costs that remain payable. Consumption-based and resident-based allocations require their own analysis; the floor-area example cannot be transferred unchanged. Our guide to non-recoverable operating costs discusses other owner expenses.

    07Risks and common mistakes

    An unclear allocation method. Present the cost category, total costs, allocation method, overall allocation base and apartment share understandably. Formal defects can affect the enforceability of an additional payment. It would be too broad to say that any missing allocation detail inevitably invalidates the entire statement. The BGH's case law on resident-based methods illustrates the importance of distinguishing essential information from unnecessary detail.

    Missing the billing deadline. Advance payments must be reconciled annually. Additional claims are generally excluded after the statutory deadline unless the landlord is not responsible for the delay. Our guide to § 556 BGB explains the rules.

    Changing the method without a legal basis. A different view of fairness does not replace the necessary agreement or the requirements for a statutory change.

    Removing vacant apartments from the calculation. Under the floor-area method, the vacant apartment's share generally remains with the owner.

    Using unverified floor areas. For statutory area-based allocation, the relevant ratio generally uses actual residential floor areas, not automatically the figures written in the Mietvertrag: BGH, judgment of 30 May 2018, VIII ZR 220/17. Have doubtful measurements checked under the applicable calculation rules. Our glossary explains the Wohnflächenverordnung, the German residential floor-area calculation regulation.

    08Conclusion for property investors

    An allocation method determines how legally recoverable costs are distributed. It does not replace an assessment of recoverability or a comprehensible statement. In the fully occupied worked example, the total distributed is unchanged. In the vacancy example, however, the owner bears operating costs in addition to losing rental income.

    For acquisition due diligence, we recommend reviewing contracts and statements together, checking the floor areas and measurement records, and including continuing operating costs in vacancy scenarios. Only build a change of allocation method into your plan after examining its legal and practical requirements.

    FAQFrequently asked questions

    Which allocation method applies without an agreement?

    Residential floor area is generally the default under § 556a Abs. 1 BGB, subject to other provisions and recorded consumption or causation. Rented condominium apartments and heating costs have special rules.

    Can operating costs be allocated by resident count?

    A valid agreement can provide for this method. Resident count does not measure actual consumption. Where actual occupancy is the agreed basis, residents and relevant changes must be documented reliably; official registration records alone are not necessarily sufficient.

    Can a landlord change the allocation method?

    Subject to its requirements, § 556a Abs. 2 BGB allows a change to recorded consumption or causation through a timely declaration in Textform. Other changes to a fixed agreed method generally require agreement; special cases need separate review.

    Who pays operating costs during vacancy?

    Under a floor-area allocation, the landlord generally bears the vacant apartment's share. Its area cannot simply be removed from the total. Other allocation methods require an examination of the specific cost structure.

    Which method applies to a rented condominium apartment?

    Unless the tenancy agreement provides otherwise, § 556a Abs. 3 BGB refers to the allocation currently applicable between condominium owners. If it conflicts with billiges Ermessen, Absatz 1 applies instead. Non-recoverable owner expenses remain excluded.

    Must the operating-cost statement identify the method?

    Yes. The allocation must be understandable and explained where necessary. Not every missing detail automatically invalidates the entire statement; the nature and scope of the defect matter.

    09Further reading

    10Sources

    The linked statutes and judgments provide source references. Editorial reference date: 28 October 2026. Calculations are our own illustrative models, not market data.

    General information only, not individual legal, tax or investment advice. Legal and tax outcomes depend on the individual circumstances.

    Written by
    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo

    Writes about Letting, Service charges (Nebenkosten), Tenancy law and Multi-family buildings.

    As a civil engineer, property investor and advisor with around 14 years of finance practice, Moe looks at buildings from a technical angle first. He writes about build quality, letting, running costs (Nebenkosten) and investments that hold up beyond the brochure.

    This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.

    Free · Instant · No sign-up

    Download this guide as a PDF

    The complete guide as a clean A4 file – with a cover page, all chapters and page numbers. Keep it on hand, read it offline, or go through it at your own pace during your consultation.

    • All chapters, tables and worked examples
    • Read offline – on your phone or printed out
    • Go through it at your own pace or pass it on
    • Free, no sign-up, no email required

    A4 format · 2,590 words · As of 02 November 2026

    Related guides

    All guides