Property advice: how to recognise trustworthy advisers
Anyone can call themselves a property adviser. We explain which licences exist, what they check and what they do not, how advisers are paid and how to check a calculation in ten minutes.
Perhaps someone called you, or you clicked on an advert and are now looking at an illustrative calculation for a tenanted flat. The person at the other end is friendly, seems knowledgeable and calls themselves a property adviser. You wonder how much of it you can believe.
The honest answer is that the title tells you nothing about that. “Property adviser” [Immobilienberater] is not a protected professional title. What matters is the person's role, licence, remuneration and, above all, the figures you can check yourself.
01Who advises you when buying a property
Property advice covers very different roles. Each comes with different duties and a different way of being paid.
| Role | Authorisation | Who usually pays | Area of expertise |
|---|---|---|---|
| Estate agent [Makler] or property sales company | § 34c GewO | Seller or developer, sometimes the buyer | Property, location, purchase process |
| Mortgage broker [Finanzierungsvermittler] | § 34i GewO | Commission from the bank | Loan, terms, choice of bank |
| Fee-only mortgage adviser [Honorar-Immobiliardarlehensberater] | § 34i(5) GewO | You, through a fee | Mortgage advice without commission |
| Bank adviser | Banking licence | The bank as employer | The bank's own mortgage |
| Tax adviser [Steuerberater] | German Tax Consultancy Act [Steuerberatungsgesetz] | You, under the statutory fee schedule | Your personal tax position |
| Surveyor, valuer [Sachverständiger, Gutachter] | Depending on the appointment | You, through a fee | Condition, value, construction quality |
| Civil-law notary [Notar] | Public office | You, under statutory fee rules | Contract and legal completion, not financial viability |
Many providers cover several roles, such as brokering both the flat and the financing. This is permitted if they hold the necessary licences. Even so, ask which role the person advising you is speaking in at that moment.
02What § 34c and § 34i actually check
A business licence sounds like a quality seal. It is more of a minimum threshold.
§ 34c GewO applies to estate agents, property developers [Bauträger], construction project administrators [Baubetreuer] and residential property managers. Anyone brokering flat sales must hold a licence. It is refused if the applicant is unreliable, for example because of a fraud conviction within the last five years, or has unsound financial circumstances (§ 34c(2) GewO). There is no competency examination for estate agents. The requirement for 20 hours of continuing professional development over three years applies only to property managers (§ 34c(2a) GewO).
§ 34i GewO applies to brokering property loans for consumers. The bar is higher here. Requirements include an IHK competency examination, professional indemnity insurance, reliability and sound financial standing (§ 34i(2) GewO). Brokers must be entered in the intermediary register, as must their employees who provide advice directly (subsection 8).
§ 34f GewO becomes relevant if you are offered units in a property fund or another investment product rather than a flat. The broker then needs this additional licence.
For more on mortgage advisers and credit brokers, their costs and how they compare with your own bank, see our guide to mortgage advisers and credit brokers.

03How advisers are paid
Advice when buying property is rarely genuinely free. It is usually funded through commission built into the purchase price or the loan.
- Commission from the seller or developer. Common for new-build properties and investment property sales companies. You pay it indirectly through the purchase price.
- Buyer's commission [Käuferprovision]. Charged on existing flats marketed by an estate agent. For owner-occupied flats and single-family houses, commission is shared under §§ 656a et seq. of the German Civil Code (BGB).
- Commission from the bank. Mortgage brokers receive this for the completed loan.
- Fee. You pay the adviser directly, and they take no commission from the lender. For mortgage advice, this is governed by § 34i(5) GewO.
None of these arrangements is inherently untrustworthy. It becomes a problem when remuneration is concealed or questions about it receive evasive answers. Someone receiving commission from the seller has an interest in the sale. You should know this so that you can put their recommendations into context.
„Why don't you hold the properties yourselves? Why sell them at all?“
A prospective buyer asked this during a consultation, and it is one of the best questions you can put to a provider. A good answer openly explains the business model: who sells, who brokers the deal and who earns what from it. An evasive answer is a reason to look more closely.
04Checking an illustrative calculation
Most offers come with a calculation. It shows what the flat will cost you each month, usually after tax. Whether the figure is correct depends on the assumptions. A hypothetical example shows what to look out for.
An existing flat is offered for €250,000 with €850 in monthly rent excluding service charges [Kaltmiete], with the purchase price fully financed and a 1% principal repayment rate [Tilgung]. The illustrative calculation uses 3.5% interest, just €30 in monthly management costs and a flat tax rate of 42%. The bottom line is an out-of-pocket cost of around €16 a month.
We recalculate the same flat for a buyer with €60,000 in taxable income. We use 3.8% interest, add €60 a month for maintenance and a 2% allowance for rental income loss, and apply the actual income tax schedule. Current offers are more likely to be around 4.0 to 4.2% (as at October 2026).
| Offer | Recalculated | |
|---|---|---|
| Rent excluding service charges, less rental income loss | €10,200 | €9,996 |
| Loan repayments | −€11,250 | −€12,000 |
| Management and maintenance | −€360 | −€1,080 |
| Result before tax | −€1,410 | −€3,084 |
| Tax saving | +€1,222 | +€1,733 |
| Result after tax | −€188 | −€1,351 |
| per month after tax | around −€16 | around −€113 |
Three assumptions make the difference. The lower interest rate reduces the repayments. Leaving out maintenance and rental income loss makes the flat look cheaper. And a 42% tax rate only applies from an income of just under €70,000; at €60,000, the marginal tax rate [Grenzsteuersatz] is 38.58%.
A flat requiring a €113 top-up can still be a good decision. But you should know that figure before buying, not after your first tax return.
Enter the purchase price, rent, interest rate and costs. The calculator shows the result before and after tax.
05Checklist: ten questions for every adviser
- 01Role
In what capacity are you advising me: as an estate agent, sales company, mortgage broker or bank?
- 02Licence
Which licence do you hold, and which authority is responsible?
- 03Remuneration
Who pays you for this sale, and in what form?
- 04Assumptions
What interest rate, tax rate, maintenance costs and rental income loss are you assuming?
- 05Before tax
What do I pay each month before the tax refund arrives?
- 06Documents
Will I receive the tenancy agreement, declaration of division [Teilungserklärung], minutes of owners' meetings [Eigentümerversammlung] and annual budget [Wirtschaftsplan] before reserving?
- 07Time
How long do I have to review the draft purchase contract? For consumers, the notary should generally make it available two weeks before notarisation (§ 17(2a) of the German Notarisation Act, BeurkG).
- 08Risks
What happens in the event of a vacancy, rising interest rates, a special levy [Sonderumlage] or resale?
- 09Third parties
May I show the documents to my tax adviser?
- 10After the purchase
Who handles letting, management and tax matters, and what does it cost?
An adviser who is happy to answer these questions is a good sign. One who becomes impatient is a warning sign.

06Warning signs
Not every one of these signs means fraud. But each is a reason to pause and seek a second opinion.
„The opportunities are heavily emphasised, while the risks are underrepresented.“
This is how a prospective buyer explained in writing why they declined an offer. The sentence describes the most common problem in advisory conversations quite accurately. Good advice presents risks just as specifically as opportunities, with figures.
07Which adviser you need, and when
- You are looking for a tenanted flat and want property selection, the purchase process and financing from a single provider.
- The provider discloses all assumptions and their remuneration.
- You have time to check the documents and calculation yourself.
- Your tax position is complicated, for example because of a business, foreign income or several flats.
- You are unsure about the condition of an older building.
- You want mortgage advice without commission; in that case, a fee-only adviser is the right route.
08Risks no advice can remove
Vacancy and rental income loss. Even the best advice cannot promise that a flat will always be let. Budget for a reserve.
Interest rates after the fixed-rate period [Zinsbindung]. If the interest rate rises when you refinance [Anschlussfinanzierung], repayments increase. In the example, one additional percentage point costs just under €2,500 a year.
Maintenance and special levies. Older buildings need money for roofs, heating and pipework. The minutes of owners' meetings show what is coming up.
Resale. Whether you achieve a higher price later depends on the market. A forecast is not a commitment.
Liability. Whether an adviser is liable for an incorrect calculation depends on the individual case. You should not rely on this. If you check the figures yourself, ideally you will never need to pursue a liability claim.
FAQFrequently asked questions
Is property adviser a protected professional title?
No. Anyone can use the title. What matters is the work they actually do. Anyone brokering flat sales needs a licence under § 34c of the German Trade Regulation Act (GewO); anyone brokering property loans needs one under § 34i GewO.
What does a licence under § 34c GewO mean?
It permits property broking and other activities such as property development or management. Reliability and sound financial standing are checked. The law does not require estate agents to pass a professional knowledge examination.
What is the difference between § 34c and § 34i GewO?
§ 34c covers property broking, while § 34i covers brokering property loans for consumers. § 34i additionally requires an IHK competency examination, professional indemnity insurance and entry in the intermediary register.
How do I find independent property advice?
For financing, fee-only mortgage advisers under § 34i(5) GewO take no commission from the lender. A tax adviser handles tax matters, while a surveyor assesses the property's condition. Commission-free advice on the purchase itself is rare and requires a fee.
Can free property advice be trustworthy?
It can. But free usually means that the adviser is paid through commission from the seller or bank. Ask about this and request all the assumptions behind the calculation.
How do I check an adviser's calculation?
Ask for the interest rate, principal repayment rate, tax rate, maintenance allowance and rental income loss assumption, then first check the result before tax. Use your own marginal tax rate and the interest rate you can actually obtain.
Can a property adviser give me tax advice?
General explanations and illustrative calculations are permitted. Advice on your personal tax affairs is reserved for tax advisers and a small number of other professions.
09Further reading
- Mortgage advisers and credit brokers
- Property investment: avoiding beginners' mistakes
- Buying a tenanted flat
- The property purchase process
- Checking a developer contract
- Calculator: property cash flow
10Sources
All sources accessed on 19 October 2026.
- § 34c GewO (estate agents, developers, property managers; grounds for refusal; continuing professional development for property managers only)
- § 34i GewO (mortgage brokers, professional competence, fee-only advisers, registration)
- § 34f GewO (financial investment intermediaries)
- § 5 StBerG (prohibition of unauthorised assistance in tax matters)
- Intermediary register (DIHK, § 34i lookup)
- § 32a EStG (2026 tax schedule)
- Illustrative calculation: own calculation, as at 19 October 2026
Note: This guide provides general information and does not replace tax, legal or investment advice for your individual circumstances. All figures are illustrative calculations with disclosed assumptions, as at 19 October 2026.

Writes about Financing and Taxes.
Romolo brings almost 17 years of banking and financing experience, including leading around 145 sales staff, to his work. He writes about financing, taxes and property decisions that fit your life for the long term.
This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.



