Rent or buy? The honest calculation and the third option
Buying feels like building wealth; renting feels like freedom. We run the numbers for both options using 2026 interest rates and explore an alternative many overlook: keep renting and buy a flat as an investment.
You have been paying rent for years and feel as though you are throwing money away. At the same time, a comparable flat now costs so much to buy that the mortgage payment would exceed your rent. So should you keep renting? Or buy anyway, because it will belong to you in the end?
There are two sides to this question, which are often conflated. One is about your home: how much security and freedom do you want? The other is about wealth: how do you build it? Separating the two reveals an option missing from most comparisons.
We run the numbers for owning your own home versus renting, using interest rates from October 2026. Then we show you the third option: continue renting your home and buy a flat as an investment.
01The real question behind “rent or buy”
Your own home is two things at once: a place to live and an investment. Each has its own rules. As a home, it should suit your life, your workplace, your family and your plans. As an investment, it should make financial sense.
These two goals do not always align. The flat you want to live in is often somewhere where purchase prices are high relative to rents. And if you might move in five years, buying means paying transaction costs that you will not recover when you sell.
The state treats the two cases differently for tax purposes. For your own home, you cannot deduct interest, depreciation or repairs. For a let flat, these are income-related expenses (§ 9 EStG) and reduce your tax bill. On the other hand, selling an owner-occupied home is usually tax-free, even within ten years.
| Owner-occupied home | Let flat | |
|---|---|---|
| Interest deductible | no | yes |
| Depreciation (AfA) | no | yes, usually 2% or 3% of the building value per year |
| Repairs deductible | no | yes |
| Rental income taxable | not applicable | yes |
| Sale within ten years | tax-free if owner-occupied | profit taxable |
| Housing security | high | none, you live elsewhere |
02Purchase price-to-rent ratio: the quick test
Before doing the calculations, it is worth looking at a single figure. The purchase price-to-rent ratio is the purchase price divided by the annual rent excluding bills for a comparable flat. It tells you how many years’ rent you are paying to buy it.
If a flat costs €350,000 and you would pay €1,150 a month excluding bills to rent the same flat, the ratio is €350,000 divided by €13,800, or around 25. Many guides describe figures around 20 as cheap and 25 or above as expensive. In sought-after major cities, flats for sale often exceed this level; in smaller cities, they tend to fall below it.
The ratio is a test, not an answer. It tells you nothing about your interest rate, your holding period or your plans for your life. For that, you need a calculation.

03The calculation: owning a flat versus renting
Lena and Jonas, both in their mid-30s, rent their home and are considering buying their 80 m² flat or a similar one. The purchase price is €350,000, and the current rent excluding bills is €1,150. They have €107,000 in savings. The names are fictional, and the figures are an illustrative calculation, not a forecast.
We compare only buying costs that are money spent and gone, just like rent. Mortgage principal repayments do not count, because they build wealth. We apply an imputed interest rate of 2% to the equity invested, because this money can no longer earn interest elsewhere.
| Year 1 | Year 11 | |
|---|---|---|
| Interest on the mortgage (€280,000, 4.1%) | €957 | €721 |
| Reserve fund contributions, management, repairs (rising by 2% per year) | €200 | €244 |
| Imputed interest on €107,000 of equity (2%) | €178 | €178 |
| Costs as an owner, excluding principal repayments | €1,335 | €1,143 |
| Rent excluding bills (rising by 2% per year) | €1,150 | €1,402 |
| Difference in favour of | Renting: €185 | Ownership: €259 |
In the first year, ownership costs Lena and Jonas around €185 a month more than renting. On top of that come principal repayments of around €466, which build wealth but still have to be paid every month. The monthly mortgage payment is €1,423, almost €300 more than the rent.
After ten years, the picture has reversed, provided the assumptions hold. Interest payments have fallen because the outstanding mortgage balance has dropped to around €211,000. Under the assumptions, the rent has risen to €1,402. Ownership is now around €259 a month cheaper.
The calculation shows why the holding period matters so much. Anyone selling again after three or four years will usually not have recouped the €37,000 in purchase transaction costs. For those who stay for 15 or 20 years, buying can pay off if the assumptions broadly hold. If rents rise more slowly or interest rates are higher when refinancing, the break-even point moves further into the future.
04The third option: keep renting and let out a flat
What if Lena and Jonas separate the two questions? They continue renting, staying flexible and living in their preferred location. And they buy a smaller flat in a city with a lower purchase price-to-rent ratio, which they let out.
„I would like an ordinary flat that I can let out.“
This is what prospective buyers tell us in our conversations when taking their first step into investment property. For tenants, this is often the natural starting point: the flat does not need to suit their own lives, but rather be suitable for letting and make financial sense.
Suppose they buy a 55 m² flat for €200,000, already let for €700 a month excluding bills. The purchase price-to-rent ratio is just under 24. They put in €40,000 of equity and borrow €180,000. The remaining €67,000 of their savings stays available. The two are not married; Jonas buys alone and has a taxable income of €70,000.
| per year | per month | |
|---|---|---|
| Rental income | €8,400 | €700 |
| Mortgage payment (€180,000 at 4.1% interest, 1.5% principal repayment rate) | −€10,080 | −€840 |
| Costs that cannot be passed on to tenants (management, reserve fund contributions) | −€720 | −€60 |
| Cash flow before tax | −€2,400 | −€200 |
| Tax loss (interest of €7,380, costs of €720, depreciation of €3,520, less rent) | −€3,220 | |
| Tax saving for Jonas (taxable income of €70,000) | +€1,336 | +€111 |
| Cash flow after tax | −€1,064 | −€89 |
In the first year, the flat costs around €200 a month before tax and around €89 after tax. In return, Lena and Jonas repay around €225 of mortgage principal every month. Their own housing situation remains unchanged, and their rent continues to rise with the market.
The distinction from an owner-occupied home is important: this flat is a business involving tenants, tax returns and risks such as void periods and repairs. The tax saving shrinks as interest payments fall. And it gives Lena and Jonas no housing security. A termination of their own tenancy because their landlord needs the property for personal use affects them just as it did before.
Run the numbers for the third option using your own tax rate.
You can find out how much equity you really need for an investment property in the guide Investing in property with little money. The guide A flat as an investment compares the advantages and disadvantages of investing in a flat.

05“Will this affect my creditworthiness for another investment or a home of my own?”
„Will this affect my creditworthiness for another investment or a home of my own?“
This question almost always comes up when tenants consider an investment property but have not ruled out buying a home of their own. The honest answer: yes, one mortgage limits your borrowing capacity for the next. By how much depends on your income, rental income and outstanding mortgage balance.
When you later buy a home of your own, the bank treats the ongoing mortgage payment on your investment property as a financial commitment. It usually counts only part of the rental income as income, often applying a deduction for costs and vacancy periods. This reduces the amount you can borrow for your own home.
The reverse is also true. If you first buy a home with a high mortgage payment, you will usually have no borrowing capacity for an investment property for years. So plan the order before you sign.
| Order | Arguments in favour | Arguments against |
|---|---|---|
| Investment property first, own home later | lower initial outlay, tax advantage, time to choose where to live | reduced borrowing capacity for your own home |
| Own home first, investment property later | housing security early on, sale usually tax-free | high mortgage payment, limited borrowing capacity for years |
| Renting and an investment property only | maximum flexibility over where you live | no home of your own in retirement, rent payments continue |
| Own home only | straightforward, rent-free in retirement | wealth tied up in one location |
You can find more on how banks assess a second mortgage in our guide Financing a second property.
06Which route suits whom
- you want to stay in the area for at least ten to 15 years
- the purchase-price-to-annual-rent ratio in your area is below 25
- the mortgage payment will not overstretch your budget even if interest rates rise
- you might move in the next few years
- the purchase-price-to-annual-rent ratio is well above 25
- you do not want to put all your savings into a flat
The third route is particularly suitable for tenants who want flexibility over where they live, have a stable income with a substantial tax burden, and can afford a monthly top-up in the early years. It is less suitable for people who do not want to deal with tenants and property management, or whose main reason for wanting their own home is housing security.
07Risks and limitations of the calculation
Every rent-or-buy calculation stands or falls on three assumptions: interest rates, rent increases and the holding period. We have calculated using an interest rate of 4.1%, rent increases of 2% and the same interest rate for follow-on financing. If interest rates rise when you refinance, ownership becomes more expensive. If rents rise more slowly, the advantage of ownership shrinks.
Buyers also bear risks that tenants do not: special levies imposed by the owners’ association, major repairs, a potential loss in value when selling, and high incidental purchase costs that cannot be recovered. A rented-out flat brings additional risks: vacancy periods, unpaid rent and dependence on the local rental market.
Tenants face different risks: rising rents, possible termination of the tenancy because the landlord needs the property for their own use, and continuing to pay rent in retirement rather than living rent-free. Which set of risks is easier for you to bear is a personal decision.
FAQFrequently asked questions
Is renting or buying cheaper in 2026?
With price-to-rent ratios of around 25 and mortgage interest rates of around 4%, renting is usually cheaper in the first few years if you compare only unrecoverable costs. Home ownership becomes cheaper over the years because the interest burden falls and rents generally rise. How long this takes depends on interest rates, rent increases and the purchase price.
What is the price-to-rent ratio?
The purchase price divided by the annual rent excluding service charges for a comparable flat. A ratio of 25 means you pay the equivalent of 25 years’ rent to buy the property. Ratios around 20 are considered relatively inexpensive, while those of 25 or above are considered relatively expensive.
When does buying become worthwhile compared with renting?
Usually only after several years, often after ten years or more. The key is to stay long enough to spread the ancillary purchase costs, which amount to around 10% of the purchase price, over that period.
Can I deduct the interest on my own home from my taxes?
No. Interest, depreciation and repairs for an owner-occupied home are not tax-deductible. For a flat you let out, they are deductible income-related expenses.
What does ‘rent and invest’ mean in property?
You continue living in rented accommodation and buy a flat to let out. This separates your housing choices from building wealth. The flat can be in a location where the relationship between purchase prices and rents is more favourable than where you live.
Does an investment property reduce my chances of buying my own home?
It reduces your borrowing capacity because the bank treats the ongoing mortgage payment as a financial commitment and only takes part of the rental income into account. Whether buying your own home later is still possible depends on your income, outstanding mortgage balance and the amount of rent you receive. Plan the sequence in advance.
How much of my own capital do I need to buy?
For an owner-occupied home, banks usually expect you to cover at least the ancillary purchase costs yourself, preferably plus another 10 to 20% of the purchase price. For a flat you let out, financing with less of your own capital may also be possible, depending on your creditworthiness, but with a higher interest rate and higher mortgage payments.
08Further reading
- Buying your first property: step by step
- A flat as an investment: advantages and disadvantages
- Investing in property with little money
- Financing a second property
- Notary fees when buying property
09Sources
- Sections 7, 9, 21 and 23 of the German Income Tax Act (EStG), gesetze-im-internet.de, accessed on 14 October 2026; Section 32a EStG in the version applicable for 2026 (Federal Law Gazette 2024 I No. 449)
- Mortgage interest rates: Dr. Klein, nominal interest rate of 4.06% for a ten-year fixed-rate period on 7 October 2026; Baufi24, interest rate commentary for October 2026 (September average: 4.16%), accessed on 14 October 2026
- Federal states’ property transfer tax rates for 2026 (3.5% to 6.5%), state legislation
- Keyword data: Semrush, Germany database, as at 14 October 2026
Disclaimer: This guide provides general information and is not a substitute for tax, mortgage or investment advice. Interest rates and terms depend on your creditworthiness and the timing.

Writes about Taxes, AfA (depreciation), Financing and Investment concept.
Andriy is Managing Director of the InvestImmo Group and has been an entrepreneur in the property industry since 2020. His experience in estate agency, property marketing and his own investments shapes his view on property selection and long-term investment concepts. His team handles the personal advice for investors.
This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.



