Guide · Letting

    Modernisation rent increases under § 559 BGB: how landlords calculate them

    New windows, insulation, heating: landlords may pass on some of the costs through the rent. We explain step by step how much, which notice periods apply and why the rent increase alone rarely makes the investment worthwhile.


    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo
    15 October 202611 min read
    Modernisation rent increases in four figures
    8%
    of the costs per year
    may be added to the annual rent
    €3/m²
    over six years
    maximum increase; only €2/m² if the rent is below €7/m²
    3 months
    advance notice
    the tenant must receive the notice this far ahead
    12.5 years
    in the example
    until the rent increase has recouped the modernisation share of the costs

    The windows in your rental flat are thirty years old. There are draughts in winter, your tenant’s heating bills are rising, and the contractor suggests taking the opportunity to insulate the façade as well. The quote for your flat comes to €24,000.

    You may pass on part of this through the rent. How much depends on three things: what genuinely counts as modernisation, which limits apply and whether you meet the deadlines. A procedural error can delay the increase by months.

    Here you will find the calculation method reflecting current case law, the procedure with all the deadlines, and a realistic calculation of when modernisation pays for itself.

    01What counts as modernisation

    Not every building project counts as modernisation. The law distinguishes between two types. Maintenance means preserving or restoring the existing condition, such as repairing a leaking roof (§ 555a BGB). The landlord alone bears these costs. Modernisation means improving the flat (§ 555b BGB).

    Type of modernisationExampleCosts recoverable through rent under § 559?
    Saving energy in the flat (no. 1)Insulation, new windows with better thermal performanceyes
    New heating system (no. 1a)Heat pump, connection to district heatingwith funding under § 559e; also under § 559 if it saves final energy as well; special rules apply
    Primary energy or climate protection generally (no. 2)Photovoltaic system that does not supply the flatno
    Saving water (no. 3)Water-saving taps and fittingsyes
    Increasing practical utility (no. 4)Balcony, lift, better sound insulationyes
    Fibre-optic connection (no. 4a)First-time fibre-optic connectionyes, subject to conditions
    General living conditions (no. 5)Playground, bicycle storage roomyes
    Circumstances beyond the landlord’s control (no. 6)Statutory obligation to retrofityes
    New living space (no. 7)Loft conversionno, separate rent

    A project often involves both. Replacing old windows with new ones maintains and improves the property at the same time. Only the portion that goes beyond maintenance then counts. Determining this portion is the most difficult step.

    02The formula: 8% after deducting the maintenance share

    The calculation has four steps. It starts with the costs attributable to your flat. Where several flats are involved, allocate the costs appropriately, usually by floor area (§ 559(3) BGB).

    From building costs to the new rent
    1. 01
      Costs attributable to the flat

      Collect invoices and determine your flat’s share.

    2. 02
      Deduct the maintenance share

      Exclude what repairs would have cost anyway. Also deduct grants and interest savings from public loans (§ 559a BGB).

    3. 03
      Apply 8% per year

      Multiplying the remaining amount by 8% gives the increase in annual rent; dividing this by 12 gives the monthly increase.

    4. 04
      Check the cap

      A maximum of €3/m² over six years, or €2/m² if the previous rent was below €7/m² (§ 559(3a) BGB).

    In 2020, the Bundesgerichtshof tightened its approach to the maintenance share. Landlords must deduct a share even if the old component was still functioning, provided that a significant portion of its useful life had already elapsed (BGH, judgment of 17 June 2020, VIII ZR 81/19). The case concerned sixty-year-old flat entrance doors and staircase windows. The landlord had passed on the full costs and had to revise the calculation.

    In practice, many landlords calculate the share based on the elapsed useful life. For a window that has lasted 30 of the usual 40 years, three quarters of the replacement cost would have been due anyway. The law does not prescribe a fixed table. Have the specialist contractor confirm the share so that you can justify it in the declaration.

    Inspection of a bright rental flat
    AI-generated illustrative image

    03Procedure and deadlines

    Passing on the costs depends on following the procedure. If you fail to give notice, or give incorrect notice, you can still obtain the increase, but six months later.

    StepDeadline and contentLegal basis
    NoticeAt least three months before work begins, in text form: nature and scope, start date and duration, expected rent increase, future operating costs, information on the form and deadline for hardship objections§ 555c BGB
    Tenant’s hardship objectionBy the end of the month following receipt of the notice, in text form§ 555d(3) BGB
    Tenant’s special right to terminateAvailable after receipt of the notice, also until the end of the following month§ 555e BGB
    Obligation to permit the workThe tenant must permit the work unless it would cause unreasonable hardship§ 555d(1), (2) BGB
    Rent increase declarationAfter completion of the work, in text form, with a calculation and explanation of the costs and deductions§ 559b(1) BGB
    New rentFrom the beginning of the third month following receipt of the declaration, e.g. receipt on 10 July, new rent from 1 October§ 559b(2) BGB
    DelaySix months later if proper notice was not given or the increase is more than 10% above the amount announced§ 559b(2) BGB
    Termination following the increaseThe tenant may give notice to terminate by the end of the second month following receipt§ 561 BGB

    The court will only consider hardship grounds relating to the rent level, such as a very low income, if the tenant has communicated them in time (§ 559(5) BGB). There is no hardship assessment if the flat is merely being brought up to a generally customary standard or if the work results from circumstances beyond your control (§ 559(4) BGB). This exception does not apply to the installation of a heating system.

    04Worked example: windows and insulation

    Mehmet lets a 65 m² flat for €487.50 excluding service charges, or €7.50/m². The owners have the windows replaced and the façade insulated. His flat’s share of the costs is €24,000, including €9,000 for the windows. The windows are 30 years old and have a typical lifespan of 40 years. The façade’s render would have needed repairs costing €3,000 (the flat’s share) anyway. The name and figures are fictitious; the calculation is an example, not a forecast.

    From €24,000 in costs to the new rent
    Costs attributable to the flat€24,000
    Maintenance component for windows (30 out of 40 years × €9,000)−€6,750
    Maintenance component for façade (render repairs due anyway)−€3,000
    Modernisation costs eligible to be passed on€14,250
    8 % of this per year€1,140
    Monthly increase+€95.00
    Cap of €3/m² × 65 m²€195.00 (does not apply)
    Own calculation, as at 15 October 2026. No public funding assumed; grants would also have to be deducted under § 559a BGB.

    The rent rises from €487.50 to €582.50, or €8.96/m². That is a noticeable jump for the tenant. In return, they save some of their heating costs; how much depends on the building.

    And for Mehmet? He pays €24,000 and receives €1,140 more rent per year. It takes around 21 years to recover the total costs through the surcharge. For a fair calculation, however, only the modernisation component of €14,250 counts, because he would have had to spend the €9,750 on maintenance at some point anyway. On that basis, it takes around 12.5 years.

    The picture changes only slightly after tax. Assume Mehmet can deduct the €24,000 immediately as maintenance expenditure and has a taxable income of €60,000 (single). Under the 2026 income tax schedule, his income tax in the year of the work then falls from €14,233 to €5,971, saving him €8,262. He pays €442 in tax on the additional rent each year, leaving €698.

    What remains of €1,140 in additional annual rent
    Additional rent from the surcharge
    +€1,140
    Income tax on this
    −€442
    Remaining after tax
    +€698
    Taxable income of €60,000, single, 2026 tax schedule under § 32a EStG, excluding the solidarity surcharge and church tax.

    The surcharge alone therefore rarely makes modernisation a good investment. It covers part of the costs. The rest must be justified by other benefits: a flat that will still be easy to let in ten years, a better energy performance certificate, fewer repairs and a higher comparable rent when it is next let to a new tenant.

    Apartment buildings with a shared green courtyard
    AI-generated illustrative image

    05Simplified procedure, heating and heat pumps

    A simplified procedure is available for smaller projects (§ 559c BGB). It avoids disputes over the maintenance component, but has strict limits.

    RuleStandard procedureSimplified procedure
    Cost limitnoneno more than €10,000 before deductions, reduced by increases over the previous five years
    Maintenance componentassessed case by caseflat rate of 30 %
    Hardship objection to the rent levelpossibleexcluded, except when installing a heating system
    Further surchargesat any timebarred for five years, with a few exceptions
    Information requiredfull explanationreference to the simplified procedure in the advance notice and rent increase declaration

    If Mehmet had only had the windows replaced for €9,000, the simplified procedure would give him €9,000 × 70 % × 8 % = €504 per year, or €42 per month. The Federal Government intends to raise the limit to €20,000. As at 15 October 2026, this is only a draft bill (BT-Drs. 21/6807).

    Special rules apply to new heating systems. A heating system may increase the rent by no more than €0.50/m² over six years (§ 559 Abs. 3a BGB). If you use public funding, you can pass on 10 % of the costs under § 559e BGB after deducting the funding and a flat-rate maintenance component of 15 %. If funding is not granted despite the eligibility criteria being met, the route under § 559 remains available. Since 29 July 2026, § 559f BGB has also applied to heat pumps: the full surcharge is only available if a specialist contractor demonstrates a seasonal performance factor of at least 2.5. Exceptions include buildings constructed after 1996 or those that can be heated with a flow temperature of no more than 55 °C. Without this evidence, you may only take half of the costs into account.

    06Leasehold-style flat ownership: when the owners’ association renovates

    As the owner of a flat, you do not make decisions alone. Windows, the façade and the heating system are usually common property. The owners’ meeting approves the work, which is paid for from the maintenance reserve or through a special levy. You can still pass your share on to your tenant under § 559 BGB if the requirements are met.

    From our conversations
    „Is the maintenance reserve already funded? Who pays for renovations?“

    We often hear this question before someone buys a tenanted flat. Renovations are paid for by the owners’ association, either from the reserve or through a special levy. The landlord may then pass on the flat’s share of the modernisation component through the rent, but not the maintenance component. The reserve and meeting minutes show how well prepared an owners’ association is.

    The sequence matters. As the landlord, you send the advance notice to the tenant, even if the owners’ association is carrying out the work. Ask the managing agent to provide the schedule, cost breakdown and allocation between flats early on. Without these figures, you can neither give advance notice nor explain the increase. Our guide to owners’ meeting minutes explains how to check the reserve and resolutions before buying.

    The surcharge is more likely to be worthwhile if …
    • the work is due anyway and improves the flat’s energy efficiency
    • the current rent is well below the comparable rent and has room to rise
    • you have time to prepare a proper advance notice and cost breakdown
    Less likely if …
    • the tenancy agreement provides for stepped rent
    • the tenant is likely to have grounds for a hardship objection and you want to avoid a lengthy dispute
    • the flat is to be sold or used as your own home soon

    07Risks and limits

    The surcharge is subject to many conditions. If the declaration lacks a clear calculation or the deduction for maintenance, it can be challenged. The tenant can then reclaim overpaid rent. You should therefore keep quotations, invoices and the justification for the maintenance component carefully.

    A modernisation surcharge is excluded where a stepped rent applies (§ 557a Abs. 2 BGB). With an index-linked rent, it is only possible for work required by circumstances beyond your control, or for a new heating system under § 555b Nr. 1a (§ 557b Abs. 2 BGB). Check the tenancy agreement before factoring in the surcharge. Find out more in our guide to stepped rent.

    Consider the tenant too. An increase of €95 can create hardship for a household on a tight budget or lead the tenant to give notice. A two-month void period can easily cost more than the surcharge brings in over a year. Many landlords therefore voluntarily agree to a lower surcharge and retain a good tenant.

    FAQFrequently asked questions

    How much can I pass on through the rent after modernisation?

    8% of the costs incurred for the flat per year, after deducting the maintenance component and any subsidies (§§ 559, 559a BGB). The resulting rent increase must not exceed €3/m² over six years, or €2/m² if the rent is below €7/m².

    What is the maintenance component?

    The portion of the costs that would also have been incurred for a straightforward repair. It cannot be passed on through the rent. According to the Federal Court of Justice (BGH), it must also be deducted if the old building component was still functioning but had already used up a substantial part of its service life (VIII ZR 81/19).

    When must I give notice of modernisation works?

    At least three months before work begins, in text form, stating the nature and scope of the works, their start date and duration, the expected rent increase and future operating costs (§ 555c BGB). If no notice is given, the higher rent takes effect six months later.

    When does the higher rent take effect?

    From the beginning of the third month after the tenant receives the rent increase declaration. If the declaration is received in July, the new rent applies from October (§ 559b(2) BGB).

    Can the tenant refuse modernisation works?

    In principle, the tenant must allow them (§ 555d BGB). Exceptions apply where the works would cause hardship for the tenant or their family, which the tenant must report in good time. After receiving notice of the works, the tenant also has a special right to terminate the tenancy.

    What is the simplified procedure?

    For costs of up to €10,000, you can deduct a flat rate of 30% as the maintenance component without having to justify it individually (§ 559c BGB). In return, further modernisation rent increases are largely barred for five years, and you must specify the procedure in both the notice of works and the rent increase declaration.

    Can I include the full cost of a heat pump in the rent increase calculation?

    Since 29 July 2026, this has only been permitted if a specialist contractor demonstrates a seasonal performance factor of at least 2.5 or the building meets one of the exceptions, such as having been built after 1996. Otherwise, you may only include half of the costs (§ 559f BGB). Heating systems are also subject to a cap of €0.50/m² over six years.

    Do modernisation rent increases also apply to stepped or index-linked rents?

    Not for stepped rents. For index-linked rents, they apply only to measures arising from circumstances beyond the landlord’s control, such as statutory obligations, or to a new heating system.

    08Further reading

    09Sources

    • Sections 555a to 555e, 557a, 557b, 558, 559, 559a, 559b, 559c, 559e, 559f and 561 of the German Civil Code (BGB), gesetze-im-internet.de, accessed on 15 October 2026
    • Section 6(1), no. 1a and Section 32a of the German Income Tax Act (EStG), gesetze-im-internet.de, accessed on 15 October 2026
    • Federal Court of Justice (BGH), judgment of 17 June 2020, VIII ZR 81/19 (deduction of notional maintenance costs for building components that are still functional)
    • Act of 23 July 2026, Federal Law Gazette (BGBl.) 2026 I No. 226 (including Section 559f BGB, in force from 29 July 2026)
    • Deutscher Bundestag: Draft Act Amending Residential and Commercial Tenancy Law, Bundestag printed paper (BT-Drs.) 21/6807 of 1 July 2026; hearing before the Legal Affairs Committee on 14 October 2026
    • Keyword data: Semrush, Germany database, as at 15 October 2026

    Disclaimer: This guide provides general information and is not a substitute for legal or tax advice tailored to your individual circumstances. For larger-scale works, have the rent increase notice reviewed by a solicitor specialising in tenancy law and the tax treatment reviewed by your tax adviser.

    Written by
    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo

    Writes about Letting, Service charges (Nebenkosten), Tenancy law and Multi-family buildings.

    As a civil engineer, property investor and advisor with around 14 years of finance practice, Moe looks at buildings from a technical angle first. He writes about build quality, letting, running costs (Nebenkosten) and investments that hold up beyond the brochure.

    This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.

    Free · Instant · No sign-up

    Download this guide as a PDF

    The complete guide as a clean A4 file – with a cover page, all chapters and page numbers. Keep it on hand, read it offline, or go through it at your own pace during your consultation.

    • All chapters, tables and worked examples
    • Read offline – on your phone or printed out
    • Go through it at your own pace or pass it on
    • Free, no sign-up, no email required

    A4 format · 3,288 words · As of 15 October 2026

    Related guides

    All guides