Guide · Letting

    Replacement tenants: what landlords can do when tenants change

    Your tenant wants to leave early and already has a replacement tenant lined up. We explain when you must agree, what checks you can carry out and how to change tenants without a costly void period.


    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo
    15 October 202610 min read
    Replacement tenants in four figures
    0
    statutory obligation
    to accept a replacement tenant in the absence of special circumstances
    3 months
    notice period
    for tenants on an open-ended tenancy agreement
    €2,850
    in this example
    what three months of vacancy cost before tax
    €1,764
    after tax
    remains as a loss

    Your tenant calls. He has a job in another city and wants to move out in six weeks. A colleague would take over the flat immediately; she has already viewed it. Would that be all right?

    At this point, many landlords say yes too quickly or no too quickly. Either can cost money. An unchecked replacement tenant can become a problem later. Rejecting one without justification can mean you stop receiving rent altogether.

    Here you will find out when you must accept a replacement tenant, what checks you are allowed to carry out and why a new agreement is almost always better than taking over the old one. At the end, there is a process for changing tenants without an expensive void period.

    01When a replacement tenant matters at all

    Whether you need to consider a replacement tenant depends on the tenancy agreement. For most agreements, the question is quickly answered.

    Type of agreementWhen the tenant can leaveRole of the replacement tenant
    Open-ended, without a waiver of the right to terminatewith three months’ notice (§ 573c BGB)only if they want to leave in less than three months; optional for you
    With a waiver of the right to terminate, including stepped-rent agreementsonly once the waiver period ends, a maximum of four yearsimportant where there is a legitimate interest
    Fixed-term tenancy agreement (§ 575 BGB)only at the agreed end dateimportant where there is a legitimate interest
    Binding replacement-tenant clauseas soon as a suitable replacement tenant is availableyou must accept a suitable replacement tenant
    Non-binding replacement-tenant clauseas specified in the agreementthe tenant may propose someone; you are free to decide

    With a standard open-ended agreement, then, you are free to choose. The tenant pays until the end of the notice period. An earlier changeover is an offer you can accept if it suits you. The guide Notice periods in tenancy agreements explains exactly how the deadlines work.

    02When you must accept a replacement tenant

    Without a clause in the agreement, there is only one narrow exception. It is based on the principle of good faith (§ 242 BGB). Two conditions must be met together.

    First, the tenant must have a legitimate interest in moving out early. Under a legal ruling still cited today, their interest must very substantially outweigh your interest in continuing the agreement (OLG Karlsruhe, 25 March 1981, 3 REMiet 2/81). A nicer, larger or cheaper flat is not enough.

    Usually recognisedUsually insufficient
    relocation for work, including at the tenant’s own request (BGH, VIII ZR 247/14)a cheaper or nicer flat
    serious illness, moving into a care homereasons that were already foreseeable when the agreement was signed
    a growing family, if the flat becomes too smallonly a short time remaining on the agreement

    Second, the tenant must provide you with a suitable and acceptable replacement tenant who would take over the agreement on its existing terms (BGH, judgment of 22 January 2003, VIII ZR 244/02). The courts decide what counts as suitable on a case-by-case basis.

    Inspection of a bright rental flat
    AI-generated illustrative image

    03Checking the replacement tenant

    Even if you would have to agree, you are entitled to check the replacement tenant. You do not have to accept someone who clearly cannot afford the rent. You may request the same information as you would from any other applicant, but no more.

    Objective reason for rejectionNot a permissible reason
    income is insufficient to cover the rent, evidence of creditworthiness is missingorigin, religion, gender, age, sexual identity
    intended use differs from the agreement, for example commercial usea family with children where the flat is an appropriate size
    significantly more occupants than the flat can accommodatemere dislike unrelated to the tenancy
    a pet that requires your consent under the agreement and for which you withhold consent on objective groundsthe replacement tenant is friends with the existing tenant
    specific indications of disruption to peaceful coexistence in the building

    Discrimination on the grounds listed in the right-hand column is prohibited by, among other legislation, the General Equal Treatment Act. Since January 2026, new guidance from the data protection authorities has governed what you may ask applicants and require them to provide. You can find an overview in the guide Tenant selection and Schufa credit reports.

    Do not let yourself be rushed into a decision. Ask the tenant for the replacement tenant’s documents and set a reasonable timeframe, such as two weeks. This leaves time for checks, and the tenant knows where they stand.

    04A new agreement rather than taking over the existing one

    A replacement tenant can move in in one of two ways. If they take over the agreement, they step into the existing contract and all terms remain unchanged. All three parties must consent to this. With a new agreement, the old tenancy ends by mutual termination agreement, and you enter into a separate agreement with the replacement tenant.

    Taking over the existing agreementNew agreement
    Rentremains unchangedcan be reset; in areas subject to the rent brake, up to 10% above the reference rent or up to the previous rent
    Depositremains in place, with settlement between the old and new tenantsnew deposit; you settle the old one
    Condition of the flatdefects and wear and tear left by the previous tenant pass to the replacement tenanthandover with a written record; claims against the previous tenant are clear
    Old clausesremain, including invalid onesup-to-date agreement template
    Work involvedlittleslightly more

    For landlords, a new agreement is almost always the better choice. You can adjust the rent to the market, use an up-to-date agreement template and properly document the condition of the flat. A mutual termination agreement with the old tenant sets out when their agreement ends. Read more in the glossary entry Mutual tenancy termination agreement.

    Limits apply to the new rent in many cities. If the flat is in an area subject to the rent brake, the rent must not exceed the local reference rent by more than 10%, unless the previous rent was already higher (§§ 556d, 556e BGB). You can only rely on an exemption if you inform the new tenant of it in text form, without being asked, before the agreement is signed.

    05Worked example: vacancy versus a seamless changeover

    Tobias lets a flat for €750 in rent excluding service charges, plus €200 as an advance payment towards operating costs. His tenant gives the required notice. We compare two approaches. In Approach A, Tobias only starts arranging the new letting after the tenant has moved out, and the flat stands empty for three months. In Approach B, prospective tenants view the flat during the notice period, and a new tenant moves in the day after the previous tenant moves out, with a new agreement at €790. The name and figures are fictional; the calculation is an example, not a forecast.

    What three months of vacancy cost
    Approach A: empty for three monthsApproach B: seamless changeover
    Lost rent excluding service charges (3 × €750)−€2,250€0
    Operating costs Tobias pays himself (3 × €200)−€600€0
    Costs before tax−€2,850€0
    Tax saving because income falls+€1,086€0
    Costs after tax−€1,764€0
    Additional rent in the first year (12 × €40), after tax€0+€295
    Own calculation, as at 15 October 2026. Taxable income €60,000, single, 2026 tax schedule under § 32a EStG, excluding the solidarity surcharge and church tax. Excludes advertising, renovation and estate agent costs.

    Three months of vacancy cost Tobias €1,764 after tax. The tax office bears part of the cost because his rental income falls. He bears the larger share himself. Approach B brings him an additional €295 a year after tax because he was able to adjust the rent under the new agreement.

    Difference between the two approaches in the first year, after tax
    No vacancy
    +€1,764
    Higher rent under the new agreement
    +€295
    Advantage of Approach B
    +€2,059
    Assumptions as in the calculation above.

    A replacement tenant proposed by your tenant can therefore be worth real money, provided they are suitable. In that case, the replacement tenant is not a problem, but the most cost-effective way to re-let the property.

    Apartment buildings with a shared green courtyard
    AI-generated illustrative image

    06Changing tenants without a void period

    Most void periods between tenants arise because the search starts too late. With a clear process, the changeover can often be seamless.

    From notice of termination to a new tenant
    1. 01
      Confirm the notice

      Confirm receipt and the tenancy end date in writing. Ask whether the tenant would like to propose a replacement tenant.

    2. 02
      Review the rent

      Check the local comparable rent and rent cap, and set the new rent.

    3. 03
      Arrange viewings

      During the notice period, the tenant may not refuse viewings arranged by agreement. A right of access exists only where there is a specific reason, and re-letting is such a reason (BGH, VIII ZR 289/13).

    4. 04
      Place an advert

      including the energy performance certificate details that are mandatory in the advert.

    5. 05
      Screen applicants

      Obtain a tenant information form, proof of income and a credit report in accordance with data protection rules.

    6. 06
      Sign the agreement

      Use an up-to-date template for the new tenancy agreement and agree the deposit.

    7. 07
      Document the handover

      Record the move-out and move-in in a handover report, including meter readings and keys. Issue the accommodation provider’s confirmation for address registration within two weeks (§ 19 BMG).

    8. 08
      Settle the deposit

      Check any outstanding claims against the former tenant and repay the balance.

    The Property handover report guide explains what to include in the handover report. The Decorative repairs guide explains whether the outgoing tenant must redecorate, while the Tenancy deposit guide explains how to settle the deposit.

    07If the flat does stand empty

    If the flat is empty, your costs continue. For a flat you own within a jointly managed building, you pay the full service charge, including the share that the tenant would otherwise cover through operating costs. Heating, electricity for basic requirements and property tax come on top.

    For tax purposes, you can also deduct these costs, interest and depreciation as income-related expenses during a void period if you still intend to let the property. You must be able to demonstrate this intention, for example through adverts and viewing appointments. Find out more in the glossary entry on Intention to let.

    Property tax relief is available for longer void periods. If the normal gross income for a year is reduced by more than half and you are not responsible for this, 25% of the property tax is waived; if the income is lost entirely, 50% is waived (§ 34 GrStG). Submit your application to the municipality by 31 March of the following year (§ 35 GrStG). Not being responsible means, above all, that you can demonstrate efforts to find a tenant at a market rent. A three-month void period is not enough to qualify for the relief.

    You are more likely to accept a proposed replacement tenant if …
    • Their creditworthiness and documents are convincing
    • You can sign a new agreement with them on current terms
    • You would otherwise face a void period
    Less likely if …
    • Documents are missing or inconsistent
    • They only want to take over the old agreement with its outdated rent, and you are not obliged to allow this
    • You intend to sell, refurbish or use the flat yourself anyway

    08Risks and limitations

    A replacement tenant from the outgoing tenant’s circle of acquaintances is not automatically a good tenant. Screen them as carefully as any other applicant. If you accept a replacement tenant as a favour without obtaining documents, you have no basis to rely on if payment problems arise. The Serial rent defaulters guide explains what to do if rent payments stop.

    Conversely, a hasty rejection can prove expensive if the tenant is entitled to be released from the tenancy. Courts decide on a case-by-case basis whether a legitimate interest exists. If you are unsure, for example where there is a long waiver of the right to terminate and a difficult applicant, a brief consultation with a property owners’ association or a lawyer specialising in tenancy law is worthwhile.

    Taking over a tenancy agreement also has pitfalls. If the replacement tenant takes over the old agreement, they also take over its invalid clauses. The Tenancy agreements: which clauses are enforceable guide explains how to check clauses.

    FAQFrequently asked questions

    Does a landlord have to accept a replacement tenant?

    Generally, no. An obligation arises only if the agreement contains a binding replacement-tenant clause, or if the tenant is tied into the tenancy for a long period, has a legitimate interest in moving out and puts forward a suitable replacement tenant whom the landlord can reasonably be expected to accept (§ 242 BGB, BGH VIII ZR 244/02).

    How many replacement tenants must the tenant propose?

    The law does not specify a number. What matters is that at least one suitable replacement tenant whom the landlord can reasonably be expected to accept is willing to take over the agreement. Some courts require several candidates to be proposed so that the landlord has a choice.

    Can I reject a replacement tenant?

    Yes, on objective grounds, for example if their income is insufficient, documents are missing or the intended use is incompatible with the agreement. Grounds such as origin, religion or age are not permitted. If the tenant is entitled to be released from the agreement and you refuse without an objective reason, you risk losing the rent from the date on which the replacement tenant could have moved in.

    Can I charge a replacement tenant a higher rent?

    Yes, under a new agreement, subject to the rent brake where it applies. If the replacement tenant takes over the existing agreement, the current rent remains unchanged. A new agreement is therefore usually more advantageous for landlords.

    What is the difference between a binding and a non-binding replacement-tenant clause?

    Under a binding replacement-tenant clause, the tenant can leave early as soon as they put forward a suitable replacement tenant. Under a non-binding clause, they can only propose replacement tenants; you are free to decide.

    Does the tenant have to allow viewings?

    Yes, during the notice period, by arrangement and at reasonable times. The landlord has a right of access only where there is a specific reason, and re-letting the property is such a reason (BGH, VIII ZR 289/13).

    Can I get property tax back if the property is vacant?

    Partly. If the gross rental income for a year is reduced by more than half and you are not responsible for this, 25% of the tax is waived; if the income is lost entirely, 50% is waived (§ 34 GrStG). The application must reach the municipality by 31 March of the following year.

    Are costs incurred during a void period tax-deductible?

    Yes, if you still intend to let the property and can demonstrate this, for example through advertisements and viewings. In that case, service charges, interest and depreciation remain deductible income-related expenses.

    09Further reading

    10Sources

    • §§ 242, 535, 556d, 556e, 557a, 573c, 575 BGB, gesetze-im-internet.de, accessed on 15 October 2026
    • § 19 Federal Registration Act, gesetze-im-internet.de, accessed on 15 October 2026
    • §§ 34, 35 Property Tax Act, gesetze-im-internet.de, accessed on 15 October 2026
    • §§ 9, 32a EStG, gesetze-im-internet.de, accessed on 15 October 2026
    • BGH, judgment of 22 January 2003, VIII ZR 244/02 (replacement tenant under § 242 BGB)
    • BGH, judgment of 7 October 2015, VIII ZR 247/14 (legitimate interest in the case of a voluntary change of job)
    • BGH, VIII ZR 289/13 (2014, landlord’s right of access only where there is a specific reason)
    • OLG Karlsruhe, ruling on a point of law of 25 March 1981, 3 REMiet 2/81 (replacement tenant, balancing of interests)
    • Datenschutzkonferenz: Guidance on obtaining information forms from prospective tenants, Version 2.0, January 2026
    • Keyword data: Semrush, Germany database, as at 15 October 2026

    Disclaimer: This guide provides general information and is not a substitute for legal or tax advice on your individual circumstances. If there is a dispute over a replacement tenant, you should involve a lawyer specialising in tenancy law or your property owners’ association at an early stage.

    Written by
    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo

    Writes about Letting, Service charges (Nebenkosten), Tenancy law and Multi-family buildings.

    As a civil engineer, property investor and advisor with around 14 years of finance practice, Moe looks at buildings from a technical angle first. He writes about build quality, letting, running costs (Nebenkosten) and investments that hold up beyond the brochure.

    This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.

    Free · Instant · No sign-up

    Download this guide as a PDF

    The complete guide as a clean A4 file – with a cover page, all chapters and page numbers. Keep it on hand, read it offline, or go through it at your own pace during your consultation.

    • All chapters, tables and worked examples
    • Read offline – on your phone or printed out
    • Go through it at your own pace or pass it on
    • Free, no sign-up, no email required

    A4 format · 3,177 words · As of 15 October 2026

    Related guides

    All guides