Smoking in German Rentals: Landlord Rights and Costs
Understand smoking restrictions, Schönheitsreparaturen and neighbour complaints, with an illustrative cost comparison for landlords.
Illustrative opening scenario: After eight years, a tenant returns the keys. The walls are yellow, brown streaks mark the door frames and a smoke smell remains throughout the apartment. A simple coat of paint appears unlikely to solve everything.
Who pays? Could the landlord have prohibited smoking from the outset? Neither the amount smoked nor the visible condition alone decides the answer. The relevant questions are the contractual obligations and the work actually required. Germany’s Bundesgerichtshof, or BGH, distinguishes ordinary wear from damage requiring work beyond Schönheitsreparaturen, meaning cosmetic redecoration.
01What the BGH says about smoking
A tenant may use the apartment within the agreed contractual limits. Where no agreement prohibits or restricts smoking, deposits resulting from smoking are generally not a breach of contract. The BGH confirmed this on 28 June 2006 in VIII ZR 124/05. Under § 538 BGB, tenants are not responsible for deterioration caused by permitted contractual use.
On 5 March 2008, in VIII ZR 37/07, the court clarified the boundary: liability can arise where the deterioration cannot be remedied through Schönheitsreparaturen and requires more extensive repair work. How quickly the marks developed does not determine that distinction.
For a practical assessment, ask for a description of the underlying surface, the affected components and the treatment required. A contractor’s estimate should explain why ordinary redecoration would be insufficient. Photographs are useful, but they do not replace a professional assessment where the cause or appropriate remedy is disputed.
02Non-smoking clauses in the Mietvertrag
Landlords seeking a smoke-free apartment should discuss their expectations before the Mietvertrag, the tenancy agreement, is concluded. An answer in a tenant application is not a substitute for an effective contractual provision. Do not assume that an inaccurate answer automatically creates a termination right or damages claim without legal assessment.
A comprehensive smoking ban in a standard-form Mietvertrag carries a significant enforceability risk. Standard terms are subject particularly to § 307 BGB. A genuinely negotiated Individualvereinbarung is legally distinct. However, the smoking judgments cited here do not provide blanket approval for every possible non-smoking clause.
Consider clear Hausordnung provisions for communal areas separately; they do not automatically prohibit smoking inside the apartment. If a tenant continues genuinely non-contractual use after an Abmahnung, a formal warning, § 541 BGB permits an Unterlassungsklage seeking an order to stop that use. See the guide to Abmahnung of tenants.

03Smoke damage at move-out: redecoration or repair?
First establish whether the tenant validly assumed Schönheitsreparaturen and whether those works are actually due. Not every decorating clause is enforceable, and moving out does not automatically require complete redecoration. The guide to Schönheitsreparaturen explains the distinction. Next assess whether there is additional damage beyond ordinary decorating work.
| Condition | Possible classification | Consequence |
|---|---|---|
| Yellowed walls remedied by wallpapering or painting | Schönheitsreparaturen | Landlord pays unless a valid tenant obligation is due |
| Extra coats of paint or stain-blocking primer | Not automatic proof of damage | Assess the work and its legal classification |
| Discoloured paint on doors or radiators | May still be cosmetic redecoration | Do not automatically charge it as damage |
| Smoke-damaged plaster or flooring requiring repair | Potentially compensable damage | Prove cause, necessity and amount |
| Burn holes in flooring or a worktop | Damage rather than ordinary wear | Assess responsibility and appropriate compensation |
This table is guidance, not a final determination of an individual case. It reflects the BGH’s distinction and the restoration principle in § 249 BGB.
Even proven damage does not automatically justify charging the full price of a new component. Age, previous condition and any improvement resulting from replacement must be considered. For property damage, VAT forms part of monetary compensation only to the extent actually incurred.
At handover, record the condition, perceived odours, pre-existing defects and return of keys in the Übergabeprotokoll, the handover record. Obtain estimates promptly and avoid premature statements confirming that no further claims exist.
04Balconies, stairwells and neighbours
Smoking on a balcony is not an unrestricted right against neighbours. In its judgment of 16 January 2015, V ZR 110/14, the BGH explained that substantial smoke interference may justify allocated periods of use. Subjective sensitivity alone is not the test. The court did not establish universally applicable smoke-free hours.
Nor does this establish a right to terminate a tenancy simply because the tenant smokes. In VIII ZR 186/14, decided on 18 February 2015, the BGH criticised insufficient factual findings about smoke nuisance and referred the case back. The judgment is neither a general prohibition nor blanket permission to terminate. Significant interference and breaches of the duty to consider others require case-specific examination.
Where interference is significant, a proposed Mietminderung, or rent reduction, should also be professionally assessed. Generic percentages are not a reliable answer to a smoke dispute. The Mietminderung reference table provides further orientation.

05Worked example: tenant change after eight years
Illustrative assumptions, not market prices or offers: Fictional landlord Ms Albrecht lets a 65 m² apartment for monthly Kaltmiete of €650, excluding an additional €180 Betriebskostenvorauszahlung, an advance payment for operating costs. Ordinary redecoration is assumed to cost €2,600 and to be her responsibility.
The model adds €1,400 for special wall treatment, €1,100 for work on doors and radiators and €400 for odour treatment: €2,900 in total. These items are not legally recoverable merely because of their descriptions. In the reimbursement scenario, the model simply assumes that the tenant actually pays this amount after assessment or settlement.
Only the additional work is assumed to cause another month of vacancy. This creates €650 in missing Kaltmiete and an assumed €180 in actual costs remaining with the owner. The €180 happens to equal the previous advance payment in this example. A real calculation must establish actual expenses and savings in consumption; the advance payment does not prove the vacancy cost.
The comparison covers three situations. The reference case has no smoke-related extra work and no additional vacancy month. In the second case, only the €2,900 of additional work is reimbursed, not the vacancy consequences. In the third, no compensation is received, for example because evidence is inadequate or the tenant cannot pay. Whether further legal claims exist is outside the model.
| Item | No additional work | Additional work, reimbursement paid | Additional work, no reimbursement |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ordinary redecoration | −€2,600 | −€2,600 | −€2,600 |
| Additional work | €0 | −€2,900 | −€2,900 |
| Reimbursement received | €0 | +€2,900 | €0 |
| Missing Kaltmiete in additional month | €0 | −€650 | −€650 |
| Uncovered owner costs in additional month | €0 | −€180 | −€180 |
| Economic burden before tax | −€2,600 | −€3,430 | −€6,330 |
| Assumed reduction in taxable rental income compared with uninterrupted letting without renovation | −€2,600 | −€3,430 | −€6,330 |
| Modelled tax reduction at 35% | +€910 | +€1,200.50 | +€2,215.50 |
| Economic burden after tax | −€1,690 | −€2,229.50 | −€4,114.50 |
Editorial model calculation. Missing rent is not an expense. However, compared with otherwise identical letting that generates rent, taxable receipts are lower. The comparison therefore includes that effect. This is not a complete property cash-flow statement or a promise of an immediately available tax refund.
Under these assumptions, the additional vacancy still creates a burden even when the extra work is reimbursed. Without reimbursement, the economic disadvantage is greater. For your own planning, also calculate a scenario without any immediately usable tax reduction: contractor invoices have to be paid regardless of when tax relief becomes available.
Ask contractors to separate ordinary redecoration from alleged additional damage. That separation assists assessment but does not establish a claim by itself. Cause, necessary scope and legal classification remain essential.
06When a non-smoking agreement merits consideration
A contractual provision is particularly worth examining where you want to protect sensitive fittings or prevent recurring conflicts over use. It does not replace inspection of the building or a realistic redecoration reserve.
| Reason for closer assessment | Why a blanket approach is insufficient |
|---|---|
| Sensitive finishes or components that are expensive to repair | A general ban does not ensure reimbursement |
| Repeated complaints within the building | First establish smoke routes and actual causation |
| A desire for clear rules of use | The provision must be effective and genuinely agreed |
| Smoking takes place only on the balcony | Neighbours’ interests may still be affected |
| Comprehensive redecoration is already planned | A renovation plan does not resolve possible neighbour disputes |
Contractual scrutiny and mutual consideration remain relevant even where smoke-free letting is the objective.
07Risks and common mistakes
Treating a standard clause as an Individualvereinbarung. A separate attachment does not solve the issue. Examine the actual negotiation and scope of the provision.
Charging every yellowed surface as damage. The BGH requires a distinction from Schönheitsreparaturen. Painting components and applying additional coats are not automatically compensable damage beyond cosmetic work.
Assuming a timely payment demand is enough. An ordinary reminder does not suspend limitation. Negotiations and court measures have their own requirements.
Relying on the deposit as a guaranteed fallback. On 10 July 2024, in VIII ZR 184/23, the BGH permitted set-off of time-barred damages claims against a Barkaution under certain circumstances. This does not create a general right to deduct any late claim. The underlying claim, cash-deposit agreement and set-off requirements must be satisfied. Any amount exceeding the deposit is not secured by that mechanism. See Mietkaution: holding the deposit.
Terminating prematurely. Complaints require specific examination. Assessment of evidence was central to the BGH smoking case.
FAQFrequently asked questions
Can a landlord prohibit smoking inside a German apartment?
Without a valid restriction, smoking generally constitutes permitted contractual use. A comprehensive standard-form ban carries significant enforceability risks. A genuinely negotiated Individualvereinbarung requires separate assessment; a signed attachment alone is insufficient.
Who pays for smoke marks when a tenant moves out?
First establish whether Schönheitsreparaturen are sufficient and whether the tenant validly assumed that obligation. More extensive smoke-related damage may justify compensation. Stain-blocking primer, extra coats or discoloured radiators alone do not establish such damage.
Can smoking justify termination?
Being a smoker is not enough. Significant interference, breaches of duty, evidence and required preliminary steps need individual assessment. In VIII ZR 186/14, the BGH referred the case back because the factual findings were inadequate.
Can tenants smoke on their balconies?
Generally yes, but neighbours’ interests matter. Substantial smoke interference may justify allocated periods of use. The BGH did not prescribe universally applicable smoke-free hours.
What is the deadline for a landlord’s damage claim?
Claims for changes or deterioration generally become time-barred six months after recovery of possession under § 548 BGB. An ordinary payment demand does not suspend limitation. Negotiations or court proceedings may do so if their respective requirements are met.
Can landlords ask applicants whether they smoke?
Do not rely on an answer as creating an enforceable non-smoking obligation. The permissibility of the question and consequences of an inaccurate answer require legal assessment. A valid agreement governing use is a separate issue.
Can a neighbour reduce rent because of cigarette smoke?
Where interference is significant, a possible Mietminderung should be assessed individually. Actual circumstances matter, not a generic percentage. Record complaints and investigate possible smoke routes through the building.
08Further reading
- Schönheitsreparaturen
- Übergabeprotokoll: apartment handover
- Abmahnung of tenants
- Tenant selection and Schufa information
- Invalid clauses in the Mietvertrag
09Sources
- § 538 BGB – ordinary contractual wear, § 541 BGB – injunctive proceedings, § 548 BGB – limitation.
- § 305 BGB – standard contractual terms, § 307 BGB – review of terms.
- § 203 BGB – negotiations, § 204 BGB – legal proceedings, § 215 BGB – set-off, § 249 BGB – damages.
- BGH, 28 June 2006, VIII ZR 124/05 – judgment copy.
- BGH, 5 March 2008, VIII ZR 37/07 – published judgment.
- BGH, 18 March 2015, VIII ZR 242/13 – judgment text.
- BGH, 16 January 2015, V ZR 110/14 – original judgment.
- VIII ZR 186/14, 18 February 2015 – legal summary.
- BGH, 10 July 2024, VIII ZR 184/23 – judgment text.
- § 9 EStG – Werbungskosten. Model calculation with an assumed tax effect, not a calculation under § 32a EStG.
Editorial date: 28 October 2026. General information, not individual legal, tax or investment advice. All example costs and tax outcomes use expressly illustrative assumptions.

Writes about Letting, Service charges (Nebenkosten), Tenancy law and Multi-family buildings.
As a civil engineer, property investor and advisor with around 14 years of finance practice, Moe looks at buildings from a technical angle first. He writes about build quality, letting, running costs (Nebenkosten) and investments that hold up beyond the brochure.
This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.



