Guide · Taxes

    Total rental surplus forecast: when the tax office looks 30 years ahead

    An intention to generate income is generally presumed for ordinary long-term residential letting. In exceptional cases, a forecast determines expense deductibility. A simplified worked example illustrates the effects of full and partial expense deductibility.


    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo
    19 October 20268 min read
    Total rental surplus forecast [Totalüberschussprognose] at a glance
    30 years
    Usual forecast period
    for long-term letting where a forecast is required
    50% to below 66%
    Share of the local market rent
    in this band, the forecast determines full expense deductibility
    straight-line
    Building depreciation used in the example
    applied to the building value excluding land
    €1,176
    Illustrative annual tax effect at 58% rent
    full expense deduction rather than apportionment, at an assumed tax rate of 40%

    Perhaps your tax office has asked you for a forecast. Perhaps you let a property to your daughter at a low rent and have read that this can cause problems. Or your flat has been making losses for tax purposes for years, and you wonder whether that might eventually become an issue.

    For ordinary long-term residential letting, a tax loss alone is generally not a reason to require a total rental surplus forecast. In exceptional cases, however, a calculation covering the expected letting period determines whether income-related expenses [Werbungskosten] can be recognised in full, in part or not at all.

    01What the forecast is intended to establish

    For tax purposes, letting generally requires an intention to achieve a surplus over the long term. This means that income over the relevant letting period should exceed the expenses recognised for tax purposes. If that intention is absent, the activity is treated as lacking an income-generating intention [Liebhaberei]. Losses from that activity cannot then be recognised for tax purposes.

    No one can observe an intention directly. Where it is not already presumed, a forecast can help substantiate it with figures. It covers the taxable results of the relevant period, including past years where applicable, rather than cash flow or capital appreciation.

    02When the tax office requires a forecast

    For ordinary residential letting intended to continue over the long term, an intention to generate income is generally presumed. This also applies to initial losses caused by interest and depreciation. However, the level of rent and particular circumstances may require a separate assessment.

    SituationForecast required?
    Ordinary long-term residential letting, rent at least 66% of the local market rentgenerally no; the letting is treated as fully remunerated for tax purposes under section 21(2), sentence 2 of the German Income Tax Act [Einkommensteuergesetz]; exceptional circumstances still require separate assessment
    Rent at least 50% but below 66% of the local market rentyes, it determines whether expenses are fully deductible
    Rent below 50%no forecast is needed for the apportionment arising from the reduced rent; expenses are deductible only for the remunerated proportion under section 21(2), sentence 1 of the German Income Tax Act
    Holiday home also used by its owner, or with owner use reservedgenerally yes
    Letting intended from the outset to last for a limited period, followed by a planned sale or owner occupationgenerally yes, over the relevant shorter period; a fixed-term tenancy alone does not establish an intention to end letting altogether
    Prolonged vacancy without discernible efforts to find tenantsthe intention to let and actual efforts are examined; a forecast alone is insufficient
    Commercial property, undeveloped landindividual assessment of the intention to generate income; the presumption for ordinary long-term residential letting does not apply
    Particularly elaborate residential propertya separate assessment may be necessary, depending on the property's specific characteristics

    Investors letting an ordinary flat to unrelated tenants at market rent on a long-term basis generally do not need a forecast. If it is already intended at purchase that letting will end after a few years through sale or owner occupation, an assessment over the shorter period may be necessary. A fixed-term tenancy or a subsequent sale does not decide this question on its own.

    Reviewing a flat’s floor plan, purchase price and running costs
    AI-generated illustrative image

    03The components of the calculation

    An important basis for the tax assessment is the German Federal Ministry of Finance letter of 8 October 2004 on the intention to generate income from letting and leasing. The calculation involves more than adding up income and expenses: the period, depreciation and estimation rules must suit the particular letting arrangement. The main components are:

    • Period: usually 30 years from acquisition or construction where the corresponding intention to let exists. If letting begins after a period of owner occupation, that later starting point is relevant. Where letting is intended from the outset to be temporary, the relevant shorter period applies.
    • Income: expected rents, including charges passed on to tenants, estimated using previous results and sufficiently specific circumstances.
    • Income-related expenses: deductible interest, running costs, management, maintenance, German property tax [Grundsteuer] and other expenditure eligible for tax recognition. Owners' association charges [Hausgeld] are not deductible in their entirety. Contributions to the maintenance reserve [Erhaltungsrücklage] of a condominium owners' association [Wohnungseigentümergemeinschaft] are not immediately deductible when paid in. Only actual expenditure by the association may qualify, depending on its tax treatment; in some cases, relief is available only through depreciation. Costs already included in owners' association charges must not be counted again.
    • Depreciation: the example uses straight-line building depreciation [AfA] under section 7(4) of the German Income Tax Act. Land is not depreciated. The relevant factors are the building depreciation basis, the applicable rate and the remaining depreciation period. Special depreciation allowances and declining-balance depreciation from the annual tax calculation cannot simply be carried over into a long-term forecast. Ask your tax adviser to establish the forecasting method applicable to your circumstances.
    • No blanket inflation uplift: projected changes in income and costs must have an explainable basis. Agreed stepped rents or other sufficiently substantiated changes may be relevant. The applicable tax estimation rules and any required safety adjustments must also be taken into account.
    • No sale profit: a future profit on disposal does not count towards the rental surplus, even if it would be tax-free.

    Interest reduces the forecast surplus to the extent that it qualifies for tax recognition. With a repayment mortgage, interest costs change over time; capital repayments are not deductible expenses. A debt-free flat has no corresponding interest expense.

    04Worked example: 58% or 62% of the local market rent

    The Brandt family has a debt-free flat held in individual ownership within a jointly owned building. The local market rent is €1,000 a month, including recoverable operating costs. Their daughter moves in and pays €580 in total each month, or 58%; the comparison assumes €620, or 62%. The mother owns the flat. She is single. For the subsequent tax comparison, a uniform tax rate of 40% is assumed on the additional rental result as a simplification. The names are fictitious and the figures are a worked example, not a forecast for your circumstances.

    The calculation assumes constant income and costs. The annual costs of €3,000 in the example consist solely of expenditure actually incurred and eligible for tax recognition, excluding contributions to a maintenance reserve and any double counting. Additional repairs, vacancies and other expenditure are not included. The 30-year calculation initially illustrates the arithmetic alone, without tax safety adjustments. For the subsequent tax comparison, a negative forecast at 58% and a positive forecast at 62% are expressly assumed as two scenarios; these classifications do not follow from the simplified calculation alone.

    First, a look at the bank account. Depreciation is not a cash outflow.

    One year in the bank account, before tax
    58%62%
    Payments from the daughter€6,960€7,440
    Recoverable operating costs−€2,400−€2,400
    Non-recoverable costs−€600−€600
    Cash flow before tax+€3,960+€4,440
    Simplified illustrative calculation: constant payments and costs. No additional reserve contributions or other cash outgoings are included.

    Next comes the simplified calculation over 30 years. In addition to expenses, it assumes straight-line depreciation of 2% on a building depreciation basis of €200,000, giving €4,000 a year. It assumes that this rate applies to the example and that depreciation remains available throughout the full 30-year period. The depreciation basis excludes land.

    Total rental surplus forecast over 30 years
    58%62%
    Income over 30 years€208,800€223,200
    Expenses 30 × €3,000−€90,000−€90,000
    Depreciation 30 × €4,000−€120,000−€120,000
    Simplified calculated surplus−€1,200+€13,200
    Simplified illustrative calculation: no rent or cost increases, no sale profit and no tax safety adjustments, with straight-line depreciation under section 7(4) of the German Income Tax Act. The figures illustrate the arithmetic; the relevant forecasting rules also apply to the tax assessment.

    At 58%, this simplified calculation produces a deficit of €1,200. Only if the forecast prepared under the relevant tax rules is also negative would the reduced-rent letting be divided into a remunerated proportion of 58% and an unremunerated proportion. In that case, 58% of the expenses used here would be deductible: €7,000 × 58% = €4,060. The income would remain fully taxable.

    The following comparison places that scenario alongside one with a positive forecast at 62%. The assumed tax rate of 40% is used solely for illustration. Actual income tax depends on the progressive tax schedule in section 32a of the German Income Tax Act and your personal circumstances. Church tax and the solidarity surcharge are not included in this example.

    What this could mean for tax each year
    58%, negative forecast assumed62%, positive forecast assumed
    Income€6,960€7,440
    Deductible income-related expenses−€4,060−€7,000
    Result on the rental income tax return supplement [Anlage V]+€2,900+€440
    Assumed tax rate on the additional result40%40%
    Additional income tax, simplified€1,160€176
    Simplified illustrative calculation: each rental result is multiplied by an assumed uniform tax rate of 40%. The forecast outcomes are assumptions of the two scenarios. The table is not an individual calculation under the income tax schedule.

    Assuming a positive forecast for tax purposes at 62%, eligible expenses would be deductible in full. At the illustrative tax rate of 40%, €2,800 a year would remain after tax at 58%, compared with €4,264 at 62%. The daughter would pay €480 more, the mother would have €1,464 more, and the family as a whole would have €984 more. In this comparison, the difference arises from the higher rent and the assumed change from partial to full expense deductibility.

    Per year after tax – simplified illustrative calculation
    Rent at 58%, negative forecast assumed
    +€2,800
    Rent at 62%, positive forecast assumed
    +€4,264
    Cash flow after illustrative income tax at an assumed rate of 40%. If the forecast were also positive at 58%, full expense deductibility would produce a tax loss of €40 rather than a surplus of €2,900. Assuming the loss could be offset in full, this would mean tax relief of €16 rather than additional tax of €1,160 – a difference of €1,176.

    The example illustrates why forecasting methodology can be crucial where rent is at least 50% but below 66% of the local market rent. The calculated deficit of €1,200 over 30 years is small: even modest changes in assumptions or tax safety adjustments can change its sign. A deficit in the simplified calculation therefore does not automatically lead to a restriction on expense deductibility. Additional deductible borrowing costs would reduce the calculated surplus if all other assumptions remained unchanged. Ask your tax adviser to calculate the forecast relevant for tax purposes and your personal tax consequences.

    Receipts and documents for the tax assessment of a rental property
    AI-generated illustrative image

    05How to prepare a forecast

    Five steps to your own total rental surplus forecast
    1. 01
      Set the period

      Usually 30 years from acquisition or construction where the corresponding intention to let exists, or from a later start to letting where applicable. If letting is intended from the outset to end through sale or owner occupation, establish the relevant shorter period.

    2. 02
      Enter the income

      Use rent including charges passed on to tenants. Include future changes only with sufficiently specific justification, such as agreed stepped rents. Apply the relevant estimation rules and any required safety adjustments.

    3. 03
      Estimate expenses

      Establish actual expenditure eligible for tax recognition using past years and known developments. Break down owners' association charges, do not deduct reserve contributions immediately, and avoid overlaps with maintenance, property tax or management costs. Classify major known works separately according to their tax treatment.

    4. 04
      Take interest from the repayment schedule

      Enter each year's interest component from the repayment schedule and use reasoned assumptions after the fixed-rate period ends. Capital repayments are not deductible expenses.

    5. 05
      Establish depreciation

      Determine the building depreciation basis, applicable rate and remaining depreciation period. Straight-line building depreciation may notably be 2%, 2.5% or 3%, depending on completion date and the applicable conditions. Once depreciation is exhausted, this item drops out. Agree the depreciation treatment required for the forecast with your tax adviser.

    Submit the calculation to the tax office as a table with annual figures and explain your assumptions. A transparent explanation makes assessment easier but does not guarantee acceptance.

    Tool
    How much interest will you pay each year?

    The repayment schedule calculator can help you establish annual interest amounts using your financing assumptions and prepare them for the forecast.

    06Who needs to consider a forecast

    A forecast becomes important
    • You let to family members at least 50% but below 66% of the local market rent.
    • You have a holiday home that you sometimes use yourself or for which you reserve owner use.
    • From the outset, you plan to end letting after a few years through owner occupation or sale.
    A forecast is generally not required
    • You let an ordinary flat to unrelated tenants over the long term at market rent, without exceptional circumstances.
    • Your rent is at least 66% of the local market rent and this is ordinary long-term residential letting without a separate exception.
    • Your flat is briefly vacant between tenants, you are demonstrably looking actively for a tenant and you retain your intention to let over the long term.

    07Risks and limitations

    Evidence can be decisive. Where an intention to generate income is not already presumed, or actual efforts to let are in doubt, the relevant facts must be substantiated. A forecast based on unrealistic assumptions does not replace that evidence.

    Circumstances can change. If local market rent rises, a family rent previously at 66% may fall below the threshold. Reassess the comparison regularly and when relevant circumstances change. A local rent index [Mietspiegel] may provide a basis; the percentage thresholds also require the appropriate comparison of operating costs.

    The forecast is an estimate. Interest after the fixed-rate period, major repairs and lost rent cannot be predicted precisely over 30 years. The tax office may arrive at different figures. A small calculated surplus or deficit is particularly sensitive to changes in assumptions and the applicable estimation rules.

    Tax is not the objective. Setting rent just above a threshold does not, on its own, show whether a flat works as an investment. Vacancy, interest rate changes and maintenance remain commercial risks. When letting to family members, the tax requirements for the terms and actual implementation of the entire agreement must also be observed. Discuss the tax arrangements with your tax adviser and legal questions about the agreement with a solicitor qualified in German law.

    FAQFrequently asked questions

    What is a total rental surplus forecast?

    It is a calculation covering the entire expected letting period, usually 30 years. It assesses whether total rental income exceeds total income-related expenses. Where a forecast is required, it helps assess the intention to generate income; reasoned assumptions and the correct tax methodology are essential.

    When do I need to prepare a total rental surplus forecast?

    In particular, where residential rent is at least 50% but below 66% of local market rent. Holiday homes with owner use reserved, lettings intended from the outset to last for a limited period, and commercial properties may also require an individual forecast. Ordinary long-term residential letting at market rent generally does not.

    How long is the forecast period?

    Usually 30 years from acquisition or construction where the corresponding intention to let exists. If letting begins after owner occupation, the later starting point is relevant. Where letting is intended from the outset to be temporary, the relevant shorter period applies.

    Which depreciation is included in the forecast?

    The example uses straight-line building depreciation under section 7(4) of the German Income Tax Act and assumes a sufficient remaining depreciation period. Land is not depreciated. Depreciation amounts from the annual tax calculation cannot simply be carried over into the forecast. Ask your tax adviser to establish the depreciation treatment applicable to your circumstances.

    Does the profit from a later sale count?

    No. A future profit on disposal is not part of the forecast rental surplus, irrespective of whether the sale would be taxable or tax-free.

    What happens if the forecast is negative?

    Where rent is at least 50% but below 66% of local market rent, a negative forecast prepared under the relevant rules leads to apportionment. Expenses are then deductible only in the ratio of the rent paid to local market rent. In other cases, losses may be disallowed if there is no intention to generate income. Ask your tax adviser to assess the consequences for your circumstances.

    My flat has been making losses for years. Does that mean it lacks an income-generating intention?

    Not automatically. For ordinary long-term residential letting to unrelated tenants at market rent, an intention to generate income is generally presumed. Losses caused by interest and depreciation alone do not rebut that presumption; exceptional circumstances require separate assessment.

    08Further reading

    09Sources

    • Section 21 of the German Income Tax Act (subsection 2: thresholds of 50% and 66%)
    • Section 7 of the German Income Tax Act (subsection 4: straight-line building depreciation)
    • Federal Ministry of Finance letter of 8 October 2004 on the intention to generate income from letting and leasing
    • German Federal Fiscal Court [Bundesfinanzhof], judgment of 6 November 2001, IX R 97/00 (principles of the surplus forecast)
    • Section 32a of the German Income Tax Act (income tax schedule; the illustrative calculation instead uses an assumed uniform tax rate)
    • Assumptions used in the example: constant rents and costs over 30 years, straight-line depreciation of 2% on €200,000, and an assumed tax rate of 40% on the additional rental result

    Note: This guide provides general information and does not replace tax, legal or investment advice for individual circumstances. Discuss arrangements for letting to family members with a tax adviser before signing the agreement. The figures are simplified illustrative calculations; actual tax treatment depends on personal circumstances and the relevant forecasting rules.

    Written by
    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo

    Writes about Investment properties, Purchase decisions and Financial viability.

    Herbert has invested in property himself since 2023 and has worked in the property industry since 2024. His advice combines an investor’s perspective with clear explanations and an open assessment of opportunities and risks.

    This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.

    Free · Instant · No sign-up

    Download this guide as a PDF

    The complete guide as a clean A4 file – with a cover page, all chapters and page numbers. Keep it on hand, read it offline, or go through it at your own pace during your consultation.

    • All chapters, tables and worked examples
    • Read offline – on your phone or printed out
    • Go through it at your own pace or pass it on
    • Free, no sign-up, no email required

    A4 format · 3,459 words · As of 19 October 2026

    Related guides

    All guides