Subletting under section 553 BGB: what landlords must allow
When your tenant asks to sublet, you have less discretion than many landlords expect. Learn when you must agree, when you may refuse, what a subletting surcharge is and why a hasty refusal can prove costly.
Section 553 | Right to sublet part of a home | where a legitimate interest arises after the tenancy agreement 3 grounds | can justify refusal | the individual, overcrowding, unreasonable burden Section 540 | Special termination right if permission is refused | unless there is a serious reason relating to the proposed occupant −€5,960 | before tax in the example | additional cost of refusal under the stated assumptions
Your tenant writes to you. His partner has moved out, and the three-room flat is too expensive for him alone. He would like to sublet one room to a colleague. Your first reaction might be: I do not know this person, and I do not want to agree.
For part of a home, a tenant is entitled to your permission if the statutory requirements are met. An unjustified refusal can give rise to damages and a special right for the tenant to end the tenancy.
A tenant generally needs the landlord’s permission to let a third party use residential accommodation under section 540 of the German Civil Code [Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch, BGB]. If the tenant wants to sublet part of the home and a legitimate interest has arisen since the tenancy agreement was concluded, such as reducing housing costs or spending an extended period abroad, section 553 BGB generally provides a right to permission. Grounds for refusal include a serious reason relating to the proposed occupant, overcrowding or another unreasonable burden on the landlord. Permission may be made conditional on a reasonable rent increase only where the arrangement would otherwise be unreasonable for the landlord. If permission is refused, the tenant can terminate the tenancy using the special statutory right and notice period, unless there is a serious reason relating to the proposed occupant.
01Subletting: the legal distinction
The law distinguishes two situations. Section 540 BGB applies when the whole home is to be sublet. The tenant needs your permission; section 553 BGB does not provide an entitlement in this situation. If you refuse permission, section 540(1), sentence 2 BGB allows the tenant to terminate using the special statutory right and notice period, unless there is a serious reason relating to the proposed occupant. For residential accommodation, the statutory notice period generally requires notice to reach the landlord by the third working day of a calendar month for the tenancy to end at the end of the second following month. It is therefore not always exactly three months from receipt.
Section 553 BGB also applies when only part of the home is to be sublet. Here, the tenant is entitled to permission if a legitimate interest has arisen since the tenancy agreement was concluded and none of the grounds for refusal applies. The agreement cannot depart from this rule to the tenant’s disadvantage, under section 553(3) BGB. A standard contractual clause prohibiting all subletting does not change that.
Retaining ‘part’ of the home does not necessarily mean keeping a separate room. Under Federal Court of Justice case law, even a studio flat can be partly sublet if the tenant does not surrender possession entirely and retains an area for personal use. Merely leaving furniture behind is not a general guarantee of entitlement (BGH VIII ZR 109/22).
02When the tenant is entitled to permission
The legitimate interest must have arisen after the tenancy agreement was concluded. A reasonable explanation carrying more than trivial weight can be sufficient.
Typical situations include separation, a flatmate moving out, a job move to another city with an intention to return, time abroad or a wish to reduce housing costs. A financial interest in reducing housing costs can also support entitlement where the property is a second home; the requirements must be met in the individual case (BGH VIII ZR 88/22).
The tenant must, in particular, name the proposed subtenant, describe how much of the home will be made available and explain the legitimate interest that arose after the agreement was concluded. Permission granted for a named person applies to that person. A subsequent change of subtenant generally requires fresh permission.

03When you may refuse
The legislation lists three grounds for refusal in section 553(1), sentence 2 BGB. These should be distinguished from the scope of permission for tourist accommodation and the question of whether profit-oriented subletting establishes a legitimate interest in the first place. A wish to make a profit does not, on its own, establish entitlement to permission. This must be distinguished from reducing the tenant’s own housing costs.
| Ground or situation | What it means | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Serious reason relating to the individual | Accommodating the particular subtenant would be unreasonable for you | previous serious harm caused by that person or specific grounds to expect disruption to other residents |
| Overcrowding | Occupancy would be excessive, taking account of the size of the home and its occupants | four additional people in a two-room flat may warrant investigation; the number of rooms alone is not decisive |
| Other unreasonable burden | Particular circumstances make the arrangement unreasonable | commercial use that burdens the building and requires separate assessment |
| Tourists | Ordinary subletting permission does not automatically cover short-term letting to tourists | listings on holiday accommodation platforms (BGH VIII ZR 210/13) |
| Subletting for profit | Profit-making alone does not establish entitlement to permission under section 553 BGB | The tenant wants to sublet solely to make a profit rather than reduce their own housing costs |
General unease, the proposed subtenant’s origin or occupation alone, or a preference to relet the property are not sufficient grounds for refusal. An unjustified refusal can result in damages for lost subletting income where the other requirements for liability are met. The special termination right under section 540 BGB must also be considered.
Give written permission for a named person and a specified part of the home. Make clear that it does not cover letting to tourists. Do not rely on a blanket right to revoke permission: whether a subsequent serious reason justifies revocation or another measure depends on the individual circumstances. Consult a lawyer if you intend to refuse or revoke permission.
04Additional rent for subletting: when and how much?
If subletting would be reasonable for you only with an appropriate rent increase, you may make permission conditional on that increase under section 553(2) BGB. This is the subletting surcharge [Untermietzuschlag]. Additional occupants do not automatically entitle you to a surcharge.
A surcharge may be relevant where there is an actual additional burden that is not otherwise covered, for example under an inclusive rent arrangement. Allocating water and waste charges by floor area rather than by the number of occupants does not, by itself, establish that the landlord bears unrecovered additional costs. The tenancy agreement, cost-recovery provisions and actual burden are decisive. Costs already recovered through the operating cost statement must not also be treated as unrecovered additional costs. If additional costs are recovered in full, those costs alone cannot justify a surcharge.
The legislation does not specify a fixed amount. Base any proposal on a demonstrable additional burden and the requirements of section 553(2) BGB. An agreed rent increase should be recorded in writing. A lawyer specialising in tenancy law can advise you if the conditions or a reasonable amount are disputed.
05Subletting without permission
A tenant who sublets without the required permission breaches their contractual obligations. This may also apply where they would have been entitled to permission. Whether termination is justified depends on the seriousness of the breach and the circumstances, particularly whether the tenant requested permission in good time and the landlord unjustifiably refused it.
- Establish the facts Who is living in the property, since when, and how much of it are they using? Record lawfully obtained information from neighbours and advertisements.
- Write to the tenant Request information and give them an opportunity to apply for permission. Assess any entitlement to permission.
- Issue a formal warning Where the arrangement is unauthorised, request in writing that it end. Termination without notice must generally be preceded by an unsuccessful warning or a deadline to remedy the breach; statutory exceptions must be considered separately.
- Obtain legal advice on termination If the tenant continues the unauthorised arrangement, termination without notice under section 543(2), no. 2 BGB or ordinary termination under section 573(2), no. 1 BGB may be possible, depending on the circumstances. Continuation alone does not replace the statutory requirements. Ask a lawyer to assess any proposed termination.
Unauthorised commercial letting to tourists can constitute a serious breach. For guidance on structuring a warning, see our guide to formal warnings to tenants.
An important point for owners: the main tenant is responsible for fault on the part of the subtenant in using the property, even if you permitted the arrangement, under section 540(2) BGB. This is not liability for every loss regardless of fault. Your contractual counterparty remains the main tenant.

06Worked example: permission or refusal
Ms Lange lets an 80 m² flat for €900 a month excluding operating costs. Following a separation, her tenant wants to sublet one room. Ms Lange is considering refusing, although she has no serious reason to do so. Simplified illustrative calculation: the names are fictional, and the figures are assumptions, not a forecast.
Scenario A: she agrees and negotiates a €30 monthly subletting surcharge. The calculation expressly assumes that the requirements of section 553(2) BGB are met and that the amount is reasonable. Allocating water and waste charges by floor area is not sufficient justification on its own.
Scenario B: she refuses, and the tenant terminates under section 540 BGB with the statutory notice period. The simplified 12-month comparison includes three paid months before departure, four months without rent during refurbishment and reletting, and five months at a renewed rent of €900 excluding operating costs. Scenario B therefore includes eight paid months in total; scenario A includes 12 months at €930, including the surcharge. The precise notice and payment dates are assumed to fit this model.
Ms Lange has borrowed €240,000 at an assumed interest rate of 3.8%. This is an illustrative assumption, not a statement about current mortgage offers. The calculation uses simplified annual interest of €9,120 and principal repayments of 1.5% of the initial amount, or €3,600. It does not model interest reductions resulting from ongoing repayments; an actual repayment schedule may differ.
For the taxable result, the €1,100 of non-recoverable costs is assumed to consist entirely of expenditure actually incurred and deductible. It excludes payments into the maintenance reserve of a condominium owners’ association [Wohnungseigentümergemeinschaft, WEG]: contributions are not immediately deductible when paid. Only actual eligible expenditure can subsequently qualify, not the full service charge [Hausgeld]. The €800 of vacancy costs and €1,200 of refurbishment and reletting costs are also assumed to be immediately deductible. Annual tax depreciation [Absetzung für Abnutzung, AfA] of €4,800 is a separate illustrative assumption, not an amount derived from the loan balance. Principal repayments are not tax-deductible expenditure.
To illustrate the tax effect, the example applies an assumed constant tax effect of 35% to each rental loss. It assumes that the loss can be offset in full against other taxable income. This is a linear modelling assumption, not a calculation under the progressive income tax tariff in section 32a of the German Income Tax Act [Einkommensteuergesetz, EStG]. Church tax and the solidarity surcharge are excluded. Actual relief depends on factors including your income, the ability to offset losses and the tax treatment of expenditure. Discuss deductibility and your personal tax position with your tax adviser.
| A: permission + surcharge | B: refusal and special termination
Rent excluding operating costs, including any surcharge | €11,160 | €7,200 Interest (simplified: 3.8% of €240,000) | −€9,120 | −€9,120 Principal repayments (1.5% of the initial amount) | −€3,600 | −€3,600 Non-recoverable costs, excluding reserve contributions | −€1,100 | −€1,100 Operating costs during vacant months | €0 | −€800 Refurbishment and reletting | €0 | −€1,200 = Cash flow before tax | −€2,660 | −€8,620 ~ Taxable result with assumed depreciation of €4,800 | −€3,860 | −€9,820 ~ Modelled tax relief at an assumed tax effect of 35% | +€1,351 | +€3,437 = Cash flow after modelled tax relief | −€1,309 | −€5,183
Simplified illustrative calculation: our calculation using the stated assumptions. Tax relief equals 35% of each rental loss, assuming it can be offset in full against other taxable income; this is not an individual tax tariff calculation. Church tax and the solidarity surcharge are excluded.
Before tax, scenario B creates an additional cost of €5,960 in this comparison year. In the simplified tax model, additional relief of €2,086 offsets part of that amount. An additional cost of €3,874 remains after modelled tax relief. There may also be exposure to damages for lost subletting income; no such amount is included.
Lower rent including the forgone surcharge | -3960 | −€3,960 Vacancy and reletting costs | -2000 | −€2,000 Disadvantage before tax | -5960 | −€5,960
Simplified illustrative calculation: our calculation using the stated assumptions. The chart shows the additional cost before tax.
The calculation assumes four months without rent. This is a scenario assumption, not a claim about typical letting times in any particular location. Even with only one vacant month, scenario A would be more favourable before tax if all other assumptions remained unchanged. However, the outcome depends on factors including the permissible surcharge, the rent achieved on reletting, costs and the actual vacancy period. Any statutory entitlement to permission must be respected regardless of this financial comparison.
07When agreeing may be appropriate
- The tenant pays reliably and wants to reduce housing costs after a separation; the statutory requirements must be met.
- The tenant retains part of the home for personal use; a second home can also qualify, and retaining a separate room is not always necessary.
- The proposed subtenant is named and there are no specific concerns about them.
- The tenant wants to let to tourists by the day or week; this must be distinguished from ordinary subletting permission.
- The tenant’s sole objective in subletting is to make a profit; that alone does not establish entitlement to permission under section 553 BGB.
- There would be overcrowding or a specific serious reason relating to the proposed subtenant.
08Risks and common mistakes
A blanket refusal. An unjustified refusal can give rise to damages. The special termination right under section 540 BGB must be considered separately; an agreement excluding ordinary termination or a fixed-term tenancy does not automatically rule it out.
Unrestricted permission. General permission ‘to sublet’ without identifying the person or scope can create questions of interpretation. Be specific, without restricting a statutory entitlement through impermissible conditions.
Restrictions on changing residential use. Local permission requirements and prohibitions may apply to short-term tourist accommodation. Whether owners also face duties or fines depends on the relevant rules and their own involvement or breach of duty; knowledge alone does not automatically result in a fine. If necessary, ask a lawyer to clarify the obligations applying to your property.
Unpaid rent remains your risk. Your claim for the contractual rent remains against the main tenant, not automatically against the subtenant. If the main tenant moves out and leaves the subtenant behind, possession proceedings may need to address both. Financial reserves and careful tenant selection help manage rental default risk more generally.
A tenant is entitled to permission to sublet part of a home where a legitimate interest has arisen since the tenancy agreement was concluded and no statutory ground for refusal applies. An interest in reducing housing costs can be sufficient. Grounds for refusal are a serious reason relating to the individual, overcrowding and another unreasonable burden. Tourist letting requires separate assessment; profit-making alone does not establish entitlement to permission. In the example, refusal creates an additional pre-tax cost of €5,960 in the comparison year. After the simplified modelled tax relief, €3,874 remains. Respond specifically and in writing, and make a surcharge a condition only where section 553(2) BGB permits it.
FAQFrequently asked questions
What does section 553 BGB cover?
Section 553 of the German Civil Code (Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch, BGB) entitles a tenant to permission to let a third party use part of their home if a legitimate interest has arisen since the tenancy agreement was concluded and no statutory ground for refusal applies. The landlord may make permission conditional on a reasonable rent increase only if the arrangement would otherwise be unreasonable.
Can a landlord prohibit subletting?
Where an entitlement under section 553 BGB exists, grounds for refusal include a serious reason relating to the proposed occupant, overcrowding or another unreasonable burden. A blanket contractual prohibition does not remove the entitlement. Section 553 BGB does not provide an entitlement to sublet the whole home. If permission is refused, section 540 BGB may give the tenant a special termination right unless there is a serious reason relating to the proposed occupant.
How much additional rent can a landlord charge for subletting?
The legislation does not specify a fixed amount. A surcharge must be reasonable and requires that the arrangement would be unreasonable without a rent increase. An actual additional burden that is not otherwise covered may be relevant. Allocating costs by floor area does not, by itself, establish entitlement; additional costs already recovered must not also be treated as an uncovered burden.
What can I do if my tenant sublets without permission?
First establish the facts, request information and assess any entitlement to permission. A formal warning may be appropriate for an unauthorised arrangement. Whether the tenancy can subsequently be terminated depends on the statutory requirements and circumstances, including whether permission requested in good time was unjustifiably refused. Ask a lawyer to assess any proposed termination.
Can my tenant let the property through holiday accommodation platforms?
Ordinary subletting permission does not automatically cover short-term letting to tourists (BGH VIII ZR 210/13). Permission covering that use is required. Local restrictions on changing residential use and separate permission requirements may also apply.
Can a tenant make a profit from subletting?
Sharing costs can establish a legitimate interest where the statutory requirements are met. A wish to make a profit does not, on its own, establish entitlement to permission under section 553 BGB. Whether a particular arrangement is permissible depends on factors including the permission granted, the actual use and applicable rent regulation. If necessary, ask a lawyer to assess the proposed arrangement.
Is the tenant liable for damage caused by the subtenant?
The main tenant is responsible for fault on the part of the subtenant in using the property, even if the landlord permitted the arrangement, under section 540(2) BGB. This does not mean liability for every loss regardless of fault.
09Further reading
- Landlords’ rights and obligations
- Formal warnings to tenants
- Invalid clauses in tenancy agreements
- Tenant selection and credit information
- Glossary: subletting
10Sources
- Section 540 BGB and section 553 BGB (use by third parties and subletting part of a home)
- Section 543 BGB and section 573 BGB (termination)
- Federal Court of Justice, judgment of 13 September 2023, VIII ZR 109/22 (partial subletting and studio flats)
- Federal Court of Justice, judgment of 27 September 2023, VIII ZR 88/22 (legitimate interest and second homes)
- Federal Court of Justice, judgment of 8 January 2014, VIII ZR 210/13 (tourists), via dejure.org
- Section 32a EStG (income tax tariff)
- Worked example: our calculation using the stated assumptions; simplified tax model with a constant tax effect of 35% rather than an individual tax tariff calculation
This guide provides general information and does not replace individual legal, tax or investment advice. The amounts in the worked example are based on assumptions and are not a forecast. Consult a lawyer or tax adviser for an assessment of your individual legal and tax position.

Writes about Investment properties, Purchase decisions and Financial viability.
Herbert has invested in property himself since 2023 and has worked in the property industry since 2024. His advice combines an investor’s perspective with clear explanations and an open assessment of opportunities and risks.
This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.



