Minor repairs clauses: what tenants pay and the limits
A valid minor repairs clause can save landlords certain costs. We explain limits and common mistakes, then compare an illustrative year with and without a valid clause.
A roller shutter strap snaps, a tap drips or a light switch comes loose. Your tenant calls, and you wonder who pays the €85 bill. For ordinary wear and tear, you generally bear the cost unless there is a valid agreement transferring it to the tenant.
A minor repairs clause [Kleinreparaturklausel] can make the tenant responsible for certain costs. However, its scope must be narrow. An excessively broad clause may be invalid in its entirety. Older tenancy agreements therefore also deserve a closer look.
01What counts as a minor repair
The landlord must keep the flat fit for use throughout the tenancy (section 535(1) of the German Civil Code). The tenant is not responsible for deterioration caused by ordinary residential use (section 538). Without a valid specific agreement, the landlord therefore generally pays for repairs arising from wear and tear.
Here, a minor repair means a small repair to a component subject to the tenant’s frequent and direct use. A standard-form agreement can transfer such costs only within narrow limits. One of the fundamental decisions on this subject is the Federal Court of Justice judgment of 7 June 1989 (VIII ZR 91/88).
If the tenant causes damage through fault, for example by using something improperly, they may be liable independently of any minor repairs clause. The clause, by contrast, concerns ordinary wear and tear.
02The four conditions for a valid clause
Standard-form tenancy agreements are generally subject to the rules governing standard terms and must not place the tenant at an unreasonable disadvantage (section 307 of the German Civil Code). The following four requirements are particularly important for a minor repairs clause. The wording as a whole remains decisive.
- 01Only components subject to frequent and direct use
The clause may cover relevant controls on water, electrical and gas fittings, heating and cooking equipment, and window, door and shutter fastening mechanisms. It does not cover every component of these installations. Concealed pipes, the roof and the central heating equipment in the basement are excluded.
- 02A maximum amount per repair
The clause must set a reasonable individual limit. The example uses €100, including travel, labour, materials and VAT. There is no statutory euro limit.
- 03An annual limit
There must be a reasonable ceiling on the combined cost of minor repairs in a year. The example uses 6% of annual rent excluding service charges. A percentage-based annual limit does not make the clause valid regardless of its other provisions.
- 04Costs only, not a duty to repair
The tenant may be required to bear eligible costs. A standard-form obligation to arrange or carry out repairs is impermissible (Federal Court of Justice, judgment of 6 May 1992, VIII ZR 129/91).
If an essential requirement is missing or the financial burden is unreasonable, the entire minor repairs clause may be invalid. An impermissible limit is not simply reduced to an acceptable amount (section 306 of the German Civil Code). This reflects the prohibition on preserving an invalid standard term by reducing its scope. An individual limit of, for example, €200 found to be unreasonable would therefore not automatically remain effective as a €100 limit. Where necessary, ask a German lawyer to assess the reasonableness of the limits and the wording as a whole.

03What happens if a repair costs more
If a repair costs €160 and the validly agreed individual limit is €100, the tenant does not pay €100 for ordinary wear and tear. They pay nothing under this clause. The repair falls outside its agreed scope, and the landlord bears the whole cost.
A standard-form requirement to contribute up to the individual limit even towards more expensive repairs undermines that restriction and jeopardises the clause’s validity.
The annual limit is equally important. Once the example’s €504 has been reached in a year, you pay for any further minor repairs arising from wear and tear yourself. Even the final reimbursement must not exceed the remaining annual allowance. Keep a simple list for each flat recording the date, component and amount.
04Sample wording and the process when a fault occurs
The following sample wording illustrates how the four requirements can be combined. The limits of €100 and 6% are illustrative assumptions. Ask a German lawyer to assess the limits and precise scope for your tenancy agreement.
The tenant shall bear the cost of minor maintenance exclusively to parts of the flat subject to their frequent and direct use, particularly the relevant controls on electrical, water and gas fittings, heating and cooking equipment, window and door fastenings, and fastening mechanisms for window shutters and roller shutters, provided that the total cost of each repair, including travel, labour, materials and VAT, does not exceed €100. The annual total shall be limited to 6% of annual rent excluding service charges. If a repair exceeds the individual limit, this clause shall not require a partial contribution. The annual maximum must not be exceeded, including by the final reimbursement. Responsibility for commissioning and carrying out the repair shall remain with the landlord.
The final sentence matters. It makes clear that you commission the contractor and the tenant, where applicable, only reimburses the cost. This also allows you to retain control over the quality of the work.
In practice, a minor repair involves five steps:
- The tenant reports the fault.
- You instruct a contractor or your property manager.
- You check whether the specific component repaired falls within the clause and whether the total bill is within the individual limit.
- You check the annual limit against your records.
- Where reimbursement is due, you forward the invoice to the tenant with a brief explanation; the amount claimed must not exceed the remaining annual allowance.

05Worked example: a year with and without a valid clause
Mr Brandt lets a 60 m² flat for €700 a month excluding service charges, or €8,400 a year. In this example, his tenancy agreement contains a clause assumed to be valid, with a €100 individual limit and an annual limit of 6%. That is €504 a year. Mr Brandt is fictitious; the simplified illustrative calculation is not a forecast.
Five repairs arise during the year: a tap handle (€85), a roller shutter strap (€75), a flush button (€95), a thermostatic radiator valve head (€60) and a radiator valve (€160). For taps and cisterns, the specific component repaired matters: frequent use of a fitting does not by itself make every component eligible under a minor repairs clause. Internal cartridges or valves therefore require a different assessment from directly operated handles or buttons. All amounts are assumed complete bills including VAT, not market-price claims. The first four repairs are assumed to qualify for reimbursement under the particular agreement.
| Amount | Tenant | Landlord | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tap handle | €85 | €85 | €0 |
| Roller shutter strap | €75 | €75 | €0 |
| Flush button | €95 | €95 | €0 |
| Thermostatic radiator valve head | €60 | €60 | €0 |
| Radiator valve (over €100) | €160 | €0 | €160 |
| Total | €475 | €315 | €160 |
If the clause were invalid, for example because it lacked an annual limit, Mr Brandt would bear the full €475. The difference in the example is €315 for the year. What does that mean for the flat’s overall finances?
He has borrowed €170,000 at an assumed interest rate of 3.8% and repays principal equal to 1.5% of the initial loan in the simplified annual model. Both percentages are applied to €170,000; the model does not account for interest falling as principal is repaid during the year. These figures do not describe a current mortgage offer. First, consider cash flow before tax.
For the tax model, all €1,000 of costs not recoverable through service charges are assumed to be deductible expenditure in the same year; this includes the €160 radiator valve repair. Costs and tenant reimbursements arise in the same year in the example and are shown on a net basis. Contributions to the owners’ association [Wohnungseigentümergemeinschaft] maintenance reserve are not included in the example. Principal repayments reduce cash flow but are not deductible expenses against rental income.
As a separate modelling assumption, the depreciable building basis is €170,000. At an assumed straight-line depreciation rate of 2%, annual depreciation [AfA] is €3,400. The rate that actually applies depends in particular on the building and the relevant tax requirements.
The tax effect is modelled using a simplified uniform rate of 40% applied to the tax loss. The model assumes that the losses are recognised for tax purposes and can be offset against sufficient other positive income in the same year. The individual income tax tariff, church tax and solidarity surcharge are not modelled. Your German tax adviser can determine your actual tax position.
| Valid clause | Invalid clause | |
|---|---|---|
| Rent excluding service charges | €8,400 | €8,400 |
| Interest (3.8% of €170,000) | −€6,460 | −€6,460 |
| Principal repayments (1.5% of €170,000) | −€2,550 | −€2,550 |
| Costs not recoverable through service charges | −€1,000 | −€1,000 |
| Additional minor repair costs borne by the landlord | €0 | −€315 |
| Cash flow before tax | −€1,610 | −€1,925 |
| Taxable rental result with assumed depreciation of €3,400 | −€2,460 | −€2,775 |
| Tax relief at an assumed tax effect of 40% | +€984 | +€1,110 |
| Cash flow after tax in the simplified model | −€626 | −€815 |
Repair costs economically borne by the landlord may qualify as deductible expenses against rental income where they are classified as immediately deductible maintenance expenditure. If the tenant reimburses costs initially paid by the landlord, the expense and reimbursement must be considered together for tax purposes; an unreduced tax benefit must not be counted on top of the reimbursement. Discuss the tax treatment with your German tax adviser.
At an assumed tax effect of 40%, the additional €315 repair costs produce additional tax relief of €126. This leaves an additional after-tax cost of €189 in the example. Over ten identical years, the arithmetic would produce €1,890 after tax and €3,150 before tax. That assumes unchanged repairs and tax effects and is not a forecast.
Whether this amount is material to an investment depends on its overall costs and income. Repairs will not necessarily occur at the same level every year. A valid clause can transfer certain costs, but it does not replace maintenance planning or legal advice on your tenancy agreement.
06Who the clause may suit
- You are entering into a new tenancy agreement and can determine its terms.
- The flat has many directly operated components, such as shutter straps, tap handles and thermostatic radiator valve heads.
- You or your property manager keep a repair record for each flat.
- You are buying a tenanted flat with an existing agreement. A clause can then only be changed with the tenant’s consent.
- The flat is new and may have little wear and tear. Savings could therefore be limited.
- You want the tenant to carry out repairs themselves. Such a standard-form obligation is impermissible.
07Risks and common mistakes
Excessive limits. The individual and annual limits must reasonably restrict the tenant’s financial burden. Simply including two maximum amounts in the agreement is not enough. Even a clause specifying precise figures can place the tenant at an unreasonable disadvantage and therefore be invalid. Ask a German lawyer to assess the limits in the context of the agreement as a whole.
No annual limit. A standard-form minor repairs clause without an annual ceiling is invalid, regardless of how low the individual limit is.
The wrong components. A clause covering concealed pipes, damage to glazing or the heating system as a whole goes beyond components subject to frequent and direct use. With taps and cisterns too, the specific component being repaired matters.
Purchased flat, existing agreement. A buyer of a tenanted flat generally takes over the existing tenancy agreement (section 566 of the German Civil Code). Before buying, check its repair provisions and budget for all minor repairs arising from wear and tear if the clause is invalid. Read more in the guide to buying a tenanted flat.
Maintenance remains your responsibility. The clause covers only small repairs. Larger repairs, refurbishment and contributions to the owners’ association maintenance reserve generally remain the owner’s responsibility. Reserve contributions are not immediately tax-deductible. Only actual expenditure that qualifies for tax relief may be taken into account; the entire owners’ service charge [Hausgeld] is not deductible as a blanket amount either. The guide to maintenance costs explains budgeting considerations. Discuss the tax treatment of individual expenses with your German tax adviser.
FAQFrequently asked questions
What counts as a minor repair in a rented flat?
Small repairs to components subject to the tenant’s frequent and direct use may qualify, such as light switches, window and door handles, roller shutter straps or thermostatic radiator valve heads. For taps and cisterns, the specific component repaired matters; internal cartridges or valves are not covered merely because the fitting as a whole is used frequently. Concealed pipes, the roof and central heating equipment are excluded.
How high can the limits in a minor repairs clause be?
There is no statutory maximum. A standard-form clause needs reasonable individual and annual limits. The simplified example uses €100 per repair and 6% of annual rent excluding service charges as assumptions, not universally permissible limits. A reasonable financial burden and the wording as a whole are decisive. Where necessary, ask a German lawyer to assess your clause.
Must the tenant pay if the repair exceeds the limit?
Not for ordinary wear and tear: if the total repair bill exceeds the validly agreed individual limit, the landlord bears the full amount. A standard-form requirement for a partial contribution up to the limit undermines this restriction. Possible liability for damage caused through fault must be assessed separately.
Is a minor repairs clause valid without an annual limit?
A standard-form minor repairs clause without an annual ceiling is invalid. The landlord then generally bears repair costs arising from wear and tear; tenant liability for damage caused through fault is unaffected.
Can the landlord require the tenant to carry out repairs?
A standard-form minor repairs clause may only provide for a limited contribution towards costs. It must not require the tenant to commission a contractor or carry out the repair themselves.
Can I add the clause to an existing tenancy agreement?
Only with the tenant’s consent, because this changes the agreement. When a new tenant moves in, you can include a legally permissible clause in the new agreement.
Are minor repairs tax-deductible for the landlord?
Repair costs economically borne by the landlord may be deductible against rental income where they qualify as immediately deductible maintenance expenditure. Tenant reimbursements must also be accounted for; an unreduced tax benefit must not be counted on top. Maintenance reserve contributions are not immediately deductible: only actual expenditure that qualifies for tax relief may be taken into account. Discuss the treatment of your individual circumstances with your German tax adviser.
08Further reading
- Invalid terms in tenancy agreements
- Decorative repairs
- Property maintenance costs
- Deductible expenses for rental property
- Template: tenancy agreement
09Sources
- Section 535 of the German Civil Code and section 538 (maintenance obligations and ordinary contractual use)
- Section 306 of the German Civil Code and section 307 (consequences of invalid terms and scrutiny of contractual terms)
- Federal Court of Justice, judgment of 7 June 1989, VIII ZR 91/88 (minor repairs clauses and limits)
- Federal Court of Justice, judgment of 6 May 1992, VIII ZR 129/91 (no tenant obligation to carry out repairs under a standard-form clause)
- Section 32a of the German Income Tax Act (statutory income tax tariff; the worked example instead uses an assumed tax effect of 40%)
- Illustrative calculations: own calculations using the assumptions stated in the article
This guide provides general information and does not replace legal, tax or investment advice for an individual case. The figures are simplified examples, not forecasts or promises of returns. Consult a German lawyer about the terms of your tenancy agreement and a German tax adviser about the tax implications.

Writes about Letting, Service charges (Nebenkosten), Tenancy law and Multi-family buildings.
As a civil engineer, property investor and advisor with around 14 years of finance practice, Moe looks at buildings from a technical angle first. He writes about build quality, letting, running costs (Nebenkosten) and investments that hold up beyond the brochure.
This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.



