Tenant Will Not Leave: Protect Your Rights and Cash Flow
A practical guide for private residential property investors in Germany
01Tenant will not leave: protect your rights and cash flow
An ended tenancy does not necessarily mean an available apartment. For a German rental investment, separate three tasks: recovering possession, pursuing payment and funding ongoing expenses.

02Act promptly after termination
Under section 545 BGB, continued occupation can renew the tenancy indefinitely. Your two-week objection period starts when you learn of that occupation. Timely receipt matters, not simply posting a letter.
State clearly that you oppose continuation beyond the termination date. Keep evidence of the wording and delivery. Have any contractual exclusion or earlier objection checked rather than assuming it works.
Also check the termination notice, service and possible continuation rights. Giving notice does not itself establish valid termination; see our notice-period guide. Statutory termination and hardship protections appear in the BGB.
03Occupation compensation and additional losses
When possession is withheld despite your demand for its return, section 546a BGB permits compensation based on the agreed rent or the customary local rent for comparable properties. An enforceable claim is not the same as cash received.
To claim higher compensation under section 546a(1) BGB, substantiate the customary local rent for comparable homes. This is not the same as a proposed rent increase under section 558 BGB.
Operating-cost advances require separate reconciliation. Once the account is due, the resulting balance generally replaces a claim for advances. Avoid double counting.
A replacement tenant’s hotel, storage or overlapping rent may create liability; a delayed sale can add financial exposure. Allow realistic handover time. Neither a buffer nor a contract clause automatically eliminates liability.
Recovery from the former tenant is restricted. Section 571(1) BGB generally requires responsibility and an equitable assessment; those restrictions do not apply where the tenant terminated. Paragraph 2 is separate: a court-granted eviction period excludes additional damages from tenancy end until that period expires. Occupation compensation is a distinct claim.
04Agreement, proceedings and enforcement
Consider a documented agreement when payments continue and a definite departure looks realistic. Seek early legal assessment of proceedings when payments stop, communication fails or another tenant is waiting.
Action checklist
- [ ] Document termination, objection and delivery.
- [ ] Identify occupants and their possession status.
- [ ] Record the departure date, compensation and key handover.
- [ ] Maintain an arrears schedule and supporting documents.
- [ ] Pursue an enforceable eviction title if possession remains withheld.
- [ ] Budget for bailiff advances and continuing expenses.
A private promise to leave is not an enforcement title. Independent co-possessors, potentially including subtenants or partners, may require a title against them. Not every occupant has that status; possession and section 750 ZPO matter.
Where applicable, section 721 ZPO allows an eviction period totalling up to one year—not a one-year limit on the entire case. Section 794a addresses eviction settlements; exceptional enforcement protection under section 765a may also apply.
A limited enforcement instruction under section 885a ZPO can reduce initial removal work but leaves storage and disposal responsibilities with you. Interim eviction under section 940a is exceptional, including concrete danger to life and specified third-party possession or security-order cases.

05Worked example: six months without possession
Every figure is an assumption, not a market quotation or forecast. Assume a 75 m² apartment, previous net rent of €750, supportable new-letting rent of €950 and monthly operating costs of €200. Paying occupants reimburse operating costs in full.
The loan remains €220,000 throughout the six months. Assumed annual interest of 3.8% produces exactly €4,180. Principal repayment, calculated at 1.5% annually, occurs at period-end: €1,650. Other non-recoverable expenditure totals €600. Only scenario C includes a €2,500 legal and court advance.
Cash flow before tax
| Six-month totals | A: €950 paid | B: €750 paid | C: nothing paid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net compensation received | €5,700 | €4,500 | €0 |
| Operating charges received | €1,200 | €1,200 | €0 |
| Operating costs paid | −€1,200 | −€1,200 | −€1,200 |
| Interest | −€4,180 | −€4,180 | −€4,180 |
| Principal repayment | −€1,650 | −€1,650 | −€1,650 |
| Other expenditure | −€600 | −€600 | −€600 |
| Legal proceedings | €0 | €0 | −€2,500 |
| Cash flow | −€730 | −€1,930 | −€10,130 |
The cash-flow difference between A and C is €9,400. Enforcement, repairs and later reimbursements are excluded. Any additional claim in B generates liquidity only when collected.
Separate tax illustration
Assume continuing rental intent, full deductibility of expenditure except principal, and €2,400 of allowable six-month depreciation. Rental-related interest and expenses may be deductible; principal repayment is not such an expense. Depreciation is non-cash. Relevant provisions are sections 7, 9 and 21 EStG.
| Model calculation | A | B | C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Taxable rental result | −€1,480 | −€2,680 | −€10,880 |
| Assumed relief at constant 35% | €518 | €938 | €3,808 |
| Cash flow plus assumed relief | −€212 | −€992 | −€6,322 |
The 35% assumption is not a calculated income-tax rate. Full loss utilisation is assumed, not promised; actual relief and timing depend on individual circumstances. For private rental income, later receipts generally enter the year received, subject to statutory exceptions.
06Risks and conclusion
Size reserves around actual outgoings, not anticipated refunds. For rent-loss insurance, check coverage, exclusions and waiting periods explicitly. Do not assume reimbursement.
Protect deadlines, avoid self-help and compare agreement with litigation using realistic dates. The investment question is whether you can fund debt service and operating costs without incoming payments.
FAQFrequently asked questions
When does the two-week period under section 545 BGB start?
For landlords, it starts upon learning of continued occupation. Ensure timely receipt of your objection and have any contractual exclusion checked.
Can I change the locks after the tenancy ends?
Not unilaterally while the tenant retains possession. Without voluntary surrender, use the lawful enforcement process through a bailiff.
Can occupation compensation exceed the previous rent?
Where section 546a BGB applies, compensation may reflect customary new-letting rent for comparable homes. You must be able to substantiate a higher figure.
Must the property be vacant within one year?
No. The one-year ceiling in section 721 ZPO concerns the eviction period granted under that provision, not the whole court and enforcement process. Exceptional enforcement protection may also apply.
Why do cash flow and the taxable result differ?
Principal repayment consumes cash but is not a deductible rental expense. Depreciation may reduce taxable income without a current cash payment. Tax relief is not necessarily available immediately.
What reserve does the example require?
The assumed no-payment scenario requires 10,130 euros before tax over six months. Enforcement and repairs require additional provision; this is not a universal reserve recommendation.
07Further reading
08Sources
Official foundations: BGB, ZPO, EStG.
General information about German law, not individual legal, tax or investment advice.

Writes about Purchase process, Notary and land registry and Letting.
Kevin combines twelve years of sales experience with nine years specialising in property and more than 500 consultations. He writes about property quality, location risks and a safe path from the first comparison to completion.
This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.



