Guide · Letting

    Rent increase requests using a German rent index: step by step towards consent

    Form, justification and deadlines determine whether a rent increase based on a German rent index succeeds. With a dated example and simplified cash flow calculations before and after tax.


    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo
    22 October 202611 min read
    Rent increase requests at a glance
    15 months
    rent must generally remain unchanged before the increase takes effect
    § 558(1) BGB
    2 calendar months
    after the month of receipt generally allowed for consent
    § 558b(2) BGB
    3 properties
    may suffice as formal justification
    § 558a(2), no. 4 BGB
    +€1,224
    over a full year before tax
    example: €102 more rent a month

    You have let a flat at the same rent for several years. Your town’s new rent index [Mietspiegel] might support a higher rent. Your tenant pays promptly, and you do not want to strain the relationship. Whether you can request an increase, and how much, nevertheless depends on the statutory requirements and the characteristics of the flat.

    This is the purpose of a rent increase request under § 558 of the German Civil Code [BGB]. It is a formal procedure with fixed deadlines. A clear explanation can make the request easier to assess; errors can delay the increase.

    01What a rent increase request is

    For an increase under § 558 BGB during an existing tenancy, the landlord cannot simply set a new rent unilaterally. The tenant’s consent is required. An entitlement to that consent exists only if all the statutory and contractual conditions are met. These include the requirement that the proposed rent must not exceed the local reference rent. This means the usual rents for comparable accommodation in the municipality or a comparable municipality, agreed or changed during the preceding six years; changes under § 560 BGB are excluded (§ 558(2) BGB).

    The request is therefore a declaration governed by statute. If the tenant does not consent, a claim seeking consent may be necessary. Formal validity, justification and substantive entitlement must therefore be assessed separately.

    A rent that has remained unchanged for a long time is a reason to assess the position, but is not in itself evidence that an increase is permissible.

    From our conversations
    „“

    No rent increase for five years: is it time to catch up?

    That can only be assessed by considering the particular flat, tenancy agreement and current local reference rent. If the existing rent is lower, an increase may be possible. The statutory rent increase cap [Kappungsgrenze] may impose a further limit. An unchanged rent alone establishes neither a financial disadvantage nor an entitlement to an increase.

    02Conditions to check before writing

    Check five points before writing the request. Depending on the outcome, an increase may be excluded, the request may be premature or only a smaller amount may be enforceable.

    1. No stepped or index-linked rent. An increase under § 558 is excluded while a stepped rent [Staffelmiete] or index-linked rent [Indexmiete] arrangement applies (§ 557a(2), § 557b(2) BGB).
    2. 15 months without a relevant change. When the new rent is due to take effect, the rent must have remained unchanged for 15 months. Increases for modernisation or operating costs are disregarded (§ 558(1) BGB).
    3. One-year waiting period. The request may be received no earlier than one year after the last relevant rent increase; the start of the tenancy must also be considered for the first increase. Increases under §§ 559–560 BGB are disregarded for this waiting period. A premature request generally needs to be made again.
    4. Rent increase cap. Rent may generally rise by no more than 20% over three years, or 15% in areas designated by state regulation (§ 558(3) BGB). Increases under §§ 559–560 BGB are excluded from this calculation. Check the regulation applying to the municipality at the relevant time. Our guide to rent increases and the statutory cap provides further information.
    5. Scope below the reference rent for the particular flat. What matters is the local reference rent that can be justified for your property. There may still be scope for an increase even if the existing rent already falls within a rent index range. However, the upper end of the range is not automatically enforceable.
    Key handover in a bright rental apartment
    AI-generated illustrative image

    03Comparing the four ways to justify a request

    The request must be justified (§ 558a(1) BGB). The explanation should enable the tenant to assess it. The legislation identifies four main methods; the list is not exhaustive.

    Ways to justify a rent increase
    MethodWhat you needStrengthLimitation
    Rent indexClassification of the flat in the appropriate category, with the proposed rent within the relevant rangea transparent basis; a qualified rent index may benefit from the statutory presumption of accuracycheck availability and cost; classification must be correct, including age, size, location and amenities
    Rent databaseInformation from a rent database within the meaning of § 558e BGBspecific information on the local reference rentcheck local availability
    Expert reportA reasoned report by a publicly appointed and sworn expertcan provide justification even without a rent indexadditional expense; obtain a quotation first
    Three comparable propertiesAt least three sufficiently comparable and identifiable properties, with details such as address, position in the building, size and rent per m²suitable properties from the landlord’s own portfolio may be usedformal justification does not replace proof of the local reference rent in a dispute

    If a qualified rent index that complies with § 558d(2) BGB contains information about your flat, you must provide that information even if you rely on comparable properties or an expert report (§ 558a(3) BGB). A qualified rent index is prepared in accordance with recognised scientific principles and recognised by the competent authority or by representatives of both landlords and tenants. It must be updated every two years and newly prepared after four years (§ 558d BGB). Municipalities with more than 50,000 inhabitants must produce a rent index (§ 558c(4) BGB); this does not automatically mean that it must be a qualified rent index.

    Where a rent index provides a range, it is generally sufficient for formal justification that the proposed rent falls within the relevant range (§ 558a(4) BGB). Whether the particular flat justifies that amount is a question of substantive entitlement. A landlord seeking the upper end should be able to support the classification using the index’s property characteristics and explanatory notes.

    04Step by step: from the request to the new rent

    The procedure follows a fixed sequence. Deadlines depend on receipt by the tenant, not the date on the letter. Weekends and public holidays can extend particular deadlines.

    Eight steps to an effective rent increase request
    1. 01
      Check the timing

      Check the last relevant increase, the start of the tenancy, the 15-month requirement and the one-year waiting period. Record the earliest possible start date for the new rent.

    2. 02
      Calculate the maximum amount

      Calculate the reference rent that can be justified for the flat and the statutory cap. The lower amount applies.

    3. 03
      Choose the justification

      Use a rent index, database, expert report or at least three comparable properties. Include the qualified rent index information where § 558a(3) BGB requires it.

    4. 04
      Write the request

      Clearly identify all landlords or their representatives, address all tenants and identify the flat. To make the calculation transparent, include the actual floor area, current and proposed net rent excluding service charges [Nettokaltmiete] in euros, the cap calculation, the start date and a request for consent. Not every one of these details is an independent formal requirement in every case.

    5. 05
      Make receipt provable

      Text form is sufficient, so email is generally possible. A messenger able to document both the contents and delivery can help establish receipt. For registered post with delivery to the letterbox, retain the available delivery records; proof of posting alone does not establish every requirement for receipt.

    6. 06
      Wait for the consent period to expire

      The tenant generally has until the end of the second calendar month after receipt (§ 558b(2) BGB). Allow for any extension of the deadline under § 193 BGB.

    7. 07
      Apply the new rent

      To the extent that consent has been given, the new rent applies from the beginning of the third calendar month after receipt (§ 558b(1) BGB). Ask the tenant to update their standing order if necessary.

    8. 08
      Bring a claim or remedy defects if consent is missing

      Observe the three-month period for bringing a claim for consent before the competent local court. Certain defects can be remedied, or a request made, during proceedings; the tenant then receives a fresh statutory consent period (§ 558b(3) BGB). Not every defect can be remedied in this way. Seek advice from a lawyer on the appropriate next steps.

    Here is a dated example. The tenancy began on 1 March 2022, and the rent has never been increased. The tenant receives the request on Friday 20 November 2026.

    Example deadlines: receipt on 20 November 2026
    RuleDate
    Receipt by the tenantreceipt of the request, assumed for this example20 November 2026
    End of consent periodend of the second calendar month; extension under § 193 BGB31 January 2027 is a Sunday, so 1 February 2027
    New rent applies frombeginning of the third calendar month, to the extent consent is given1 February 2027
    Filing a claim: planning datetimely filing within the three-month litigation period30 April 2027
    Tenant’s special termination rightin this example, the landlord receives notice in January 2027tenancy ends on 31 March 2027; the increase does not take effect
    Example under §§ 193, 558b and 561 BGB. The filing date of 30 April 2027 is a precautionary planning date. Allow a buffer when bringing a claim and have a lawyer calculate the applicable litigation deadline.

    If the rent increase request is not received until 4 December 2026, the higher rent starts on 1 March 2027, assuming the other requirements are met. The relevant point is the change in the month of receipt, not a particular number of days’ delay in posting.

    Silence is not consent. Repeated payment of the higher rent without reservation may, in an individual case, amount to implied consent. You should not rely on this. Ask instead for express confirmation in text form.

    The tenant may also give partial consent, for example to an increase of €60 rather than €102. The agreed portion then applies from the beginning of the third calendar month (§ 558b(1) BGB: to the extent that consent is given). A claim for consent to the remainder may be brought within the applicable deadline.

    In proceedings, the court examines whether the proposed rent exceeds the local reference rent. Subject to the statutory requirements, a qualified rent index may benefit from a presumption that it accurately reflects that reference rent (§ 558d(3) BGB). Three comparable properties may formally justify a request, but do not automatically determine the outcome of a claim. The court may need further evidence, such as an expert report. Costs are allocated according to the court’s decision and may be apportioned where each side succeeds only in part.

    An increase under § 558 BGB also gives the tenant a special termination right under § 561 BGB. If the tenant validly terminates within the statutory period, the increase does not take effect. A possible termination and subsequent void period therefore belong in the financial assessment. The deadline for giving notice and the date on which the tenancy ends must be calculated separately. A lawyer can advise you on a disputed increase or termination.

    Apartment floor plan, calculator and keys for reviewing a property investment
    AI-generated illustrative image

    06Worked example: what an extra €102 a month brings

    The Sommer family bought a 68 m² flat for €200,000, financed with a €160,000 loan. Their tenant has paid an unchanged net rent of €578 since March 2022, equivalent to €8.50 per m². The example assumes a rent index range of €9.40 to €10.60 per m², with a midpoint of €10.00. The names are fictional, and the figures are calculation assumptions, not a forecast or a statement about a particular local rent index.

    The family requests €10.00 per m², or €680. This assumes that the flat’s characteristics justify that amount and that no other increases need to be included in the relevant three-year period. Starting from €578, a 20% cap would permit up to €693.60; a 15% cap would permit up to €664.70. In the latter case, the maximum would therefore be €664.70 rather than €680. The following calculation assumes a 20% cap.

    First, consider cash flow before tax. The interest rate of 3.8% and repayment rate of 1.5% are illustrative assumptions only. Both are applied to €160,000 for simplicity; changes in the outstanding balance during the year are not modelled. The calculation compares twelve months at the old rent with twelve months at the new rent. It does not represent the 2027 calendar year, in which the example increase starts in February.

    For the taxable result, the €900 of costs not recoverable from the tenant is assumed to consist entirely of expenditure actually incurred and deductible in the year concerned. Contributions to the maintenance reserve of a condominium owners’ association [Wohnungseigentümergemeinschaft] are not immediately deductible. A deduction may arise only when the money is actually used for eligible expenditure; the entire owners’ service charge [Hausgeld] must not be deducted indiscriminately. Depreciation [AfA] of €3,200 is a separate assumption and cannot be derived from the purchase price without the building allocation, acquisition costs and applicable depreciation rate.

    The after-tax calculation is deliberately simplified: both rental losses are fully offset against other taxable income in the model. Tax relief is calculated using an assumed constant rate of 35%; church tax and the solidarity surcharge are excluded. This is not a calculation under the progressive income tax tariff or a statement about the Sommer family’s personal tax liability.

    Annual position before and after the rent increase
    Rent €578Rent €680
    Annual net rent€6,936€8,160
    Interest: 3.8% of €160,000, simplified−€6,080−€6,080
    Capital repayments: 1.5% of €160,000, simplified−€2,400−€2,400
    Non-recoverable costs, assumed fully deductible here−€900−€900
    Cash flow before tax−€2,444−€1,220
    Taxable result with assumed depreciation of €3,200−€3,244−€2,020
    Tax relief at an assumed rate of 35%+€1,135.40+€707.00
    Cash flow after tax in the simplified model−€1,308.60−€513.00
    Illustrative calculation, simplified. Tax relief: €3,244 × 35% = €1,135.40 and €2,020 × 35% = €707.00 respectively. Full offset of losses against other taxable income is assumed; church tax and the solidarity surcharge are excluded. Capital repayments reduce cash flow, not the taxable result. Depreciation reduces the taxable result but does not involve an ongoing cash payment.

    Annual cash flow before tax improves by €1,224. In the simplified tax model, tax relief falls by €428.40, leaving a €795.60 improvement in cash flow after tax. The calculated monthly cash contribution falls from €109.05 to €42.75. Despite the higher rent, cash flow remains negative in this example. Discuss your actual tax relief and ability to offset losses with your tax adviser.

    Annual effect of the rent increase
    Additional rent before tax
    +€1,224
    Lower tax relief at an assumed rate of 35%
    −€428.40
    Additional cash flow after tax in the simplified model
    +€795.60
    Illustrative calculation, simplified: €1,224 × 35% = €428.40 additional tax compared with the starting scenario; €1,224 − €428.40 = €795.60. The assumptions in the annual calculation apply.

    What does an error cost? If an invalid request must be made again, for example because it was received too early, the increase may be delayed. A delay of three to five months at €102 additional rent a month equates to €306–€510 in rent forgone before tax. This is a scenario calculation, not a fixed procedural timetable. With a 15% cap, the example would initially permit an increase of only €86.70 rather than €102, a difference of €15.30 a month. This is a statutory limit, not a permanent loss caused by a checking error; any later increases need to be assessed separately.

    Tool
    How much can you increase the rent?

    Use the calculator as an initial guide to deadlines, the rent increase cap and the possible start date for the new rent. A lawyer can advise on local requirements and the legal validity of your specific request where needed.

    07When this procedure is worth considering

    A request under § 558 may suit you
    • Your rent is below the reference rent that can be justified for the flat and will have remained unchanged for at least 15 months when the increase starts, apart from changes excluded by statute.
    • An up-to-date, preferably qualified rent index or another suitable means of justification is available.
    • Your agreement has no effective stepped or index-linked rent arrangement and does not otherwise exclude the increase; the specific terms of a fixed-term tenancy also need checking.
    Another approach may be preferable
    • Your agreement provides for stepped or index-linked rent. Its own mechanism applies; see stepped rents.
    • The possible additional rent is only a few euros. Weigh this against the work involved and the effect on the tenancy relationship.
    • You have carried out modernisation work. An increase under § 559 may be possible if its requirements are met; avoid counting the same improvement twice.

    08Risks and common mistakes

    Formal defects. Unclear identification of the parties making the request or their representatives, failure to account for all contracting parties, missing justification or premature receipt can jeopardise the request. If both spouses are landlords, both must act or be validly represented. Not every missing signature or name automatically invalidates a request regardless of context.

    Incorrect classification. Incorrect classification of the building’s age, the flat’s size or its amenities may mean that the proposed amount is not fully justified. Whether there is also a formal defect depends on the particular error. The key distinction is between a comprehensible justification for the request and the rent that is actually permissible. Seek advice from a lawyer on disputed cases.

    The tenancy relationship. A factual letter and a transparent table can help communication. A conversation beforehand is an option, but guarantees neither consent nor that the tenant will stay. Whether a void period would cost more than the expected additional rent depends particularly on its duration, the previous rent and reletting costs.

    Tax and interest. Additional rent generally increases taxable rental receipts; the actual tax effect depends on the overall taxable result. The increase does not remove other risks: higher interest rates when refinancing, maintenance and void periods remain relevant. Include your personal tax position in the calculation with support from a tax adviser.

    Legislative changes. Your request is governed by the applicable legislation and local regulations. Political announcements or bills do not change the law in force. When new rules are introduced, take account of their commencement dates and any transitional provisions. Further context is available in our guide to the 2026 tenancy law reform. A lawyer can advise which rules apply to your case.

    FAQFrequently asked questions

    What should a rent increase request contain?

    The request must be issued in text form and justified. The parties making it or their representatives, all affected tenants, the flat and the proposed increase must be clearly identifiable. For transparency, also include the actual floor area, current and proposed net rent, supporting evidence, the statutory cap calculation, the start date and a request for consent. Not every detail is an independent formal requirement in every case.

    How long does the tenant have to consent to the increase?

    Generally until the end of the second calendar month after receipt. If the request arrives in November, the period generally ends at the end of January. If the deadline falls on a Saturday, Sunday or relevant statutory public holiday, account for the extension under § 193 BGB.

    Must the tenant consent to an increase based on a rent index?

    An entitlement to consent exists only if all statutory and contractual requirements are met. These include a valid request, the waiting periods, and the limits imposed by the local reference rent and statutory cap. Without consent, the landlord may bring a claim within the deadline. The tenant also has a special termination right under § 561 BGB. A lawyer can help with a dispute over the increase.

    Are three comparable properties enough to justify the request?

    At least three sufficiently comparable and identifiable properties may provide formal justification under § 558a(2), no. 4 BGB, including suitable properties from the landlord’s own portfolio. If a qualified rent index contains information about the flat and the conditions of § 558a(3) BGB apply, that information must also be supplied. Formal justification does not establish the permissible rent in a dispute.

    Can I send the rent increase request by email?

    Generally yes: text form is sufficient, and a handwritten signature is not required. However, receipt must be provable if disputed. A messenger who can document the contents and delivery may help. For registered post delivered to the letterbox, retain the available delivery records; proof of posting alone does not establish every aspect of receipt.

    What happens if the tenant gives only partial consent?

    To the extent that the tenant consents, the higher rent applies from the beginning of the third calendar month after receipt. The landlord may bring a claim for consent to the remaining amount within the applicable litigation deadline, provided the requirements are met. A lawyer can assess the deadline and prospects of success.

    What if the litigation deadline has been missed?

    You can no longer obtain the outstanding consent through a claim based on that request. A new request is possible if the requirements applying at that time are met, and a new consent period begins. Any partial consent already validly given remains effective and may be relevant to the next assessment. Discuss the next steps with a lawyer.

    09Further reading

    10Sources

    • § 558 BGB, § 558a BGB, § 558b BGB, § 558c BGB, § 558d BGB, § 561 BGB
    • § 557a BGB and § 557b BGB (exclusion for stepped and index-linked rents)
    • § 193 BGB (deadlines falling on Saturdays, Sundays and statutory public holidays)
    • BGH VIII ZR 266/14 (actual floor area)
    • § 32a EStG (statutory income tax tariff; the illustrative calculation expressly uses a simplified constant tax rate instead)
    • Illustrative calculation, simplified: fictional property and financing; assumptions and calculations shown in the text and tables

    This guide provides general information and does not replace individual legal, tax or investment advice. The figures are illustrative calculation assumptions, not a return forecast. Discuss your specific rent increase request with a lawyer and your personal tax position with your tax adviser.

    Written by
    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo

    Writes about Financing and Taxes.

    Romolo brings almost 17 years of banking and financing experience, including leading around 145 sales staff, to his work. He writes about financing, taxes and property decisions that fit your life for the long term.

    This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.

    Free · Instant · No sign-up

    Download this guide as a PDF

    The complete guide as a clean A4 file – with a cover page, all chapters and page numbers. Keep it on hand, read it offline, or go through it at your own pace during your consultation.

    • All chapters, tables and worked examples
    • Read offline – on your phone or printed out
    • Go through it at your own pace or pass it on
    • Free, no sign-up, no email required

    A4 format · 4,233 words · As of 22 October 2026

    Related guides

    All guides