Increasing operating cost advance payments: rules for landlords
If advance payments do not cover recoverable operating costs, you fund the gap until the balancing payment arrives. Learn what section 560 of the German Civil Code allows, how to calculate the new amount and what it means for cash flow.
In the following example, the annual operating cost statement [Betriebskostenabrechnung] has been sent, and your tenant owes a balancing payment of €480. You recover the money only when that payment arrives. During the accounting year, you funded recoverable operating costs that the monthly advance payments did not fully cover. For a flat in a jointly owned building, these costs may be paid through the owner's service charge [Hausgeld] or directly by you.
Adjusting the operating cost advance payment [Nebenkostenvorauszahlung] addresses this gap. It does not require the tenant's consent, but it must rest on a sound annual statement and a reasonable calculation. An incorrectly calculated amount can make all or part of the increase open to challenge.
01What section 560(4) of the German Civil Code allows
A tenancy agreement may provide for a fixed operating cost payment, which is not reconciled against actual costs. Alternatively, the tenant pays advances that are reconciled annually (section 556(2) and (3) of the German Civil Code). This guide concerns advance payments for residential tenancies.
The rule for advance payments is straightforward. Following an annual statement, either party may adjust the amount by giving notice in text form (section 560(4) of the German Civil Code). This right is not restricted to landlords. If the statement shows a substantial credit and lower ongoing costs are expected, the tenant may also reduce the advance payment.
The law also requires advance payments to be set at a reasonable level (section 556(2), sentence 2, of the German Civil Code). This means basing them on the anticipated recoverable costs.
02Requirements for an increase
Before calculating an amount, check three points. If one is missing, the increase is open to challenge.
- 01Advance payments agreed
The tenancy agreement provides for monthly operating cost advance payments, not a fixed payment or an all-inclusive rent.
- 02Statement prepared and received
An adjustment requires an annual statement that the tenant has received; an increase based solely on speculation is insufficient. An adjustment can also take place during the calendar year. The statement must generally reach the tenant within twelve months of the end of the accounting period (section 556(3) of the German Civil Code). Missing this deadline particularly affects balancing payment claims and does not automatically prevent a prospective adjustment.
- 03Correct accounting basis
According to the Federal Court of Justice, the costs used for the adjustment must be substantively correct (judgment of 15 May 2012, VIII ZR 245/11). Non-recoverable items or incorrect floor areas must not inflate the new amount. Errors must be corrected; not every error necessarily invalidates every part of an adjustment.
If the statement includes the building manager's fee from the owner's service charge or a repair, that cost item is substantively incorrect. It must not enter the calculation of the new advance payment. Our guide to non-recoverable operating costs explains which items can actually be passed on.

03How to calculate the new advance payment
Start with the total recoverable costs attributable to the flat in the latest statement. For a complete accounting year, dividing this amount by twelve gives the monthly starting figure. For shorter periods or a tenancy covering only part of the year, the period and any seasonal consumption must be considered; simply dividing by twelve would not provide a meaningful figure.
You may add cost increases that are already established or specifically foreseeable. The Federal Court of Justice expressly permitted this (judgment of 28 September 2011, VIII ZR 294/10). Specific foreseeable cost reductions must also be taken into account. An abstract uplift, such as 10% ‘just in case’, is not permitted.
| Item | Permitted? | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Costs in the latest statement | Yes | Total recoverable costs for a full year divided by twelve |
| Specific confirmed increase | Yes | New property tax assessment, new caretaker services contract |
| Documented foreseeable price increase | Yes, if specific | Announced increase in the energy supplier's instalments, insofar as it demonstrates a specific cost increase |
| Flat-rate contingency uplift | No | ‘Plus 10% in case prices rise’ |
| Non-recoverable costs | No | Management, maintenance, maintenance reserve contributions |
A flat in a jointly owned building: the annual budget as evidence
For a rented flat, the annual budget [Wirtschaftsplan] of the owners' association [Wohnungseigentümergemeinschaft, WEG] can indicate specific foreseeable increases. It sets out the building's expected costs; the owners resolve the advance contributions on this basis. If the provision for insurance, caretaker services or refuse collection rises because of new contracts or assessments, those documents can substantiate the increase.
Be cautious with estimates alone. If the managing agent budgets a blanket 10% increase for every item, this is just as abstract an uplift for your tenant as one you devise yourself. Include only recoverable items with a specific justification and a correctly calculated share for the flat. Attach the relevant budget extract and, where appropriate, the supporting documents. The budget does not replace the required annual operating cost statement.
04Form and timing of the increase
The notice must be in text form: a legible declaration naming the person making it, on a durable medium, such as a letter, email or fax. A signature is not required. You can send the adjustment with the annual statement; you should be able to prove receipt.
Section 560(4) of the German Civil Code does not specify an express notice period. For a prospective adjustment, the next payment due after receipt of the notice is generally the relevant starting point. A clearly stated later start date can avoid disputes about receipt and which payment is affected. The following sample uses 1 December 2026 and assumes that the notice is received beforehand. Even if you allow a month's notice, the other statutory requirements must still be met.
| Content | |
|---|---|
| Subject | Adjustment of operating cost advance payments under section 560(4) of the German Civil Code |
| Basis | Annual operating cost statement for 2025 dated 15 October 2026 |
| Costs in the statement | €2,760.00 per year |
| Specific increase | Property tax under the new assessment: +€96.00 per year |
| New advance payment | €238.00 per month from 1 December 2026 |
The connection with the annual statement matters. If you wait six months before increasing the payment, you may still rely on the latest statement, but must consider the costs foreseeable by then. Additional interim funding may have been needed in the meantime. It therefore makes sense to send a substantiated adjustment with the annual statement.

05Worked example: what an advance payment that is too low costs you
Stefanie Lorenz owns a rented flat measuring 68 m². She pays the owners' association a monthly service charge of €390. The total recoverable operating costs relevant to this example average €230 per month. This includes recoverable costs accounted for through the owner's service charge and any property tax she pays directly; the €230 should therefore not be read as solely a component of that service charge. Her tenant has paid advances of €190 since the tenancy began. The name and case are fictional; the figures form a simplified illustrative calculation, not a forecast.
The statement for the full year 2025 shows recoverable costs of €2,760. The tenant paid €2,280 in advances, leaving a balancing payment of €480. In this example, the municipality has also issued a higher property tax assessment for 2026: an additional €96 per year for this flat. The annual comparison below assumes that the resulting total of €2,856 remains constant.
| Without adjustment | With adjustment | |
|---|---|---|
| Recoverable operating costs including property tax | −€2,856 | −€2,856 |
| Tenant's advance payments | +€2,280 | +€2,856 |
| Funded pending the next annual statement | −€576 | €0 |
| Monthly advance payment | €190 | €238 |
Without an adjustment, Ms Lorenz provides an additional €576 in interim funding over a full year under these assumptions, reducing pre-tax cash flow by an average of €48 per month. If the adjustment takes effect only on 1 December 2026, however, the advance payment rises by €48 for just one month of 2026; the remaining calculated shortfall is €528 at the assumed annual cost level. The full €576 cash-flow improvement requires twelve months at the higher advance payment.
The interim funding is recovered only through the subsequent balancing payment, provided the tenant pays. If the statement is not issued until towards the end of the following year, almost two years may pass between the first cost payment and the balancing payment; depending on when payment arrives, it may take longer. Moving out does not remove the tenant's obligation to pay, but can make the subsequent administration more difficult. Non-payment can result in a loss.
What about tax? The tenant's advance payments and balancing payments are generally rental income. Tax-deductible operating costs actually paid may be claimed as rental expenses [Werbungskosten]. The entire owner's service charge is not immediately deductible: in particular, contributions to the owners' association's maintenance reserve [Erhaltungsrücklage] are not deductible rental expenses when paid into the reserve. A deduction may arise only when the association actually spends the money, insofar as the particular expenditure qualifies for deduction. Other costs must also be classified according to their tax treatment.
Income and deductible expenditure generally follow the cash receipts and payments principle, subject to statutory exceptions. A later balancing payment can move income into another tax year. This does not mean that the overall tax burden across several years necessarily stays the same; a qualified tax adviser should assess the individual effect.
06When an adjustment makes sense
- The statement shows a balancing payment due and comparable ongoing costs are still expected.
- A new assessment or contract demonstrably increases costs.
- Your tenant has paid the same amount for years although recoverable costs have risen.
- The statement contains errors or disputed items: clarify these first and correct them where necessary.
- The balancing payment results from a one-off effect, such as a cold winter: assess whether it is relevant to future costs.
- The statement shows a substantial credit and lower costs are still expected: consider a reduction; the tenant may also give notice of one.
07Risks and common mistakes
Invalid increase. An adjustment based on incorrect costs or including a flat-rate uplift is open to challenge. Advance payments actually made must be credited in the next annual statement. Any separate rights to repayment or set-off require individual assessment; this does not create an unrestricted right to offset amounts against ongoing payments.
Late statement. If the statement arrives more than twelve months after the end of the accounting period, additional payment claims are generally excluded unless the landlord is not responsible for the delay (section 556(3) of the German Civil Code). A reasonable prospective adjustment is a separate matter.
Payment default. Large balancing payments can place tenants under financial pressure. A landlord claiming, for example, €500 each year may face requests for instalments or non-payment. An appropriate advance payment can reduce this risk, but does not eliminate it.
New tenancy, old amount. Do not automatically carry over the advance payment from the previous agreement when tenants change. Use the latest statement and specific foreseeable changes, including any changes in usage where relevant. Even a realistic amount does not rule out a later balancing payment.
Tenant retention. An excessive advance payment is open to legal challenge and can strain the relationship with the tenant. A transparent calculation supports a reliable, long-term tenancy rather than seeking the greatest possible short-term cash inflow.
FAQFrequently asked questions
When can I increase operating cost advance payments?
After the tenant has received an annual operating cost statement. The adjustment must rest on a sound statement and reasonable cost figures under section 560(4) of the German Civil Code. It can also take place during the calendar year; simply assuming that costs will rise is insufficient.
Does the tenant have to agree to the increase?
No. Your notice in text form is sufficient if the statutory requirements are met. The tenant may check whether the new amount is reasonable and the underlying costs are correct.
How much can I increase the advance payment?
The starting point is the recoverable costs for a complete accounting year divided by twelve. Specific foreseeable cost changes must be taken into account. A flat-rate contingency uplift is not permitted (Federal Court of Justice, VIII ZR 294/10). Shorter accounting periods require separate assessment.
When does the new advance payment take effect?
Section 560(4) of the German Civil Code does not specify an express notice period. For a prospective adjustment, the next payment due after receipt of the notice is generally the relevant starting point. State a clear start date and retain evidence of receipt. Even if you allow a month's notice, the other statutory requirements must still be met.
Can the tenant reduce the advance payment?
Yes. Either party has this right under section 560(4) of the German Civil Code. If the statement shows a credit and anticipated costs justify a lower amount, the tenant may give notice in text form reducing the advance payment to a reasonable level.
Is an email sufficient for the increase?
Yes. Text form requires a legible declaration on a durable medium naming the person making it. An email meeting these requirements is sufficient; a signature is not necessary. You should be able to prove receipt.
What if the annual statement was incorrect?
Incorrect costs must not inflate the new advance payment (Federal Court of Justice, VIII ZR 245/11). Correct the statement and recalculate a reasonable advance payment on that basis. Not every error automatically invalidates every part of an adjustment. Consult a lawyer if the legal consequences are disputed.
08Further reading
- Annual operating cost statements for landlords
- Checking an operating cost statement
- Non-recoverable operating costs
- Owner's service charges for a flat
- Calculator: operating cost statement deadline
- Template: operating cost statement
09Sources
- German Civil Code, section 556 and section 560
- Federal Court of Justice, judgment of 28 September 2011, VIII ZR 294/10 (no abstract contingency uplift; specific increases permitted)
- Federal Court of Justice, judgment of 15 May 2012, VIII ZR 245/11 (substantively correct costs as the basis for adjustment)
- Worked example: author's calculation using the assumptions stated in the example
This guide provides general information. Consult a lawyer for a legal assessment of your tenancy and a tax adviser for tax questions. The worked examples are simplified and based on the assumptions stated in each case.

Writes about Existing properties, Investment calculations and Property assessment.
Rula has worked in financial services since 2021. He focuses on existing investment properties, transparent calculations and an honest assessment of building condition and running costs.
This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.



