Guide · Vermietung & Verwaltung

    Windows, balconies and water damage: who pays in an owners’ association?

    External windows are common property, even when they are in your flat. Understand ownership and cost allocation, with a comparison of two window replacement cost rules.


    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo
    21 October 20268 min read
    Who pays what at a glance
    Windows
    common property
    external windows shape the façade, § 5 WEG
    Balcony slab
    common property
    the surface finish may be individually owned
    €3,360
    your share in the example
    when the association replaces 40 windows
    €4,200
    with individual cost allocation
    for three windows under the applicable cost rule

    Your tenant reports that the bedroom window no longer closes and is letting in a draught. Your first thought is a window installer. Your second should be the declaration of division [Teilungserklärung]. Although the external window is in your flat, it forms part of the common property [Gemeinschaftseigentum]. If you replace it without authorisation, you could be left paying the bill yourself.

    The question of who pays has two parts. Who owns the component? And who bears the costs under the community rules [Gemeinschaftsordnung] and resolutions?

    01The basic rule under § 5 WEG

    Individually owned property comprises your rooms and components that can be altered, removed or installed without adversely affecting the common property or other owners beyond the legally permitted extent and without changing the building’s external appearance (§ 5(1) WEG). Anything necessary for the building’s integrity or safety, or serving shared use, must be common property, even if it is inside your flat (§ 5(2) WEG).

    An initial question is therefore: does an alteration affect the external appearance, structural stability or a shared function? If so, that points towards common property. If it affects only your flat, individual ownership may be possible; location inside the flat is not decisive on its own.

    The reverse is also possible. Owners can agree that components which could be individually owned will instead form part of the common property (§ 5(3) WEG). However, anything protected by § 5(2) cannot be made individually owned property.

    From our conversations
    „What happens after major damage, such as roof damage or a water leak — does every owner have to contribute extra?“

    A useful question when buying: if the maintenance reserve, insurance proceeds and other available funds are insufficient, a special levy [Sonderumlage] may be needed. The association must resolve how to fund the work. Each owner’s contribution depends on the applicable cost allocation rule, not necessarily their co-ownership share. An adequately funded maintenance reserve can make such additional payments less frequent, but cannot rule them out.

    02What belongs to whom: an overview

    The table shows the general allocation. In each case, the component’s function and the declaration of division need to be considered. The declaration cannot turn mandatory common property into individually owned property.

    ComponentGeneral allocationReason
    External windows, including frames and glassCommon propertyShape the façade and protect the building
    Internal window sillIndividual ownership possibleProvided it has no shared function or external effect
    Roller shutters, external blindsUsually common propertyExternal appearance; individual internal operating components require separate assessment
    Flat entrance doorCommon propertyBoundary with the communal stairwell and shared functions
    Balcony: slab, waterproofing, parapet, railingsCommon propertyStructural stability, waterproofing, façade
    Balcony: finish above the waterproofingIndividual ownership possibleProvided it has no waterproofing or other shared function
    Load-bearing walls, structural floors, screedLoad-bearing walls and structural floors: common property; screed depends on functionStructural stability; assess the screed’s acoustic and fire protection functions in particular
    Non-load-bearing internal walls, floor finishes, tilesIndividual ownership possibleProvided only the flat is affected and there is no shared function
    Risers, main pipe runsCommon propertyServe several flats
    Branch pipework serving only your flatCase-by-case assessmentExclusive supply is not enough; check location, function and allocation
    RadiatorsDepends on function and the declaration of divisionFor one-pipe systems, assess effects on the overall system in particular
    Roof, façade, stairwell, central heating plantCommon propertyShared use and building integrity
    Inspection of the shared heating system in an apartment building
    AI-generated illustrative image

    03Ownership and costs are separate questions

    Who owns a component is one question. Who pays for it may be another. There are three routes:

    1. Statutory rule. All owners bear the costs of common property according to their co-ownership shares (§ 16(2), sentence 1 WEG).
    2. Declaration of division or community rules. The community rules may require individual owners to bear particular costs for their flat’s windows, entrance door or balcony, even though these remain common property. The wording and scope of the valid provision are decisive.
    3. Resolution. Since 2020, owners have been able to resolve by a simple majority to allocate individual costs or specified types of costs differently (§ 16(2), sentence 2 WEG), for example for an upcoming window replacement. The resolution must meet the legal requirements for proper management.

    Always read both the ownership allocation in the declaration of division and the cost provisions in the community rules and register of resolutions [Beschluss-Sammlung]. A valid rule making each owner responsible for the replacement costs of their flat’s windows substantially changes the calculation, as the example below shows. A clause dealing only with maintenance should not automatically be treated as a comprehensive obligation to pay replacement costs.

    If you want more than the association plans to do

    Some owners want to replace their windows earlier or install better ones, such as triple glazing, while the association is still waiting. As external windows are common property, an appropriate decision by the association is required. Where the work constitutes a structural alteration, it can be authorised by resolution (§ 20(1) WEG). An individual owner granted permission for such an alteration generally bears its costs and is alone entitled to its benefits (§ 21(1) WEG). The same resolution should address future maintenance and cost allocation. Otherwise, disputes may arise later over who pays for repairs.

    You have more freedom with individually owned property. Works going beyond maintenance do not require permission if they cause no other owner a disadvantage exceeding what is unavoidable in orderly communal living (§ 13(2) WEG). A new floor finish may therefore be your responsibility, but acoustic protection and other owners’ rights still matter. Intervening in screed that performs a shared function is a different matter. Discuss unclear cost provisions and any work you plan to commission independently with a lawyer.

    04Water damage: who pays for what?

    Water damage brings together ownership, cause, liability and insurance. Proper management includes adequate insurance of the common property at reinstatement value (§ 19(2), no. 3 WEG). Buildings insurance may cover insured escape-of-water damage to the building, including affected parts of individually owned property. The policy determines which losses are insured. For the allocation of excesses, the applicable cost rules and resolutions also need to be checked; the location of the leak alone is not decisive.

    What to do after water damage
    1. 01
      Limit the damage

      Turn off the water and inform neighbours. If common property faces imminent damage, any owner may immediately take necessary action (§ 18(3) WEG).

    2. 02
      Inform the managing agent

      The agent should coordinate notification to the buildings insurer and the necessary leak detection and drying within their authority.

    3. 03
      Establish the cause

      Is the leak in a riser or a pipe serving one flat? Check ownership, insurance cover, cost allocation rules and potential liability claims. Ownership of the leaking pipe alone does not determine responsibility for all uninsured consequential losses.

    4. 04
      Provide access

      You must allow access to your flat for legally required works where the statutory conditions are met (§ 14(1), no. 2 WEG). If an interference that must be tolerated exceeds a reasonable level, appropriate financial compensation may be claimed (§ 14(3) WEG).

    5. 05
      Involve the tenant

      Damage to the tenant’s furniture and belongings may be covered by their contents insurance, depending on the policy; liability claims may also arise. A substantial impairment of the agreed use of the flat may entitle the tenant to a rent reduction.

    Inspection of a freshly renovated rental apartment
    AI-generated illustrative image

    05Worked example: three old windows, two cost rules

    Sandra owns a rented flat with three windows dating from the 1990s in a building with 40 windows. Her co-ownership share is 60/1,000. The example assumes a uniform cost of €1,400 per window, including installation, with no additional costs. The name, building and price are fictional. This is a simplified illustrative calculation, not a statement of market prices or a forecast.

    Option A applies the statutory rule. The association replaces all 40 windows for €56,000 and allocates the costs by ownership share. Option B assumes the same replacement of all 40 windows, but a valid provision in the community rules assigns each owner the replacement costs for their flat’s windows.

    Sandra’s window replacement costs
    A: Allocation by ownership shareB: Each owner bears their windows’ costs
    Total project cost€56,000€56,000
    Calculation of Sandra’s share€56,000 × 60/1,0003 × €1,400
    Sandra’s share before tax€3,360€4,200
    Taxable income after deduction€56,640€55,800
    Income tax before the additional deduction€14,233€14,233
    Income tax after the additional deduction€12,956€12,643
    Income tax saving at €60,000 taxable income before deduction€1,277€1,590
    Sandra’s cost after income tax€2,083€2,610
    Simplified illustrative calculation: 2026 income tax tariff under § 32a(1) of the German Income Tax Act [EStG], individual assessment, with €60,000 taxable income before the additional deduction. Income tax under the tariff is rounded down to whole euros as required by law. The calculation assumes like-for-like replacement, maintenance expenditure fully eligible for immediate deduction and actual payment by the association in the relevant year; the property was acquired more than three years earlier. Church tax, the solidarity surcharge and other tax interactions are excluded. The tax saving is the difference between income tax before and after the deduction. Discuss your personal tax treatment with your tax adviser.

    Option B costs Sandra more because three of the 40 equally priced windows represent 7.5% of the total cost, whereas her co-ownership share is only 6%. Conversely, individual cost allocation may be cheaper if the costs of the windows assigned to her flat are below her share of the overall cost. Window area alone does not determine this.

    If the replacement is paid from the maintenance reserve [Erhaltungsrücklage], paying into that reserve is not itself deductible. Only Sandra’s share of actual expenditure by the association that qualifies for tax relief may be taken into account; the full service charge [Hausgeld] is not the relevant amount (German Federal Fiscal Court [BFH], judgment of 14 January 2025, IX R 19/24). Whether an immediate deduction or depreciation is required depends on the tax classification. Discuss this with your tax adviser.

    Comparing Sandra’s costs before tax
    A: Allocation by ownership share
    −€3,360
    B: Costs of her own windows
    −€4,200
    Difference: €840 before tax. Under the assumptions of the simplified illustrative calculation, the difference after income tax is €527.

    06Who particularly needs to consider this?

    Check carefully
    • You are buying in an older building where windows, balconies or pipework will soon need attention.
    • Your flat has more windows than average or a large balcony.
    • The community rules are old and contain specific cost provisions.
    Less critical, but still check
    • A new-build property with outstanding rights to claim against the developer for defects: check scope, deadlines and enforceability.
    • The association has recently refurbished windows and balconies: check workmanship, funding and remaining requirements.

    07Risks and common mistakes

    Arranging work without authority. Owners who replace common property without the required authorisation and outside an emergency risk bearing the costs themselves. They may also have to reverse the work, for example where it involves an unauthorised façade alteration.

    Incorrect ownership assumptions. Treating external windows or a flat entrance door as individually owned property can confuse responsibility for the work with responsibility for its cost. This may lead to disputes and additional expense.

    Underestimating the reserve. If windows, balconies and pipework need replacement in the coming years and the reserve is small, a special levy may be necessary. Meeting minutes and the financial position report [Vermögensbericht] can indicate funding needs before purchase, but do not replace a technical condition assessment.

    Not checking insurance. Excesses, exclusions and changes in buildings insurance premiums may affect your costs through service charges and additional payments.

    FAQFrequently asked questions

    Are windows common property or individually owned?

    External windows, including their frames and glass, are common property, even when they are in your flat. They shape the external appearance and protect the building (§ 5 WEG). An internal window sill may be individually owned if it performs no shared function.

    Who pays for new windows in an individually owned flat?

    Owners generally bear the costs according to their co-ownership shares. A valid agreement may assign particular replacement costs to individual owners. A lawful resolution can also change the allocation (§ 16(2), sentence 2 WEG). Individual responsibility for costs does not automatically authorise an owner to arrange replacement independently.

    Is a balcony individually owned property?

    The balcony space and a surface finish with no shared function may be individually owned. The slab, waterproofing, parapet and railings are common property. The component’s function and the legally permissible allocation in the declaration of division are decisive.

    Who pays for water damage in an individually owned flat?

    Buildings insurance pays for insured losses within the agreed policy terms. For excesses and uninsured costs, ownership, cost allocation rules and potential liability claims must be considered; the location of the leak alone is not decisive. Damage to a tenant’s belongings may be covered by their contents insurance.

    Can I arrange to replace my window myself?

    As external windows are common property, you need appropriate authorisation from the association. If common property faces imminent damage, you may take necessary action to prevent it (§ 18(3) WEG). This does not automatically justify replacing an entire window. Without the required authorisation, you risk bearing the costs yourself.

    Is a flat entrance door common property?

    The door between a flat and the communal stairwell is common property. A different description in the declaration of division cannot turn mandatory common property into individually owned property. Cost allocation may nevertheless be regulated separately.

    Can I deduct repair costs for common property from tax?

    For a rented property, your share of qualifying repair expenditure may be deductible. Whether immediate deduction or depreciation is required depends on its classification. Contributions to the maintenance reserve are not immediately deductible; what matters is the association’s actual qualifying expenditure, not the full service charge. Discuss the classification with your tax adviser.

    08Further reading

    09Sources

    This guide provides general information. Consult a lawyer about the legal circumstances of your case and your tax adviser about its tax treatment.

    Written by
    Investment Advisor at InvestImmo

    Writes about Investment properties, New builds and renovation and Financing.

    Nadeem is a qualified insurance and finance merchant, spent around eight years self-employed in the insurance and finance industry and has specialised in investment property since 2024. He writes about new builds, renovation, financing and the running costs of rented property.

    This guide does not replace tax or legal advice. All figures are example calculations with disclosed assumptions.

    Free · Instant · No sign-up

    Download this guide as a PDF

    The complete guide as a clean A4 file – with a cover page, all chapters and page numbers. Keep it on hand, read it offline, or go through it at your own pace during your consultation.

    • All chapters, tables and worked examples
    • Read offline – on your phone or printed out
    • Go through it at your own pace or pass it on
    • Free, no sign-up, no email required

    A4 format · 2,946 words · As of 21 October 2026

    Related guides

    All guides